Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When will someone grow a pair and create a proper justice system?

108 replies

girlfriend44 · 11/07/2022 19:42

Ava Whites killer gets 13 years today for stabbing her to death in Liverpool last November.

The judge refused to name him as well.
We just keep hearing crappy sentences and decisions all the time?
All on the side of the offender?

Do you think anything will ever change? Why couldn't we hear the news he's been locked up for 35 years and he has been named?
Someone some balls needs to take charge. Countryside an embarrassment.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Discovereads · 13/07/2022 14:27

girlfriend44 · 11/07/2022 19:42

Ava Whites killer gets 13 years today for stabbing her to death in Liverpool last November.

The judge refused to name him as well.
We just keep hearing crappy sentences and decisions all the time?
All on the side of the offender?

Do you think anything will ever change? Why couldn't we hear the news he's been locked up for 35 years and he has been named?
Someone some balls needs to take charge. Countryside an embarrassment.

He can’t be named as he is only 15
He can’t get a life sentence as he is only 15

I wouldn’t want you in charge of the justice system if you think minors should get life sentences and be named. You sound very antiquated and if you think life sentences for children is ok would likely be in favour of bringing back the death penalty for adults. No thanks.

SnowyLamb · 13/07/2022 14:23

girlfriend44 · 13/07/2022 14:01

Problem is we are seeing more and more parents who cant control and arent interested. Lots are NOT victims of DV they are just crap parents and crap at discipline etc. These children become societys problem. Let loose to wander the streets.

What will happen to his remaining siblings?

Do you know any of these parents?

I've worked with troubled teens for a long time. I've met some dreadful parents, but I've never met one who really doesn't care.

They're all doing their best with the resources they have. Often they had dreadful childhoods themselves and are living lives the average MNetter couldn't begin to imagine, with trauma, voilence, poverty, poor education, addiction all just a way of life and no support network at all. Compared to their own experiences they believe they are doing a good job. And in some ways they are, they get up and keep going everyday in circumstances that would fell the vast majority of us.

When they or their child is struggling society, even the structures that should be there to support them, want to strike them down rather than support them, as ably demonstrated by this thread.

girlfriend44 · 13/07/2022 14:01

SnowyLamb · 13/07/2022 12:27

"A lot" of tax payer support? A minute fraction of what it would cost to keep him in prison.

Of course there's a lot of anger when serious crime is committed, but I can't believe people think the answer for a child who is vulnerable himself is to lock him up indefinitely.

All this money could have been so much better spent supporting the mother "who couldn't control him" but no everyone wants to judge her, a victim of DV, too.

Problem is we are seeing more and more parents who cant control and arent interested. Lots are NOT victims of DV they are just crap parents and crap at discipline etc. These children become societys problem. Let loose to wander the streets.

What will happen to his remaining siblings?

OP posts:
Awwlookatmybabyspider · 13/07/2022 12:48

FoggySpecs · 11/07/2022 19:52

The UK judicial system is pretty good, thank goodness we don't have American style sentences. Although they need to do something to keep criminal barristers going to maintain standards. Cases like that of Ava White are always emotive, but I think not naming the perpetrators is good, some gain a sort of cult celebrity status which is far worse.

If our justice system is "pretty good" I'd hate to see really bad.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 13/07/2022 12:45

13 years AKA 6.5 years, absolutely joke.😠

SnowyLamb · 13/07/2022 12:27

JudgeJ · 13/07/2022 11:31

But he will be a relatively young man when he's released, free to enjoy life with a lot of tax-payer support.

"A lot" of tax payer support? A minute fraction of what it would cost to keep him in prison.

Of course there's a lot of anger when serious crime is committed, but I can't believe people think the answer for a child who is vulnerable himself is to lock him up indefinitely.

All this money could have been so much better spent supporting the mother "who couldn't control him" but no everyone wants to judge her, a victim of DV, too.

Blueuggboots · 13/07/2022 12:08

I also agree that judges are often out of step with public opinion.

My old neighbour and his best friend were the criminal blight of the local town - they were charged and found guilty. One of the rules of them being on bail was not to have contact with each other. They appealed and the judge over ruled it saying it wasn't fair to deprive them of their friendship, despite most of their time together being spent doing criminal activity!!! 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

Blueuggboots · 13/07/2022 12:06

Being called a nonce or paedophile by a juvenile detainee is a daily occurrence for the police and for prison/YO staff I should think.

You might want to look at the impact of adverse childhood experiences (ACE's) in relation to juvenile offenders. A large number of these children will have had hideous life experiences. Not everyone is lucky enough to grow up in a kind protective family - and I'm not saying that's the sole solution either.

girlfriend44 · 13/07/2022 12:02

How grim, his father is in prison for assaulting his mother. He has a previous conviction for assaulting a policewoman or a community support officer.

He went to a special school!

Mother obvs unable to control or discipline him.

OP posts:
Andante57 · 13/07/2022 11:35

Believed be the victim criminal exploitation

ghosty, sorry, I don’t understand this sentence. Has the murderer had criminal exploitation?

JudgeJ · 13/07/2022 11:31

FunDragon · 11/07/2022 20:02

He’s not been named because he’s a minor surely?

And 13 years is a long sentence for a juvenile offender. It’s almost his whole life again.

But he will be a relatively young man when he's released, free to enjoy life with a lot of tax-payer support.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 13/07/2022 11:24

The UK justice system actually is pretty good overall. That doesn't mean there are not misjustices, but it's basis it decent.

Re sentencing, prison is in the UK meant mainly for rehabilitation purposes, and protecting the public, not punishment or retribution. I am glad of that. I would NOT want to see a US style justfice/ prison policy here.

The perpetrator was a minor. His sentence was issued on that basis. In my view, rightly so from a policy perspective. We don't trial children as adults. Also, as others have pointed it out, it's a minimum sentence. He will be assessed to determine whether he poses danger to the public before his release, and in reality he will likely be under some kind of supervision for the rest of his life.

AppelFrench · 13/07/2022 11:19

FoggySpecs · 11/07/2022 19:52

The UK judicial system is pretty good, thank goodness we don't have American style sentences. Although they need to do something to keep criminal barristers going to maintain standards. Cases like that of Ava White are always emotive, but I think not naming the perpetrators is good, some gain a sort of cult celebrity status which is far worse.

As a victim of severe crime, I totally disagree with you.

Adelishious · 13/07/2022 11:14

Florenz · 12/07/2022 21:54

Of course there is a line between law-abiders and criminals. The former obey the law, the latter do not obey the law. There is no grey area.

There is clearly a grey area in many, many cases. Only the most sheltered of people could think otherwise. You defend yourself in an assault, but go a bit over the top? Clearly a grey area as you need to defend yourself but could easily find yourself guilty of a serious criminal offence. That's just one of many examples of why it's never just black & white

girlfriend44 · 13/07/2022 00:21

Redbone · 12/07/2022 22:15

I agree . The sentences handed out in this country are a joke. It is possibly the one thing that I agree with, with the USA. This boy should never be let loose on society and his parents should be held accountable too.

Yes to parents. At the moment under 16s can do anything and the parents are not held accountable.
Pretty obvious that the burgers killers parents should have been in the Dock too.

How can it be nothing to do with them when their 10 Yr old kill?
Do they also carry on raising their other children?

OP posts:
MiniPiccolo · 12/07/2022 23:01

Tsandjdarethrbest · 12/07/2022 22:10

Any so-called law abider could became a criminal in a heartbeat. You may want to believe there are goodies and baddies and they are distinct from one another but that’s wrong. Also consider that many criminals are very often victims of very serious crimes themselves.

Them also being victims of crime and abuse doesn't suddenly mean they're no longer a threat to society after serving half a lenient sentence. If anything it means they are inherently more dangerous, sociopathic damaged and broken, and now have more criminal contacts.

They are almost impossible to rehabilitate, will always reoffend, normally in increasing severity.

In some instances permanent exclusion from society is what's best for society. The individual is no longer relevant to it's function.

MiniPiccolo · 12/07/2022 22:50

girlfriend44 · 11/07/2022 19:42

Ava Whites killer gets 13 years today for stabbing her to death in Liverpool last November.

The judge refused to name him as well.
We just keep hearing crappy sentences and decisions all the time?
All on the side of the offender?

Do you think anything will ever change? Why couldn't we hear the news he's been locked up for 35 years and he has been named?
Someone some balls needs to take charge. Countryside an embarrassment.

There will be people inside when he transfers to an adult unit that don't much like kiddy killers. He's also a cocky little shit with an IQ similar to roadkill. Unlikely he will last long to be honest, OP.

And everyone in Liverpool knows the scrote's name.

Duttercup · 12/07/2022 22:47

Do you honestly mean that if your 13 yo child was out with friends and got stabbed to death, your first thought would be about the childhood and the welfare of her killer?

No, of course not. But that's why we have a criminal justice system and not vigilantism.

shreddednips · 12/07/2022 22:29

Bubblebubblebah · 11/07/2022 23:24

We have people committing multiple offences, often when on bail and of course they are eligible for free legal aid.

Having representation is actually one of the ways to ensure justice. Have you seen literacy levels of criminals? They wouldn't stand a chance against a lawyer and that would not be ok.
Many people are all about lack of human rights unless it suits their argument it seems to me.

And saying that everyone should have representation should they need it, doesn't mean standing up for criminals and "think they are cool" or whatever it was

I agree. I understand why certain people's access to legal aid leaves a sour taste, but the fact is that sometimes, people are accused of crimes they haven't committed and some of them won't be able to access legal representation. Being able to have a fair trial has to apply to everyone, even people whose crimes make our blood boil.

MichelleScarn · 12/07/2022 22:16

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 12/07/2022 22:08

Yes, what an utterly ridiculous situation we've arrived at where we leave oversight of our criminal justice system to those trained and with the experience to do so. I mean, what next? People having surgeons perform operations? Taking your car to a qualified mechanic to be diagnosed and repaired? Expecting the people who teach our children to be literate and numerate?

Heaven forbid. Far better to leave these things in the hands of barely educated, vindictive Sun/Mail readers with no insight whatseover.

What is is about Crime/Punishment threads that brings out the absolute puddle drinkers?

What do you mean by 'puddle drinker'? Do you honestly mean that if your 13 yo child was out with friends and got stabbed to death, your first thought would be about the childhood and the welfare of her killer?

Redbone · 12/07/2022 22:15

I agree . The sentences handed out in this country are a joke. It is possibly the one thing that I agree with, with the USA. This boy should never be let loose on society and his parents should be held accountable too.

Tsandjdarethrbest · 12/07/2022 22:10

Any so-called law abider could became a criminal in a heartbeat. You may want to believe there are goodies and baddies and they are distinct from one another but that’s wrong. Also consider that many criminals are very often victims of very serious crimes themselves.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 12/07/2022 22:08

Florenz · 12/07/2022 18:08

It's disgusting. The people working in the system always think they know better than the general public who pay their wages and who are at risk from the criminals when they are released. It's the wrong way round. They work for us. It isn't for them to tell them "we're right, you're wrong" and they do what the public wants, if they refuse, sack them, jail them for aiding, abetting, providing succour to criminals. The ONLY thing that matters in dealing with criminals is the rights of non-criminals to live a life unaffected by criminal activity. The rights of criminals should no concern whatsoever, they should forfeit these rights when they choose to break the law.

Yes, what an utterly ridiculous situation we've arrived at where we leave oversight of our criminal justice system to those trained and with the experience to do so. I mean, what next? People having surgeons perform operations? Taking your car to a qualified mechanic to be diagnosed and repaired? Expecting the people who teach our children to be literate and numerate?

Heaven forbid. Far better to leave these things in the hands of barely educated, vindictive Sun/Mail readers with no insight whatseover.

What is is about Crime/Punishment threads that brings out the absolute puddle drinkers?

MichelleScarn · 12/07/2022 21:58

Florenz · 12/07/2022 21:54

Of course there is a line between law-abiders and criminals. The former obey the law, the latter do not obey the law. There is no grey area.

Well when the criminals assault or offend against the law abiders it seems to be 'meh oh well, how can you think negatively against them/expect punitive action (the criminals) you don't know what they've been through'

Florenz · 12/07/2022 21:54

Of course there is a line between law-abiders and criminals. The former obey the law, the latter do not obey the law. There is no grey area.

Swipe left for the next trending thread