Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 14:29

MsPincher · 14/07/2022 14:27

If you’re doing it because that’s what works best for your family regardless of wider social consequences, why do you need other people to validate your choices?

Which is exactly why I asked the question in the first place.

PP said she categorically didn't care, as it was best for her and her family. Then said she wouldn't be insulted. So I asked if she was insulted by it. Either you care (and are insulted) or you don't (and aren't insulted because you don't care). Or something!

MsPincher · 14/07/2022 14:27

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 14:24

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer it's not just the why, it's the how they should be valued. I mean, what does valuing a SAHP look like? If you've chosen to be one, and your partner supports you, surely that in itself is the value. What more are people looking for?! I honestly don't get that bit

If you’re doing it because that’s what works best for your family regardless of wider social consequences, why do you need other people to validate your choices?

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 14:27

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 14:24

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer it's not just the why, it's the how they should be valued. I mean, what does valuing a SAHP look like? If you've chosen to be one, and your partner supports you, surely that in itself is the value. What more are people looking for?! I honestly don't get that bit

Apparently its telling them how amazing they are for supporting their husband's glorious careers, and NEVER suggesting that they might possibly be putting themselves in a prevarious financial position.

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 14:24

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer it's not just the why, it's the how they should be valued. I mean, what does valuing a SAHP look like? If you've chosen to be one, and your partner supports you, surely that in itself is the value. What more are people looking for?! I honestly don't get that bit

MsPincher · 14/07/2022 14:22

OooErr · 14/07/2022 12:48

@5128gap

EXACTLY. SAY IT LOUDER FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE BACK.

I have made the point on multiple threads but it somehow always gets ignored.

In the long run policy choices should discourage SAHP. Meaning better funded childcare, part-time working etc. But I actively oppose things like 'tax breaks for SAHP' unless they are carers for disabled children.

This!

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 14:17

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 14:12

I don't think SAHPs do anything extra in terms of parenting functions. I simply think they spend more hours in the home/involved in childcare while WOHPs work and outsource childcare while they do so.
Neither situation is better or worse for children...some setups suit certain people/families better, or people may not have a choice for financial reasons or because they have a child with additional needs etc.

I just wish people on both sides would stop judging others. On this thread pps have said they don't value what SAHMs do. You can given examples of the opposite. It seems very conceited to me to say one doesn't value what a stranger is doing.

But it's not a personal value juddment. In my above examply I am not saying Jane isn't worthless or useless. It's in response to this "we as SAHMs should be valued by society". Ok, but why exactly. You provide value to your family and your partners. You provide value to yourself. Great, amazing. I am happy you have found what you want to do. That doesn't mean that is of value to society and needs to be recognised does it? Especailly by all the SAHMs on this thread proclaiming how they don't care what anyone thinks, becaue it's what's best for them.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 14:14

all around me, in a highly populated area, that type of SAHM is the norm.

I don't think anyone on here has denied that what is all around you personally is your norm.

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 14:14

Seems we've got to the nub of the issue here. Society should value good parenting because ultimately that benefits us all. We all know how costly the impact of neglect and poor parenting can be.

Good parenting is not dependent on working or not.

If two parents decide that for their family, they want to have one parent SAH then obviously both parents should value that decision and the roles of each other. Outside the family, wider society really doesn't give a hoot.

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 14:12

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 13:25

Ok - what is it that you think woh don't do then..... In terms of parenting. I mean of course not for as many hours, and certainly not the function of childcare during work hours which is outsourced for obvious reasons, but in terms of parenting functions. This is how it came out last round that the SAHM in question actually only really believed that the woh brought in money and not much else....

I don't think SAHPs do anything extra in terms of parenting functions. I simply think they spend more hours in the home/involved in childcare while WOHPs work and outsource childcare while they do so.
Neither situation is better or worse for children...some setups suit certain people/families better, or people may not have a choice for financial reasons or because they have a child with additional needs etc.

