Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No refund on bridal make up after trial

136 replies

MakeupWoes · 11/07/2022 17:39

I booked a highly recommended artist for my bridal makeup, and had to secure with a non refundable deposit before I was allowed a trial.

I've since had a trial, and the makeup was shocking. My face was caked on (I get for pictures), but in the heat, it was literally running down my face. It transferred everytime something brushed my face.

I'm left with proceeding with someone who's make up I really dislike because I can't afford to lose the deposit, or I have to borrow the money to change to someone else. WWYD?

OP posts:
headiiinthecloudsssss · 11/07/2022 19:51

Can you show us a photo of a section of your face? (So your full face isn't showing revealing your identity).

Perhaps some of us can work out what went wrong or reassure you it isn't as terrible as you thing?

rainyskylight · 11/07/2022 19:50

I don’t know why you need to wear loads of make up???? I spent some time in the lead up to my wedding researching, trying and selecting bits and pieces that I normally wouldn’t buy as they’re a little more expensive. I did my own make up, and looked like myself on my wedding day, with make up that suited my skin type. I could touched up with my own products in the ladies or before the photos.

find it very strange women spending £300 to look like someone else. And to wear makeup that might not suit their skin for their wedding day.

Luidaeg · 11/07/2022 19:50

Aprilx · 11/07/2022 17:57

I wouldn’t expect a refund for this. She needs paying for her time and products. You cannot expect that somebody comes round and does your make up and you don’t pay.

so if you book me to come and make your face up for a wedding, and I turn up with markers and felt tips you'd be fine with paying me?

Trial was not fit for purpose, OP didnt just 'not like it' - it was falling off her face, My face was caked on (I get for pictures), but in the heat, it was literally running down my face. It transferred everytime something brushed my face.

CopperLily · 11/07/2022 19:49

eurochick · 11/07/2022 17:57

My wedding make up trial was also dreadful. I asked for a subtle natural look and when I saw myself in the mirror when she was finished I resembled a hooker. It was dreadful.

I binned the MUA, visited some make up counters for tips and nice products and did my own. I looked like myself and felt comfortable. You really don't need to have the slap caked on.

I had the same experience, I was covered in thick orange makeup that was so terrible that I cried all the way home. My tears washed 2 lines of foundation off my face and stained my white t-shirt. It must've been the shittest foundation around and NOT suitable for anyone, least of all a bride!

I threw myself on the mercy of the Estée Lauder staff in Boots 4 days before my wedding and they pulled out all the stops to find me the right shades of makeup and showed me how to apply it correctly. They were fantastic!

PutOnAHappyFace · 11/07/2022 19:48

The fact the make up was transferring onto I'm guessing clothes etc shows it was a bad job in my opinion. Most people who aren't even MUAs who are ok at make up use a decent powder/setting spray routine so this doesn't happen.

Cameronnorrieisabitofalright · 11/07/2022 19:48

So it was pointless having a trial when she is going to do it the way SHE wants anyway!!
You have been swizzed op.

creativelady22 · 11/07/2022 19:45

Just an alternative perspective here. If she has blocked the date out for your wedding, she is in effect losing a job that day. Makeup artists only have x many slots per year and it's part of their income so the deposit is reasonable.

I would do as others have said and speak to her about the issues and try and resolve it with another trial... these girls had a terrible time in Covid and lost a lot so I'm sure would rather meet halfway than lose a booking? The current heat is not ideal either. Good luck I know it's awful

FallopianTubeTrain · 11/07/2022 19:40

Ask her to do it much lighter / provide your on foundation for her to use, be assertive and override the 'for the photos' bollocks

Get yourself some urban decay all nighter setting spray and apply liberally over the top when it's done

If you still have some trust there that is.

Mine wasn't quite what I wanted when we did the trial so I asked for some changes on the day and it was fine.

headiiinthecloudsssss · 11/07/2022 19:39

I think the issue is the deposit is too high an amount, I wouldn't have been comfortable putting that much down and potentially losing it.

I think because you are really unhappy with the result she should offer to do another trial free and try to rectify it.

Whopbamboom · 11/07/2022 19:39

MakeupWoes · 11/07/2022 17:49

The artist advised me it had to be thicker for photos, and I wasn't about to argue considering that is her job and assumingly she knows better than I. So whilst I asked about the thickness, she explained why.

However, it wasn't until it all started running once I was getting on with my day, that I saw the real problem of it moving so much

The artist advised me it had to be thicker for photos

I am a professional wedding photographer and this is RUBBISH.

This is not studio make up, it's not makeup designed to be in harsh, direct light where colours will be blown out and any detail lost. Whatever is on your face will show on camera as it is.

I only ever hear this from crap makeup artists and those who don't know the difference between heavy studio makeup and anything else.

If a makeup artist tells you this, run a mile.

Britannah · 11/07/2022 19:37

You should have made it clear in your original post that you have paid for the trial AND the again to secure your slot. As it’s a deposit I can understand why she wouldn’t refund that however how can she justify asking people for a deposit before their trial if they are paying for that separately?! I would have questioned that before paying tbh but you didn’t so if I was you and you genuinely can’t afford to go elsewhere then I would detail in writing all the changes you would like making. She will then have the pressure of getting it right on the day however long it takes but that’s her issue. If she comes highly recommended she should be able to achieve the look you want!

loopylum · 11/07/2022 19:36

My face was caked on (I get for pictures), but in the heat, it was literally running down my face. It transferred everytime something brushed my face.

