Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
Topgub · 16/07/2022 14:59

@BessieFinkNottle

So do wp. Who also have caring responsibilities.

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 14:50

Not being in paid employment doesn't have to mean you're not working, it simply means you're not paid for your work.
Lots of SAHPs work very hard indeed.

Topgub · 16/07/2022 14:03

@BessieFinkNottle

I said if they choose not to work, then they most likely don't have a great work ethic.

They're choosing not to work. It's kind of a given

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 13:32

@Topgub

Caring for dependents may or may not be relevant to a conversation about employment, depending on circumstances. It's certainly relevant to a conversation about work ethic though.

You said upthread you believe that SAHPs - because they're not in paid employment - most probably have a poorer work ethic. Simply put, I don't accept this assumption.

Topgub · 16/07/2022 12:38

Caring for dependents is part of life. No one gets paid for it. (If you don't count carers allowance)

Its hard work at times but it's not relevant to conversations about employment.

5128gap · 16/07/2022 11:52

AppleCharlottie · 16/07/2022 11:24

If you are a carer, either for your own child or for someone else, I'm sure there are few people who would suggest you don't work very hard.
But that is a particular circumstance, and different from SAHMs who are not also carers.
Quite frankly, unless they have a particularly demanding partner who believes himself entitled to a certain level of return for his support, those in the latter category can work as hard or not as they please. We all have to run homes. If you have all day to spend on it, you could make a pretty easy life for yourself if you chose. (And once again, that doesn't mean you personally if you are also a carer)

@5128gap I have to say, it's not just people with disabled children who work hard. Looking after babies and young children is hard work too, especially if you have more than one.

Parents of very young children, and of children with additional needs, make up a significant proportion of SAHPs, I would think.

Also, many mothers I know tend to work part-time while their children are in primary school (which finishes at approx 1.30pm for 5 and 6 year olds or 2.30pm for 7 -13 year olds here.) It does still seem to be mostly mothers who go part-time unfortunately, although this is changing slowly.

Yes, I don't disagree. All this really arose from a poster portraying a very different lifestyle, and congratulating themselves on their superiority in choosing a life of ease.
I don't think that poster, or indeed the OP with her descriptions of SAHMs as wealthy privileged women, living the dream, has done much to demonstrate that though.

AppleCharlottie · 16/07/2022 11:24

If you are a carer, either for your own child or for someone else, I'm sure there are few people who would suggest you don't work very hard.
But that is a particular circumstance, and different from SAHMs who are not also carers.
Quite frankly, unless they have a particularly demanding partner who believes himself entitled to a certain level of return for his support, those in the latter category can work as hard or not as they please. We all have to run homes. If you have all day to spend on it, you could make a pretty easy life for yourself if you chose. (And once again, that doesn't mean you personally if you are also a carer)

@5128gap I have to say, it's not just people with disabled children who work hard. Looking after babies and young children is hard work too, especially if you have more than one.

Parents of very young children, and of children with additional needs, make up a significant proportion of SAHPs, I would think.

Also, many mothers I know tend to work part-time while their children are in primary school (which finishes at approx 1.30pm for 5 and 6 year olds or 2.30pm for 7 -13 year olds here.) It does still seem to be mostly mothers who go part-time unfortunately, although this is changing slowly.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/07/2022 11:07

@BessieFinkNottle

I think the comments about lack of work ethic etc are not directed at you. They were primarily directed at @Comedycook with her simplistic and insulting assessment of the motives behind mothers who work.

Nobody is suggesting that there is anything reprehensible about raising your children FT. They are (well I am) saying that women who work mostly don’t do so to fund frivolous things like fast cars and other status symbols. And that anyone suggesting otherwise is either stupid or being deliberately antagonistic.

5128gap · 16/07/2022 10:57

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 10:23

But it stands to reason if you've chosen to not work you probably have less work ethic.

But this is my point - please listen.
I haven't chosen not to work.
I just don't get paid for the work I do.

And some people do have fewer choices than others, that's hardly news.

If you are a carer, either for your own child or for someone else, I'm sure there are few people who would suggest you don't work very hard.
But that is a particular circumstance, and different from SAHMs who are not also carers.
Quite frankly, unless they have a particularly demanding partner who believes himself entitled to a certain level of return for his support, those in the latter category can work as hard or not as they please. We all have to run homes. If you have all day to spend on it, you could make a pretty easy life for yourself if you chose. (And once again, that doesn't mean you personally if you are also a carer)

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 10:41

Fair enough @5128gap.

I understand what you mean.

Others obviously do think SAHPs are rejecting a work ethic (eg @Topgub) so it's sometimes not clear what people are saying exactly. Thanks for your clarification.

Snoredoeurve · 16/07/2022 10:34

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 10:23

But it stands to reason if you've chosen to not work you probably have less work ethic.

But this is my point - please listen.
I haven't chosen not to work.
I just don't get paid for the work I do.

And some people do have fewer choices than others, that's hardly news.

Strawman though.
You havent rejected the work ethic whilst going around stating women who WOH do it to buy flash designer goods ( such a 90s argument!) and taking a moralistic tone.
Its been recognised that many women have no choice but thats not what was being referred to here.

missdemeanors · 16/07/2022 10:23

I'm not sure @Comedycook did say a partner was financing her to potter around. She mentioned later she'd worked FT, PT, and been a SAHM. It's possible she earned shedloads and made good investments during the job she 'hated.' If that was the case, She obviously didn't count herself among the 'more more more' brigade.
One things clear: she's completely incapable of applying any logic to her posts

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 10:23

But it stands to reason if you've chosen to not work you probably have less work ethic.

But this is my point - please listen.
I haven't chosen not to work.
I just don't get paid for the work I do.

And some people do have fewer choices than others, that's hardly news.

5128gap · 16/07/2022 10:18

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 10:05

I accept that.

What I don't accept is that my DH (and others like him) are doing this because I (and other SAHPs) "reject a work ethic".

I work very hard but it's unpaid work.
And that's not always a choice either. Not really.

I didn't say you rejected a work ethic.
@Comedycook said they did.
Unless you are allowing a man to support you simply because you prefer to 'potter around' ( in that poster's own words) all the time judging yourself superior to those who work because of your lack of materialism, there is nothing in that comment to offend you.

Topgub · 16/07/2022 10:09

@BessieFinkNottle

I think there's often more choice than people are willing to acknowledge.

I havent commented on your work ethic.

But it stands to reason if you've chosen to not work you probably have less work ethic.

If it genuinely wasn't a choice then most of this discussion isn't even relevant to you.

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 10:05

Topgub · 16/07/2022 09:55

@BessieFinkNottle

Someone is funding their lifestyle.

Anyone who doesn't work needs someone to fund that lifestyle choice.

I accept that.

What I don't accept is that my DH (and others like him) are doing this because I (and other SAHPs) "reject a work ethic".

I work very hard but it's unpaid work.
And that's not always a choice either. Not really.

Topgub · 16/07/2022 09:55

@BessieFinkNottle

Someone is funding their lifestyle.

Anyone who doesn't work needs someone to fund that lifestyle choice.

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 09:49

@missdemeanors Yes, I know it's intended in reply to a pp, but @Comedycook never said anything about having a partner subsidising her lifestyle (did she?)
SAHPs on the other hand are supported financially by their partners so those comments cut a bit close to the bone.

ReneBumsWombats · 16/07/2022 09:46

Ah yes, men work for mortgages and food and shoes for the kids, while women work for Botox and Jimmy Choos. I forgot about that.

missdemeanors · 16/07/2022 09:39

@BessieFinkNottle no one is saying you don't. They're commenting on an offensive post claiming that people who work are doing it because they are materialistic and just want more more more.

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 09:37

or insist upon a man subsiding my choice to reject the work ethic (for myself, not him, obviously).

Lots of SAHPs, particularly those with young children, or disabled chikdren, don't spend their days "pottering" either. They work very hard. I don't work within the home, rather than outside it, because I "reject a work ethic"!

Snoredoeurve · 16/07/2022 09:32

So, if I wanted to 'potter around' my choices would be to either top up my income with benefits, taken from the pot quite unnecessarily because I am fully able to work full time; or insist upon a man subsiding my choice to reject the work ethic (for myself, not him, obviously).
Neither of which sits easily with me.

Ah yes the men are allowed a work ethic but of course they are not doing it for flash cars or designer handbags.

Thats a real 90s attitude, all SITC and splurging your wages on shoes and leaving your poor little children wrings hands
Most people I know are both WOH to provide for their families and for their pension.
How will you manage your pension @Comedycook ?
The CII report I mentioned above shows that many women are woefully unprepared.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/07/2022 09:20

@5128gap

Thank you for articulating this in a way I was too angry to manage 😀

5128gap · 16/07/2022 09:16

Comedycook · 15/07/2022 23:30

I've never enjoyed working....even pre kids, I hated it. I was academically able and had the potential to have a successful career but it's never appealed to me. I just don't care enough. I'd rather have less money and more time. I'd rather potter round the house and have less material possessions than work full time and have a flash car and designer shit...the world is so superficial. We are sold the lie that our worth is measured by our possessions. I haven't fallen for it. A lot of you have though.

I don't value material possessions either. But I need to eat, house myself and my dependents, and provide a means for us to participate in our community, and for the children I chose to bring into the world to have the resources to access at least some of the opportunities it offers.
Unfortunately within the sector I chose to work (third sector, because making a positive difference to others is one way i measure worth) the pay is poor, and there are no part time jobs that would enable me to afford to do these things.
So, if I wanted to 'potter around' my choices would be to either top up my income with benefits, taken from the pot quite unnecessarily because I am fully able to work full time; or insist upon a man subsiding my choice to reject the work ethic (for myself, not him, obviously).
Neither of which sits easily with me.
You have obviously found a way to have a lifestyle that suits you, which is excellent. But you really haven't gained some special insight into what 'really matters' that the rest of the gullible herd haven't hit on.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/07/2022 09:10

@missdemeanors

I try to make it an iron rule to be civil and respectful to posters on these sorts of threads but I cannot hide my contempt for people who lack the intelligence to grasp that sometimes people need to work to support their children.

Invariably the people who come out with this sort of shit are from wealthy backgrounds and have never been touched by financial concerns.

Swipe left for the next trending thread