Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
Festivibe · 12/07/2022 22:01

Pointing out the pitfalls isn't going to change the system

yes it is. Change happens when people are educated.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/07/2022 21:59

Statistically the overwhelming majority of sahms are financially vulnerable."Do you have evidence for this? Or is it just something you have decided?

Oh for fuck's sake. Starting to think this can't be real.

MrsBwced · 12/07/2022 21:54

Festivibe · 12/07/2022 20:27

@MrsBwced because I care when women are fucked over by an inherently misogynistic system that enables and supports men’s careers and financial stability and leaves women vulnerable. And when women themselves argue vociferously for this when other women are just trying to ensure others are protected….it’s a bit annoying to be honest.

So it's a greater good thing rather than aimed at an individual?
I find it frustrating that when it's accepted that the system is misogynistic (and I don't think anyone would argue otherwise) women are often berated by other women for being a product of the system.
Pointing out the pitfalls isn't going to change the system.
If a woman is on a low wage, the household can't afford childcare then there's a good chance it will be her that gives up work to look after the children. don't think many women in that situation will be unaware that they have taken a risk with their financial position.

Summersolargirl · 12/07/2022 21:48

iabr · 12/07/2022 21:27

"Statistically the overwhelming majority of sahms are financially vulnerable."

Do you have evidence for this? Or is it just something you have decided?

What is this overwhelming majority?

Regardless, when an individual SAHM posts about her situation, she is not a statistic. She is an individual, like anyone else. She may well be posting because she is worried about finances. But if she is not, then she is not. You can't insist that know her situation better than her because 'overwhelming majorities' and 'statistics.' This is ridiculous . Would you do this to anyone else. Would you tell a woman working that she must be financially vulnerable because 'statistics.' And then, if she she doesn't conform to your ideas about what she should be, tell her she doesn't care about the position of women in general? No you would not. So ehu is it reasonable to talk to SAHM as if the same and don't know their own minds or understand their own lives?

Good grief.

iabr · 12/07/2022 21:27

"Statistically the overwhelming majority of sahms are financially vulnerable."

Do you have evidence for this? Or is it just something you have decided?

What is this overwhelming majority?

Regardless, when an individual SAHM posts about her situation, she is not a statistic. She is an individual, like anyone else. She may well be posting because she is worried about finances. But if she is not, then she is not. You can't insist that know her situation better than her because 'overwhelming majorities' and 'statistics.' This is ridiculous . Would you do this to anyone else. Would you tell a woman working that she must be financially vulnerable because 'statistics.' And then, if she she doesn't conform to your ideas about what she should be, tell her she doesn't care about the position of women in general? No you would not. So ehu is it reasonable to talk to SAHM as if the same and don't know their own minds or understand their own lives?

OP posts:
declutteringmymind · 12/07/2022 21:26

I also think a lot of women don't have a valid on paper choice. Sometimes their earnings don't cover childcare, or their job isn't conjucive to a child/school routine to make it affordable. It's basically not worth the hassle for the extra money sometimes. I'm sure there are some families have made the decisions based in the economy of it in the short term.

This is also due to the fact that more caring and low paid work is done by women still, so it will be the mother who takes the career hit.

5128gap · 12/07/2022 21:23

DyingForACuppa · 12/07/2022 21:07

For couples who pool money, if childcare costs are higher than the one of the parent's wages then affectively the higher wage earner is 'paying' for the other to work, but you never see the same sort of sneery comments about that. Lots of SAHM bashing and hate around.

(To be clear, there are good reasons to want your partner to pay for you to work - e.g. if it preserves your earning potential do you gain in the long run, or you think you'd struggle to get back into work if they died, or if you don't trust them to always pool money. But there are situations where it just doesn't make financial sense for the lower earner to work as opposed to looking after children themselves).

No. The higher earner is paying towards the care of their child while they are at work and unable to care for them themselves.
The lower earner is doing the same.

Summersolargirl · 12/07/2022 21:22

Op no one is saying sahm are financially vulnerable on the whole when in the relationship, although there are many pockets of that. Abuse creeps in. Lack of respect. It’s predominant if the relationship ends. For whatever reason. Or if something happens to the earning partner.

bottom line is you’re not entitled to your husbands earnings. They give you what they give you and pay what they pay for you through choice. And it’s a choice they can cease any time they wish.

