Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
ApplesandBunions · 12/07/2022 10:47

iabr · 12/07/2022 10:40

But that's skewed logic ApplesandBunions, because people generally only post on AIBU or Relationships when they are in problematic circumstances. This goes for SAHMs or women in general or who work in any capacity.

People don't post to say "Hi, just thought I'd let you know, I have an amazing husband, my kids are doing brilliantly, we are mega millionaires and I don't work. I spend my life doing exactly what I want. AIBU?"

Nobody could ever post that because they would be accused of "stealth bragging" (well not even stealth), or being "tone deaf."

But you can't possibly extrapolate what you may read on the Relationships board as a definite truth about all SAHMs everywhere. It's skewed logic. Of course not all SAHMs are financially vulnerable with hideous husbands. Those SAHMs are just not posting on Relationships or AIBU because they have nothing to ask.

The cohort of people posting about their circumstances on MN is exactly who we're talking about, though, so this doesn't remotely wash either.

Honestly, you had some decent points about use of language and about it being structural factors that make SAHPs vulnerable. Those are valid. Then you drag them down with obvious nonsense.

Wollycraft66 · 12/07/2022 10:45

@iabr

Even if perfectly happy SAHM (like me!) do post, we get told that we actually aren’t happy and we just don’t know it lol. Or that we’re vulnerable and don’t know it (because no SAHM could possibly know anything about her families finance seeing as we all git hitched up straight of daddy’s farm at 18).

Dont sweat it, as a SAHM whatever you post here will be pulled apart by the bitters. Enjoy your life and family and don’t let the bitters get you down babe.

iabr · 12/07/2022 10:40

But that's skewed logic ApplesandBunions, because people generally only post on AIBU or Relationships when they are in problematic circumstances. This goes for SAHMs or women in general or who work in any capacity.

People don't post to say "Hi, just thought I'd let you know, I have an amazing husband, my kids are doing brilliantly, we are mega millionaires and I don't work. I spend my life doing exactly what I want. AIBU?"

Nobody could ever post that because they would be accused of "stealth bragging" (well not even stealth), or being "tone deaf."

But you can't possibly extrapolate what you may read on the Relationships board as a definite truth about all SAHMs everywhere. It's skewed logic. Of course not all SAHMs are financially vulnerable with hideous husbands. Those SAHMs are just not posting on Relationships or AIBU because they have nothing to ask.

OP posts:
alphapie · 12/07/2022 10:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hmm
Wollycraft66 · 12/07/2022 10:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ApplesandBunions · 12/07/2022 10:30

ComtesseDeSpair · 12/07/2022 10:29

Apart from your rather specious example of a former teacher married to a multimillionaire, who knows she’ll probably do alright if she gets divorced, I’m not sure where you’re getting all here examples of SAHMs who insist they aren’t financially vulnerable and are correct you’re referring to.

What’s far more common on MN is women who don’t think they’re vulnerable “because I know my DH would never ever cheat, he can’t stand cheaters” or “DH has always said he’d make sure me and the kids are looked after if we split up and I trust him” or “if we do split up I know I’m legally entitled to stay in the family home until the DC are 18 because that’s what happened to my friend when her marriage ended”; none of which are quite the same as a woman understanding her own situation well.

Yup. And sure there are some posters on MN who are SAHPs with significant assets of their own, there's at least one who crops up a lot talking about how it's the norm in their circle. But it's quite clear what's more common on here.

ComtesseDeSpair · 12/07/2022 10:29

Apart from your rather specious example of a former teacher married to a multimillionaire, who knows she’ll probably do alright if she gets divorced, I’m not sure where you’re getting all here examples of SAHMs who insist they aren’t financially vulnerable and are correct you’re referring to.

What’s far more common on MN is women who don’t think they’re vulnerable “because I know my DH would never ever cheat, he can’t stand cheaters” or “DH has always said he’d make sure me and the kids are looked after if we split up and I trust him” or “if we do split up I know I’m legally entitled to stay in the family home until the DC are 18 because that’s what happened to my friend when her marriage ended”; none of which are quite the same as a woman understanding her own situation well.

