Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
Bonheurdupasse · 11/07/2022 23:06

You have to understand that on a wider European, let alone global scale, being able to be a SAHM is something restricted to a small subset of women, social class wise, in a small subset of countries (country wealth wise).
Hence the reaction from other people who look on at the phenomenon.

amicissimma · 11/07/2022 23:06

I think a lot of people on MN think that the only contribution of value to a relationship is financial.

My DH and I did not bring children into the relationship until we were financially stable - both of us contributed to that. When I became a SAHM we both insured that I had a pension and savings in my name, which was also advantageous from a tax POV. The house was in both names. I probably understood our financial situation slightly better than DH because I was in charge of day-to-day admin.

If we had split or one of us had died, I would have been in roughly the same financial position as DH because of the way our finances are arranged, but he would have been in a worse position than me because I knew how all the children's lives and life admin worked and he didn't.

But we both valued the other's contribution to the relationship. And we worked as a team in the best interests of the whole family. So many people on here seem to be in some kind of competition with their OH, which looks stressful to me.

dworky · 11/07/2022 23:05

Hold on, you're not 'living off a man' if you're caring for a child. He couldn't work without childcare so his wage belongs to both parents (or her wage if he does the childcare).

iabr · 11/07/2022 23:04

I'm not talking about myself. I'm not a SAHM as I said. It's about MN and the accepted discourse on here about SAHMs.

If a.SAHM comes on and tells you she is financially vulnerable, then by all means give her advice in that context.,

But if a SAHM tells you she is not financially vulnerable - then just accept that and stop insisting she is!

OP posts:
Cyclebabble · 11/07/2022 23:02

I have posted previously about having the reverse problem. In my family my DH has only worked for around three years. I absolutely wanted him to, but he could not get on with colleagues/managers at work and having walked out a series of jobs early on he felt it was important that he had the right job to go back to. Many years later the right job never quite turned up. There have been positives. He did stop at home after I went back from Mat leave and he did do the school runs and other things. TBH though, after they were all at school I have struggled to understand what he spends more than say a day a week on. I work, sometimes under quite a lot of pressure. His weekdays do not- Pilates, hobby classes and at least one weekday pub trip make up a typical week.

I do not criticise anyone who stays at home, but IME sometimes this does feel like a good deal for one partner- and not the other.

iabr · 11/07/2022 23:00

FrangipaniBlue - do the women who can't afford childcare still not work once the children start school though? I'm not talking about SAHMs who take a couple years out because iIf the prohibitive cost of childcare. This is quite common. Leave it to the individual to assess the risk and how this will affect her career. Regardless, a few years out is not the same as being a longer-term SAHM ten years (in which case you're almost certainly never going back to what you did before) or never returning U.K. work at all.

OP posts:
Joyfultoes · 11/07/2022 22:58

@iabr so basically this whole thread was just for you to tell everyone that you’re so wealthy you’re not financially vulnerable. Good for you

ShirleyPhallus · 11/07/2022 22:55

iabr · 11/07/2022 22:49

"It’s incredibly unlikely that if a woman has taken 5-10 years out of her career to look after children that she’ll still have the same prospects to get back in to the workforce. Very sad but it’s true."

Again, it totally depends. What is to say she even wanted to go back to what she did before? That's rarely the plan with SAHMs who take decades out. As if they're going to expect to just get back in where they left off. They're not. They usually retrain or do something else. Or they're in a financial situation where they don't have to work and it would make no difference if they did do the whole conversation is irrelevant.

You are absolutely naively deluded if you think that women can easily take 5-10 years off and be able to enter the workforce again in a new industry or role at the same or more money than they made before. It just doesn’t happen.

If they’re so wealthy from having a rich husband that they have a silly little job just for entertainment then I still believe that power imbalance is a huge thing.

ComtesseDeSpair · 11/07/2022 22:52

In general, if a woman tells you she has good reasons for not working, just listen to her and accept what she says. She understands her situation better than you.

I think you’d be surprised how many women think they are secure when they actually aren’t. A surprising number of women simply don’t realise or understand that they are vulnerable: belief in common law marriage / that if you’ve been living together for X number of years it’s the same as being legally married and you have the same rights comes up more frequently than you’d imagine on MN threads; as does the erroneous belief that if a woman has children she’s legally entitled to stay in the family home until they are 18, and that her husband will be ordered to pay for it.

Some women will, of course, be correct in their assessment of their own security. But don’t necessarily assume it, just because they’ve told you they don’t need to worry.

ShandaLear · 11/07/2022 22:52

The minute you rely on someone else to support you, you are vulnerable. That’s not rocket science.

FrangipaniBlue · 11/07/2022 22:52

Sorry OP but I think you're living in a very privileged bubble.

I don't know a single SAHM who is either a) independently wealthy or b) married to a wealthy man.

Every single SAHM I know does so because the are average middle of the road income families where the cost of childcare far outweighs the woman's earning potential and so they stay at home.

THIS is the "norm".

Without exception ALL of the independently wealthy women I know all work full time.

it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence

I'm not sure you fully understand what the word "independence" means.

iabr · 11/07/2022 22:49

"It’s incredibly unlikely that if a woman has taken 5-10 years out of her career to look after children that she’ll still have the same prospects to get back in to the workforce. Very sad but it’s true."

Again, it totally depends. What is to say she even wanted to go back to what she did before? That's rarely the plan with SAHMs who take decades out. As if they're going to expect to just get back in where they left off. They're not. They usually retrain or do something else. Or they're in a financial situation where they don't have to work and it would make no difference if they did do the whole conversation is irrelevant.

OP posts:
ApplesandBunions · 11/07/2022 22:43

iabr · 11/07/2022 21:39

"No, but not having a job almost always means a lack of financial security."

No it does not.

This is what I mean. Never assume.

Many SAHMs are only SAHMs because they are possibly some of the least financially insecure women in the U.K.

Yet in MN they are always told they MUST be financially vulnerable.

Nah, not 'many'. More than zero, yes. But no, MNers not caveating discussion with obviously you may be one of an extremely small group of independently wealthy people isn't actually a problem that needs solving.

iabr · 11/07/2022 22:42

additional needs - not adoption !

OP posts:
iabr · 11/07/2022 22:41

"Your example of the £m friend is a complete outlier compared to the average woman"

My whole point is that 'the average woman' is generally not a SAHM! She might be for a year or two, but what I'm talking about is women who SAH for much longer periods, or never work again after children. These are not generally 'average' families making decisions in the context of average incomes. Or even higher incomes.

No SAHM I know has taken the risk of living if a fixed 'income" - ie his income. It's rarely as simple as that.

These families may only account for the wealthiest 0.5% or some such families in the U.K, - of course. I'm by no means claiming long term SAHMs are typical in the population. My point is that it's within that demographic that long term SAHMs (aka women who don't need to work) will be most heavily represented.

The other type of long-term SAHM will be someone who can't work - either due to children with adoption so needs perhaps, or health issues. In these cases, it's even more disingenuous to rant about how financially vulnerable they are as SAHMs.

Just find out the specific circumstances. In general, if a woman tells you she has good reasons for not working, just listen to her and accept what she says. She understands her situation better than you. That's all I'm saying and why I'm posting, basically.

OP posts:
Joyfultoes · 11/07/2022 22:39

This is what I mean - assumptions. How do you know someone only has MW jobs ahead of them for life? They could literally be anyone and have done anything before!

I’m totally lost as to the point you’re making op. It seems to be ‘don’t use an average person as an example when discussing financial vulnerability as they may in fact be a really wealthy person.’

if so I’d say to you….wtf?

AntlerRose · 11/07/2022 22:37

I do think its worth remembering not all sahm gave up careers with lots of earning potential. Many will have been in a minimum wage jobs anyway which is why childcare was prohibitive.

ShirleyPhallus · 11/07/2022 22:34

iabr · 11/07/2022 22:23

"If you have half the cost of a house and no income you’re still pretty fucked if you split. There’s only minimum wage jobs ahead of you for life."

This is what I mean - assumptions. How do you know someone only has MW jobs ahead of them for life? They could literally be anyone and have done anything before!

It’s incredibly unlikely that if a woman has taken 5-10 years out of her career to look after children that she’ll still have the same prospects to get back in to the workforce. Very sad but it’s true.

Crazycrazylady · 11/07/2022 22:33

I think it's really important that women (and men) are always in a position to support themselves ion their own ( if it came to it) as no one knows what the fixture holds.
Marriages can break down. Spouses can get sick or die..

Lots of sahp who let their skills lapse run the risk of struggling to support themselves and their families on their own if they had to ..
I'm not sure why you're getting so annoyed by that fast:

RoseslnTheHospital · 11/07/2022 22:31

iabr · 11/07/2022 22:23

"If you have half the cost of a house and no income you’re still pretty fucked if you split. There’s only minimum wage jobs ahead of you for life."

This is what I mean - assumptions. How do you know someone only has MW jobs ahead of them for life? They could literally be anyone and have done anything before!

Because in the absence of any other information, this is an accurate summary of the situation. Attempting to get a decent job after several years, decades of not working is not easy.

You are taking offence at people making accurate points. If I were a SAHM posting about my relationship and other posters said I was financially vulnerable when I wasn't, I would explain why I wasn't and that would be the end of it. Or, if I were vulnerable I would accept that I was taking a risk on the goodwill of my partner/husband. No need to take massive offence over reasonable assumptions made by strangers.

StClare101 · 11/07/2022 22:25

There are threads on here at least weekly of women who are trapped due to finances and can’t leave. So yes, not working does mean a certain level of financial vulnerability, particularly if not married.

iabr · 11/07/2022 22:23

"If you have half the cost of a house and no income you’re still pretty fucked if you split. There’s only minimum wage jobs ahead of you for life."

This is what I mean - assumptions. How do you know someone only has MW jobs ahead of them for life? They could literally be anyone and have done anything before!

OP posts:
Lovemypeaceandquiet · 11/07/2022 22:22

I wouldn’t use middle class scenario to justify stating how financially secure SAHMs are @iabr

According to sciencedaily.com , 25% of British society can be classed as middle class, and 6% as upper class.

You example only applies to about 1/3 of society.

“Save the Children estimates there are over 870,000 stay-at-home mums in England who would prefer to work if they could arrange good quality childcare which is convenient, reliable and affordable.

The figures, which are based on new analysis of the Department for Education’s Childcare and early years survey of parents in England, also show that childcare issues are the number one barrier preventing mums from working.” Source

ShirleyPhallus · 11/07/2022 22:22

iabr · 11/07/2022 22:16

My point is, that in AIBU, SAHMs are constantly being told they are financially vulnerable.

If they reply, "er, thanks for the concern, but I'm not," nobody will have it and they are just told they are. Cue post upon post about the DH will leave them; probably already having an affair; they will never work again; they have no pension...., It becomes a pile on usually, and it's very clear that people just project their own circumstances - eg. if I were a SAHM I would be / feel financially vulnerable, therefore it must be so for everyone...,

I'm not denying many women ARE financially vulnerable. But it's never as simple as just having a job versus not having a job. It depends what the job is , but more importantly, what the underlying wealth is.

As I say, if a SAHM tells you she is not financially vulnerable, just accept that and stop insisting she is!

I only thought this today as a lady so know is recently divorced and she's walked away with millions having been a SAHM for about 14 years. She was a teacher before. If she needs to get back to work in the future, it's not going to be impossible. She knew where she stood financially and this is why she was a SAHM. But if she had been on here she would have been patronised and told she was financially vulnerable. I am not a SAHM anymore but was for about a decade. I work for myself part/time from home, as do probably most women I know who have returned to work after a gap. It's not always doom and gloom like it's made out to be on here.

As I say, if a SAHM tells you she is not financially vulnerable, just accept that and stop insisting she is!

SAHMs are MORE financially vulnerable than women who are independently wealthy.

Your example of the £m friend is a complete outlier compared to the average woman

User112 · 11/07/2022 22:21

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

Yes I do. At anyone exploiting a partner to have a lifestyle beyond their means.