Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
MrsBwced · 12/07/2022 14:19

Oh if we're doing anecdotes,
I've got a friend who desperately wants to get divorced but can't afford a house and childcare on her own, so they are living miserably together. They both work full time but overstretched on the house and don't want to downgrade or leave school catchment.

I've got another friend who split with her husband. She was a SAHM, he worked two minimum wage jobs. She moved into rented accommodation, got a place at university, got a council house and is about to start a job. She's really happy.

ShirleyPhallus · 12/07/2022 14:17

MrsBwced · 12/07/2022 14:02

some SAHMs aren’t in control of budgets and money but receive an allowance - vulnerable
some SAHMs are treated as skivvies by their husbands and do a proportionally higher amount of work

These two can happen to anyone regardless of employment, someone who is financially abusive will control all income including what the other person has earned.
If we're going to use MN threads as evidence there are loads of threads about couples where the woman is doing 99% of all the childcare and household stuff on top of working full time. Which funnily enough is an argument often used against SAHP when they say "I do all childcare and household stuff" the scornful reply from the WOHP is usually "I do all that and work"

That’s why I said “some”, but if you have your own job and career you are at least aware of what’s coming in to your bank account. Lots of threads on here show that the man gives the woman an “allowance” and she has little to no idea of what he does with the rest of his salary

ReneBumsWombats · 12/07/2022 14:16

iabr · 12/07/2022 14:01

The main vulnerability comes from no longer having the working parent's income. So a SAHP might not be financially vulnerable while in the relationship, but be extremely vulnerable without it.

And people are seriously suggesting SAHP are unaware of this?

EXACTLY!

Given the number of highly vulnerable women in that very position...

It appears that of those who do get bitten by this, it's not that they didn't know it was theoretically possible, it's that they didn't think it would happen. Can't hurt to reiterate the need for protection.

Of course, if you really are not vulnerable, then this doesn't apply to you and it's hard to see why you'd be so angry about a discussion for those it affects every day. Your life's great and you're safe, so why attack people for trying to warn or assist those who aren't lucky enough to be you?

ReneBumsWombats · 12/07/2022 14:13

iabr · 12/07/2022 12:50

ReneBumsWombats - I did not intervene on a thread by women complaining they are financially vulnerable, to say they are wrong. Ffs. I started the thread for the exact opposite - to try to get people to stop stereotyping! Some SAHMs will indeed be financially vulnerable and those SAHMs are perhaps more likely to be posting on AIBU or relationships. But that cannot be used as an excuse to stereotype all SAHMs. Nor is it an excuse to be spiteful. There is never a need to be spiteful to anyone. Can't stand those sort of posters.

If you want a constructive discussion about SAHMs or women who work PT, try listening with an open mind to the full spectrum of women who do just that. Obviously they are as varied as any other women. If you're only prepared to think about SAHMs as 'vulnerable', that's your prejudice blocking you from a fuller and more realistic understanding.

And in your noble attempt to stop stereotyping, you're ignoring the material reality for most people beyond an exceedingly fortunate few.

Like I said. Posters mention general truths, someone comes in to complain that it doesn't apply to them, is told that in that case they're not among the people being discussed and....tantrum!

Cameleongirl · 12/07/2022 14:10

@FunDragon i agree that working
p-t in your spouse’s business with no legal stake in the business, is very risky and does make you vulnerable.

It’s very different if you’re a part-owner. One of my friend’s went through a brutal divorce, he worked and they also ran a lucrative business on the side. She ran the business while at home with young children and they owned it 50-50. When he left, she bought him out and continues to run it successfully several years later, as she was the real business brain, tbh. She says it makes him angry that she’s succeeded.

Adversity · 12/07/2022 14:04

Taking yourself out of the workplace means getting behind with technology, procedures, training and registration running out in some professions.

Pension issues, you need 35 years for a full state pension, state pension is not that much so unless the family pot can pay for a personal pension for you then it’s not great plus it means no employer contributions to a pension, so always worse.

MrsBwced · 12/07/2022 14:02

some SAHMs aren’t in control of budgets and money but receive an allowance - vulnerable
some SAHMs are treated as skivvies by their husbands and do a proportionally higher amount of work

These two can happen to anyone regardless of employment, someone who is financially abusive will control all income including what the other person has earned.
If we're going to use MN threads as evidence there are loads of threads about couples where the woman is doing 99% of all the childcare and household stuff on top of working full time. Which funnily enough is an argument often used against SAHP when they say "I do all childcare and household stuff" the scornful reply from the WOHP is usually "I do all that and work"

FunDragon · 12/07/2022 14:01

I’ve told this story before on MN. But I have a friend who is a SAHM. Two lovely school age children. Lovely house. She did do paid work before she had the children, but part time in her husband’s business (and it wasn’t really work, it was really just for tax advantages - it was worth using her personal allowance to take more money out of the company without paying tax on it). So everything she had and did was tied up with him.

