Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 13:33

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer
very good point.

Parenting is a relationship. It's about imparting what you believe are good values, providing enriching experiences, role modelling .... It can be done well (or not!) regardless of whether one, both or neither parent works. Parenting is not inherently about WOH/SAH.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 13:32

It may sound cynical, but it's the truth.

It doesn't sound cynical, it just sounds relevant to only a very small percentage of society. And if you're that well off, it's hard to feel too much sympathy when your only problem is people on the Internet assuming you're not loaded when you are.

MsPincher · 14/07/2022 13:30

MrsBwced · 14/07/2022 13:17

But SAHPs are the only ones actively facilitating someone's lack of domestic responsibilities. It's not comparable to a situation where people don't have them in the first place.

Working patterns often need to change when kids come along, but when we have a situation where SAHP (predominately women) are ensuring their partner can carry on regardless, this will of course negatively impact women (mostly) who don't have that kind of support.

Again, it's not just SAHM facilitating this. My in laws do all childcare for SIL and her DH they go to their house, care for the kids and the dog, cook all the meals do chores, take them to clubs etc.
Two of my DC have friends who live with GP's during the week while their parents work, another lived with an Aunt as her Dad worked abroad and her mum in a city miles away.
My children's godparents have a full time nanny who does the same.

To be fair there is something in this - the reason working patterns often are difficult for working parents (especially in higher paid jobs) is because so many men still have someone else doing the grunt work.

But that being said a lot of women claim to be facilitating their male partners in my profession by not working. Yet the women in equivalent jobs are working without having someone to facilitate them (usually they have a working spouse rather than me with no spouse).

as a matter of feminism the stereotypical division of labour has led to women individually being poorer and as a class. I suppose though it does benefit some individual women (at least while they are in the relationship) as they don’t have to work and yet can access wealth. But it’s a bad thing for women as a whole imo. And some men too who often barely know anything of their kids lives and are left working stressful jobs when they’d rather not.

TheKeatingFive · 14/07/2022 13:30

Oh, if you only mean people who are making that claim thekeatimgfive then I think you and I are talking at cross purposes. I know you weren't addressing me here but it's the same point.

Sorry yes I do mean that. I tried to clarify in another post, but it has all become a bit confusing.

ApplesandBunions · 14/07/2022 13:28

I doubt they're claiming credit for SIL/DH's progress in their careers however. Which is specifically what I'm talking about

Oh, if you only mean people who are making that claim thekeatimgfive then I think you and I are talking at cross purposes. I know you weren't addressing me here but it's the same point.

iabr · 14/07/2022 13:27

"Personally I do not think anyone is secure if they are financially dependent on someone else"

If by "financially dependent" you mean "income dependent" you are right and I would 100% agree.

Nobody I know, who has made the lifestyle choice to be a SAHM long term or indefinitely, would have done that if they were dependent on the DH income alone. They would not take that risk (not beyond a year or two max). More importantly, they would not subject their children to that risk. Even if the DH is a mega-high earner salary-wise, it's still a massive risk because if he goes, the massive salary goes with him. This is obvious.

In areas where there are a lot of long term SAHMs (through choice as opposed to necessity), these will high asset families (property, investments etc).In these cases, there are many ways to take steps to ensure you and your children are not financially vulnerable. To put it bluntly, I don't think anyone I know would have been a SAHM if they weren't certain they could walk out of the marriage with more then they could have earned themselves over the same period (and more than mitigate against loss of future earning potential and pension). It may sound cynical, but it's the truth.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 14/07/2022 13:26

To be very clear, I don't have any issue with couple who organise their lives this way.

It's when SAHM's come on here and say that them being at home has been
a driving force in DH's career progress and he couldn't have done it without them as SAHM, that's what I find problematic from a feminist POV. And I have never heard a similar sentiment from a man.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 13:25

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 13:22

No, there was a thread not too long ago where SAHP were literally saying they did not believe that woh parents did this sort of thing. And that they acknowledged that bringing in money to the home was a part of parenting, therefore woh were doing parenting.

My point is not everyone thinks the same!
SAHMs don't all have the same opinions, neither do WOHMs.
Just because one SAHM says something nasty doesn't mean the next SAHM who posts should be attacked. The same for WOHMs.

What I was objecting to upthread was a pp saying they had never seen comments suggesting that WOHMs do all that a SAHM do and work. In fact, those comments crop up on MN with numbing regularity.

Ok - what is it that you think woh don't do then..... In terms of parenting. I mean of course not for as many hours, and certainly not the function of childcare during work hours which is outsourced for obvious reasons, but in terms of parenting functions. This is how it came out last round that the SAHM in question actually only really believed that the woh brought in money and not much else....

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 13:22

No, there was a thread not too long ago where SAHP were literally saying they did not believe that woh parents did this sort of thing. And that they acknowledged that bringing in money to the home was a part of parenting, therefore woh were doing parenting.

My point is not everyone thinks the same!
SAHMs don't all have the same opinions, neither do WOHMs.
Just because one SAHM says something nasty doesn't mean the next SAHM who posts should be attacked. The same for WOHMs.

What I was objecting to upthread was a pp saying they had never seen comments suggesting that WOHMs do all that a SAHM do and work. In fact, those comments crop up on MN with numbing regularity.

TheKeatingFive · 14/07/2022 13:22

My in laws do all childcare for SIL and her DH they go to their house, care for the kids and the dog, cook all the meals do chores, take them to clubs etc.

I doubt they're claiming credit for SIL/DH's progress in their careers however. Which is specifically what I'm talking about.

Two of my DC have friends who live with GP's during the week while their parents work, another lived with an Aunt as her Dad worked abroad and her mum in a city miles away.

Those are highly unusual situations to be fair.

My children's godparents have a full time nanny who does the same.

She's being paid to do a job. Again, not the same thing.

In none of these cases are the facilitators focused on facilitating only men to do their jobs. And that's the bit that's problematic from a feminism POV.

ImAvingOops · 14/07/2022 13:21

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 12:38

Do you consider it an insult if someone says that a SAHM doesn't have value from an objective, societal perspective?

I don't feel insulted by that tbh. I do feel insulted by being called a leech or told my dh won't respect me, because I am adding value to our family. And it's just rude and nasty and generally disrespectful to speak about people like that.

And I'm not sure that all jobs add value to society either. Lots of people aren't earning enough to pay tax or aren't doing jobs that make society better.

ApplesandBunions · 14/07/2022 13:21

TheKeatingFive · 14/07/2022 13:04

It's valid to talk about how some people in the workplace have much more significant domestic responsibilities than others, and the impact this has, but men with SAHPs are only one part of that picture. And it is quite telling that it gets framed as SAHPs look at the impact your facilitation has.

But SAHPs are the only ones actively facilitating someone's lack of domestic responsibilities. It's not comparable to a situation where people don't have them in the first place.

Working patterns often need to change when kids come along, but when we have a situation where SAHP (predominately women) are ensuring their partner can carry on regardless, this will of course negatively impact women (mostly) who don't have that kind of support.

So yes, I think it's a very problematic position from a feminist point of view.

As pointed out a couple of posts up, this simply isn't true. It's also highly problematic from a feminist point of view to frame the issue in this way, with no matching demands on the people who are getting facilitated, and are generally the more powerful and advantaged parties.

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 13:19

@MrsBwced true but it's predominantly women who facilitate this which is an issue

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 13:19

MsPincher · 14/07/2022 13:18

Some sahm make stupid claims to woh parents (I didn’t have kids for someone else to raise them) and some don’t. Not possible to make a blanket generalization

As opposed to woh, who are all a humogenous group of SAHM sneering meanies?

MsPincher · 14/07/2022 13:18

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 13:10

No, there was a thread not too long ago where SAHP were literally saying they did not believe that woh parents did this sort of thing. And that they acknowledged that bringing in money to the home was a part of parenting, therefore woh were doing parenting.

Some sahm make stupid claims to woh parents (I didn’t have kids for someone else to raise them) and some don’t. Not possible to make a blanket generalization

MrsBwced · 14/07/2022 13:17

But SAHPs are the only ones actively facilitating someone's lack of domestic responsibilities. It's not comparable to a situation where people don't have them in the first place.

Working patterns often need to change when kids come along, but when we have a situation where SAHP (predominately women) are ensuring their partner can carry on regardless, this will of course negatively impact women (mostly) who don't have that kind of support.

Again, it's not just SAHM facilitating this. My in laws do all childcare for SIL and her DH they go to their house, care for the kids and the dog, cook all the meals do chores, take them to clubs etc.
Two of my DC have friends who live with GP's during the week while their parents work, another lived with an Aunt as her Dad worked abroad and her mum in a city miles away.
My children's godparents have a full time nanny who does the same.

MsPincher · 14/07/2022 13:15

I’ve never seen any sahm being criticized for being “just a mum”. Single mums (like me) on the other hand are fair game it seems on mn for criticism. Someone told me on a thread that I should have had an abortion. I am a hard working professional who pays my own way.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 13:12

to add @Marynotsocontrary I think it's worth noting that there's a whole thread of woh sayng they aren't sneering, and are told they are by SAHM. But when the shoe is on the other foot and woh are recounting what they have had said to them then they are definitely just imagining misunderstanding it all.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 13:10

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 13:07

That's because when you dig into what those SAHPs mean, what they mean is that you actually don't raise your kids or parent them other than brining in money. They can't imagine a woh parent actually spends time with, nutures, reads with, cooks for, cleans after their kids. They seem to imagine that those woh sweep in for an hour before an dafter work and outsource the rest. Presumably because that's what they allow their working husbands to do. When in fact all those things still need to be done by someone and, in the absence of the SAHP, they are done by those woh parents. Believe it or not!

No, this is the problem.
You are saying here what you think they mean.
I have read threads on here where the OP was extremely clear that she did not mean anything negative. She was clear that, if circumstances allowed, she would prefer to work outside the home. She felt she was letting her children down financially. Yet as soon as she said 'I'm a SAHM' others (WOHM) thought she was sneering at them as you have described above. She wasn't.
And she was attacked by many instead of receiving support.

As I said, listening to and not pre-judging people is crucial so I agree with the OP of this thread.

No, there was a thread not too long ago where SAHP were literally saying they did not believe that woh parents did this sort of thing. And that they acknowledged that bringing in money to the home was a part of parenting, therefore woh were doing parenting.

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 13:10

One thing I've always found a little problematic about the issue of people feeling valued, is what would that actually look like in reality?

I mean, if I'd decided to be a SAHM, I would have expected my DH to show that he valued it (because presumably it would have been a joint decision.) But in terms of wider society.... well, it wouldn't occur to me to expect 'society' to 'value' something which would have been a personal choice and didn't affect anyone outside our own family.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 13:09

iabr · 14/07/2022 13:05

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer You don't need to justify why you work part-time. Whatever works for you, works for you. Obviously. My whole point is that no woman should need to justify anything - including SAHMs.

I dont' feel a need to justify it per se. I do feel though that I don't need to contribute to an issue in society that I find massively annoying and which has negatively impacted me personally.

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 13:07

That's because when you dig into what those SAHPs mean, what they mean is that you actually don't raise your kids or parent them other than brining in money. They can't imagine a woh parent actually spends time with, nutures, reads with, cooks for, cleans after their kids. They seem to imagine that those woh sweep in for an hour before an dafter work and outsource the rest. Presumably because that's what they allow their working husbands to do. When in fact all those things still need to be done by someone and, in the absence of the SAHP, they are done by those woh parents. Believe it or not!

No, this is the problem.
You are saying here what you think they mean.
I have read threads on here where the OP was extremely clear that she did not mean anything negative. She was clear that, if circumstances allowed, she would prefer to work outside the home. She felt she was letting her children down financially. Yet as soon as she said 'I'm a SAHM' others (WOHM) thought she was sneering at them as you have described above. She wasn't.
And she was attacked by many instead of receiving support.

As I said, listening to and not pre-judging people is crucial so I agree with the OP of this thread.

iabr · 14/07/2022 13:05

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer You don't need to justify why you work part-time. Whatever works for you, works for you. Obviously. My whole point is that no woman should need to justify anything - including SAHMs.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 14/07/2022 13:04

It's valid to talk about how some people in the workplace have much more significant domestic responsibilities than others, and the impact this has, but men with SAHPs are only one part of that picture. And it is quite telling that it gets framed as SAHPs look at the impact your facilitation has.

But SAHPs are the only ones actively facilitating someone's lack of domestic responsibilities. It's not comparable to a situation where people don't have them in the first place.

Working patterns often need to change when kids come along, but when we have a situation where SAHP (predominately women) are ensuring their partner can carry on regardless, this will of course negatively impact women (mostly) who don't have that kind of support.

So yes, I think it's a very problematic position from a feminist point of view.

MrsBwced · 14/07/2022 13:00

I think society should value all caring roles even unpaid ones. I think good parenting regardless of whether the parent is at home or working is absolutely valuable to society as is caring for the disabled and elderly.