Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
SuperCamp · 14/07/2022 12:59

A lot of generalisation there, OP.

But then there is often a lot of generalisation on MN.

For example, marriage is not always in the best interests of women or their children. If she owns a significant asset (e.g a house she bought before meeting him), earns more than him, is entering a second marriage that could see him inherit over her kids, etc.

I am always concerned to see women look at the whole context and do their best for their security, but never sneer at anyone.

Being a SAHM I would want to see a woman using family finances to pay into a pension if household income allows. To make sure her NI record is full. To be on the deeds to the house if not married, etc etc.

Personally I do not think anyone is secure if they are financially dependent on someone else. Or if they forgo promotion, professional development, a pension etc without knowing they will be OK in the longer term.

But that doesn’t mean I sneer at them, or their choices and decisions.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 12:58

@iabr I work part time. Because I want time with my children and work life balance. I do not need to do this for my DH, his arrangements are relatively unaffected either way, although we both acnkoweldge it makes our lives easier and we feel it has a benefit to our family.
But I also, without a doubt, go above and beyond to make sure that it doesn't negatively impact my work. Because for me it's important to illustrate to the people I work with that being part time doesn't mean you do a bad job, or you don't have equal value.

OooErr · 14/07/2022 12:54

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 12:44

If a SAHM dares to suggest this than they are told it's rubbish, what they do would simply be outsourced if they weren't around or they have no significant impact because after all working mothers do all that and work full time.

That's not the comments I see.

"That's not the comments I see."
Maybe you're not a SAHM so not particularly sensitive to these comments. But I assure you they're on MN. I've seen them repeatedly.
Some WOHM on here absolutely insist that they do everything a SAHM does and they work too! When SAHMs point out, yes, of course they do the same job, but that the SAHMs simply put in more hours as they don't outsource childcare...so it's same job, but longer hours vs shorter hours at home plus work....it seems to incense some WOHM. It really does. I've seen it on here time and again. It's very strange.
I could understand it if or when the SAHMs were implying they did a better job...but I've seen conversations just as I've described above, with a SAHM clearly acknowledging they do the same job and just choose to support the family in different ways. Some say they would love to contribute financially but can't because of their particular circumstances. And they still get raged at by some on here! As I said, it's strange and I believe the OP is right...women could with listening to what other women are saying.

Everybody is 'sensitive' to comments that attack them. There may be 100 supportive comments, 2 anti comments. But you only remember the latter.
Unless you used a machine learning algorithm and did a statistical analysis of exactly how many there are nobody knows for certain.

What I remember is an equal amount of snipping from both sides, by people who have extreme opinions. And a lot of them are retaliatory. So to answer your question the WOHM are probably 'incensed' because people have made comments like them being a part-time parent/ outsourcing theyr children/damage nursery does and the other way around is r.e. all the assumptions about SAHM that have been already discussed on this thread.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 12:53

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 12:44

If a SAHM dares to suggest this than they are told it's rubbish, what they do would simply be outsourced if they weren't around or they have no significant impact because after all working mothers do all that and work full time.

That's not the comments I see.

"That's not the comments I see."
Maybe you're not a SAHM so not particularly sensitive to these comments. But I assure you they're on MN. I've seen them repeatedly.
Some WOHM on here absolutely insist that they do everything a SAHM does and they work too! When SAHMs point out, yes, of course they do the same job, but that the SAHMs simply put in more hours as they don't outsource childcare...so it's same job, but longer hours vs shorter hours at home plus work....it seems to incense some WOHM. It really does. I've seen it on here time and again. It's very strange.
I could understand it if or when the SAHMs were implying they did a better job...but I've seen conversations just as I've described above, with a SAHM clearly acknowledging they do the same job and just choose to support the family in different ways. Some say they would love to contribute financially but can't because of their particular circumstances. And they still get raged at by some on here! As I said, it's strange and I believe the OP is right...women could with listening to what other women are saying.

That's because when you dig into what those SAHPs mean, what they mean is that you actually don't raise your kids or parent them other than brining in money. They can't imagine a woh parent actually spends time with, nutures, reads with, cooks for, cleans after their kids. They seem to imagine that those woh sweep in for an hour before an dafter work and outsource the rest. Presumably because that's what they allow their working husbands to do. When in fact all those things still need to be done by someone and, in the absence of the SAHP, they are done by those woh parents. Believe it or not!

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 12:50

There's a huge amount of societal value in children being raised well and becoming positive, considerate and productive members of society.

An absolutely key issue though, is that this doesn't have anything to do with WOH/SAH per se, since it's entirely possible to raise children with love, with their needs met and with sound values, whether you are a working or non working parent. And of course conversely, it's true that children can be neglected, abused and not raised well in a family where both, one or neither parent works.

To put it simply: society should value good parenting.

If a family decide for their own individual circumstance they want one parent to SAH then that's entirely up them but there's no reason why society as a whole should value that choice for it's own sake. Of course one would hope that the SAH themselves and their partner value it!

iabr · 14/07/2022 12:49

Just catching up. I don't want to stifle your discussion, but there will always be a carbon copy of this debate on any thread that is directly or obliquely related to 'SAHM.' In the past I've posted about something totally unrelated, but a few pages in, someone asks, "are you a SAHM OP?" And then that's it! The whole topic is derailed into this exact debate about the impact of SAHMs in society.

The fact that, on MN, SAHMs are almost expected to justify themselves or accept some kind of special responsibility for structural inequality is related to my point in the OP.

That point being - the whole WOHM v SAHM mentality on here is an utter nonsense. It is so ridiculously simplistic and does my head in, tbh.

Far more relevant to think of where you may fit on a spectrum. For instance -

What about the millions of women who work part-time in some capacity? Are they also contributing to structural inequality if they are enabling the DH to continue full time? Why do threads from women who work part time not inevitably develop into this wider debate about structural inequality?

What about women who work full time for low / average wages, but whose lifestyle is very significantly 'propped up' by a much higher earning husband? Yes she's ostensibly a WOHM, but is there really that much difference when you think about it?

What about women who are just low earners anyway? Particularly the women on next to MW who are looking after our children for us so that we can earn higher salaries than them? Should they be skewered at for not aiming to earn more? Is their decision to remain in low paid 'caring' roles' something to be ashamed of because they should be striving to push themselves harder to redress structural inequality?

Where would we be if these women in childcare were not prepared to work for practically MW to facilitate US (men and women) being able to work?

Ultimately, we are all 'facilitated' to some extent and by someone somewhere - whether it's a lower-paid childcare worker; a spouse who can works limited / fixed or more flexible hours; your mother or family members doing it for free perhaps? All these types of 'support' will come with their own benefits and limitations. The SAHM model is just one of an almost many models,. I totally get the point about structural inequality (obviously), but it's just another variation of family set-up with its own benefits and setbacks for women. When it works, it most certainly works - as has been the case for our family. It would not work for everyone though, and I completely accept it's not a choice most families are even in a position to make anyway these days..But realistically nobody is going to make their own life or their family's life harder if they don't need to. At the end of the day, families decide for themselves if they need two full time incomes or they don't. If they don't, it offers up other options. Simple as that really. You do what you need to do, but also what you want to do and what you can do.

OP posts:
OooErr · 14/07/2022 12:48

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/07/2022 08:15

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer

Regardless of what you think of being a SAHP, and women's right to choose to do just that, there is not doubt that women choosing that route has a negative impact on gender equality in the work place.

You raise a really important point and one which bears unpacking a bit.

This whole argument of "If I didn't SAH my husband wouldn't have been able to achieve what he has at work" is problematic for me because it perpetuates the idea that a working man needs and deserves a home helpmeet while a working woman doesn't. This attitude is really toxic and unhelpful to those of us who have to work and who have to compete with these men who are "facilitated" by SAHMs.

When I do encounter sexism at work its invariably not around my performance its around my inability to be basically sitting at a desk or going drinking in the City 24/7.

I work much harder than most of my male colleagues because as a single parent I have to. I have to start work at 6.30am to get a couple of hours in before the commute. I have to work most evenings. I put in far more hours and frankly I am better at my job than a lot of them.

But I still get told off for not being more "present" and not being able to network and be seen. And consequently I haven't been as far promoted as many of my male colleagues.

If I had a "facilitator" I would be able to go drinking in the City 2/3 nights a week and play golf and sit at my desk scratching my arse and looking at social media until 7pm. But I don't because I can't and consequently I work much more efficiently as a result. But I am still judged to be handicapped by my inability to "participate" in the social side of the job.

The phenomenon of the "facilitating" SAHM plays a part in this. It allows these men to be being "present" and "participating". I'm not saying that SAHMs owe working mums not to do this.

Clearly women have to make the choices that suit them best and fair enough as you can't sacrifice your life and happiness for a notional societal goal. But when people come on here and trot out this line about the "invaluable support" they are providing to their husband to further his career (for him to go out drinking) it does make me bristle.

If there were fewer of the "facilitators" the men in corporate life would have to step up a bit more on the home front and organise their schedules better in a way women in careers now have to. Women would be better supported at home, would be freed up to get more done, their children would see more of their dads and they able to earn at greater parity with men and the balance of responsibilities between the sexes would hopefully start to even out. So, sue me, but I feel a bit cynical about those SAHMs who celebrate the fact that they are facilitating their DH's glittering careers.

@5128gap

EXACTLY. SAY IT LOUDER FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK.

I have made the point on multiple threads but it somehow always gets ignored.

In the long run policy choices should discourage SAHP. Meaning better funded childcare, part-time working etc. But I actively oppose things like 'tax breaks for SAHP' unless they are carers for disabled children.

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 12:44

If a SAHM dares to suggest this than they are told it's rubbish, what they do would simply be outsourced if they weren't around or they have no significant impact because after all working mothers do all that and work full time.

That's not the comments I see.

"That's not the comments I see."
Maybe you're not a SAHM so not particularly sensitive to these comments. But I assure you they're on MN. I've seen them repeatedly.
Some WOHM on here absolutely insist that they do everything a SAHM does and they work too! When SAHMs point out, yes, of course they do the same job, but that the SAHMs simply put in more hours as they don't outsource childcare...so it's same job, but longer hours vs shorter hours at home plus work....it seems to incense some WOHM. It really does. I've seen it on here time and again. It's very strange.
I could understand it if or when the SAHMs were implying they did a better job...but I've seen conversations just as I've described above, with a SAHM clearly acknowledging they do the same job and just choose to support the family in different ways. Some say they would love to contribute financially but can't because of their particular circumstances. And they still get raged at by some on here! As I said, it's strange and I believe the OP is right...women could with listening to what other women are saying.

5128gap · 14/07/2022 12:38

MrsBwced · 14/07/2022 12:24

I think that's a slightly different argument. Often SAHPs argue that their role should be as highly valued as a person's role outside the home, and demonstrate this by explaining that their DH would have been unable to save the planet, negotiate world peace or whatever he does without them. The counter argument is that he could indeed have done it without them, but would just have had to work harder, or pay for the support, like people without a SAHP do.
That's not quite how I've seen the discussions go.
In my experience SAHP are told this is what they have to tell themselves to make peace with the fact they are in fact spongers or leeches, while simultaneously being told what they do is enabling our husbands at the detriment of everybody else.
I don't think there's anything wrong with wanting to be valued by society. Everybody deserves respect regardless of employment status.

Everyone, well almost everyone, deserves respect as a human being, and for their strengths and qualities. Not everyone deserves respect and to be valued by society for their role. If you choose a role that benefits no one other than yourself and your partner, it's not reasonable to expect respect for that, other than (hopefully) from your partner. It doesn't mean people are saying that you're not a valued and worthwhile person, merely that your role of SAHP is not what you're valued for.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 12:38

ImAvingOops · 14/07/2022 12:33

I don't care if society doesn't value what I do - I saw value in it and so did my husband, and it's our views that matter. But it would be nice not to be insulted.

Do you consider it an insult if someone says that a SAHM doesn't have value from an objective, societal perspective?

ImAvingOops · 14/07/2022 12:33

I don't care if society doesn't value what I do - I saw value in it and so did my husband, and it's our views that matter. But it would be nice not to be insulted.

ImAvingOops · 14/07/2022 12:30

@MrsBwced a contract within a marriage or relationship.
I guess comparable to when you buy a house - the mortgage is a big financial commitment and you have to sign that you can afford it, agree to the t&c.
One person becoming a sahp is equally a huge commitment with far reaching financial consequences. It wouldn't hurt if people had it spelled out to them what these were.

Mary46 · 14/07/2022 12:29

Have been sahm. Its def risky if one job goes though. I was home when kids young. Part T now but could do with more hours. Its too risky rely on 1 wage

TheLostNights · 14/07/2022 12:28

I have a female friend who is single, works in a low paid job and is judged constantly. I have another female friend who again, has a low paying job but her husband earns big money so they can afford a lovely house and holidays. She is seen as successful. 😕 yet if her husband left her, she would be judged the same as other friend.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 12:26

MrsBwced · 14/07/2022 12:24

I think that's a slightly different argument. Often SAHPs argue that their role should be as highly valued as a person's role outside the home, and demonstrate this by explaining that their DH would have been unable to save the planet, negotiate world peace or whatever he does without them. The counter argument is that he could indeed have done it without them, but would just have had to work harder, or pay for the support, like people without a SAHP do.
That's not quite how I've seen the discussions go.
In my experience SAHP are told this is what they have to tell themselves to make peace with the fact they are in fact spongers or leeches, while simultaneously being told what they do is enabling our husbands at the detriment of everybody else.
I don't think there's anything wrong with wanting to be valued by society. Everybody deserves respect regardless of employment status.

I acknowlege that many people wouldn't consider propping up a man as a benefit to society. I can see how it might benefit the individual family (although ref pps's comment on two wages may be better from a tax and secruity stand point), but society, not. Not least because of the negative implications on gender equality.

MrsBwced · 14/07/2022 12:24

I think that's a slightly different argument. Often SAHPs argue that their role should be as highly valued as a person's role outside the home, and demonstrate this by explaining that their DH would have been unable to save the planet, negotiate world peace or whatever he does without them. The counter argument is that he could indeed have done it without them, but would just have had to work harder, or pay for the support, like people without a SAHP do.
That's not quite how I've seen the discussions go.
In my experience SAHP are told this is what they have to tell themselves to make peace with the fact they are in fact spongers or leeches, while simultaneously being told what they do is enabling our husbands at the detriment of everybody else.
I don't think there's anything wrong with wanting to be valued by society. Everybody deserves respect regardless of employment status.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 12:12

It would be beneficial if couples sign legally enforceable contracts when they decide for one to be a sahp - signalling that they acknowledge the benefit to the family as a whole, recognising that this arrangement will have implications for earning potential etc of the sahp and therefore agreeing that the wohp income belongs to both parties, both now and in the future should they divorce, until the sahp is sufficiently compensated financially.

A marriage contract?

Hankunamatata · 14/07/2022 12:03

I think you need to plan for the worse and hope for the best which many women and men dont do. I kept my job, if dh disappears tomorrow I know I could up my hours and keep everything running and the house. We keep separate savings of the same amount so neither of us are vulnerable. I earn less as pick up more of childcare so we pay into a private pension for me. I hope to be married forever but I plan for the worse

5128gap · 14/07/2022 11:52

MrsBwced · 14/07/2022 11:37

Those men couldn't do what they do without those women and would therefore have to change.
If a SAHM dares to suggest this than they are told it's rubbish, what they do would simply be outsourced if they weren't around or they have no significant impact because after all working mothers do all that and work full time.

I think that's a slightly different argument. Often SAHPs argue that their role should be as highly valued as a person's role outside the home, and demonstrate this by explaining that their DH would have been unable to save the planet, negotiate world peace or whatever he does without them. The counter argument is that he could indeed have done it without them, but would just have had to work harder, or pay for the support, like people without a SAHP do.

ImAvingOops · 14/07/2022 11:51

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer you might not have seen those comments but trust me, they are definitely there and crop up on most sahp threads.

ImAvingOops · 14/07/2022 11:49

Most of what is wrong in society could be fixed if men as a class changed their behaviour!
Starting with paying proper child support - it would make a lot of sahm much less vulnerable if this was properly enforced as a starter.

Personally I'd like for there to be public information campaigns so that non married women know the common law wife thing isn't real. It would be beneficial if couples sign legally enforceable contracts when they decide for one to be a sahp - signalling that they acknowledge the benefit to the family as a whole, recognising that this arrangement will have implications for earning potential etc of the sahp and therefore agreeing that the wohp income belongs to both parties, both now and in the future should they divorce, until the sahp is sufficiently compensated financially. I think this would really focus both parties attention on what they are agreeing to and ensure that neither is disadvantaged or advantaged more than the other. If a wohp won't sign, then you know from the get go that you've married someone who won't protect you if the shit hits the fan.
It shouldn't be necessary but sadly I think it is, at least until we live in a world where men aren't allowed to duck responsibility for their dc.

ApplesandBunions · 14/07/2022 11:41

5128gap · 14/07/2022 11:33

If there were men on the thread with SAHPs I'm fairly certain they would be being asked to think about the impact of their behaviour.
I'm equally certain most wouldn't care less.
Very few men would be interested in relinquishing some of their own advantage to uplift women, so there very little point in sitting around asking them to see the error of their ways.

I'm much less certain than you are that men would be held equally accountable, but agree that lots of them simply wouldn't give a shit if they were. However, none of that means framing the issue as simply SAHPs ought to consider the wider impact of their actions is justifiable, especially as there's no reason to imagine people who have made a particular decision for what they perceive to be the good of their families are going to be any more receptive.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 11:41

MrsBwced · 14/07/2022 11:37

Those men couldn't do what they do without those women and would therefore have to change.
If a SAHM dares to suggest this than they are told it's rubbish, what they do would simply be outsourced if they weren't around or they have no significant impact because after all working mothers do all that and work full time.

That's not the comments I see. I don't think anyone denies that SAHMs enable men to reduce their responsibility at home or as fathers. Quite the opposite. But people question the value/ benefit of doing so.

ApplesandBunions · 14/07/2022 11:39

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 11:32

hey? You've lost me entirely....

And I didn't say only one group should consider the impact of their behaviours....

Then I'm not sure where you think we disagree?

MrsBwced · 14/07/2022 11:37

Those men couldn't do what they do without those women and would therefore have to change.
If a SAHM dares to suggest this than they are told it's rubbish, what they do would simply be outsourced if they weren't around or they have no significant impact because after all working mothers do all that and work full time.