DyingForACuppa · 12/07/2022 21:07

For couples who pool money, if childcare costs are higher than the one of the parent's wages then affectively the higher wage earner is 'paying' for the other to work, but you never see the same sort of sneery comments about that. Lots of SAHM bashing and hate around.

(To be clear, there are good reasons to want your partner to pay for you to work - e.g. if it preserves your earning potential do you gain in the long run, or you think you'd struggle to get back into work if they died, or if you don't trust them to always pool money. But there are situations where it just doesn't make financial sense for the lower earner to work as opposed to looking after children themselves).

AmericanStickInsect · 12/07/2022 21:07

I think it's just preparation for many.
For some that's saying - ok, I have a family to support, I will keep my career going so that if anything were to ever happen to DH/our partnership I could financially support the family.
For others that's saying - ok, I have a family to support, I will be a SAHM but take steps to ensure if anything were to ever happen to my DH/our partnership I have the best chance of being able to financially support the family.
Couples that work/earn unequally aren't necessarily 'dependent', they both have jobs that have financial value that could in theory be capitalised on if necessary.
However if you are a SAHM with no financial cushion/protection, you are more vulnerable and you may be depending on the arrangement with a partner remaining static.
It just comes down to vulnerabilities, majority of cases you are more financially vulnerable (especially over the long term) if you don't work.
I'd need to know that I could stand on my own two feet and support myself and my children financially and childcare wise if I had to. Working allows me that, SAHM parenting doesn't.
No sneering or judgement, just a personal priority based on some facts.

ReneBumsWombats · 12/07/2022 21:03

iabr · 12/07/2022 20:23

"its just not representative of 95% of the population."

Did I say it was? Does it need to be?

SAHMs are not representative of the majority of the population anyway. The majority of families these days are two income families.

SAHM families are in the minority, but where they exist, it will be in the situations I've described and generally, there will be a higher occurrence of SAHMs at either end of the economic spectrum and also in certain areas. Some will be financially vulnerable. Some will not. Don't assume unless they tell you. Christ on a bike, how hard can this be?

You're worried about people thinking a SAHM might be vulnerable when she's actually loaded, we're worried about women getting fucked over as they do every day.

You do you...

Summersolargirl · 12/07/2022 21:03

Mellowyellow222 · 12/07/2022 20:31

I think the problem is your message should don’t comment on peoples finances unless they ask. And then an observation that you have noticed this more when women say they are SAHMs.

but then you quite aggressively and defensively started to argue about SAHMs being independently wealthy and not requiring an income. That is a different argument - and it’s probably wrong for the majority of SAHMs.

this is clearly something you have gotten yourself extremely worked up about. I haven’t seen the posts you referred to - but they sound rude and patronising.

so stick to the message of not giving unsolicited financial advice. Muddying it with financially independent one precenters changed the debate and people will naturally challenger you.

I’d agree with this. There is clearly a signficant issue here. Statistically the overwhelming majority of sahms are financially vulnerable. No one is sneering at anyone. They are pointing out the huge risks of not being financially independent or able to support yourself independently. That’s not sneering.

now sure a tiny tiny percentage won’t be, they will be independently wealthy or married to someone in the top 0.02 percent of the population or whatever. 20 percent of mothers are financially inactive. For many reasons. But it’s a tiny proportion that it’s because they ar e independently wealthy or set for life.

I really don’t understand why you keep arguing like it’s a significant portion when every single person knows that’s not true.

Scottishgirl85 · 12/07/2022 20:55

I don't know who's sneering. But it is no question that many sahms are indeed financially vulnerable, particularly if unmarried. Even if married, if they have no income or up-to-date skills, they could be in difficulty if they found themselves needing to house and support themselves following a divorce. I'm also not sure how many sahms contribute to a pension.

iabr · 12/07/2022 20:47

"you seem to have an issue but are failing to make logical arguments other than keeping repeating the majority of sahms are financially secure if a split pccurs"

No, I'm not saying that at all.

The word I have repeatedly used is SOME.

Some SAHMs will be financially secure. Some will not.

Just like women who are in paid work. Some will be more financially secure than others for a whole host of reasons.

I can't keep repeating the obvious.

OP posts:
Mellowyellow222 · 12/07/2022 20:31

I think the problem is your message should don’t comment on peoples finances unless they ask. And then an observation that you have noticed this more when women say they are SAHMs.

but then you quite aggressively and defensively started to argue about SAHMs being independently wealthy and not requiring an income. That is a different argument - and it’s probably wrong for the majority of SAHMs.

this is clearly something you have gotten yourself extremely worked up about. I haven’t seen the posts you referred to - but they sound rude and patronising.

so stick to the message of not giving unsolicited financial advice. Muddying it with financially independent one precenters changed the debate and people will naturally challenger you.

Summersolargirl · 12/07/2022 20:29

iabr · 12/07/2022 20:05

The thread is talking about SAHM threads in general on AIBU which nearly always take a certain time and direction. Not attitudes towards me specifically. I can't keep explaining this. As stated in the OP, why assume a woman who is SAH is, by default, going to be more financially vulnerable than someone who works part time or full time? It's all about the wider context. This should hardly need pointing out.

Fine if a SAHM actually posts about being financially vulnerable. But if she, despite 'advice' claims she's in in that score, take her word for it, in the same way as you would anyone else. That's it.

How many times do you need to ask the same question? How many times do you need people to answer. Because unless you’ve married someone incredibly wealthy and had a long marriage then unless you’re independently wealthy in your own right then you’re vulnerable. Every single time.

most sahm are not in this category. The top one percent of earners in the uk only earn 160k. Not enough to keep the ex financially secure when split. Particularly now that courts like clean breaks.

you seem to have an issue but are failing to make logical arguments other than keeping repeating the majority of sahms are financially secure if a split pccurs

statistically this is impossible. If you compare the number of stay at home mums v the amount of wealthy for life or high earners. Statistically the overwhelming majority are vulnerable.

Festivibe · 12/07/2022 20:27

@MrsBwced because I care when women are fucked over by an inherently misogynistic system that enables and supports men’s careers and financial stability and leaves women vulnerable. And when women themselves argue vociferously for this when other women are just trying to ensure others are protected….it’s a bit annoying to be honest.

iabr · 12/07/2022 20:23

"its just not representative of 95% of the population."

Did I say it was? Does it need to be?

SAHMs are not representative of the majority of the population anyway. The majority of families these days are two income families.

SAHM families are in the minority, but where they exist, it will be in the situations I've described and generally, there will be a higher occurrence of SAHMs at either end of the economic spectrum and also in certain areas. Some will be financially vulnerable. Some will not. Don't assume unless they tell you. Christ on a bike, how hard can this be?

OP posts:
PaperTyger · 12/07/2022 20:20

Too tired, very true.

iabr · 12/07/2022 20:14

Sorry for all the typos. I meant to say, if a SAHM tells you she is ok in that score (financially), then just take her word for it, as you would anyone else's.

Whst is the point on a thread by a SAHM who is not asking for financial advice, to keep on giving it regardless? I'm not talking about me. I'm telling about the way people pile on to SAHM threads with unsolicited advice not remotely asked for by the poster. Then, when she tells them she is not financially vulnerable, she is berated for not understanding the plight of other women!

OP posts:
TowerRavenSeven · 12/07/2022 20:12

No sneering here, I worked many years before my husband (8 years older), bought my own house which we used to buy our house, and brought a large inheritance into the marriage. I work part time at a non profit and don’t bring in enough to pay for much. With so I contributed, after investing I’ve brought in a LOT.

Mellowyellow222 · 12/07/2022 20:07

I don’t think the super wealthy women you are describing are particularly common. I also don’t think they would describe themselves as Stay At Home mums!!

you clearly either live in a very wealthy privileged bubble, or spend a lot of time watching TV shows about the super wealthy.

its just not representative of 95% of the population.

PaperTyger · 12/07/2022 20:07

I do agree op , essentially.

But when you truly love someone who cares.

These things only usually come to play in divorce.

Unfortunately my mil contradicts my own feelings about it.
She feels she has worked hard and is superior, as a sham, she will refer to basic every day activities as major work she has to do.
She days her and her dh ,fil worked extremely hard to get ahead.

But it's his large salary? As a sham I think she did the bare minimum!

iabr · 12/07/2022 20:06

tone not time.

OP posts:
iabr · 12/07/2022 20:05

The thread is talking about SAHM threads in general on AIBU which nearly always take a certain time and direction. Not attitudes towards me specifically. I can't keep explaining this. As stated in the OP, why assume a woman who is SAH is, by default, going to be more financially vulnerable than someone who works part time or full time? It's all about the wider context. This should hardly need pointing out.

Fine if a SAHM actually posts about being financially vulnerable. But if she, despite 'advice' claims she's in in that score, take her word for it, in the same way as you would anyone else. That's it.

OP posts: