Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 15/07/2022 07:54

@TruthHertz

A common belief on here is that men often enjoy a great privilege in being able to continue their oh so fulfilling office job whilst the poor woman has to endure spending time with the children. I mean, it's every lottery winner's dream isn't it to keep slogging away earning money towards the MD's nice new yacht.

I find the disparaging attitude towards work from some elements on here quite depressing. Whenever someone suggests its a net benefit for mothers to work someone else will pop up with a bunch of hoary old clichés about the "MD's nice new yacht" or "climbing the corporate ladder", as if people who work are all just mindless corporate automatons who do so out of greed and vanity. In this narrative all office jobs are desperately dull and all working mothers are bitter and jealous and desperate to find a man to enable them to stay at home.

Yes there are some jobs which are relentless and very stressful and many with a lot of internal politics, and yes some WOHMs stereotype SAHMs so its cuts both ways and its understandable that some SAHMs feel they have been given a hard time.

But its worth being clear about what work actually means for some of us. Work, for me, isn't a vanity project or something which enables me to swan about playing at climbing the corporate ladder. It is being able to put food on my child's table and being able to remain in my small home. I'm a single parent so if I didn't work I'd rely on benefits and be living below the poverty line.

I'm lucky enough to (mostly) also enjoy my work, for which I'm extremely grateful. Its stimulating and varied and most of the people are nice. But it means I work extremely hard and often use childcare.

In my calculation this improves my life. It means I can afford things for me and my child. It is intellectually stimulating. It supports my social life and it means I am independent and do not have to rely on either a man or the state for support.

Those of you who are lucky enough to have the choice not to work are entitled to feel that working full time doesn't suit you. But please stop with the disparaging 1980s clichés about corporate capitalism or about other people's motives for wanting to be able to support themselves. For many of us work is freedom and dignity. If you can't empathise with that then at least have the decency not to pigeonhole those of us who don't have the choice.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 07:46

TheLostNights · 14/07/2022 12:28

I have a female friend who is single, works in a low paid job and is judged constantly. I have another female friend who again, has a low paying job but her husband earns big money so they can afford a lovely house and holidays. She is seen as successful. 😕 yet if her husband left her, she would be judged the same as other friend.

@TheLostNights

Which one of these two females are you?

5128gap · 15/07/2022 07:38

TruthHertz · 14/07/2022 23:56

A common belief on here is that men often enjoy a great privilege in being able to continue their oh so fulfilling office job whilst the poor woman has to endure spending time with the children. I mean, it's every lottery winner's dream isn't it to keep slogging away earning money towards the MD's nice new yacht.

Depends on your perspective. I'm fortunate enough to have a paid job that's fulfilling and interesting. Great colleagues, stimulating and fun. On the other hand, I found my brief stint as a SAHM an excruciating slog. It wasn't difficult, but the tedium of the cook, wash, clean, feed, play, walk, repeat actually made me feel very trapped and depressed. I was incredibly jealous of people who got to go to work, my partner included. We swapped in the end as he didn't mind the pace so much. It really depends on personality which is the hardest life to lead.

missdemeanors · 15/07/2022 07:37

It's actually a bit more complex than that; it's about earning potential, longer term prospects, pension provision..

And yea of course there will always be the outliers- women with trust funds, or who manage to bounce back into a senior position in the workplace after years out of it. But that isn't the norm.

It might all seem obvious stuff but if it were that obvious maybe we wouldn't have so many women who realise too late their careers prospects are damaged, or who struggle hugely after marriage break ups, or who enter retirement age with no decent occupational pension

MrsBwced · 15/07/2022 07:29

It’s hardly controversial that women who have no income could be financially vulnerable.
I agree, it's basically saying if you and your DH/DP split up then you won't be a couple anymore, or if you don't have a wage when you are in a relationship then you don't have a wage if you're single and yet people feel the need to point it out repeatedly. Bizarre.

the7Vabo · 15/07/2022 07:18

This thread is very odd. It’s hardly controversial that women who have no income could be financially vulnerable. Moreover it sounds like a statement that comes from a good place - a place of concern.

TruthHertz · 14/07/2022 23:56

5128gap · 14/07/2022 22:08

Which group are you classing as the ones with the easier lives and which ones as lashing out from inflated pride? There is such disparity of views, I can't tell.
Depending on the posters perspective SAHMs do both less and more than working ones, and are both the judges and and judged.

A common belief on here is that men often enjoy a great privilege in being able to continue their oh so fulfilling office job whilst the poor woman has to endure spending time with the children. I mean, it's every lottery winner's dream isn't it to keep slogging away earning money towards the MD's nice new yacht.

MrsBwced · 14/07/2022 23:44

@missdemeanors
As I said in my post, on MN I've only ever seen it in the context in my example. It's posted in a way that doesn't come across as factual. The language used in other posts usually gives an idea of how it's intended.

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 23:24

Apologies I didn't make it clear. I was replying to your comment that
I've no idea what other people think! I can only go by what people write on threads.

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 23:06

I didn't write those things so I don't know why you're quoting me in a post about sniping and gaslighting.

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 22:58

Sorry should have said

  • not contributing to society. Full stop.
(As if tax was the only way you can contribute.)
Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 22:55

@missdemeanors
Well, pp have written on this thread that SAHMs are

  • not helpful for other women in the workplace (as they are giving men an unfair advantage)
  • not contributing to society via taxes etc

So that's fairly clear.

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 22:44

I've no idea what other people think! I can only go by what people write on threads.
Yes, sniping goes both ways.

I was simply pointing out that there aren't necessarily things a WOHM doesn't do that she would do if she were a SAHM. Obviously not as frequently, because some of the time, some of the tasks/ activities are done by other people caring for the child.

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 22:31

*not contributing

Marynotsocontrary · 14/07/2022 22:29

So I wouldn't agree that I didn't do all the things I would have done had I been a SAHM - rather it was a case of not doing them as many times because there were other people caring for them some of the time.

Yes, I think that's the way it's meant sometimes...and of course SAHPs and WOHPs are equally valid and good parents. BUT there's often the 'and I work too' added put-down said to SAHMs. The extra childcare that they do doesn't seem to 'match up' in the eyes of many.

Some think it's not feminist enough, that we're letting down other women because it's giving men an unfair advantage in the workplace.

Or we should be paying more tax.We're not contributing to society.

All that has been suggested on this thread alone. The choice to stay home for family reasons is certainly looked down on by some as a less valid option.

And it can't all be 'concern', there is a lot of gaslighting going on. SAHMs can see what people think on here. They're saying it, for heaven's sake...why pretend otherwise? And yes, some women are trapped at home (some are trapped at work too). But others aren't and I think that's all the OP is saying - don't assume you know best about another person's circumstances. And the sniping on here goes both ways so please recognise that too.

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 22:25

I'm not justifying anything. I was responding to a post by @MrsBwced about a quote she's read

iabr · 14/07/2022 22:22

missdemeanors - you don't need to justify anything. Nobody keeps count of these things and it's impossible to quantify. So what if a nanny changed a few nappies, you were busy doing something else in your child's interests. I have nothing but respect for mums who work, whatever they do, and I hope that doesn't sound patronising (it's really not intended to). The whole SAHM / WOHM thing is the worst thing about AIBU. No such thing as a typical WOHM, but no such thing as a typical SAHM. And no such thing as a typical part-timer either! Everyone is just doing the best they can for their kids, whatever that may look like.

OP posts:
5128gap · 14/07/2022 22:08

TruthHertz · 14/07/2022 21:43

A lot of women seem to secretly experience cognitive dissonance around the realisation that the grass isn't always greener but won't admit it, so they lash out at other women who have the easier lives that their inflated sense of pride prevents them from having themselves.

Which group are you classing as the ones with the easier lives and which ones as lashing out from inflated pride? There is such disparity of views, I can't tell.
Depending on the posters perspective SAHMs do both less and more than working ones, and are both the judges and and judged.

missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 21:55

@MrsBwced re: the comment you quote about a WOHM saying they do everything a SAHM does... I agree that if it's intended to be offensive then that's really off.

But (and I'm just stating this as another perspective , not to argue about it!) it could also be intended as a simple fact: that there is no particular thing they don't do that a SAHM does. I mean, tbh I can't think of anything I didn't do as a WOHM.... I changed nappies, fed my children, took them for walks, played games, read to them, and later as they grew older, helped them with homework, went to sports days etc. Sure, I wasn't the only person to do these things. When they were small, their wonderful nursery would sometimes be doing those things. As would, of course, my DH. And their grandparents. And wider family and friends.

So I wouldn't agree that I didn't do all the things I would have done had I been a SAHM - rather it was a case of not doing them as many times because there were other people caring for them some of the time.

iabr · 14/07/2022 21:51

"Many women are, and more so if they're not earning or only earning part time for years. These factors also mean they're less likely to increase earning and get more senior posts if they do re enter the workplace. Those are facts. Not opinions. And many of us believe that's an important gender issue."

But WHY are you telling me this again snd again and again. You are preaching to the choir! You REALLY don't need to explain this. It's like Groundhog Day.

All I'm saying is SAHMs vary as much as the next woman in terms of financial vulnerability. Why is that so contentious?

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 21:45

iabr · 14/07/2022 21:43

ReneBumsWombats - calm down, you're getting a bit carried away with yourself now.

Sorry for engaging in my own thread. Why are you still here then?

I'm pissing myself laughing, don't worry about me.

As for why I'm here, because I'm procrastinating. Obviously.

TruthHertz · 14/07/2022 21:43

A lot of women seem to secretly experience cognitive dissonance around the realisation that the grass isn't always greener but won't admit it, so they lash out at other women who have the easier lives that their inflated sense of pride prevents them from having themselves.

iabr · 14/07/2022 21:43

ReneBumsWombats - calm down, you're getting a bit carried away with yourself now.

Sorry for engaging in my own thread. Why are you still here then?

OP posts:
missdemeanors · 14/07/2022 21:42

No one is obsessed with your finances. You're not financially vulnerable- Woopi doo that's great for you. Many women are, and more so if they're not earning or only earning part time for years. These factors also mean they're less likely to increase earning and get more senior posts if they do re enter the workplace. Those are facts. Not opinions. And many of us believe that's an important gender issue.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/07/2022 21:38

iabr · 14/07/2022 21:36

" You are REALLY offended at the idea that you might not have zillions in a trust fund, aren't you?"

Why are you so obsessed with my finances? What is that about?

Uh, I'm not the one who started and sustained a 22 page thread complaining that people say giving up work is likely to make me vulnerable because EVERYONE I KNOW WIPES THEIR BUMS WITH TENNERS