Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL/ PIL and grandkids - how much involvement/ interest is appropriate without overstepping?

87 replies

ThisMuch · 11/07/2022 18:54

Hi all, just looking forward to your take on this matter. In your experience, what is too much? What kind of behaviour from MIL/FIL justifies DIL's/ DS's annoyance or causes them to withdraw (particularly DIL)? How to offer support without appearing overbearing? This could be aplicable for the mother's parents as well in some cases, of course.

Context: GP want to spend as much time with GC and have as much involvement in DS's life as possible. This can be too much for a couple that wants independence and has different priorities. Sticky subjects are:

  • Tending to children's needs during family gatherings (e.g. preparing their meal and making sure they are fed, putting them to sleep, putting sunscreen on them, changing baby's nappies). Is it OK for GP to take on some of these tasks or can that be perceived as interferring?
  • Holding babies and physical affection with children. How much is too much?
  • Calling to "request" family time - suggesting they visit for holidays, weekends. Organising meetings so that they also visit extended family. Visiting to take children to the park/ cinema
  • Calling/ texting to check how doctor appointments/school functions/other events went

Thanks!

OP posts:
TheOriginalClownfish · 12/07/2022 11:43

Not a day goes by when I don't miss my lovely MIL. Her way of doing things had changed by the time DS came along but she was incredibly respectful of the way I did things, and supportive of it. She saw her role as a grandmother as first an foremost a support to her grandchild's parents - in the way we wanted/needed, not in the way she thought we should do things. She was incredibly proud of my mothering, showed it and I bloody love her for that.

If I put his routine up on the fridge, she followed it to a tee, or checked when she wasn't sure. She didn't try to take the baby off me, or try to angle for time alone with him - she loved to see us all coming and I never felt any less welcome than DS. Not once.

When we said we weren't doing the usual Christmas going to hers now we had DS and wanted to start our own family Christmas traditions beginning with staying at home for Christmas, she was supportive but she must have been feeling sad a little I'm sure.

When DS was about 6 months old, DP was cajoling me to go to the pub with the rest of them. I didn't know if I was ready to leave DS, and she was the only one in the room who told me it was ok to not be ready to leave the baby and that they could all wait until I was ready. (I did go, she babysat and didn't roll her eyes when I insisted on driving in case I needed to pop home to check Grin )

To give you an example, she bottle fed all of hers - just the way it was done in her location at that time. I exclusively breastfed, but she was supportive even though it was outside of her experience or knowledge. I mentioned in passing that breastfeeding is thirsty work and any time I visited and needed to BF, she would always put a glass of water within arms reach for me when I was BFing, and I just thought that was so thoughtful.

She wouldn't have been keen on the rocker t-shirts we put DS in, never would have said anything about what he wore. And when she would buy baby clothes, she used to quickly text DP before buying. My DM on the other hand would buy expensive, uncomfortable shirts, waistcoats and dicky bows for DS - a pointed dig at what she thought he should be wearing.

She did feed him more chocolate than he should have had. But because she did all the really supportive stuff, I could easily let the excess treats slide.

Summerwhereareyou · 12/07/2022 11:23

As pp said it depends on the relationship?

I would have happily let dm do all those things but she came from a loving kind place.

Unfortunately mil comes from a "your not doing it right place" so trying to include her has been extremely hard.

If dm.had over stepped or did something I would have very easily been able to say and she would have accepted!

With mil,I couldn't even let her know dd asthma syntpmms because " she's brought up 3 dc and they are alive and well ".

Ncwinc · 12/07/2022 11:10

It all depends on how the child’s parents feel and their relationship with the ILs/their parents. If the child’s parents are fine with something, great. If they feel it’s too much or overstepping then you’re going to have problems. Just because something is fine by me or another poster doesn’t mean it’s fine for the child’s parents.

takealettermsjones · 12/07/2022 11:09

Porcupineintherough · 12/07/2022 10:58

Well heaven forfend that a grandparent get anything out of the relationship. Hmm

I don't think anyone's saying that grandparents shouldn't get anything from the relationship, just that it changes the answers. E.g. cuddles when requested from kid? Fab. Cuddles when grandma wants one but kid has said no? Not so much.

Porcupineintherough · 12/07/2022 10:58

Margotshypotheticaldog · 11/07/2022 22:02

Basically is it about helping the parents and baby or fulfilling the grandparent's needs?

Well heaven forfend that a grandparent get anything out of the relationship. Hmm

Turnthatoff · 12/07/2022 10:54

My parents are no longer around, my MIL is, though quite elderly. My children are teenagers now. I consider us a bog standard family. I’ve had to grit my teeth a few times with MIL, but I guess that’s normal?

but the stuff in the OP? All perfectly fine and just happened organically, you know? Like at a family gathering for example…someone or other would pick up a random baby (I had 3 in 18 months) if I was busy, or take them off me if I was trying to eat. I guess plenty of nappies were changed if I was otherwise occupied. They often chased a random toddler to replace a sun hat. I assume sunscreen was applied on occasion, or a jumper wrestled on when it got cold.

No specific requests were made to see the kids as they were seen often enough. When we lived overseas they would visit, and stay. I’m not crazy about close quarters with my MIL but id never have dreamed of not inviting her.

there were no health issues with the kids, but if there were of course id have kept them informed. I think all of the above is quite normal, in a normal family where everyone respects boundaries, and parents remember that grandparents are batshit crazy in love with their grandkids and mean well.

I did pay for childcare through, but mum was a godsend on the days where one of them had a temperature and I couldn’t drop them off at childcare but had to work.

thelittlestbird · 12/07/2022 10:19

Totally dependent on existing relationship between couple and the GPs I think, and also how the parents have found parenthood. Me and DH have struggled and my parents have been as involved as it's possible to be. We've been enormously grateful. MIL is another story and the contrast is really upsetting for my DH.

morescrummythanyummy · 12/07/2022 09:44

I find my PIL (who are fussy but have a lot of other interests) pretty easy to deal with.

Found it harder with my parents, who have always been very hands off, but the moment I had my first DC they were all over us like a rash, kept talking about when DC would be old enough to stay with them (in another country - flying alone), took DC off my DH and out for a walk, not saying where they were going or for how long, the moment I stepped in the shower when they came to visit the first time after DC was born. Messaged me when pregnant every day with a new baby name, most of which had a link to the country they live in (and I didn't grow up in). Have had to redraw boundaries with them and it is pretty good now, I would say. Try to be forgiving (they are over excited and anxious about their relationship with DC) but firm - never let them do something that really concerns you to keep the peace, as resentment will eat away at you; give away some easy wins early. Saying no gets more respect if done sparingly, fairly and kindly.

If you are the GP, OP, you seem perhaps a bit much. Some GPs naturally have this relationship with GC because they naturally had a very close relationship with their DC that was based on mutual understanding and good boundaries (not being enmeshed and codependent - sons who are "close" to their mothers because their mothers do everything for them and they are too lazy to draw boundaries and be a grown up are not "close" to their mothers, they are just lazy). You can't force this. Follow the parents' lead, be useful. By the time you get a second GC, you'll probably be given more leeway than with the first - you'll be trusted and parents will have their hands full. Play a long game, rather than focusing on trying to maximise what you "should" have from the outset.

DilemmaDelilah · 12/07/2022 08:54

Oh - and further to my previous (very long) post. If I am told about something that is happening with my grandchild I think my daughter would be quite annoyed if I didn't care enough to ask how it went! If I'm not told and find out in another way then I wouldn't ask, but I might steer the conversation in such a way that would make it easy for her to update me - if she wanted to.

DilemmaDelilah · 12/07/2022 08:47

I think we have it pretty much right, but I am the mum not the MIL. We try to have family lunch around once a month. Occasionally we all do something together, but it's not very often as we don't have the energy to do that very often, but the occasional picnic, visit to the theatre, walk in the woods etc. We have the GCs to stay overnight about once a month - originally at their Mums request (the first couple of times) but now I just ask her whether the children would like to come and stay. When they were tiny I would ask whether she wanted help re: feeding or nappy changing and she usually did. Tiny babies were offered to me to hold usually and given back when asked or before. I looked after the eldest for half a day a week for the first couple of years to save on childcare when my daughter went back to work. She asks me for babysitting occasionally and I have a standing commitment to have the children for 2 days every half term as her annual leave doesn't cover all the school holidays. Basically she trusts me to look after her children in the same way that she does, and when they are with me I treat them as my own. Bedtimes are the same as at home. If anything I am a little more strict than she is but she doesn't mind. Cuddles are up to the children - they frequently ask for cuddles but I don't demand them. I do ask for a kiss hello or goodbye if one isn't offered, but it usually isn't offered because they are distracted rather than because they don't want to, and I never force it. If they don't want to then that is that. We have an excellent relationship with the children and they take us for granted in very much the same way as they do their parents. I think my daughter always assumed that I would help out and I would be close to her children. if anything I think she would like me to do more with them but neither of us are very healthy and we just don't have the energy!
The difficulties arise when there are different expectations I think. I don't understand why a mother would feel it necessary to be with their child all the time and wouldn't want to allow the GPs to build that close relationship, but I do understand and accept that some people feel that way.

SmashingEgg · 12/07/2022 08:23

Fortunately, my D.I.Ls are grown ups who have never had an issue with any of those things that you mentioned op.

easyday · 12/07/2022 08:18

Sounds pretty normal to me. I never had that - my pil couldn't care less, a little cuddle then baby back to me (or father) and as kids were expected to play quietly while adults chatted.
My own parents lived in another country but when around came over once a week and we'd go see them for a week on holiday. They babysat a couple times but were well in to their 70s when my kids came along.
I'd have been happy if someone took over looking after my kids on social occasions- sounds great! But if you think it's too much then gently reassert yourself.

Wouldloveanother · 12/07/2022 07:51

As far as I’m concerned when MIL is around there’s nothing I can do for DD that she can’t - Comfort her if she has an accident, get a drink or some food etc. I would be a bit 🤨 if she, for example, booked a day out with Dd without telling me first. She lives down the road and drops in when she likes, usually twice a week or so which I know would drive most posters on here nuts though 😅 I’m quite chilled I think.

110APiccadilly · 12/07/2022 07:48

This is just my take, and FWIW applies to my parents as well as my in-laws.

Tending to children's needs during family gatherings (e.g. preparing their meal and making sure they are fed, putting them to sleep, putting sunscreen on them, changing baby's nappies). Is it OK for GP to take on some of these tasks or can that be perceived as interferring?

All fine, but check with me first. So saying, "Would you like me to sort out X's food for them?" is great. Just going ahead and doing it feels like you don't think I will!

Holding babies and physical affection with children. How much is too much?

Too much is when the child is fed up. So unlimited cuddles but if my baby is crying because they want milk or my toddler is squirming and saying, "Down," then you need to stop.

Calling to "request" family time - suggesting they visit for holidays, weekends. Organising meetings so that they also visit extended family. Visiting to take children to the park/ cinema.

Suggestions are great but you have to be able to take a refusal gracefully. Sometimes they might have other plans, or just be tired. I do find my MIL doesn't realise how tiring DH finds big family gatherings, for instance, and will really push them when he doesn't feel he can face one.

Calling/ texting to check how doctor appointments/school functions/other events went

I'd rather a text, and let me take my time answering. In particula if something hasn't gone well, I'd like some time to process that myself before I have to go round telling everyone. (Applies particularly to doctors' appointments.)

Hope that's helpful, though as I say it's just how I feel about things.

GoldenSpiral · 12/07/2022 07:47

I have a great relationship with my in laws and see them once a week. They babysit for me for a couple of hours and we have lunch together afterwards. Here are my thoughts as a mum to a 20 month old:

I wouldn't like a GP 'showing off' how involved they to extended family at a family gathering by grabbing my DC and 'helping'. Some people do this and I can see how it would be irritating. However, if a GP offered some help I may or may not accept but would appreciate the offer either way.

If a baby is crying then you should not insist on comforting the baby. If a parent comes to you and asks for the baby then you must give the baby to the parent. Otherwise, if you are holding a content baby with permission then no amount of physical affection is a problem in my view. You just need to remember that you don't have a right to override a parent. If they need to take a GC for a feed etc, then don't fight it or act hard done by.

