Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 14/07/2022 09:45

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer

I agree with you about men becoming more like women being the greatest benefit and the hardest to achieve.

Not sure what the solution is to this really except to keep plugging on.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 09:41

@Thepeopleversuswork

Of course it doesn't exist in a vacuum and of course challenging the status quo isn't going to be easy. Things only change when people fight for change. And it is always balanced against what is best for the individual (person or family). But sticking to the norm does perpetuate it. There's absolutely no doubt about that.

I loathe to say it, but the people who can make the biggest positive difference for gender eqaulity is men acting more like women do, rather than the other way around. I agree with you that would benefit everyone.

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/07/2022 09:24

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer

Ok, but so do men. In theory at least. They choose the latter. Women seem to choose the former.

But these choices aren't arbitrary and don't happen in a vacuum. Men and women both have vast degrees of societal and economic pressure put on them to fit into one of these "tracks".

Men have historically been expected to be breadwinners (and still are to a large extent despite more female high earners) and are judged for not achieving this. So for them to consciously step off that track makes them anomalous and takes a degree of guts. Some men now embrace that but there is definitely a societal pressure on them to prioritise earning and "providing" over other things which benefit a family.

Women obviously have historically been pushed towards caring and nurturing (and administrative) roles within the family and a lot of them still do gravitate towards these roles.

It's quite hard to buck these trends. An increasing amount of men and women do but its still harder than going with the default.

And actually if men took on a few more traditionally "feminine" roles in the family and women took on a more masculine approach to earning money it would be a net benefit to everyone in most cases in my view, both at an individual/family level and society. I think it would enhance family life to have men be more present and it would massively support women to advance in the workplace if they were able to step up more and do more without constantly juggling childcare/cleaning/life admin. Not to mention the influence on the next generation of girls and boys of seeing a more egalitarian influence from their parents.

Again, I have no problem with people taking the "default" role for their sex and organising their families on traditional lines if that suits them. And I recognise that for many people this is the only viable option.

But when I hear women actively celebrating the fact that they are choosing to "facilitate" their husbands at work and actively perpetuating structures which really hold other women back at work and enable men to keep these structures in place it does frustrate me.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 09:10

@Thepeopleversuswork

"I totally agree with that. Most women (unless they are independently wealthy) face an invidious choice between either being fully or partially dependent on a man (with all the risks that go with that) or having the shape of their lives dictated to a large extent by the demands of their employer."

Ok, but so do men. In theory at least. They choose the latter. Women seem to choose the former.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 09:04

@Thepeopleversuswork Totally agree. Women who stay at home facilitating their husbands careers have a negative impact of mothers' ablity to compete effectively in the workforce, and on changing the culture. It's of course not the individual SAHM's responisbility to do that, but it is the impact.

Also, it's the issue of representation. When women become mothers and step off the career ladder because their job doesn't align with family life, rather than fighting for their rights to have both, it creates a lack of respresentation in women in senior positions. Again, not the responsibility of individual women, but that's the impact.

The one thing that would really help gender equality in the workplace would be if men made the same choices women make - whether it's taking time out, using their paternity leave, fleixble working, stepping up to care responsibility on an equal footing to women. But of could if you have a SAHP at home - doing all those things, and having to provide for - you don't do that.

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/07/2022 09:03

@ImAvingOops

I totally agree with that. Most women (unless they are independently wealthy) face an invidious choice between either being fully or partially dependent on a man (with all the risks that go with that) or having the shape of their lives dictated to a large extent by the demands of their employer.

I happen to see the latter as the lesser evil, partly because I don't have an alternative at the moment but I also would be really scared to rely on someone else for financial security. Plus I like working and it suits my personality far more than staying at home would. But I recognise that that wouldn't work for all women. We all make choices to fit our circumstances and we should all have the right not to have those choices judged by others in different circumstances.

And you're right also that the right to choice is paramount. In a free society every woman has the right to choose not to work if there is support available to her and that's a valid choice whatever the impact is on women at large.

But it would be nice sometimes if people with the luxury of not having to work to support their children would stop to think that this rhetoric about "supporting" their husbands to maximise their income unimpeded by the demands of childcare or domestic work is actually quite harmful to those of us who do have to do all of the above.

ImAvingOops · 14/07/2022 08:46

Not all choices are feminist. I think feminism is about equality of opportunity, rather than the freedom to choose whatever you like.
But women don't really have equality of opportunity - it all seems to go pear shaped in terms of earnings/career progression once children come along. Women are still discriminated against at this point, because we are still the default parent. It's really hard to maintain a full time job and not be super busy and knackered. Unless you have lots of help.
Honestly, part of why I opted out and sah is because I didn't want to be doing a full on job and loads of child/house stuff. And I didn't want (and couldn't afford even with 2 salaries) to pay for lots of help.

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/07/2022 08:37

@5128gap

You are right and I don’t blame women at all for doing this. It’s often far easier.

I do however sometimes wish people wouldn’t position this as being about “choice” as if this was a feminist argument and a net benefit to women in general. “Choice” is now seen as the ultimate goal of feminism, which is slightly specious. Actually this choice, while understandable at a personal level, is not something that benefits women in general.

ImAvingOops · 14/07/2022 08:35

I wouldn't be sah to facilitate my dh going out socialising with work. Fuck that!
But I do think you are right to say that when a man has a lot of back up at home, it does make it easier for him to get promotions. For my dh that meant doing the work trips away, not having to leave work because the kids are sick/on school holidays. However I've been on a lot of threads where wohm have said that the husband didn't need a sah wife, that he would have achieved all he has if she had been working too, that they could have outsourced everything the sahm did since there would be 2 salaries coming in. Both those things can't be true (unless the levels of earning ran to enough for tag teams of nannies and a big enough home to house them!)

I think the solution is to forcibly change the work culture, so unsocial hours aren't the norm, that on site crèches and subsidised good quality childcare exists wherever you live. Because women aren't likely to give up on being a sahm if that benefits their families, just because other women can't or don't want to. The change has to come from society and employers.

5128gap · 14/07/2022 08:29

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/07/2022 08:15

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer

Regardless of what you think of being a SAHP, and women's right to choose to do just that, there is not doubt that women choosing that route has a negative impact on gender equality in the work place.

You raise a really important point and one which bears unpacking a bit.

This whole argument of "If I didn't SAH my husband wouldn't have been able to achieve what he has at work" is problematic for me because it perpetuates the idea that a working man needs and deserves a home helpmeet while a working woman doesn't. This attitude is really toxic and unhelpful to those of us who have to work and who have to compete with these men who are "facilitated" by SAHMs.

When I do encounter sexism at work its invariably not around my performance its around my inability to be basically sitting at a desk or going drinking in the City 24/7.

I work much harder than most of my male colleagues because as a single parent I have to. I have to start work at 6.30am to get a couple of hours in before the commute. I have to work most evenings. I put in far more hours and frankly I am better at my job than a lot of them.

But I still get told off for not being more "present" and not being able to network and be seen. And consequently I haven't been as far promoted as many of my male colleagues.

If I had a "facilitator" I would be able to go drinking in the City 2/3 nights a week and play golf and sit at my desk scratching my arse and looking at social media until 7pm. But I don't because I can't and consequently I work much more efficiently as a result. But I am still judged to be handicapped by my inability to "participate" in the social side of the job.

The phenomenon of the "facilitating" SAHM plays a part in this. It allows these men to be being "present" and "participating". I'm not saying that SAHMs owe working mums not to do this.

Clearly women have to make the choices that suit them best and fair enough as you can't sacrifice your life and happiness for a notional societal goal. But when people come on here and trot out this line about the "invaluable support" they are providing to their husband to further his career (for him to go out drinking) it does make me bristle.

If there were fewer of the "facilitators" the men in corporate life would have to step up a bit more on the home front and organise their schedules better in a way women in careers now have to. Women would be better supported at home, would be freed up to get more done, their children would see more of their dads and they able to earn at greater parity with men and the balance of responsibilities between the sexes would hopefully start to even out. So, sue me, but I feel a bit cynical about those SAHMs who celebrate the fact that they are facilitating their DH's glittering careers.

I agree with your post. And I think its quite conflicting for feminists. On the one hand supporting and valuing other womens choices, but on the other being expected to support something that harms other women. But it's not women's fault society is structured as it is, and perhaps you can't blame those who've found a way to turn it to their individual advantage.
I suppose women who speak about facilitating their husband's career are doing so to justify their value to him. Its a response to the freeloader arguments. There's few who try to claim the role is beneficial to society in general.

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/07/2022 08:15

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer

Regardless of what you think of being a SAHP, and women's right to choose to do just that, there is not doubt that women choosing that route has a negative impact on gender equality in the work place.

You raise a really important point and one which bears unpacking a bit.

This whole argument of "If I didn't SAH my husband wouldn't have been able to achieve what he has at work" is problematic for me because it perpetuates the idea that a working man needs and deserves a home helpmeet while a working woman doesn't. This attitude is really toxic and unhelpful to those of us who have to work and who have to compete with these men who are "facilitated" by SAHMs.

When I do encounter sexism at work its invariably not around my performance its around my inability to be basically sitting at a desk or going drinking in the City 24/7.

I work much harder than most of my male colleagues because as a single parent I have to. I have to start work at 6.30am to get a couple of hours in before the commute. I have to work most evenings. I put in far more hours and frankly I am better at my job than a lot of them.

But I still get told off for not being more "present" and not being able to network and be seen. And consequently I haven't been as far promoted as many of my male colleagues.

If I had a "facilitator" I would be able to go drinking in the City 2/3 nights a week and play golf and sit at my desk scratching my arse and looking at social media until 7pm. But I don't because I can't and consequently I work much more efficiently as a result. But I am still judged to be handicapped by my inability to "participate" in the social side of the job.

The phenomenon of the "facilitating" SAHM plays a part in this. It allows these men to be being "present" and "participating". I'm not saying that SAHMs owe working mums not to do this.

Clearly women have to make the choices that suit them best and fair enough as you can't sacrifice your life and happiness for a notional societal goal. But when people come on here and trot out this line about the "invaluable support" they are providing to their husband to further his career (for him to go out drinking) it does make me bristle.

If there were fewer of the "facilitators" the men in corporate life would have to step up a bit more on the home front and organise their schedules better in a way women in careers now have to. Women would be better supported at home, would be freed up to get more done, their children would see more of their dads and they able to earn at greater parity with men and the balance of responsibilities between the sexes would hopefully start to even out. So, sue me, but I feel a bit cynical about those SAHMs who celebrate the fact that they are facilitating their DH's glittering careers.

ImAvingOops · 14/07/2022 07:58

People have low self esteem for all kinds of reasons. I'm not sure that their work status is the major one, unless they are stuck doing something they really dislike or there is a specific problem attached to what they do, like bullying at work or a relationship issue.

If some women feel bad about sah, that might be because they are spending too much time on mn, reading about how their contributions to the family are not as valid as the financial one? Or being called spongers!

I think high self esteem comes from knowing you did the best you could with the information you had available at the time and not caring too much about the opinions of strangers, who aren't living your life.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 07:51

I can't believe we have ended up discussing millionaire SAHPs here. Surely they are just so rare that they are hardly worth including in the debate.
Yes, if you are a SAHM married to a millionaire, you are probably going to be ok financially. Not so much guaranteed for the 99% of other SAHPs who are not married to millionaires.

Even if you are married divorce and division of assets takes time. If you really want to seperate the husband (with the job) is refusing to leave, or leaving and refusing to pay for the house (or would pay for the house but no other bills, food, expenses etc), then you have a good period that needs to be funded with.... well, that''s the question. Would benefits stretch? Could you pick up a job quickly?

What about when the divorce has gone through? Most couples don't have sufficient assets and savings to fund two households. So how will you fund buying out the house or renting somewhere else with no job? Is the plan just to rely on benefits and a council house? And how quickly do you think that's all put in place.

All the above can of course be resolved. But it takes time. And it does leave yu financially vulnerable. When the choice is between staying with a dickhead or going to a bedsit for an indefinite amount of time with 3 kids becuase there is no financial independence to do anything else, many women choose to stay. That's not a position I would wish to be in.

Mellowyellow222 · 14/07/2022 07:45

This thread has made me question my friendship group😂

Out of my close friends who all went to university none are stay at home parents. One does work part time while her daughter is small.

I do know two SAHMs - more friends of the family. Neither are wealthy, both have taken a lifestyle hit, neither volunteer or sit in the board of any larger charity, neither raise millions for the community, both worry about money. Living if one income, even if it is above average, is tough. Both have been out of the workforce for five plus years.

i Would say they are more typical of stay at home than the examples of high achievers cited on this thread. In fact I’m not sure why these women who do so much voluntary work don’t work part time? It seems odd - unless their volunteering is PTA etc.

5128gap · 14/07/2022 07:14

Mellowyellow222 · 14/07/2022 00:27

It sounds like you either live in the upper east side of Manhattan- or read a lot of books based there. The ladies you are describing aren’t your typical stay at home mums - they must only be about 1% of SAHMs.

they have nannies and cleaners and trust funds.

There is weird trend on this thread to glamorise SAHMs and this wealthy group of high achieving ladies who will be fine with or without a man. That will be case for a small number but he vast majority of the population is not this lucky.

There's also a world of difference between being able to find oneself an unpaid role in a sector that can't afford to pay someone, or where your contribution is an add on to the main body of the work rather than essential (PTA for example) and competing for a salaried role in the job market.
This is no disrespect to volunteers who make an invaluable contribution, and obviously volunteering does help to retain skill sets. But its a bit of a myth that employers accept the transferable skills gained from running a home and voluntary work as of equal value to a decade or more of direct experience in the field.

