Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When will someone grow a pair and create a proper justice system?

108 replies

girlfriend44 · 11/07/2022 19:42

Ava Whites killer gets 13 years today for stabbing her to death in Liverpool last November.

The judge refused to name him as well.
We just keep hearing crappy sentences and decisions all the time?
All on the side of the offender?

Do you think anything will ever change? Why couldn't we hear the news he's been locked up for 35 years and he has been named?
Someone some balls needs to take charge. Countryside an embarrassment.

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 11/07/2022 23:29

Bubblebubblebah · 11/07/2022 23:24

We have people committing multiple offences, often when on bail and of course they are eligible for free legal aid.

Having representation is actually one of the ways to ensure justice. Have you seen literacy levels of criminals? They wouldn't stand a chance against a lawyer and that would not be ok.
Many people are all about lack of human rights unless it suits their argument it seems to me.

And saying that everyone should have representation should they need it, doesn't mean standing up for criminals and "think they are cool" or whatever it was

Are you misquoting there with the 'thinking they are cool' statement?
How you have extrapolated that referred to involved professionals if so I am confused.
This comment is in relation to the 15yo allegedly being exploited into stabbing Ava by their peers.

Bubblebubblebah · 11/07/2022 23:26

bellac11 · 11/07/2022 23:16

I hope we are moving away from naming criminals, it makes it 'all about them', how many without looking it up can name Ted Bundy's victims, Peter Sutcliff etc etc

But the perpetrators names live on.

In this case of course there are different reasons for not naming but I dont want to remember the convict, we should remember the victims.

I agree. Especially in some cases they really should not be named. Person x (3/22) would tone lots of the fame down.

Bubblebubblebah · 11/07/2022 23:24

We have people committing multiple offences, often when on bail and of course they are eligible for free legal aid.

Having representation is actually one of the ways to ensure justice. Have you seen literacy levels of criminals? They wouldn't stand a chance against a lawyer and that would not be ok.
Many people are all about lack of human rights unless it suits their argument it seems to me.

And saying that everyone should have representation should they need it, doesn't mean standing up for criminals and "think they are cool" or whatever it was

GirlDownUnder22 · 11/07/2022 23:19

girlfriend44 · 11/07/2022 22:59

Give the parents a few years in the clink too might make them more responsible for their kids.

You can read the texts he sent to his mother that night clearly no control over him.

You really have no clue at all, do you?

Tsandjdarethrbest · 11/07/2022 23:18

The victims definitely do not come last.

bellac11 · 11/07/2022 23:16

I hope we are moving away from naming criminals, it makes it 'all about them', how many without looking it up can name Ted Bundy's victims, Peter Sutcliff etc etc

But the perpetrators names live on.

In this case of course there are different reasons for not naming but I dont want to remember the convict, we should remember the victims.

LadyEloise1 · 11/07/2022 23:12

myyellowcar · 11/07/2022 20:13

I’m with you OP, it’s a system that puts the victim last and leaves the public at risk.

I absolutely agree.
I know it's no consolation but it's happening in Ireland too - soft sentencing - but it's even worse.
We have people committing multiple offences, often when on bail and of course they are eligible for free legal aid.
The victim comes last Sad

Tsandjdarethrbest · 11/07/2022 23:05

I hate these threads. They are so ignorant. People who work in the criminal justice system do an extremely hard job as well as they possibly can, only to be told by people who have a snapshot of a case they are clueless and out of touch. They’re not. They live in the so-called real world too.

girlfriend44 · 11/07/2022 22:59

Give the parents a few years in the clink too might make them more responsible for their kids.

You can read the texts he sent to his mother that night clearly no control over him.

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 11/07/2022 22:52

girlfriend44 · 11/07/2022 22:13

But she was only 13 and had loads of years yet if he hadn't taken it. He will still be free in his 20s.

This is what I struggle with, and how anything acknowledging this is back to sympathy for the murderer. I know and understand that there is dreadful circumstances people grow up in, but I just don't understand how the focus and sympathy always slips to them. Are there really people out there who think murdering children is great and a cool thing to do?

girlfriend44 · 11/07/2022 22:13

FunDragon · 11/07/2022 20:02

He’s not been named because he’s a minor surely?

And 13 years is a long sentence for a juvenile offender. It’s almost his whole life again.

But she was only 13 and had loads of years yet if he hadn't taken it. He will still be free in his 20s.

OP posts:
dottypotter · 11/07/2022 20:55

Yes we see it all the time. Sentences for murder have got right down. Life is cheap sadly.

Why can't teenagers be named? its all on their side.
Some are, some aren't it's not even consistent.

ghostyslovesheets · 11/07/2022 20:47

Lockheart · 11/07/2022 20:27

You don't understand. It's not about excusing the stabbing, it's a probable reason as to why his name hasn't been released - to avoid jeopardising any other current criminal trials or investigations in which he is involved.

thank you for getting it - honestly the main issue with people screaming for justice is they don;t understand the current system - also the judge - with all the facts of the case and background on the defendant is better placed to make a choice about naming him than you are OP.