I just wish people on both sides would stop judging others. On this thread pps have said they don't value what SAHMs do. You can given examples of the opposite. It seems very conceited to me to say one doesn't value what a stranger is doing.

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 14:10

'Which is only a valid point in this context if you consider good parent and SAHP to be interchangeable terms.*'
*
Exactly! And obviously they're not, because there are good, satisfactory and piss poor parents among all elements of society, working or not!

iabr · 14/07/2022 14:09

ReneBumsWombats

" It doesn't sound cynical, it just sounds relevant to only a very small percentage of society"

Of course it's only relevant to a very small percentage of society. That is precisely because SAHMs are a small percentage of society anyway, and the ones I describe will be a certain proportion of those. I can't tell you the relative size of that proportion. There is no census info. about household wealth in relation to having. SAHM (as far as I can tell, maybe someone has something)? But all I can tell you is all around me, in a highly populated area, that type of SAHM is the norm. I would be interested to see data actually for the demographics and locations of families with women who SAH beyond the ore-school years. I suspect around me there are hundreds of thousands, but hard to know how this fits with the overall national picture without any data to contextualise.

OP posts:
Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 14:09

5128gap · 14/07/2022 14:04

Its not arrogance to say that certain roles are valued by society and others are not. Its an objective statement of fact. Sometimes imo 'society' gets it wrong, like the greater value attached to jobs that make profit as oppose to those that help people; but as a general rule, people value roles that they percieve to bring benefit to themselves and others.
Which is why most people would place greater value on the role of a surgeon than that of a social media influencer, for example.
Obviously within this people's opinions vary dependent on the own priorities, but realistically few people will value a role they don't feel has any positive impact on their lives.
I don't see what wrong with pointing that out, when surely its just common sense?

Agreed.

I can see the societal value in good parenting. But does SAHPing mean good parenting? Can that not be achieved by woh parents? It is no benefit to me (or society) that Jane chooses not to work so Bob can work all hours. In fact that arguably has an indirect negative impact for me (for all the reasons we've already touched on). So would I say Jane's role (not Jane herself as person) as a SAHM has societal value. No.

Were it the other way around, so that Bob was a SAHD I would - perhaps unfairly - feel it had more value, because it would be challenging the traditional gender roles that hold so many women back.

MsPincher · 14/07/2022 14:08

TheKeatingFive · 14/07/2022 14:05

I think SIL and BIL would be the first ones to say they couldn't do it without them.

Presumably the in-laws have had their own lives/careers though. I doubt they're actually going round asking for that kind of credit however. If they are I'm sure people think they're deluded.@

In doing what works best for my family I am to be held accountable for facilitating my husband's career (though I'm not allowed to say that's what I'm doing)

In doing what's best for your family, you are doing just that - and of course that's your choice to make. However I do think there are wider implications of that.

If what's best for your family is you stepping out of the workforce in order to facilitate your DH's rise within that, then there are obvious repercussions for other women and feminist principles generally. I'm not saying that's your conflict to solve, but at least be aware of it.

Yes agreed. It’s not an attack on individuals but these choices have consequences for other women and society in general.

TheKeatingFive · 14/07/2022 14:08

However those who are employed who could be facilitating change but who have other means to enable them to have a family with minimal impact on their careers

In none of the cases that you use as a comparison point is anyone stepping back from the workforce in order to facilitate someone else's rise within it.

5128gap · 14/07/2022 14:08

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 13:51

'I am just amazed that any human being has the sheer arrogance to declare what roles are to be considered 'valued' 'from an 'objective, societal perspective.' I mean, really? Astonishing is all I can say.'

Astonishing? Really?

It seems pretty obvious to me that being a good parent is a role that objectively, society should value. It is far better for society as a whole to have parents who fulfil their childrens' physical and emotional needs, who love them, impart decent values in them, support their education etc

The cost to society of neglectful or poor parenting is huge- both financially and in other ways.

And of course there are a huge number of paid jobs which benefit society tremendously too.

Which is only a valid point in this context if you consider good parent and SAHP to be interchangeable terms.

MsPincher · 14/07/2022 14:06

ImAvingOops · 14/07/2022 13:38

But that being said a lot of women claim to be facilitating their male partners in my profession by not working. Yet the women in equivalent jobs are working without having someone to facilitate them

And there are posts from these women saying that they are at a disadvantage because their colleagues have support. So therefore it must be true that the sahm are facilitating their spouses careers.

women with children competing with men with no childcare responsibilities are definitely at a disadvantage yes. But it’s not true that they need a non working spouse to do their job or that those with someone else to pick up the slack couldn’t be doing more at home. The very fact they are working shows that.

What we do need is for more men to insist on family friendly hours and to take more responsibility with the kids. That would make a big difference to sex inequality.

TheKeatingFive · 14/07/2022 14:05

I think SIL and BIL would be the first ones to say they couldn't do it without them.

Presumably the in-laws have had their own lives/careers though. I doubt they're actually going round asking for that kind of credit however. If they are I'm sure people think they're deluded.@

In doing what works best for my family I am to be held accountable for facilitating my husband's career (though I'm not allowed to say that's what I'm doing)

In doing what's best for your family, you are doing just that - and of course that's your choice to make. However I do think there are wider implications of that.

If what's best for your family is you stepping out of the workforce in order to facilitate your DH's rise within that, then there are obvious repercussions for other women and feminist principles generally. I'm not saying that's your conflict to solve, but at least be aware of it.

5128gap · 14/07/2022 14:04

iabr · 14/07/2022 13:45

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer

"Do you consider it an insult if someone says that a SAHM doesn't have value from an objective, societal perspective?"

I don't really care to be honest because 'value' is so subjective as to be almost meaningless. I do wonder why some posters need to bang on about this ad infinitum though. But that's about them. I'm not responsible for these people.

I have my own views about roles that are valuable in society. The difference is, I don't inflict these in other people because I would never expect anyone to care.

I am just amazed that any human being has the sheer arrogance to declare what roles are to be considered 'valued' 'from an 'objective, societal perspective.' I mean, really? Astonishing is all I can say.

Its not arrogance to say that certain roles are valued by society and others are not. Its an objective statement of fact. Sometimes imo 'society' gets it wrong, like the greater value attached to jobs that make profit as oppose to those that help people; but as a general rule, people value roles that they percieve to bring benefit to themselves and others.
Which is why most people would place greater value on the role of a surgeon than that of a social media influencer, for example.
Obviously within this people's opinions vary dependent on the own priorities, but realistically few people will value a role they don't feel has any positive impact on their lives.
I don't see what wrong with pointing that out, when surely its just common sense?

MrsBwced · 14/07/2022 13:58

I doubt they're claiming credit for SIL/DH's progress in their careers however. Which is specifically what I'm talking about.

Ha! You clearly haven't met my in laws.

I think SIL and BIL would be the first ones to say they couldn't do it without them. Just like my husband says the same about me.

Those are highly unusual situations to be fair.
In the UK yes, although having a SAHP isn't a majority situation either. There's not many at my DC's school especially now they're older, most parents work at least part time.

In none of these cases are the facilitators focused on facilitating only men to do their jobs. And that's the bit that's problematic from a feminism POV.
And this is what I have a problem with.
In doing what works best for my family I am to be held accountable for facilitating my husband's career (though I'm not allowed to say that's what I'm doing)
I should be in the workplace in order for things to change and help pave the way for others.
However those who are employed who could be facilitating change but who have other means to enable them to have a family with minimal impact on their careers because presumably that's what is best for their families are not accountable.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 13:53

I am just amazed that any human being has the sheer arrogance to declare what roles are to be considered 'valued' 'from an 'objective, societal perspective.' I mean, really? Astonishing is all I can say.

What amazes and astonishes you?

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 14/07/2022 13:53

@iabr I am not talked about value as a person. Be atonished for your out of context conclusions all you want.

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 13:51

'I am just amazed that any human being has the sheer arrogance to declare what roles are to be considered 'valued' 'from an 'objective, societal perspective.' I mean, really? Astonishing is all I can say.'

Astonishing? Really?

It seems pretty obvious to me that being a good parent is a role that objectively, society should value. It is far better for society as a whole to have parents who fulfil their childrens' physical and emotional needs, who love them, impart decent values in them, support their education etc

The cost to society of neglectful or poor parenting is huge- both financially and in other ways.

And of course there are a huge number of paid jobs which benefit society tremendously too.

iabr · 14/07/2022 13:45

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer

"Do you consider it an insult if someone says that a SAHM doesn't have value from an objective, societal perspective?"

I don't really care to be honest because 'value' is so subjective as to be almost meaningless. I do wonder why some posters need to bang on about this ad infinitum though. But that's about them. I'm not responsible for these people.

I have my own views about roles that are valuable in society. The difference is, I don't inflict these in other people because I would never expect anyone to care.

I am just amazed that any human being has the sheer arrogance to declare what roles are to be considered 'valued' 'from an 'objective, societal perspective.' I mean, really? Astonishing is all I can say.

OP posts:
ImAvingOops · 14/07/2022 13:38

But that being said a lot of women claim to be facilitating their male partners in my profession by not working. Yet the women in equivalent jobs are working without having someone to facilitate them

And there are posts from these women saying that they are at a disadvantage because their colleagues have support. So therefore it must be true that the sahm are facilitating their spouses careers.

MsPincher · 14/07/2022 13:35

iabr · 14/07/2022 12:49

Just catching up. I don't want to stifle your discussion, but there will always be a carbon copy of this debate on any thread that is directly or obliquely related to 'SAHM.' In the past I've posted about something totally unrelated, but a few pages in, someone asks, "are you a SAHM OP?" And then that's it! The whole topic is derailed into this exact debate about the impact of SAHMs in society.

The fact that, on MN, SAHMs are almost expected to justify themselves or accept some kind of special responsibility for structural inequality is related to my point in the OP.

That point being - the whole WOHM v SAHM mentality on here is an utter nonsense. It is so ridiculously simplistic and does my head in, tbh.

Far more relevant to think of where you may fit on a spectrum. For instance -

What about the millions of women who work part-time in some capacity? Are they also contributing to structural inequality if they are enabling the DH to continue full time? Why do threads from women who work part time not inevitably develop into this wider debate about structural inequality?

What about women who work full time for low / average wages, but whose lifestyle is very significantly 'propped up' by a much higher earning husband? Yes she's ostensibly a WOHM, but is there really that much difference when you think about it?

What about women who are just low earners anyway? Particularly the women on next to MW who are looking after our children for us so that we can earn higher salaries than them? Should they be skewered at for not aiming to earn more? Is their decision to remain in low paid 'caring' roles' something to be ashamed of because they should be striving to push themselves harder to redress structural inequality?

Where would we be if these women in childcare were not prepared to work for practically MW to facilitate US (men and women) being able to work?

Ultimately, we are all 'facilitated' to some extent and by someone somewhere - whether it's a lower-paid childcare worker; a spouse who can works limited / fixed or more flexible hours; your mother or family members doing it for free perhaps? All these types of 'support' will come with their own benefits and limitations. The SAHM model is just one of an almost many models,. I totally get the point about structural inequality (obviously), but it's just another variation of family set-up with its own benefits and setbacks for women. When it works, it most certainly works - as has been the case for our family. It would not work for everyone though, and I completely accept it's not a choice most families are even in a position to make anyway these days..But realistically nobody is going to make their own life or their family's life harder if they don't need to. At the end of the day, families decide for themselves if they need two full time incomes or they don't. If they don't, it offers up other options. Simple as that really. You do what you need to do, but also what you want to do and what you can do.

I think that yes, rather obviously the structural inequality issue applies to women who live off their dh partially or fully. And to men who rely on women to take the childcare burden disproportionately regardless of whether than person is working or not. Why would it not?