Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Living off a man!!!

833 replies

iabr · 11/07/2022 20:57

If you are among the posters on here who always sneer at SAHMs for 'living off the husband,' do you also -

  • sneer at women who work PT and therefore earn less than their husbands - so are, by definition, also 'living off the husband" to a greater or lesser extent?
  • sneer at women who work full-time, but still earn significantly less than the husband, so the house and other expenses are largely funded by his higher income anyway?
  • sneer at any woman who has a dual income lifestyle that she couldn't maintain on her own salary / wealth?
I really don't want to get into endless personal anecdotes of - "Well I earn £x and DH earns £x..." This is about the issue of 'financial independence' within families per se. - ie . recognising that it's accrued family wealth that determines financial independence and it's not necessarily always as simple as who earns what. A SAHM may well have greater financial independence than a woman on a high salary, depending on that family's underlying financial circumstances.

So AIBU to say to MN - Stop telling SAHMs they are 'financially vulnerable' - unless you know the details of their unique financial family circumstances!

OP posts:
Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 15/07/2022 10:53

iabr · 15/07/2022 10:44

I have had years in MN of being told I am living off a man, useless, sponging, poor example to my kids, people secretly pity me, stupid, wasting my education, wasting my life, suffocating my children, a skivvy, a surrendered wife, financially vulnerable, naive, don't understand my own mind, no differntv a prostitute... All this and more for years. On a forum for mums. Do you think this is ok?

It's not "advice". Bollocks to that. Every poster in here knows full well what I'm talking about. Drop the pretence. And yes, it is upsetting. Damn right. Its. patronising at best, and vicious at worst. Dismiss it all you want, but it most definitely happens and it's disgusting on this forum.

Anywsy, yes to whoever said it. I am upset by some poster from a few days ago. I shouldn't have expected anything else from this thread either, though at least people have refrained from direct insults, which is guess is something. I've had Covid and my husband is away and I regret in engaging in this thread because it will never change on here.

Errrr, literally noone has said the vast majority that on this thread,, and what they have said was in response to your own comments. Maybe you have heard it elsewhere but, as you yourself have noted, we can't speak for everyone, and you might be reading it from a particularly sensitive place (I think the woh mums were accused of "misunderstanding" - talk about patronising?).

However it sounds like stepping back is a good idea if you are feeling too emotional to debate it.

iabr · 15/07/2022 10:44

I have had years in MN of being told I am living off a man, useless, sponging, poor example to my kids, people secretly pity me, stupid, wasting my education, wasting my life, suffocating my children, a skivvy, a surrendered wife, financially vulnerable, naive, don't understand my own mind, no differntv a prostitute... All this and more for years. On a forum for mums. Do you think this is ok?

It's not "advice". Bollocks to that. Every poster in here knows full well what I'm talking about. Drop the pretence. And yes, it is upsetting. Damn right. Its. patronising at best, and vicious at worst. Dismiss it all you want, but it most definitely happens and it's disgusting on this forum.

Anywsy, yes to whoever said it. I am upset by some poster from a few days ago. I shouldn't have expected anything else from this thread either, though at least people have refrained from direct insults, which is guess is something. I've had Covid and my husband is away and I regret in engaging in this thread because it will never change on here.

OP posts:
MsPincher · 15/07/2022 10:42

ImAvingOops · 15/07/2022 10:33

You’ve been banging on for 3 days

This is unfair. It's her thread! If she didn't come back and argue her case, she would be criticised for starting a thread and buggering off!

Yeah but in this case she started a thread about sahm and then ranted at everyone for talking about sahms.

ImAvingOops · 15/07/2022 10:33

You’ve been banging on for 3 days

This is unfair. It's her thread! If she didn't come back and argue her case, she would be criticised for starting a thread and buggering off!

MsPincher · 15/07/2022 10:32

iabr · 14/07/2022 19:52

Anyway, I can't say it again.

Next time people are out and about in office hours, but see one of "the SAHMs" (she will be instantly recognisable by her unmistakeable air of 'low self-esteem), do me a favour will you....

Chuck a fiver at and point her kid's buggy in the direction of the nearest day nursery. If she looks confused, a quick scintillating lecture on how she is facilitating structural inequality should do the trick.

Why on earth would anyone do that? I’ve heard they’re not financially vulnerable anyway…

you are coming across as incoherent and angry. If your aim was to say not to make assumptions about people you could have said so instead of endless angry posts about other things.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 15/07/2022 10:16

Oh @iabr this is clearly a matter close to your heart. Because you are all over the place.
"People sneer"
[posters explain why they've said wht they've said , explaining they aren't sneering],
"Oh you aree generalising, I am really rich and financially secure"
[ok, not you but generally],,,
"generally SAHMs are really financially secure"
[that not my experience]
"prove it, your expereince is just anecdontal, generally they are" [ok you prove it]
"...."
"people don't value SAHMs and slag us off"
[people slag of woh mums too]
"no they don't, it's only ever the one rogue poster, and you are just misunderstanding what they are saying. Anyway SAHPs are so valuable to their husbands and society because all that good stuff we do"
[we disgree]
"why are you commenting on the value of SAHPs. :Anyway I don't care about my value in society, beause I am valued at home"
[ok great, good for you, women need to make choices based on their persoan cirumstances, not society]
"but how dare you define me by my status in society!!!! Why are you even commenting on this"
[you started the tread and discussed this....]

Anyway, i think you catch the drift. You invited and continued this discussion. It's not like you asked a question about your cat and then everyone started "sneering" at you being a SAHP out of the blue, is it?

the fact is an adult that doesn't work, and relies entirely on the goodwill of another adult, is financially vulnerable. Are there other factors that can make adults vulnerable? Of course. But that's not the question you asked. Does it mean ALL SAHPs are financially vulnerable? No, and as far as I can see no one is saying that.

missdemeanors · 15/07/2022 10:14

But presumably someone would only mention being a SAHM if it was relevant to their thread. I mean, I wouldn't randomly mention that I'm a WOHM! I would only mention it if it had some bearing on the topic I was posting.

Luredbyapomegranate · 15/07/2022 10:14

Bloody hell OP, with all the things going on in the world can you not think of anything better to put your energy into?

You’ve been banging on for 3 days, in a very heightened fashion. I think you need to go deal with whatever is actually bugging you.

the7Vabo · 15/07/2022 10:12

iabr · 15/07/2022 10:03

the7Vabo - yes I could just never mention being a SAHM to avoid the 'concern' lectures and inevitable misapprehensions, but equally you could avoid threads like this if they make you angry. Apologies anyway and have a good day.

There is a hell of a difference between never mentioning being a SAHM and starting a thread titled “living off a man!!!” bemoaning what you feel are people’s criticisms of your life choices despite the fact that they may well be coming from a place of genuine concern.
Yes I’m angered by you, lucky you that you can come to such an agreement with your husband, nobody has to gloss over financial vulnerability or financial abuse which mainly affects women to protect your ego. Because goodness forbid that you should feel your privileged life choices are subject to criticism.
If people are using this website to highlight the dangers of being financially vulnerable in relationships - good for them!!

iabr · 15/07/2022 10:03

the7Vabo - yes I could just never mention being a SAHM to avoid the 'concern' lectures and inevitable misapprehensions, but equally you could avoid threads like this if they make you angry. Apologies anyway and have a good day.

OP posts:
iabr · 15/07/2022 09:54

Unless you are prohibited from working by the cost of childcare, or prevented from working by a controlling husband, the decision to become a SAHM is like anything else in life, a cost-benefit analysis.

Of course if you have zero assets and would be solely dependent on your husband's salary, I wouldn't recommend living indefinitely like that.

You can't be a SAHM with a man who sees money as anything other than family money. Even if you were earning, it would all be one and the same. You have to have a husband who respects you and who values and appreciates your role (and vice versa). You are supporting him; he is supporting you and your common goal is your children and a less stressful family life. It wouldn't suit everyone, but it doesn't need to and it doesn't matter as long as you know what you're doing. Maybe the SAHM model works best when both parents feel they are getting the better deal?!!

It's a cost-benefit analysis, and many families feel the benefit of having a parent at home outweighs the cost of the loss of a second income and the cost and hassle of childcare. That's all it is. Just like people may work part-time or a few hours less for the same reasons.

If you're just going to be a SAHM for one year or two, then you will have a good idea how difficult it will be to get back into work. Totally dependent on what you do. Or maybe you have no intention of going back into that field anyway and you are using the SAH period as an opportunity to reassess, retrain or change direction.

There are many things you can do to mitigate against financial vulnerability. I could tell you how we have done that, but that's just us and irrelevant really as everyone's circumstances will be different and different women would be intending to SAH for different lengths of time. People know what's right for them and that's it really.

Yieyr are so many things that can make you financially vulnerable - taking out a mortgage you struggle with; spending or living on credit beyond your means; redundancy; lack of job security; lack of opportunity; geographical factors; mental health; illness; having an financially inept partner; a partner who gambles or who has an addiction; a partner who is financially abusive or secretive; hidden debts - all sorts of things. In any of these circumstances, there is less likely to be a SAHM, put it that way.

OP posts:
MrsBwced · 15/07/2022 09:37

If you're protected, great. You can dismiss the discussion or, better yet, share your own advice on staying secure.
I have done many times.

the7Vabo · 15/07/2022 09:36

iabr · 15/07/2022 08:58

Ok, so @Thepeopleversuswork has very reasonably asked that people don't pigeonhole her as a working single mum.

The correct reply to that would be, "yes of course."

Or would you just come riding in on your high horse to declare the definitive situation for 'the vast majority' of single mums (no stats, just based purely on MN threads); then obfuscate her request into some imperious public service announcement for the benefit of some imaginary audience who aren't even on that thread -

"we continue to spread information for the sake of those who don't realise..."

I’m sorry OP my patience is thin this morning. If you managed to be a SAHM & be financially secure & also go back to part time work - good for you. Not everyone is so lucky. So instead of making people giving others advice about your ego why don’t you focus on how fortunate you have been & practice gratefulness.

Are people critical of SAHM yes, people are also critical of working mothers. A bit of criticism on an Internet forum that you can choose to avoid shouldn’t be such a big concern.

Like many people I’m about to log on to a very responsible job I hate because I need to do so to pay the bills. I have to put very young children in almost full time childcare, I’d bloody love to work part time. Equally I’m sure there are women out there desperate to get back into the workforce & many who are stuck in less than ideal situations due to lack of money.

You sound like you have it good OP - focus your energies on that.

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/07/2022 09:21

@WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps

Yep the mumsnet fairy tale in paragraph 2 is a myth that just doesn't happen in real life. Struggling financially, and trying to make ends meet at the end of each month is way more likely for most single women with children, than the flashy, wonderful life some mumsnetters portray. (That's even the case for some single women without children too!)

What's your point with this comment though? Of course most women don't swan out of an abusive marriage with no income into a £100k + job. Most women don't have jobs like this period.

Is that a reason not to work and not to aim for financial independence? No of course its not. Any financial independence is better than none. If you're going to be working really hard to make ends meet, living in a shitty area etc, surely better that you and your children get some control over the fruits of your labour, however meagre.

LuaDipa · 15/07/2022 09:11

TooTiredToSleepRightNow · 11/07/2022 21:35

I’m a sahm. Do you even frequent on mumsnet?

Sahm do make themselves vulnerable to an extent. Let’s not kid ourselves. That’s why it’s important to make sure you’re married and have assets in your name. There are different versions of sahm and it’s all about legal protection should shit hit the fan. And yes keeping your toes in the water, keeping skills up should you need to work. I’m glad there is a forum that exists that tells women realities so they can make informed choices rather than paint a fantasy. I don’t see what’s so offensive. If my daughter decided to become a sahm rather than give her lecture about the pros and cons I’ll send her over to the relationships board and let her decide. I went into it quite naively even though I know I’m better off than many so I made sure all loose ends were tied. Thanks to mumsnet.

Great post.

My mum worried sick about me giving up work when I had my dc. She was a relatively young widow left with 3 kids. Fortunately my ddad always planned ahead and left us relatively secure but she had always worked and she continued to do so as she worried about not being able to provide for us. She was worried that if anything happened I would be left high and dry so she gave me some great advice about protecting myself.

As it was I was already married, everything we owned was as a couple, we had a joint account and I took care of all the finances because dh is useless with that sort of thing. I was very secure in my position and it worked well for us for 10 years. Dh knows how lucky he is that he could concentrate fully on his career without worrying about the kids and it’s paid off in a big way for us.

I’m now back at work, I earn a decent wage but not a fraction of what dh earns. I still take care of the finances and know exactly where every penny is. If I was that way inclined I would have a better chance of hiding assets than dh.

But not every situation is the same. If dh and I weren’t married, if we didn’t share a bank account, if he was secretive about his earnings or stingy and talked about ‘his’ money or if he hadn’t been willing to pay his share of things like childcare and maternity costs in the first instance there is no way I would have entered into this arrangement. It only works if there is full transparency and trust. If there isn’t you shouldn’t put yourself at risk. It’s important to protect yourself and some women don’t have anywhere to discuss these issues. It’s good that they have somewhere they can seek advice.

missdemeanors · 15/07/2022 09:10

gave up

missdemeanors · 15/07/2022 09:10

There are numerous threads from women who say they have up work because of childcare costs. Its actually very common - perhaps the default position - to think short term. If I'd just thought short term I might very well have given up work because for a few years our childcare costs equated to my salary! I'm glad though that I looked at the bigger picture; career progression, pension etc and chose to hang on in there.

And of course it's a balance because it's important to enjoy the moment as well as creating long term security.

Ultimately, however much the OP keeps saying this is MN 'opinion', it really isn't. Check the facts. Look at the statistics. If you don't believe that women and in particular mothers as a group are much more financially vulnerable than men, then you're living in some parallel universe

the7Vabo · 15/07/2022 08:58

MrsBwced · 15/07/2022 08:24

Of course I was being a bit flippant but are there really that many women who weren't aware of the risk they took in giving up work.
SAHM are the minority so presumably the majority of women have decided against it. The ones who are posting about things going wrong for them have either realised too late or knew and decided to do it anyway.
I'm just not sure who exactly is supposed to benefit from all this 'concern'.

I think a lot of people don’t think it through. Lots of us are guilty of short-term thinking. A woman may give up work when a relationship is in a good place, or because of childcare costs or if she doesn’t want to leave a baby etc. without fully considering the risks.

I have a job I loath. It is certainly a “good” job on paper but at times being a SAHM seems very attractive to me.

iabr · 15/07/2022 08:58

Ok, so @Thepeopleversuswork has very reasonably asked that people don't pigeonhole her as a working single mum.

The correct reply to that would be, "yes of course."

Or would you just come riding in on your high horse to declare the definitive situation for 'the vast majority' of single mums (no stats, just based purely on MN threads); then obfuscate her request into some imperious public service announcement for the benefit of some imaginary audience who aren't even on that thread -

"we continue to spread information for the sake of those who don't realise..."

OP posts:
missdemeanors · 15/07/2022 08:32

Yes, threads on MN would certainly suggest that a lot of women aren't aware of how vulnerable they are/ could become. Plus of course it's borne out by the stats about women and their financial vulnerability compared to men. And within that group of women, the subset of women who are out of the workplace, or have significant gaps in their working life.

ReneBumsWombats · 15/07/2022 08:28

are there really that many women who weren't aware of the risk they took in giving up work.

From the number of threads we get on the subject, I'd say yes. Certainly too many. Unmarried SAHM with no personal assets out the wazoo. So many people STILL believe the "common law wife" stuff.

What's worse: we continue to spread information for the sake of those who don't realise, even though we all know some women are well protected, or we cease talking about it and allow the issue to worsen, so that those protected women need never hear it?

If you're protected, great. You can dismiss the discussion or, better yet, share your own advice on staying secure.

MrsBwced · 15/07/2022 08:24

missdemeanors · 15/07/2022 07:37

It's actually a bit more complex than that; it's about earning potential, longer term prospects, pension provision..

And yea of course there will always be the outliers- women with trust funds, or who manage to bounce back into a senior position in the workplace after years out of it. But that isn't the norm.

It might all seem obvious stuff but if it were that obvious maybe we wouldn't have so many women who realise too late their careers prospects are damaged, or who struggle hugely after marriage break ups, or who enter retirement age with no decent occupational pension

Of course I was being a bit flippant but are there really that many women who weren't aware of the risk they took in giving up work.
SAHM are the minority so presumably the majority of women have decided against it. The ones who are posting about things going wrong for them have either realised too late or knew and decided to do it anyway.
I'm just not sure who exactly is supposed to benefit from all this 'concern'.

ReneBumsWombats · 15/07/2022 08:17

It's a mumsnet myth that most women leave their man, start a new degree at university, and are happy and successful, and gain a huge group of new friends, a shiny new £100K+ a year career, and go on to live happily ever after with a wonderful new man. Always much younger than her of course, who looks like Tom Hardy, and even though every man wants to shag her, she stays faithful to this new man coz 'the sex is amazing.' 🙄

You see that a lot on here? Which board are you reading?

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 15/07/2022 08:08

Royalbloo · 14/07/2022 19:27

No "sneering" here - just genuine concern for the plethora of women who leave the job market and make themselves vulnerable to financial abuse and no prospects. It's very scary to think of all the women stuck in awful relationships because of money.

But equally, a lot of single working women are miserable as fuck too. Not every woman has the life and career of the RG uni-educated mumsnetters on £350K a year in their 'niche' career, and living in a swanky £3 million pad by the River Thames. Many MANY single women live in an average or shitty area, in a cramped flat or terraced house, (or they house share.) And they're on the bones of their arse trying to make ends meet by begging for as many hours as they can get at work, to enable them to pay the bills. Especially single women with children.

It's a mumsnet myth that most women leave their man, start a new degree at university, and are happy and successful, and gain a huge group of new friends, a shiny new £100K+ a year career, and go on to live happily ever after with a wonderful new man. Always much younger than her of course, who looks like Tom Hardy, and even though every man wants to shag her, she stays faithful to this new man coz 'the sex is amazing.' 🙄

Yep the mumsnet fairy tale in paragraph 2 is a myth that just doesn't happen in real life. Struggling financially, and trying to make ends meet at the end of each month is way more likely for most single women with children, than the flashy, wonderful life some mumsnetters portray. (That's even the case for some single women without children too!)

missdemeanors · 15/07/2022 08:03

@Thepeopleversuswork well said.

At the end of the day, work is a fact of life for almost everyone. Very few people are born into so much wealth that they never need to do a day's work in their life.

And although a minority might make disparaging remarks about work, I have yet to meet any parent who doesn't have high aspirations for their own children. All the parents I know are keen for their children to do well at school/ university/ the job market. I have yet to meet a parent who doesn't care. Or one whose aspiration for their child is to 'marry into money' so they don't need to work.
So that tells me something.