I work with young offenders - it's daft to dismiss the issues of exploitation, ASD, illiteracy, trauma, FASD, ASD, ODD, shit parenting and the care system when trying to understand why children commit crimes

maddening · 11/07/2022 20:43

Lockheart · 11/07/2022 20:01

Nothing is stopping you OP, if you want. Campaign for change. Lobby your MPs. Study our legal system and our laws.

I suspect you won't, because your entire OP suggests ignorance on a massive scale.

Part of starting an action could be public discussions, say on a public forum, where you get to understand public opinion and listen to points of debate.

The op may well find other like minded people while doing such a debate or be signposted to a group that already does this sort of activity.

So debating here is pretty much a good thing to do.

Lockheart · 11/07/2022 20:27

MichelleScarn · 11/07/2022 20:25

How can they blame his stabbing someone to death be about his being exploited?

You don't understand. It's not about excusing the stabbing, it's a probable reason as to why his name hasn't been released - to avoid jeopardising any other current criminal trials or investigations in which he is involved.

Scianel · 11/07/2022 20:26

I agree sentencing in the UK is nonsense. I daresay offenders won't come out better people but if they're locked up for long enough that won't be an issue.
One case that stuck with me a few years ago was the rape of a toddler with injuries so severe the medical staff were described as being in tears and traumatised.
A whole eight years the guy got.

Bubblebubblebah · 11/07/2022 20:25

Lockheart · 11/07/2022 20:01

Nothing is stopping you OP, if you want. Campaign for change. Lobby your MPs. Study our legal system and our laws.

I suspect you won't, because your entire OP suggests ignorance on a massive scale.

This is all these threads always need

stargirl1701 · 11/07/2022 20:25

Isn't the offender a child too? It seems reasonable to withhold his name and have a minimum tariff of 13 years to me.

MichelleScarn · 11/07/2022 20:25

ghostyslovesheets · 11/07/2022 20:05

They haven’t released his identity as he was 14, has SEN and ADHD and is belittling be the victim criminal exploitation

he has been sentenced to a MINIMUM of 13 years not just 13 years

How can they blame his stabbing someone to death be about his being exploited?

DdraigGoch · 11/07/2022 20:23

The judge will have had the full case in front of them to sentence, far more than anyone else.
No matter what the details of the case, the judge can only sentence in line with the guidelines. So I don't blame the judge in this case, I say that the guidelines should be tougher all around. There are of course judges whose sentences and the remarks they give while handing them down fail to display an understanding of the effect that crime has on the victim.

Sentencing guidelines in the UK are actually some of the most fair/acceptable across the globe.
The main consideration dictating the length of sentences in the UK is the need to keep levels of overcrowding in check. That's why the guidelines have been watered down over the years.

There's no proof that the longer you lock someone up the better type of person they are upon release. If anything it's the opposite.
If you lock a burglar up for five years, he won't be reoffending during those five years. He can't be breaking into your house while he's locked in a cell.

Prisons really need to be a place of reform and rehabilitation and punishment and extremely long sentences don't serve that purpose for one index offence such as this. So a balance is struck.
The primary purpose of imprisonment is to keep the public safe. When prolific criminals get locked up their long-suffering neighbours breathe a sigh of relief. Reforming offenders is important too, but when persistent criminals receive one short sentence after another, there's no time to start reforming.

Just think a prisoner today could be your neighbour tomorrow.
Whereas if said prisoner was sentenced to a longer term, he wouldn't be my neighbour for another few years.

isadoradancing123 · 11/07/2022 20:18

Sen, adhd, etc not a reason to carry a knife, stab someone to death, be clever enough to hide the evidence, clothes he was wearing etc. why shouldnt he be named, he was capable of doing the crime

myyellowcar · 11/07/2022 20:13

I’m with you OP, it’s a system that puts the victim last and leaves the public at risk.

Georgeskitchen · 11/07/2022 20:10

It's a minimum 13 year sentence which will be reviewed at the end of that to see if he is capable of being rehabilitated into society. Probably depends on his behaviour while inside.
I wouldn't hold out much hope since while being interviewed by the police his response was " shut up you nonce". What a little charmer!!
The news report said he wouldn't be named because of concerns about reprisals against his family, although I should imagine a large section of Liverpool locals will already know exactly who he is

ghostyslovesheets · 11/07/2022 20:06

Believed not belittling!

ghostyslovesheets · 11/07/2022 20:05

They haven’t released his identity as he was 14, has SEN and ADHD and is belittling be the victim criminal exploitation

he has been sentenced to a MINIMUM of 13 years not just 13 years