If you are calling to request family time every weekend then it is too much. I say this as someone that sees her in laws once a week, but it is during the week as I am a SAHM. If I were you, then I would always make it clear that it is never a problem for the parents to turn down an invite as you understand that their own family time on weekends is also precious. You are not entitled to any amount of family time. You should never organise for extended family to see the baby without first agreeing it with the parents. I would hate it if GPs visited my home uninvited.

I don't mind GPs asking how appointments and events have gone.

My in laws have been excellent as GPs and I'm very grateful to have them. I don't see my own parents much due to distance but they have also been great. I'm sure if you are respectful then you won't have any troubles either.

lollipoprainbow · 12/07/2022 07:43

Changing nappies, hugging, taking to park, calling to see how they are. Sounds terrible OP.

ShirleyPhallus · 12/07/2022 07:38

lollipoprainbow · 12/07/2022 07:18

Just be grateful your kids have GP's Christ almighty !!!

its absolutely fine to be irritated by people sometimes, you don’t always need to be unwaveringly grateful for them just being alive

lollipoprainbow · 12/07/2022 07:36

@bandek of course but having loving hands on GP's for my dd would be a privilege. She doesn't have any.

bandek · 12/07/2022 07:29

lollipoprainbow · 12/07/2022 07:18

Just be grateful your kids have GP's Christ almighty !!!

People never do things that annoy you?

lollipoprainbow · 12/07/2022 07:18

Just be grateful your kids have GP's Christ almighty !!!

Queensize · 12/07/2022 07:10

Repeating what others have said - and stating the obvious - never take a baby off a mother without an invitation. My mil has been a nightmare for snatching babies - and that's how it felt, like snatching. It upset me so much and was one of a number of ways she alienated me in the baby years.

ShirleyPhallus · 12/07/2022 06:54

The main thing for me is to offer but be respectful if the answer is no. And think about whether your reaction is appropriate. And don’t make it about you.

My MIL is a lovely but a total fusspot so if DD has a doctors appt I have to play down whatever the response is otherwise my husband or I get a big shocked look from her, descending in to a sad face and asking if this will be a lifelong condition when it’s just a cold.

Asiama · 12/07/2022 06:42

I think all these things can be normal if there is a good relationship between parents and GPs, and the GPs respect the parents' role as parents, don't try to undermine / interfere, and put the child's needs and parents' wishes over their own wishes. The fact you call these "sticking points" suggests to me that these are areas the parents don't want GPs to step into and the GPs should respect that.

I have a great relationship with my in-laws and a poor relationship with my parents, now NC.

Tending to children's needs: PILs would have offered help and I would have accepted it. My mother would have either just done it and it would have come across as interfering, then acted all offended when asked to back off, and told me how I'm doing it all wrong and her way is better.

Holding babies: too much is when the child doesn't want it, or you don't let go when the parents want you to for whatever reason (eg it's time to feed but you want more cuddles). Follow the needs of the child, not the wants of the GP.

Calling to request family time: GPs can ask. parents can say no, GPs need to accept it and not badger or act offended. PILs would make suggestions and back off straight away if we said no. My mother would arrange things and tell us where and when for us to turn up, then be extremely upset when we say no.

Calling for doctor updates: really depends on the relationship. PILs would ask in order to support me, my mother would ask so that she could tell me how she disagrees.

ToastedCrumpetwithCheese · 11/07/2022 22:37

We don't live very close to either set of grandparents though, so that's a very natural way of limiting the frequency of contact. We would have different boundaries if we lived closer (and in fact moved away to improve our relationship with them).

ToastedCrumpetwithCheese · 11/07/2022 22:35

In all these examples...generally speaking, if DD was happy, then I'd roll with it. It meant that if I did step in it was because DD wasn't happy and not about how I felt about it.

I will say that my PIL are nice people, no dodgy history and we get on fairly well. DH and I are quite capable of saying no if things don't suit us and the more we've done it, the easier (and more expected) it has become. They very much know that our children come first.

But babies aren't babies for long and the PIL doing things when they were younger didn't take away from how much our children loved us. It sometimes felt a bit like that, but we will always been mum and dad. Now they're older we send them off to the grandparents on holiday!!! Maybe the grandparents regret building relationships with them when they were younger Grin they can't get rid of them now!!!