WarOnSlugs · 14/07/2022 01:53

Having millions means you can do pretty much whatever you want.

Money = choices

If you aren't being goady then you need a reality check.

Most people would love to never have to work again and have the "problem" of working out what they'd most like to do with their time.

WarOnSlugs · 14/07/2022 01:52

I don't think millions compensates for a shattered self esteem and not knowing what to do with yourself after years of unemployment.

Do you realise how absurd this statement would sound to most people, given how the majority of households with whatever domestic setup are currently struggling with living costs?

Cameleongirl · 14/07/2022 01:50

Sorry about the typos!

Cameleongirl · 14/07/2022 01:50

@Hatsoff5 Yoy do t seem willing to recognize that SAHP’s can’t be stereotyped though, that they reflect the entire population, from the wealthy to those on a low income.
You seem determined to characterize them as people with lie self-esteem and for example.

I only know a few SAHP’s, ranging from wealthy to those married to teachers and civil servants. They’re not exclusively women. Low self-esteem and poor networks to help them find employment simply aren’t common characteristics among them.

Sorry if that doesn’t fit your stereotype and narrative.

Hatsoff5 · 14/07/2022 01:31

Mellowyellow222 · 14/07/2022 00:27

It sounds like you either live in the upper east side of Manhattan- or read a lot of books based there. The ladies you are describing aren’t your typical stay at home mums - they must only be about 1% of SAHMs.

they have nannies and cleaners and trust funds.

There is weird trend on this thread to glamorise SAHMs and this wealthy group of high achieving ladies who will be fine with or without a man. That will be case for a small number but he vast majority of the population is not this lucky.

It sounds like The housewives shows ffs 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Hatsoff5 · 14/07/2022 01:21

Cameleongirl · 14/07/2022 00:49

@Mellowyellow222 I wish! This was in response to @Hatsoff5 ’s comment about wealthy SAHP’s who get divorced:

I don't think millions compensates for a shattered self esteem and not knowing what to do with yourself after years of unemployment. It would be daunting to most.

The poster seems to assume that SAHP’s do nothing with their time, it’s just not my experience of those I know. Perhaps it’s just that I’m attracted to people who get things done so they’re the ones I’m friends with. 🤷

The thing is you and others are unwilling to see wider SAHM in general. Despite your unrealistic circle or personal circumstances. It doesn't change the facts... your circle is the minority don't you see?

Clearly not. I didn't assume SAHM do nothing but the majority of the population can't afford not to work sorry to burst your bubble..

Cameleongirl · 14/07/2022 00:49

@Mellowyellow222 I wish! This was in response to @Hatsoff5 ’s comment about wealthy SAHP’s who get divorced:

I don't think millions compensates for a shattered self esteem and not knowing what to do with yourself after years of unemployment. It would be daunting to most.

The poster seems to assume that SAHP’s do nothing with their time, it’s just not my experience of those I know. Perhaps it’s just that I’m attracted to people who get things done so they’re the ones I’m friends with. 🤷

Mellowyellow222 · 14/07/2022 00:27

Cameleongirl · 14/07/2022 00:13

@Hatsoff5 You're assuming that SAHP's do absolutely nothing with their time though, the long term ones I know are very involved with charities, serve on boards, local government, etc. One lawyer I know stayed at home for several years, but she's working again now, her connections helped her find a new job. Another long term SAHP I know has just led a community campaign to buy some land to build a new city park, raising $9 million!

I know not every SAHP is like this, but I don't think they're all lacking in self-esteem!

It sounds like you either live in the upper east side of Manhattan- or read a lot of books based there. The ladies you are describing aren’t your typical stay at home mums - they must only be about 1% of SAHMs.

they have nannies and cleaners and trust funds.

There is weird trend on this thread to glamorise SAHMs and this wealthy group of high achieving ladies who will be fine with or without a man. That will be case for a small number but he vast majority of the population is not this lucky.

Cameleongirl · 14/07/2022 00:13

@Hatsoff5 You're assuming that SAHP's do absolutely nothing with their time though, the long term ones I know are very involved with charities, serve on boards, local government, etc. One lawyer I know stayed at home for several years, but she's working again now, her connections helped her find a new job. Another long term SAHP I know has just led a community campaign to buy some land to build a new city park, raising $9 million!

I know not every SAHP is like this, but I don't think they're all lacking in self-esteem!

Hatsoff5 · 13/07/2022 23:39

Weirdlynormal · 13/07/2022 18:40

Divorce is v. different when there’s millions to be divided

true, but that is a fairly small proportion of people.

I don't think millions compensates for a shattered self esteem and not knowing what to do with yourself after years of unemployment. It would be daunting to most.