It's makeup, not magic. Everything is going to slide off in this heat

Oceanus · 11/07/2022 19:33

In my experience, Bobbi Brown have the easiest products for a smokey eye if you haven't hit 40 yet but it can pricey. They'll give you a little drawing with the products they've used. For foundation I would go elsewhere or use your own. You could try contouring instead, it looks fab in pictures.

Oceanus · 11/07/2022 19:30

MakeupWoes · 11/07/2022 17:49

The artist advised me it had to be thicker for photos, and I wasn't about to argue considering that is her job and assumingly she knows better than I. So whilst I asked about the thickness, she explained why.

However, it wasn't until it all started running once I was getting on with my day, that I saw the real problem of it moving so much

That's not true. It doesn't have to be thicker for photos! hhaaha! You need good prep, good makeup and then a good setting spray. Usually pros use Skindinavia bridal spray to set makeup.
Looking patchy or cakey comes from bad application and/or bad products. Are you sure you got a pro? A lot of people watch youtube videos and then start doing it "professionaly", others aren't cut out for it. It's not as easy as it sounds, to me anyway. I can make my face look presentable but I could never do it to another person, if anything because what works for me might not work for others.
It's sad you were taken advantage of but look at this way: it wasn't on your wedding day! Then you would have been really distraught.
This can still be fixed. Maybe you can get a proper pro to do it or you can splurge on a few good products and do it yourself.
Go to a good makeup counter and ask for help. Have them do your face. Go for a walk down the shops and see how you look in a few hours. It usually takes me a couple of hours to see if makeup holds or ends up looking patchy (if you're young-ish it shouldn't take you so long).
Go to John Lewis, try to call ahead if you can, that way you have several options. Take an honest friend with you if you can, not your mother. Mothers always think we look bloody great no matter what.

Aprilx · 11/07/2022 19:28

FlamingoQueen · 11/07/2022 18:29

Could you go to a department store and book a Bobbi Brown (or similar) makeover?

On her wedding day?

Whodoiwanttobe · 11/07/2022 19:05

MakeupWoes · 11/07/2022 17:49

The artist advised me it had to be thicker for photos, and I wasn't about to argue considering that is her job and assumingly she knows better than I. So whilst I asked about the thickness, she explained why.

However, it wasn't until it all started running once I was getting on with my day, that I saw the real problem of it moving so much

Mine did this and I hated it. I went with it and felt like I didn’t look like me! You don’t need it for photos unless you’ve got really bad skin i.e acne that you need/want covering. Don’t go with it you’ll regret it like I did!
Tell her you don’t like it and try and get her to change it. Ask her to use your normal foundation so you don’t look caked?

SnowyLamb · 11/07/2022 19:03

Honestly do your own. Look like yourself.

OooErr · 11/07/2022 18:59

Also I don’t understand how the deposit is related to the trial.
surely a trial is to decide whether you want services. A deposit means you already do. Contradictory concepts indeee…

OooErr · 11/07/2022 18:57

If your skin is already relative flawless you don’t need cake makeup. You’re not a stage performer.

Since you’ve spent the money I’d ask her if she can do another trial? Did you not see photos of her other work, were they all caked too?

Rodion · 11/07/2022 18:52

I think not liking her style (which posisbly includes thickness of product, i cant decide) and the end result is a risk that you accepted when you paid the deposit. I would avoid people who make those sort of demands in the future.

However, makeup that runs down your face is clearly unsuitable for a wedding so I'd say she hasn't delivered on the wedding makeup trial in any way. I would want another trial for free to try a look that won't be prone to running.

Enjoyallthewine · 11/07/2022 18:52

Definitely contact her, tell her how your makeup was after the trial and what you did and didn’t like. Suggest a re-trial and the use of a setting spray to help keep your makeup in place after she has done it? Feedback should be important to her.

HavfrueDenizKisi · 11/07/2022 18:52

Of course you don't bloody need pancake makeup for photos for a wedding. What utter rubbish.

My wedding make up was very natural and subtle but lasted longer than if I had done it myself. But it most certainly wasn't one inch Instagram blogger style.

No doubt the MUA only works in one way so spun you this bullshit.

However no idea about deposit. I'd cut my losses and run!

gigglinggirl · 11/07/2022 18:51

I definitely wouldn’t stick with this MUA. Do you have any friends who are good at doing make-up? For my wedding, I took one such friend with me to a make-up counter (we chose a sales person who looked amazing, make-up definitely not caked on) and she basically showed my friend what to do. We bought a few products so it was good for her, and my make-up looked great on the day. Good luck!

MakeupWoes · 11/07/2022 18:50

SafelySoftly · 11/07/2022 18:20

Do your own make up..? If money is so tight you’d need to borrow £80 I can’t believe you’d even have contemplated having a make up artist at all.

I was trying to treat myself with this, because I haven't been very well, which is why finance has been tight.
Both are vastly improving, hence why I said to borrow the money, because I will pay it back.

My wedding was moved because of covid, sometimes shit happens

OP posts:
Suprima · 11/07/2022 18:48

Why are you having a make up trial during a heatwave?

I imagine the products she used today as a
trial for your actual wedding will be fine in cool September

Swipe left for the next trending thread