It won’t be a hugely shocking twist to this story that a couple of years ago she found out he was cheating. Well, specifically she found messages and explicit pictures from another woman on his phone.

It all blew up. He managed to convince her he wasn’t cheating. He absolutely was, he admitted it to other friends, and the content of the messages was pretty clear. But she believed him because she wanted to. She was terrified of any other options.

He also convinced her that it was her fault. She’d been too wrapped up in the kids and hadn’t been keeping him interested in bed. So in addition to everything else, she now has to be mauled in bed every night, doing dirty stuff she doesn’t want to do.

He’s won in every possible way. Imagine cheating on your spouse and being able to convince them it was their fault. And getting them to have more sex with you. He held ALL the cards in that relationship.

I’m not saying that all SAHMs are vulnerable - smart/privileged ones will ensure they minimise their vulnerability as far as they can. My SIL is one. She’s held onto the flat she used to live in, kept it in her own name, and she rents it out. So she has her own income stream/property if she ever needs to tell my BIL to fuck off. She also has a qualification and career history that mean she could walk back into work at the drop of a hat if she needed to. She’s clever, she’s very privileged, and she’s not vulnerable in the slightest.

But I’ve given an example of a woman who was vulnerable. That said, she’s ok. She’s still in the lovely house. Lots of nice things. She gets to spend lots of time with her kids. Maybe in her head, her dignity and a bit of unwanted anal sex are an acceptable price to pay for those privileges. But some proper work history, skills and experience prior to having children, and/or working PT outside her husband’s business, just might have saved her from having to live in such a humiliating way.

iabr · 12/07/2022 14:01

The main vulnerability comes from no longer having the working parent's income. So a SAHP might not be financially vulnerable while in the relationship, but be extremely vulnerable without it.

And people are seriously suggesting SAHP are unaware of this?

EXACTLY!

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 12/07/2022 14:00

Good points, @ShirleyPhallus
although the impact of a spouse dying depends on the life insurance situation. If DH or I die, the surviving spouse will receive a very large payout, we sometimes joke about this when our cooking is questionable. 😂

iabr · 12/07/2022 14:00

Some or all of that may be true ShorleyPhallus, but equally, it may not be.

OP posts:
MrsBwced · 12/07/2022 13:54

The main vulnerability comes from no longer having the working parent's income. So a SAHP might not be financially vulnerable while in the relationship, but be extremely vulnerable without it.

And people are seriously suggesting SAHP are unaware of this?

ShirleyPhallus · 12/07/2022 13:44

iabr · 12/07/2022 13:16

I did not say "SAHMs are the antithesis of financially vulnerable" (but you know that). I said some will be and you never know who you are talking to. So better to listen to an individual, rather than assume.

If anyone is going to make a statement that "most SAHMs are financially vulnerable, then you have to define what you mean by that and in relation to who and what. Eg. in relation to someone in minimum wage with no savings, or a woman on £x with 2 children? What is the framework for comparison?

By my definition, SAHMs are financially vulnerable because:


  • they are reliant on someone else giving them money

  • they are reliant that that one person who gives them money is going to be trustworthy, faithful and not die in the immediate future

  • by putting themselves out of the workforce they are losing earning power by the month / year

  • if they are in the situation of having to work again they will be disadvantaged by it

  • some SAHMs aren’t in control of budgets and money but receive an allowance - vulnerable

  • some SAHMs are treated as skivvies by their husbands and do a proportionally higher amount of work

Cameleongirl · 12/07/2022 13:43

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/07/2022 13:34

@iabr

"Then define 'financially vulnerable' - would you mean risk of being homeless? Less than £x in available funds? Less than the average salary - savings in the U.K? What?"

The main vulnerability comes from no longer having the working parent's income. So a SAHP might not be financially vulnerable while in the relationship, but be extremely vulnerable without it.

If the SAHP had half a million in savings, for example, I don’t think they’d be classed as financially vulnerable, even if they would be potentially homeless when the family home was sold. I agree that those types of SAHP’s are very different to the “average”SAHP.

iabr · 12/07/2022 13:41

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer - Few SAHMs I can think of in real life are 'income dependent.' Very few women don't work for decades are happy to just live on a given salary, even if it's a very high one. It is rarely like that in my direct experience.

OP posts:
MrsBwced · 12/07/2022 13:37

Festivibe · 12/07/2022 13:20

I think the reason people get frustrated and snippy at many SAHM on here is that they often insist THEY don’t have to worry as THEIR relationship is rock solid.

But many posters have experience of thinking that and then their world turning upside down in a day, minute, hour. So it’s frustration that some women stick their heads so deep in the sand it comes across as smug but also stupid frankly considering the weight of evidence on this forum!

Why is it frustrating that some women trust their husbands though?
Surely everyone trusts their partners unless they give them a reason not to.
I wouldn't be married if I didn't trust my husband regardless of my employment status. I'm certainly not going to change my mind just because a stranger on MN has had a relationship breakdown.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 12/07/2022 13:34

@iabr

"Then define 'financially vulnerable' - would you mean risk of being homeless? Less than £x in available funds? Less than the average salary - savings in the U.K? What?"

The main vulnerability comes from no longer having the working parent's income. So a SAHP might not be financially vulnerable while in the relationship, but be extremely vulnerable without it.

iabr · 12/07/2022 13:32

It would be interesting to conduct a survey about SAHMs geographic locations across the U.K. You would first have to define SAHM for the purpose of the survey - eg. someone who hasn't worked for 1 year, 5 years, 10 years? Someone who is a SAHM indefinitely is likely to be in a very different demographic than someone who is just taking a year or two out to avoid childcare.

Then define 'financially vulnerable' - would you mean risk of being homeless? Less than £x in available funds? Less than the average salary - savings in the U.K? What?

I would expect to see 'clusters' of SAHMs in certain areas. For instance, there are large SAHM demographics in parts of Surrey for example. Definitely, areas of London have a lot more longer-term SAHMs than average. Wealthier areas will probably be more SAHM-heavy.

Similarly there may be clusters if SAHMs in other areas where they are not working because the cost of childcare is prohibitive.

Then there will be everyone and everything inbetween. I would suspect that some SAHMs would be very financially vulnerable, but others not at all when measured against some sort of national average. But unless that survey is carried out, who knows?

OP posts:
Festivibe · 12/07/2022 13:20

I think the reason people get frustrated and snippy at many SAHM on here is that they often insist THEY don’t have to worry as THEIR relationship is rock solid.

But many posters have experience of thinking that and then their world turning upside down in a day, minute, hour. So it’s frustration that some women stick their heads so deep in the sand it comes across as smug but also stupid frankly considering the weight of evidence on this forum!

ApplesandBunions · 12/07/2022 13:20

iabr · 12/07/2022 13:16

I did not say "SAHMs are the antithesis of financially vulnerable" (but you know that). I said some will be and you never know who you are talking to. So better to listen to an individual, rather than assume.

If anyone is going to make a statement that "most SAHMs are financially vulnerable, then you have to define what you mean by that and in relation to who and what. Eg. in relation to someone in minimum wage with no savings, or a woman on £x with 2 children? What is the framework for comparison?

Didn't say you did. I said, correctly, that you said many were. Here's the direct quote from 11.08 today

many SAHMs, contrary to the MN accepted discourse, are the antithesis of financially vulnerable.

You didn't provide any evidence for that either, for this or your claim that the majority of women who say they can't leave bad relationships are working. If unverified assertions with nothing to back them up are a problem, stop making them yourself.

MrsBwced · 12/07/2022 13:18

A minority of SAHPs are financially secure, we have seen time and time again posters come on here claiming they're financially secure and it turns out they really aren't.

Most SAHPs leave themselves financially vulnerable and many don't even realise it.

Interested to read the reasoning behind this as it's not something I have seen on MN.
I've seen SAHM who are financially secure and those who aren't, who are fully aware of the fact they aren't but have decided the risk is one worth taking.

There are posters who have taken the risk and it hasn't worked out but that's different to them being unaware in the first place.

I find it hard to believe there's a huge majority of SAHM who aren't aware that not having independent income means they don't have independent income.

iabr · 12/07/2022 13:16

I did not say "SAHMs are the antithesis of financially vulnerable" (but you know that). I said some will be and you never know who you are talking to. So better to listen to an individual, rather than assume.

If anyone is going to make a statement that "most SAHMs are financially vulnerable, then you have to define what you mean by that and in relation to who and what. Eg. in relation to someone in minimum wage with no savings, or a woman on £x with 2 children? What is the framework for comparison?

OP posts:
ApplesandBunions · 12/07/2022 13:02

"A minority of SAHPs are financially secure"

How do you know it's a minority? Have you done s survey?

If she hasn't, it'll be the same as you assuring us that the majority of women who report not being able to leave bad relationships are working and that many SAHPs are the antithesis of financially vulnerable. Those are both direct quotes from you on this thread and you clearly don't have anything to back it up or we'd have seen it by now.

alphapie · 12/07/2022 13:02

iabr · 12/07/2022 12:59

"A minority of SAHPs are financially secure"

How do you know it's a minority? Have you done s survey?

What is your definition of 'financially secure?

Can you imagine any other factors that may contribute to how financially secure someone is?

Are all women who work financially secure? What is your framework for comparison?

'Financially secure' in relation to who? Over what time period? In what circumstances?

As stated in another comment, surveys have been done on this.

iabr · 12/07/2022 12:59

"A minority of SAHPs are financially secure"

How do you know it's a minority? Have you done s survey?

What is your definition of 'financially secure?

Can you imagine any other factors that may contribute to how financially secure someone is?

Are all women who work financially secure? What is your framework for comparison?

'Financially secure' in relation to who? Over what time period? In what circumstances?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread