Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend and her husband’s financial arrangement

88 replies

Salvia89 · 11/07/2022 22:10

Hi all,

I was chatting to my friend (Let’s call her Emma) the other day.. she and her husband have a 1.5 year old DC and she’s been back at work for 6 months after mat leave.

She mentioned in passing that it’s soul destroying working and only getting about £200 at the end of the month after paying nursery fees and I said “well you need to think of it as a joint expense.. I.e you’re only really paying half.. or actually even less if you think of it proportionally from your salaries”. She’s probably on a salary of mid 20s and husband is on about 80k I guess.

She said “well no, as I pay for nursery out of my wage. Tom (not real name) pays for everything else like mortgage, meals out etc, so it’s fine”. I said “hmm… ok” then the conversation moved on.

Later I remembered a time when we were chatting towards the end of her Mat leave where she said she’d blown her months cash on a lunch that we had out. The only money that she was getting on mat leave was her crappy mat pay which for the end I think was next to nothing!

He on the other hand was going out for fancy dinners with his mates.

I mentioned that it seemed a little very unfair and she said that he’s give her some extra money if asked so it was fine.

she doesn’t seem worried by the situation and seems quite happy..

Do you all agree that this is massively unfair?! Surely as a married couple with kids you pool your resources.. especially when there’s such a disparity in salaries.

Anyway.. my AIBU. Should I bring it up again and advise her to seek a fairer agreement?

YABU - they both seem happy so let them get on with it
YANBU - it’s worth bringing it up again and suggesting a fairer split.

OP posts:
notacooldad · 12/07/2022 12:59

It's not the way me and Dh do things but each to their own I guess.

sammylady37 · 12/07/2022 12:56

Sandra1984 · 12/07/2022 12:50

@sammylady37 Christ, where to start with this bullshit? ‘His child’? It’s their child, it’s not like she’s doing him a massive favour that is of no benefit to herself. And if she presents him with that invoice, would she be happy for him to present her with one for housing costs for her and their child, as well as a bill for half of everything else he currently pays?

Her friend sound very happy with the arrangement so I don't see where the problems lies herein. I (like the OP) personally wouldn't be happy at all but that's just me. As long as people are happy who cares?

Well if you agree that the woman in question is happy with the arrangement , why did you post saying her husband should be making her happy instead of contributing to her misery??

Hairbear2 · 12/07/2022 12:55

My ex expected me to contribute most or all (can’t remember exactly) of my mat money to the joint account. Same when i was back working. I’m self employed so I didn’t get a great sum anyway, but then wasn’t left with much at all.

Sandra1984 · 12/07/2022 12:50

@sammylady37 Christ, where to start with this bullshit? ‘His child’? It’s their child, it’s not like she’s doing him a massive favour that is of no benefit to herself. And if she presents him with that invoice, would she be happy for him to present her with one for housing costs for her and their child, as well as a bill for half of everything else he currently pays?

Her friend sound very happy with the arrangement so I don't see where the problems lies herein. I (like the OP) personally wouldn't be happy at all but that's just me. As long as people are happy who cares?

sammylady37 · 12/07/2022 12:38

Sandra1984 · 12/07/2022 08:47

If I were her I would draw him a big fat hefty invoice $$$ for childcare, baby sitting, carrying a baby in her womb for 9 months and financial/professional loses from having to take maternity leave. Yes it's unfair and he should be making the mother of his child happy while she goes through the hard ordeal of raising HIS child, instead he's contributing to her misery.

Christ, where to start with this bullshit? ‘His child’? It’s their child, it’s not like she’s doing him a massive favour that is of no benefit to herself. And if she presents him with that invoice, would she be happy for him to present her with one for housing costs for her and their child, as well as a bill for half of everything else he currently pays?

berksandbeyond · 12/07/2022 12:32

We did this - I paid nursery and 'my bills' - mobile phone etc, and husband paid everything else. How is that financially abusive?!
I'd have been a lot worse off if I'd paid half of
Nursery
Mortgage
Food
Gas
Elec
Water
Insurance
Council tax
Petrol
Savings...

People are weird

10HailMarys · 12/07/2022 12:03

Nobody can say whether this is 'financial abuse' based on what you've said. There is a hell of a lot more to 'financial abuse' than what you've described. I think some people on Mumsnet think financial abuse is essentially any arrangement which isn't the one they have with their own partner. One person having more disposable income than the other isn't financial abuse, and if Tom is paying for everything else - mortgage, bills, holidays, etc - then the arrangement doesn't sound colossally unfair to me. We also don't know what savings etc he has - for all you know, he might be putting a chunk of cash away every month to provide for the family's future.

I don't think the 'soul-destroying' comment is an indication that she feels the arrangement is unfair or has been imposed on her. We cannot possibly know either way.

Ultimately, your friend is an adult and her financial arrangements and 'fun money' are not really your business.

My sister used to go on about how 'weird' it is that DP and I don't have a joint bank account and don't do our finances the way she does with her partner, until I told her that she really needed to mind her own bloody business.

Sandra1984 · 12/07/2022 08:47

Salvia89 · 11/07/2022 23:15

I think the issue lies in that her finances have taken a massive hit since having DC whereas his haven’t. Obviously I don’t know the ins and out of their financial arrangements but before DC she never complained about not being able to afford a coffee etc. i wouldn’t bat an eyelid if their joint income is low, but it’s really not!

Since she’s been on mat leave she’s had to live on a pittance whereas his life is financially more or less the same.

If I were her I would draw him a big fat hefty invoice $$$ for childcare, baby sitting, carrying a baby in her womb for 9 months and financial/professional loses from having to take maternity leave. Yes it's unfair and he should be making the mother of his child happy while she goes through the hard ordeal of raising HIS child, instead he's contributing to her misery.

BarbaraofSeville · 12/07/2022 08:25

Salvia89 · 12/07/2022 08:13

If we had one joint pot for everything I think we’d both feel guilty if we wanted to buy ourselves something big 😂

It doesn't even have to be something big. People can spend an awful lot of money in £5 here and £10 there, which is why it's a good idea to separate off some money for personal spending so you know that essentials are covered and both partners have access to some of their own money.

PegasusReturns · 12/07/2022 08:20

It sounds - and likely is - unfair, due to the disparity in earnings.

I don’t subscribe to the everything equal school of thought - DH and I have separate finances - but there does need to be some equity. To have one half of a couple being able to afford significantly more than the other is unfair

MsVestibule · 12/07/2022 08:20

It does seem very unfair. I don't think you should bring it up again, but be ready with a 'do you think it's fair that having a baby has impacted your finances when it's barely made a dent in your DH's?' type question. I'd frame it as a series of questions to get her thinking, rather than you telling her how they should be doing it.

He either hasn't thought about it or he's a complete dick. Neither is great. I'm taking a wild guess that she does most of the domestic stuff and is more likely to take the day off if the baby is poorly?

Salvia89 · 12/07/2022 08:13

If we had one joint pot for everything I think we’d both feel guilty if we wanted to buy ourselves something big 😂

OP posts:
Salvia89 · 12/07/2022 08:11

We earn similar amounts so put in 80% of our earnings to a joint account that has all DDs for mortgage, bills etc. Any meals put, family days, holidays etc comes from there. The 20% we keep back is for our own purchases, presents, nights out with friends etc. Works well for us. I can’t imagine having to work out who paid the shopping last or having to remind my partner or be reminded to transfer X to them for Y. Seems like a massive faff!

OP posts:
Q2C4 · 12/07/2022 08:10

Worldgonecrazy · 12/07/2022 07:24

I think you are a good friend who wants to help. The only fair way to pool income is by ratio. So if she earns £20k and he earns £80 k she should be paying 20% if all bills and he 80%. Then what is left should be discussed jointly, whether to split equally or on a different ratio.

It will be interesting to see what happens when she no longer has childcare costs, and if her husband suddenly decides she should pay towards the bills!

It would be fairer to calculate the % contributions on an after tax basis since that's the actual amount of cash each partner will have to contribute. Someone on £80k will be suffering a higher tax burden than someone on £20k - the ratios should reflect this.

BarbaraofSeville · 12/07/2022 07:54

boobot1 · 12/07/2022 07:51

To be honest I think the whole separate bank accounts is weird. We have one account all bills and spending come out of it. I spend what I like, so does he, never been a problem.
I would refuse to live like that, but each to their own.

That only works if neither of you overspend relative to your income.

If either of you are the 'see money must spend it' type then they'll be off buying themselves all sorts of none essentials and the time that the DDs for the mortgage, council tax etc come due, there isn't enough money to pay them...

boobot1 · 12/07/2022 07:51

To be honest I think the whole separate bank accounts is weird. We have one account all bills and spending come out of it. I spend what I like, so does he, never been a problem.
I would refuse to live like that, but each to their own.

BarbaraofSeville · 12/07/2022 07:43

She suffers for having DC and he doesn’t

This is the key point. They should be able to afford similar lifestyles, due to having equal amounts of personal money for things like eating out, hobbies, clothes, tech etc. They should also both be able to save similar amounts, not him have loads more savings in his name. After all, he's already likely to have a much larger pension.

This is most fairly achieved by pooling all resources, using these to pay all joint costs like mortgage, bills, childcare, groceries etc and then splitting what's left 50/50. Using a percentage system doesn't work when there's a large disparity in earnings because he'll still be left with loads more spending money than her.

Her job isn't necessarily easier/lower stress/shorter hours due to lower pay, many low paid jobs are high stress and irregular/long hours plus what if she was also a lawyer? They'd likely both be working longer hours, more childcare would be needed, plus he'd need to do more at home that she's likely doing more of now.

Worldgonecrazy · 12/07/2022 07:24

I think you are a good friend who wants to help. The only fair way to pool income is by ratio. So if she earns £20k and he earns £80 k she should be paying 20% if all bills and he 80%. Then what is left should be discussed jointly, whether to split equally or on a different ratio.

It will be interesting to see what happens when she no longer has childcare costs, and if her husband suddenly decides she should pay towards the bills!

110APiccadilly · 12/07/2022 07:06

Up to them to make their own financial arrangements I suppose. I find it sad that it's so normal for couples to have shared life/ house/ children but not finances, but you can't make people do it.

Salvia89 · 12/07/2022 07:02

Thanks all!

Interesting thread and glad I asked. In other finance split threads (where the situation is usually a million times worse than this) nearly everyone replies that they pool resources then split once you are married/have DC. It’s interesting to see here that lots of you don’t do that and are happy.

Tbh it still doesn’t sit right with me, especially as her lack of funds is due to DC. She suffers for having DC and he doesn’t. He’s obviously not transferring her much extra money (more likely she’s just not asking) when she’s skint when he’s obviously not.

I’ve not bought it up twice.. she has. She wasn’t blowing £200 one one meal out.. at that point she had even less per month, as was at the end of mat leave. I won’t bring it up again out of the blue, but if she complains about lack of cash again I’ll tell her that it doesn’t seem fair and mention how I do it (pooling). She’s one of my oldest friends so don’t think she’ll be offended by my comment.

OP posts:
BalloonsAndWhistles · 12/07/2022 05:36

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/07/2022 22:14

Yep, you are her mate, and she is being financially abused. Take her out to lunch, tell her what the norm is (you don’t need to make it the purpose of the lunch, but I think you should say - I’ve been wanting to raise this as your arrangement is unusual, and it may not be the best thing for uou), and then just say it’s normal for a couple to have joint finances and pay into a pot that covers everything on a percentage basis)

I think the percentage thing is weird. Everything just goes into a big pot here and all bills come out of it, including our (equal) personal spends.

Lanareyrey · 12/07/2022 02:18

I think people get confused on what financial abuse actually is...

Seywot · 12/07/2022 01:56

What if finances dictated decisions? Tom pays for the mortgage so he looks into best ones in his opinion and gets on with it without too much involvement from Emma. Emma chooses the nursery and childcare arrangements that work for her and Tom respects her decision making.

Appleblum · 12/07/2022 01:49

She's not being financially abused. Her husband pays for everything else and she has access to her own money. He also helps her out when she asks him for money.

£200 is about £50 a week to spend on stuff not already budgeted for. Many people manage on that! But I agree it is not a lot and she could perhaps ask her DH for a monthly contribution towards the childcare costs so that she does not have to approach him for money every month.

DarkCharlotte · 12/07/2022 01:47

He is financially abusing her & neglecting to pay for his own child's care

Yet keeping a very nice home over their head, paying for holidays and meals and the majority of the family bills. Such neglect I've never seen in my life 🙄

Just because he doesn't pay for the childcare, doesn't mean he isn't supporting his children's care in other ways financially. Likewise, is OP neglecting to pay for her child's care/security because she doesn't contribute to the mortgage? No?

Swipe left for the next trending thread