ApplesandBunions · 12/07/2022 10:24

iabr · 12/07/2022 10:15

ApplesandBunions - if a woman tells you she is not financially vulnerable, then who are you to tell her otherwise, just based on the one fact you know about her, that she is a SAHM? Can you not see how that insistence could come across as patronising? Why would you think you understand her situation better than her? I find that so odd.

Because it's a fact that there have been lots of threads on here over the years from SAHPs (and others, if that makes it easier for you to accept, but we're talking about SAHPs) who were incorrect about their level of vulnerability. People can and do get this stuff wrong all the time. Now admittedly I do have some professional experience in this area, so it's not quite an even comparison, but that's the point really. Not everyone's assessment is equally valid.

And the idea that this is typically happening based on nothing more than the person having said they're a SAHP won't wash either. It's not like people typically post that and nothing else. It might have happened at some point, but no, this isn't a problem that needs addressing on MN.

iabr · 12/07/2022 10:15

ApplesandBunions - if a woman tells you she is not financially vulnerable, then who are you to tell her otherwise, just based on the one fact you know about her, that she is a SAHM? Can you not see how that insistence could come across as patronising? Why would you think you understand her situation better than her? I find that so odd.

OP posts:
ApplesandBunions · 12/07/2022 10:05

You'd have done better not tying a valid point about spiteful use of language to the frankly daft insistence that a SAHP who considers herself not financially vulnerable must be presumed correct.

ImAvingOops · 12/07/2022 10:01

I think feeling sensitive it reasonable if someone has called you a leech or said you have no self respect for being a sahm

alphapie · 12/07/2022 09:58

iabr · 12/07/2022 09:36

No it is definitely sneering in AIBU. It creeps into every SAHM thread. Loaded phrases such as 'leeches,' 'no self-respect,' 'little woman,' 'the 1950s' 'brain dead' - I could go on. All on AIBU in recent weeks.

If people want a discussion about structural inequality there is no need use spiteful language. The difference is glaringly obvious.

If you see people making those comments report their posts, there are mean people everywhere, no need to get so sensitive about it

iabr · 12/07/2022 09:36

No it is definitely sneering in AIBU. It creeps into every SAHM thread. Loaded phrases such as 'leeches,' 'no self-respect,' 'little woman,' 'the 1950s' 'brain dead' - I could go on. All on AIBU in recent weeks.

If people want a discussion about structural inequality there is no need use spiteful language. The difference is glaringly obvious.

OP posts:
Takeme2thebeach · 12/07/2022 09:32

Op, most of the time people don’t RTFT and that’s why they go on and on about financial vulnerability. A lot of posters will just read the first post. Then the op posts they are financially secure later
Many sahp on here, that come for advice, are vulnerable. I’m on here loads and have lost track of those who are unmarried and given up their careers and then their partner dumps them.
If an op put that in the event they split they would still be rich beyond their wildest dreams, then those posting otherwise are just assuming they are the more typical sahp on here ( and not reading)

InChocolateWeTrust · 12/07/2022 09:28

I don't think it's sneering. It's usually just expressing comcern that so many women end up in a precarious financial situation.

This

I've also seen threads where a woman wants to remain a housewife, and it's clear their partner/husband isn't really willing to support them to not work (particularly with older children). In those cases people will tend to advise that it's not sustainable (or fair) to continue refusing to work for an income unless your partner is happy to support you financially.

ImAvingOops · 12/07/2022 09:23

Fucking phone

ImAvingOops · 12/07/2022 09:23

Some salary = sole salary. For some reason my autocorrect doesn't recognise some as a word!

iabr · 12/07/2022 09:22

I would agree with you though MangshorJhol. You just described just a couple of differing scenarios and this is my whole point. There is no typical. Like I said, if someone (SAHM or working) posts about being financially vulnerable, then comment / advise accordingly. But equally, if a SAHM (or anyone) tells you she is not financially vulnerable, then just accept that and, for want if a better expression, put a sock in it. No need to declare or speculate or or lecture her about what her must children must surely think; or what her husband wants or thinks; or random anecdotes about Bob the office who left his wife or whatever.

OP posts:
ImAvingOops · 12/07/2022 09:21

Well yes, but women attack each other for making choices according to their own circumstances and preferences instead of appreciating that the real problem isn't the choices that women are making.

There is an imbalance in the amount of mental load and house stuff women do, irrespective of whether they sah or work full time. Arguably sah evens things up a bit in that the woman is refusing to be responsible for everything - earning money and all the thinking/doing for the house and kids?

I don't really get the argument that childcare is a shared expense and that women need to stop offsetting the cost against their some salary. It's still money gone from the household income, however you slice and dice it. Some people consider it an investment for future earnings, some can't afford to make the choice and some would prefer the easier home life of not balancing 2 jobs along with raising kids.

Fairislefandango · 12/07/2022 09:08

I still come back to the view that it isn't sah which makes people vulnerable, more society's reluctance to hold men responsible for their children post divorce. This is what allows them to screw over the mothers of their children.

Yes but a woman can't change society's attitude, she can only control her own circumstances (to a certain extent). Besides, it's not only divorce which can put you in that position - also life-limiting illness or loss of a partner etc.

MangshorJhol · 12/07/2022 09:05

Also I think it’s fine what your OWN individual circumstances but you are as at the same risk of sweeping generalisations that you are accusing others of.

I would bet a lot of money that SAHM or WOHM most marriages involve a considerable level of power imbalance. This is why women do the invisible labour. The mental load that women carry. The last minute school costume? Presents for Christmas? MN is literally full of threads where women go above and beyond in the holiday season with their useless partners doing the bare minimum. That’s an imbalance.

There is a lot of research on how when BOTH men and women work the same hours, women still do the majority of the housework. It’s called double duty. That’s an imbalance.

There is also research cited above about women who would like to work but can’t because of the cost of childcare (which means that childcare is seen as the woman’s job- not a cost that comes out of the family income). That’s an imbalance.

These power imbalances are well documented. Your saying that it doesn’t apply to you…means it doesn’t apply to YOU. It applies to many many many people (as the research demonstrates).

MangshorJhol · 12/07/2022 08:59

I know plenty of women who after their kids go to school find it hard to get back into the workplace. This is a combination of time- if you take 7/8 years off finding a job is not easy.
If you then don’t need a job/can work PT only then your family finances are such that you belong to an uber wealthy subset.

The reality is that for many women with average qualifications the problem is that even when kids go to school there are school holidays and school hours and finding a job that fits around that (usually with a husband who does much less housework) is impossible. Especially when you have been out of the work force.

ImAvingOops · 12/07/2022 08:48

I don't feel like a 'kept woman' - I feel like a woman who is in a partnership, where we each contribute different things!
He provided the money and I provided childcare and the security of never having to worry about work when the kids were sick/school holidays.

I certainly don't feel unequal or as if there's a power imbalance.

I think there are a lot of women in awful relationships where sah would make their lives worse but there are also plenty of dual income families where neither can afford to leave - you need to earn a fair bit to maintain a home and children as a single person.

I still come back to the view that it isn't sah which makes people vulnerable, more society's reluctance to hold men responsible for their children post divorce. This is what allows them to screw over the mothers of their children.

AntlerRose · 12/07/2022 08:06

SofiaSoFar · 12/07/2022 07:20

I quite agree.

It's absolutely not the case that, "Without her he could not pursue his career". Just another trope that's often repeated on these threads with little basis.

The more common scenario where the SAHM is trapped is one where the man doesn't have much of a career, either.

For "men with careers" there's often more money around which funds childcare and better enables the female to also maintain/return to her career.

I disagree with this. I know two widowers who really struggled to maintain their careers because the cost of childcare that allows you the level of flexibility needed for some careers is so high. These men were also completley comfortable with the child's mother doing bedtime every night etc but felt unable to leave it to staff so had to stall/change careers, both had to move to cheaper homes.

I also think a lot of men build their careers during the early years of parenthood rather than having the career in plac, so they havent yet got the big income. Even if they have good childcare in place and a working spouse, they still rely heavily on the working spouse /sahm to do much more of the nursery drop offs, overnights when he is in a trip etc. My dh lived in another country to build his career, only coming back every oher weekend. He was totally reliant on me to do all the wrap around etc. If i stopped he would have been stuck at a much lower career point.

I think a lot women facilitate their partners careers and this is rarely acknowledged.

iabr · 12/07/2022 07:54

power imbalance!

OP posts: