Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughters birthday coming up WWYD?

58 replies

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 11/07/2022 15:38

Of course in virtually all families you celebrate a birthday with cards presents cake etc ,

Except in this case my daughter has gone no contact with us. We really really don’t know why but it escalated after Xmas when I dared to ask for a photo of our grandchildren at Xmas . That was the final straw apparently. At this point she said she wanted nothing more to do with us. We weren’t seeing them in person anyhow due to the previous deterioration in relationship but had communicated by text for a few days following Xmas a very rare occurrence in itself.

Before that , communication was sporadic, to say the least . We haven’t seen the gc for several years they are now 5 and 3 . And for nearly 2 years they sent I think a photo about 3 times with a short message. This has really affected my mental health .

Encouraged by her grandparents she did send me a birthday present ( before the after Christmas row) They were trying to act as peacemakers She admitted that inadvertently during the row , that was the case . So it wasn’t her “choice” but due to their pressure. She also sent a Mother’s Day card hand written just “from….”

To be honest these things leave me worse mentally than no contact at all , they feel like they are sent with no emotion no love , more some kind of perceived duty.

When her grandad died this year she sent a very short “sorry for your loss” text to her dad, his son. Flowers to her grandma but no call and didn’t go to the funeral. She has told us she hates her sister and now her brother too . I mention these because I am aware of the hard deal mums experiencing NC get on AIBU and I wanted you see the picture . We really don’t know why she is like this and what she thinks we have done to go NC with us.

No Father’s Day card and just a moon pig card for DH birthday recently.

We resolved some time ago to continue to mark the gc birthdays Christmas and Easter And have sent presents and cards though it does get trickier not knowing what they like . In fact we do get responses to emails from us requesting ideas from our son in law to these . No other time. Rarely do we get any thank you for things.

Even when we did have some sort of relationship, most of their replies was only when we were getting things for them. They wouldn't reply to phone calls, emails nor texts . Nothing for months on end. Too busy was their excuse.

So my dilemma. To mark a forthcoming birthday or not ( mid thirties) . A card maybe to try to keep doors open? WWYD?

OP posts:
PineForestsAndSunshine · 11/07/2022 17:09

AMindNeedsBooks · 11/07/2022 16:34

When you asked for a photo of the GC, did youi say 'Hi, could you send me a photo of GC when you get a chance?' or 'Can you send a photo of the GC because you've only sent 3 in 2 years and it's affecting my mental health'?

This is a good point.

I know you didn't ask for opinions on the rift itself OP so don't feel like you need to respond to this, is there is a lot of drama in your relationships? Has anyone mentioned the drama triangle to you? Not the best link sorry

Personally I would send something that lets your DD know you are thinking of her without bringing more drama to the situation. I definitely would not send a gift or anything she would feel guilty refusing or discarding. Just a simple card saying that you both wish her a very happy birthday.

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 11/07/2022 17:00

For those who express surprise at us not knowing the reason. We truly don’t and of course have asked her several times. Reached out many times .
it may be the long standing thing that I think she has disliked/ hated her sister from birth ( 10 yeas older)

OP posts:
caramac04 · 11/07/2022 16:58

If my mother had sent me a card it would have gone in the bin.
she did text me once, absolutely vile and sweary. Probably to goad and manipulate me to apologise.
She told lies about me to cover why I went NC but I’ll never regret it.

bpirockin · 11/07/2022 16:54

I know there is a general view that no-one goes NC with a parent for no reason, but let's remember that the "reason" may well be that the family or parent are simply not reacting in the desired way to said offspring. If people with personality disorders or addictions etc. don't get what they want/hope for, then they inevitably move on to people who will tolerate their bullshit.

I don't know the full story, and without talking to both parties it's impossible to know, but I am biased because my own sister is NC, takes great delight in telling anyone who'll listen how awful her family are, never send birthday greetings/gifts etc. What she doesn't tell them is that they did for years and never got any thanks, included her in events that she inevitably made awkward at best, and tired of her lies, expectations and general unpleasantness. My Mum won't put herself up for more hurt, but I know that if my sister reached out to her now, she would not turn her away. I don't expect her to do that, but fully expect her to turn up at the funeral and play the victim, and then leave counting and probably arguing about whatever she's been left - because she'll want and apparently believe she deserves more, even when the split will be equal. Personally, I wish Mum would cut her out of her Will altogether and leave her 'share' to my nephew who has had to live with her BS his whole life, and missed out on a lot because of it. Unfortunately, that's not my call.

If you are willing to risk further hurt then why not send a card and ask if you can meet up and talk through her 'issues'. Then listen, really listen, before responding. Or maybe she could write it all down. it will hurt but at least you'll know what's going on in her head. She has a right to her feelings, but maybe she's misunderstood something you said or your intentions.

It may be time to let go, and maybe the letting go will give you both some clarity. It seems to me that you are in a phase where you're giving her the power to keep hurting you, and nobody deserves that.

Cameronnorrieisabitofalright · 11/07/2022 16:47

Knowing him he won't care about that! He further instigated rows with other siblings until there is likely no way back now.
He had issues from when I divorced years ago. Op is your dc holding some misguided judgments against you?

AMindNeedsBooks · 11/07/2022 16:44

Cameronnorrieisabitofalright · 11/07/2022 16:38

My adult ds lost the plot one Xmas and assaulted a small sibling. Haven't heard from him. Have still sent cards on birthday and Xmas to him and his dc. Haven't expected a response. He is free to bin should he choose.. Without instruction to stop I will continue to send.
Sorry you are in a similar situation op.
It's a hard one for non in a similar position to understand...

I think the difference is you know why he's NC. He assaulted a young sibling and will be ashamed and not want to face up to it.

Cameronnorrieisabitofalright · 11/07/2022 16:38

My adult ds lost the plot one Xmas and assaulted a small sibling. Haven't heard from him. Have still sent cards on birthday and Xmas to him and his dc. Haven't expected a response. He is free to bin should he choose.. Without instruction to stop I will continue to send.
Sorry you are in a similar situation op.
It's a hard one for non in a similar position to understand...

AMindNeedsBooks · 11/07/2022 16:34

When you asked for a photo of the GC, did youi say 'Hi, could you send me a photo of GC when you get a chance?' or 'Can you send a photo of the GC because you've only sent 3 in 2 years and it's affecting my mental health'?

Mally100 · 11/07/2022 16:33

“You sound impossible to please. Picking apart every single communication, to the level of noting that she put "from" rather than "love from" in a card.”

And this is how you spot that there is much more going on. Op isn't being truthful and I'm sure the daughter has very good reason to be NC.

xogossipgirlxo · 11/07/2022 16:33

I wish we knew the other side of the story. I am saying this, because I limited the contact with my mum and I had my reasons. You can send a card, but don't expect much of it.

Soggycrisps · 11/07/2022 16:30

Yes send a heartfelt card and present.
If you want to write some sort of letter saying that you don't understand why she's gone NC with you do that separately. It wouldn't be nice to get that sort of letter on her birthday.

SarahSissions · 11/07/2022 16:30

just send a card, sign it “our door is always open, love, 2bee” and leave it at that.

OneFrenchEgg · 11/07/2022 16:29

Who knows? There's loads of humans in this world dealing with poor mental health, unforgotten hurts, emotional injuries which may or may not have happened as they perceive it.

In the end, keep your own kindness and just leave the door open. Send a card, with love. I kept trying with my dsis, and then after years we met for a coffee and agreed to not go over old ground, just meet and put it right for the next generation. There's always hope but sometimes picking at wounds keeps them from healing,

Testina · 11/07/2022 16:27

“You sound impossible to please. Picking apart every single communication, to the level of noting that she put "from" rather than "love from" in a card.”

Indeed. It’s a big deal to send a card that you don’t really want to send - that “from” is actually quite possibly a huge deal from her. My mother would go straight to attention seeking wailing at the lack of “love” instead of being pleased to receive a card.

10HailMarys · 11/07/2022 16:26

Whenever someone says they don't know why someone has gone NC with them on here, people always reply and say 'Well, you must have done something wrong for them to do that.' And I'm sure in many cases that's completely true. But not always. In every story of someone going NC, there's someone who's behaving appallingly and inexplicably - but it is not always the person on the receiving end of the estrangement. Sometimes it is the person who has chosen to walk away who is the irrational/paranoid/unstable one.

OP, nobody here can judge the situation between you and your daughter but personally in your situation I would send a card wishing her a happy birthday and hoping she has a lovely day. I'd do that with no expectation of anything in return, however.

AMindNeedsBooks · 11/07/2022 16:26

My Mum has blamed me and my siblings for making her mental health worse. We were also selfish for not wanting a close relationship with her despite her awful behaviour growing up. 2 of us are NC with her although it took a long time due to FOG. FOG was the only reason I spoke to her or sent her anything. She is completely in denial about her behaviour. Perhaps the issue with her siblings could be that they are trying to guilt her into having a relationship with you? That has happened with my siblings in the past although we have a good relationship.

I would love to feel like I have a Mum but she is toxic. I never sent thoughtful cards with lovely words in them either because it would have been a lie.

justfiveminutes · 11/07/2022 16:25

What reasons has she given you for going nc?

Why was she cross that you asked for a photo?

I do think that you must have an idea of her reasons even if you think they're trumped up or absolute lies.

Having said that, it is possible for adult children to be abusive to their parents too - I've seen it.

Testina · 11/07/2022 16:24

You do seem to be hinting that she’s being quite mercenary, accepting gifts and only having contact over things received - but it sometimes being ignored.

My own experience… I wanted nothing to do with my mother. But at the same time, I didn’t want to look petty, or start rows. The obvious time for her to attempt contact was “present” events - like a child’s birthday. Depending on how I was feeling about her behaviour, that either felt like an olive branch that was too little too late, or an outright manipulation. Makes you look like the unreasonable bitch to their mates, doesn’t it, rejecting a child’s birthday present, or request for idea for same. And the olive branch thing… I didn’t want one, but nor did I want to take the olive branch and smack her round the face with it! So sometimes that kindness, or manners, would win out and I’d say thank you. Other times, I just saw it as a manipulation. So given my experience, I don’t assume that accepting presents is necessarily her using you when it suits. I expect it’s far more complex.

SunshineAndFizz · 11/07/2022 16:24

Kids don't just stop talking to their family for no reason.

You must have an idea why she's doing this? If genuinely not, then ask her?

zingally · 11/07/2022 16:23

Sorry, but I do not believe that a child goes NC with a parent for no reason. Simply don't believe it. And I roll my eyes even harder when the parent plays all hard done by and "no idea why".

You sound impossible to please. Picking apart every single communication, to the level of noting that she put "from" rather than "love from" in a card.

Send a card and gift if you want to. Make no mention of the no-contact because that'll just seem attention-seeking and looking for drama. Just put "Dear DD, happy birthday, hope you have a lovely day. Love from DM and DF."

Testina · 11/07/2022 16:19

@Crestofawave2 “your comment around the cards and gifts not being thoughtful enough scream of someone impossible to please. Could that be your daughters issue?”

Where did you read that?

madasawethen · 11/07/2022 16:09

Just send the card and gift.
I wouldn't mention the no contact. No snark, no guilt trip.
Just "thinking of you, hope you have a lovely bd."

I've had family members who have fallen in and out with each other. It can happen for many different reasons. People with undiagnosed mental illness, present or past alcohol drug issues, too busy cant be bothered, any number of things.

Madmog · 11/07/2022 16:06

As said before, if you feel you want to try and keep doors open, send something - if only a card. I wouldn't anything too sentimental in it, other than if you'd be up to seeing her sometime, just to say let me know if you'd like to meet up for coffee, meal out. The rest is up to her.

CousinKrispy · 11/07/2022 16:05

I think if she's said she doesn't want you to contact her, you should respect her wishes, although I know that must be terribly difficult.

The fact that they are still accepting cards and gifts for the GC may make it more complicated.

I assume that you've previously communicated that the door is always open should she change her mind? In which case I would respect her wishes and remain out of contact now. She may then feel more inclined to reach out herself when she is ready.

Crunchingleaf · 11/07/2022 15:59

I was inclined to think you were completely glossing over the past when you said you have no idea why this has happened. The fact she doesn’t speak to her brother or sister is interesting and could be a clue as to reason she doesn’t want to speak to you.
I barely speak to my mother but I still talk to my siblings and am close to my sister. My issue is with out mother not with rest of family. No harm in trying to keep door open but you might have to be brutally honest with yourself when looking at the past in order to move past whatever is going on here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread