Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
MrsBwced · 17/07/2022 12:22

Women choose it, but also society pays less (values less) traditional women's work. The gender pay gap is still very real, with women being paid less per hour than men.

I was talking about this the other day with DD, even within the lower paid jobs the men doing them often earn more than women.
Our male window cleaner, traditionally a male role charges £20 to clean our windows once a fortnight, it takes him about 20 minutes maximum.
DD and her housemates employ a female cleaner, traditionally a female role for two hours once a fortnight, they pay her £20 an hour.

Our hairdresser is DD's friends Mum. She rents a chair in a salon, the salon is part of a chain owned by a former male hairdresser. I hadn't noticed until she pointed it out but apparently it's quite a typical set up, she said when you consider it a lot of the big names in hairdressing are men. Lots of salons have full female staff but a male name as the brand.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 17/07/2022 10:21

Liz1tummypain · 16/07/2022 21:00

Sadly I think often women do choose poorly paid work. Nothing on our chromosomes gives us a preference for being poorer than men. But still, somehow women choose to go into hairdressing, pet grooming, cleaning jobs, working in nail bars, telephone sales, all kinds of jobs that few men consider for more than a few minutes. Women can choose this kind of job and they do. It’s a fact that women often do choose poorly paid work. ( Which is fine if they can balance their budget accordingly)

Women choose it, but also society pays less (values less) traditional women's work. The gender pay gap is still very real, with women being paid less per hour than men.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 17/07/2022 10:19

ImAvingOops · 16/07/2022 19:32

Work ethic is important in that money needs to be earned in order to support children and life in general. But is it important for its own sake if, as a couple, one of you is happy to do that bit and earns enough to support the family? And the other one wants to provide the day to day care? Going to work isn't the be all and end all. It rather depends on a)how much you need it to finance your life and b) whether you derive personal satisfaction from it. Not everyone does.

And this goes back to the root of the thread. If it's for income as a couple only, no it doesn't really matter who earns the money. But for financial security for the non-earning parent it does. and arguably for a couple it does too (i.e. two jobs less likely to be lost at the same time, two personal allowances etc). Same re the NMW argument. Just because you are a low earner doesn't mean you have less to lose by relying on a man.

Also, there are distinctions to be made in these discussions - a SAHP to a small or disabled child no doubt provides care. We can argue what's harder (work vs childcare) till the cows come home, but no doubt it's hard work to be in sole care of child all day. But once if that child is in school most of the day, doesn't that change? It's often then that the "facilating the husband" really comes in becuase women say "oh, I couldn't do pick ups around my job if I worked". Why does the woman specifically have to stay home t faciliate this?

5128gap · 16/07/2022 21:19

Liz1tummypain · 16/07/2022 21:00

Sadly I think often women do choose poorly paid work. Nothing on our chromosomes gives us a preference for being poorer than men. But still, somehow women choose to go into hairdressing, pet grooming, cleaning jobs, working in nail bars, telephone sales, all kinds of jobs that few men consider for more than a few minutes. Women can choose this kind of job and they do. It’s a fact that women often do choose poorly paid work. ( Which is fine if they can balance their budget accordingly)

I've never seen a man in a nail bar ( though tbf I've never been in one) but they absolutely work in all those other industries, or a close equivalent. Hospitality, retail, call centres, barbers...men all over the place. Not to mention unskilled work in factories, warehouses, labouring. On MN every man might be a high earner doing something vague in the city with IT or other people's money, but in real life far more men earn low wages than are high earners. Do you also think they've deliberately chosen to bypass well paid work for these occupations?

Summersolargirl · 16/07/2022 21:15

Liz1tummypain · 16/07/2022 21:00

Sadly I think often women do choose poorly paid work. Nothing on our chromosomes gives us a preference for being poorer than men. But still, somehow women choose to go into hairdressing, pet grooming, cleaning jobs, working in nail bars, telephone sales, all kinds of jobs that few men consider for more than a few minutes. Women can choose this kind of job and they do. It’s a fact that women often do choose poorly paid work. ( Which is fine if they can balance their budget accordingly)

when clearly these are obviously female dominated and lowest paid, I don’t think women chose it any more. Decades ago, sure, as they expected to stop when they had kids, but I don’t think young women chose this today, it’s more they do it becayse there is no other options,

Liz1tummypain · 16/07/2022 21:00

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/07/2022 16:22

I would dispute that it’s as high as 99%. It’s definitely a majority but female breadwinners are more common than they were.

But many men often choose that scenario because consciously or otherwise they prioritise work over family life because they find family life to be a drag.

They tell themselves its about being a “provider”.

But actually quite a lot of the time it’s an opt out of family life and it proves to be a double negative impact for the woman, a) because it’s harder for her to advance in her own career due to lack of engagement from the father and b) because she gets very little help at home.

Certainly if men did more on the domestic front it would go a long way to redress this imbalance.

Sadly I think often women do choose poorly paid work. Nothing on our chromosomes gives us a preference for being poorer than men. But still, somehow women choose to go into hairdressing, pet grooming, cleaning jobs, working in nail bars, telephone sales, all kinds of jobs that few men consider for more than a few minutes. Women can choose this kind of job and they do. It’s a fact that women often do choose poorly paid work. ( Which is fine if they can balance their budget accordingly)

TruthHertz · 16/07/2022 20:11

missdemeanors · 16/07/2022 19:52

Is a woman on NMW going to be quite so wary of stalling her career or is shacking up with a financially successful guy actually much more likely to raise her quality of life?

Quite possibly. But most people want to marry someone they love; earning power isn't top of the list for most of us. And like I said, a lot of people meet their partner at Uni or through work. It's quite common for people to partner someone at a similar level of earning. I imagine couples where one is on a six figure salary and the other on NMW are relatively rare.

Many couples start out earning a similar amount - it's after having kids that the gap starts to widen. And that's a worrying issue.

Agreed, but I'm talking more about the risk element to be fair. The 'should I give up my job to be a SAHM' element. If you work in retail then it's probs less a dilemma than if you're a Head of Finance.

Although to be fair a lot of studies show that women place financial security much higher than men, which I'm guessing may be down to the traditional setup where the man usually becomes the main provider.

Men were found to regularly seek a loving partner who is physically attractive and healthy, while women tended to opt for a partner with status and resources, as well as someone who was educated, dependable and intelligent.

www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/life-style/love-sex/what-men-and-women-look-for-in-an-ideal-partner-a6755706.html%3famp

missdemeanors · 16/07/2022 19:52

Is a woman on NMW going to be quite so wary of stalling her career or is shacking up with a financially successful guy actually much more likely to raise her quality of life?

Quite possibly. But most people want to marry someone they love; earning power isn't top of the list for most of us. And like I said, a lot of people meet their partner at Uni or through work. It's quite common for people to partner someone at a similar level of earning. I imagine couples where one is on a six figure salary and the other on NMW are relatively rare.

Many couples start out earning a similar amount - it's after having kids that the gap starts to widen. And that's a worrying issue.

ImAvingOops · 16/07/2022 19:32

Work ethic is important in that money needs to be earned in order to support children and life in general. But is it important for its own sake if, as a couple, one of you is happy to do that bit and earns enough to support the family? And the other one wants to provide the day to day care? Going to work isn't the be all and end all. It rather depends on a)how much you need it to finance your life and b) whether you derive personal satisfaction from it. Not everyone does.

TruthHertz · 16/07/2022 19:31

I also feel like this is very middle class/professional framed, with all the talk of 'career progression'. Is a woman on NMW going to be quite so wary of stalling her career or is shacking up with a financially successful guy actually much more likely to raise her quality of life?

TruthHertz · 16/07/2022 19:27

I don't know. There's certainly a lot of very self assured statements about 'what men think' but were it the other way around I'm not sure we'd be so accepting that they know exactly how we experience life. In fact, I usually read statements to the contrary on here.

Topgub · 16/07/2022 18:54

@BessieFinkNottle

In all of your examples why is the childcare solely the wonans responsibility?

Are there no men in these scenarios?

Is your mum of 2/3 young children a single parent? Why did she choose to have 3 kids close together if she can't afford childcare?

Being a carer for disabled children isn't the same as being a sahm but again are all female carers for disabled children single parents? There's literally no scope for sharing the burden?

I also haven't mentioned laziness. That was your word.

But yes, I'd say someone who choses to stay home with a baby rather than work too has less work ethic than someone who chooses to do both

How many men give up work because they want to stay home to experience their luck and just be with their baby?

missdemeanors · 16/07/2022 18:45

@BessieFinkNottle I agree; not everyone has equal choices, far from it. And a child with a disability throws a whole other level of difficulty into the situation.

I also suspect there will always be some couples who do have choices available to them where they'll opt for the set-up of husband being sole provider and wife being a SAHM long term, maybe never working full time again. But now that (disabilities and other specifics apart) society has progressed, I would expect those traditional provider/carer models to become fewer and fewer. Going back 50 years when I was a child, that model came about largely through lack of choice. Women weren't encouraged, in fact in many cases actively discouraged from having a good career and of course regulated childcare was almost non existent.

Nowadays, with girls outperforming boys at school and having higher aspirations, I would imagine more of them are likely to want to hang on to their career. And parallel to that, aren't we encouraging boys to be more nurturing, and to feel able to demonstrate that side of their character?

So all in all, where possible I think a balance of providing / caring between mother and father is the optimum set up for everyone, including the child.

5128gap · 16/07/2022 18:38

I certainly think men should play a more active role in family and domestic life, but its a bit of a chicken and egg situation. I imagine the man who is going to get in at 7pm in an evening and immediately turn his hand to hoovering and cooking tea when his partner has been home all day, without any resentment, is a rare man indeed. With very small children who arguably can take all day to care for, maybe, but not as a long term prospect. And in all honesty I'd have some sympathy. A SAHM with school age children has plenty of time to do all the domestic work, so it's difficult to justify requiring the working partner to share it. And so roles get further reinforced.

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 17:53

@Topgub

"It is entirely possible to have caring responsibilities and a job/career."

It's entirely possible for some people to have caring responsibilities and a job/career.

"(I'm) suggesting those who don't have a job/career through choice have a poorer work ethic than those who do."

Maybe some.

But "through choice"...what does that really mean? There is little in your hypothesis to suggest the range of situations women find themselves in when they become mothers.

A mother with two/three young children who can only earn minimum wage and literally cannot afford childcare fees? Does she really have much choice? Is she off the hook or do you judge her too?

Mothers of disabled children are disproportionately likely to be SAHMs...I think something like 16% work outside the home versus the usual figure of about 60%. Because specalist childcare is even more difficult to access and even more expensive. But some manage it so technically there is a choice of course...I suppose the 84% who are SAHMs just have a poor work ethic.

And what about a mother who gets her one chance of motherhood after years of trying and wants to stay home and experience her luck and her baby for a while. Is that just laziness too?

You speak about "choice" as if life were the same for everyone. And of course it's not, nowhere close. Women make decisions for all sorts of reasons and maybe you haven't considered many of them. Do you really judge others who haven't been as lucky as you, or who simply have a different way of living their life?

ReneBumsWombats · 16/07/2022 17:33

Equally, some women can be territorial about the children and sideline their husband from being as hands on as he might want to be. And yes, some women are even territorial over housework! ('He can't load the dishwasher properly ...')

I was thinking this. Breadwinner might be secure that they're not easily replaceable, but a non-working partner might need to engineer things to feel irreplaceable, since arguably, anyone can do the domestics (which is not to say it's not tiring or real work, but it's not "skilled" or selective in the way most jobs are).

missdemeanors · 16/07/2022 17:29

@Topgub

I think the 'territorial' thing can come from both sides. Some men see the workplace as 'theirs', it's more comfortable for them to have a wife at home taking care of things so that they can abdicate responsibility. Equally, some women can be territorial about the children and sideline their husband from being as hands on as he might want to be. And yes, some women are even territorial over housework! ('He can't load the dishwasher properly ...')

I guess where couples have this dynamic, it then becomes entrenched over time and even if one partner is no longer happy with the status quo and starts feeling resentful, it becomes harder and harder to shift to a more balanced dynamic.

@Thepeopleversuswork interestingly my DH was brought up in the opposite of a progressive household... it was traditional dad going out to work, mum staying at home, barely expecting dad to lift a Finger round the house. So perhaps the choices we make are sometimes a reaction against our own experience.

Topgub · 16/07/2022 17:16

@Thepeopleversuswork

Mostly because women choose for it to be that way.

You only have to read a cleaning thread to see nonsense like oh doesn't know how to dress kids/load the dishwasher/cook/hang washing out etc

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/07/2022 17:12

@missdemeanors

I hope you’re right and certainly there seem to be more men around who consciously want to play a more active role in family life than in the past which is great.

But I’m afraid I still think in the majority of marriages and relationships men default to a more limited role which doesn’t go significantly beyond being a provider and doing a bit to “help” their wife/partner when they see fit. In the vast majority of relationships women, regardless of whether they work or not, do the lion’s share of domestic work and childcare.

The scenario you describe in your own marriage is great but it relies on the man having had a relatively progressive upbringing and being comfortable with his wife being an equal partner in the relationship and while this is more common than it used to be I don’t think it’s the default by a long shot.

I hope that’s changing but you only have to log onto these boards once a day to see that lack of domestic support is probably the biggest single bugbear for women.

missdemeanors · 16/07/2022 16:53

@Thepeopleversuswork I think the bottom line is that there's positives and negatives about both scenarios: WOHP and SAHP. Lots of benefits to working- using your skills and experience, the social interaction and of course the financial independence and long term security. But in most jobs there's downsides too, and even in the most interesting job, there's days you probably don't want to drag yourself out of bed at stupid o'clock for the nursery run.

Similarly, looking after young children can be an absolute joy, but it's also relentless, there's nothing exciting about changing the 8th nappy of the day or refereeing screaming toddlers. And the SAHP inevitably ends up doing more on the domestic front because they're in the house to do it.

All this is the reason DH and I have tried to carve things up as evenly as possible. It hasn't been ideal (I said upthread, our babies were born long before transferable leave which is something we'd have loved) but we've done our best. Neither of us wanted to be funnelled into 'provider' or 'carer.' I'm as good at my job as dh is at his. He was equally good at changing nappies, reading stories and refereeing the toddlers as I was. Probably better than me at cooking dinner!

I hope for my own children the balance gets even easier to achieve. I don't think men and women are really so far apart that 99% of men just want to be breadwinner and 99% of women want to leave the workplace. And when you look at the things which attract a couple to each other it's often similar levels of education and standing in the workplace as well as shared goals and values.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/07/2022 16:22

TruthHertz · 16/07/2022 15:20

Women don't choose poorly paid work, there's nothing on the second X chromosome that gives us a preference for being poorer than men.

Yes, but they also don't have the pressure of being the main breadwinner which a man can be 99% sure he'll be.

I would dispute that it’s as high as 99%. It’s definitely a majority but female breadwinners are more common than they were.

But many men often choose that scenario because consciously or otherwise they prioritise work over family life because they find family life to be a drag.

They tell themselves its about being a “provider”.

But actually quite a lot of the time it’s an opt out of family life and it proves to be a double negative impact for the woman, a) because it’s harder for her to advance in her own career due to lack of engagement from the father and b) because she gets very little help at home.

Certainly if men did more on the domestic front it would go a long way to redress this imbalance.

Topgub · 16/07/2022 15:51

@BessieFinkNottle

Some sahm might work hard. Some don't

That has nothing to do with work ethic really.

Work ethic is defined as attitudes towards your job.

You can work hard at home and have a poor work ethic because you've chosen not to have a job.

It is entirely possible to have caring responsibilities and a job/career.

Suggesting those who don't have a job/career through choice have a poorer work ethic than those who do.

TruthHertz · 16/07/2022 15:20

Women don't choose poorly paid work, there's nothing on the second X chromosome that gives us a preference for being poorer than men.

Yes, but they also don't have the pressure of being the main breadwinner which a man can be 99% sure he'll be.

MrsBwced · 16/07/2022 15:18

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 14:50

Not being in paid employment doesn't have to mean you're not working, it simply means you're not paid for your work.
Lots of SAHPs work very hard indeed.

Exactly, giving up a job to look after small children is giving up paid work to do unpaid work.

BessieFinkNottle · 16/07/2022 15:16

Yes, of course WPs work very hard. I'm not disputing that for a moment.
My issue is that you can't seem to accept that many SAHPs work very hard too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread