Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughters birthday coming up WWYD?

58 replies

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 11/07/2022 15:38

Of course in virtually all families you celebrate a birthday with cards presents cake etc ,

Except in this case my daughter has gone no contact with us. We really really don’t know why but it escalated after Xmas when I dared to ask for a photo of our grandchildren at Xmas . That was the final straw apparently. At this point she said she wanted nothing more to do with us. We weren’t seeing them in person anyhow due to the previous deterioration in relationship but had communicated by text for a few days following Xmas a very rare occurrence in itself.

Before that , communication was sporadic, to say the least . We haven’t seen the gc for several years they are now 5 and 3 . And for nearly 2 years they sent I think a photo about 3 times with a short message. This has really affected my mental health .

Encouraged by her grandparents she did send me a birthday present ( before the after Christmas row) They were trying to act as peacemakers She admitted that inadvertently during the row , that was the case . So it wasn’t her “choice” but due to their pressure. She also sent a Mother’s Day card hand written just “from….”

To be honest these things leave me worse mentally than no contact at all , they feel like they are sent with no emotion no love , more some kind of perceived duty.

When her grandad died this year she sent a very short “sorry for your loss” text to her dad, his son. Flowers to her grandma but no call and didn’t go to the funeral. She has told us she hates her sister and now her brother too . I mention these because I am aware of the hard deal mums experiencing NC get on AIBU and I wanted you see the picture . We really don’t know why she is like this and what she thinks we have done to go NC with us.

No Father’s Day card and just a moon pig card for DH birthday recently.

We resolved some time ago to continue to mark the gc birthdays Christmas and Easter And have sent presents and cards though it does get trickier not knowing what they like . In fact we do get responses to emails from us requesting ideas from our son in law to these . No other time. Rarely do we get any thank you for things.

Even when we did have some sort of relationship, most of their replies was only when we were getting things for them. They wouldn't reply to phone calls, emails nor texts . Nothing for months on end. Too busy was their excuse.

So my dilemma. To mark a forthcoming birthday or not ( mid thirties) . A card maybe to try to keep doors open? WWYD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
chipchopchap · 12/07/2022 08:17

I'm NC with my parents. I am yet to meet someone who has gone NC with their parents for no real reason.
In all honesty it's actually very very hard to maintain NC. Everyone asks me questions about my mum. Once you get to know colleagues they ask things like, does your mum do this or that, your parent friends ask, does your mum help much. It's so so hard so I doubt very much it's ever for no reason whatsoever.
I am actually ashamed I've had to go NC with my mum but I know 100% I had to.

I have no advice to you. For the first couple of years my mum sent me something. I ignored it. I then moved house and didn't leave an address. But any suggestion to me that people go NC with their parents for no reason does not sit well with me. There's always a reason, you just might not know what it is.

Teacupsandtoast · 12/07/2022 08:08

OP - is your daughter the one who has the horrid partner and lives on an Irish croft?

Chooksnroses · 12/07/2022 08:00

phishy · 11/07/2022 20:17

Not only would I not send a birthday present, I’d also stop sending presents to the grandkids.

I wouldn’t reward their bad behaviour.

The trouble is you're then punishing people who are not at fault.

sixtiesbaby88 · 11/07/2022 22:00

SummaLuvin · 11/07/2022 18:34

I'm surprised no-one has mentioned the daughter is potentially a victim of domestic abuse. Abusive partners wield control by isolating people for this loved ones and support network leading them 100% reliant on them. This is a wild suggestion, but might makes sense if OP is honest about it genuinely coming from nowhere and the fact she has now cut off from siblings.

This. Think of all the abuse victims who are isolated from their families - the classic red flag. My child was bullied into cutting contact with us by their spouse. Luckily over time our child found the strength to see it as is now getting divorced and is back in contact with us. It's not always the case that the parent is at fault and knows the reason but refuses to see it

Arenanewbie · 11/07/2022 20:39

I would make an effort and send her a nice card with nice words but only if you genuinely feel like it.
There are always a reason for going NC, it can be a result of misunderstanding or lack of knowledge about something but there are always a reason. I wouldn’t say that you were to blame but there was something to trigger this. A few people mentioned abusive relationship, I would do some digging to eliminate this. Tbh I would prefer that my daughter finally realised that as a mum I was far from perfect then that she’s in abusive relationship.
By the way I think the relationship often changes when children become parents themselves. Now when my Dd is a teen I can’t fathom certain parental approaches my parents used, before I thought it’s normal family life.

phishy · 11/07/2022 20:26

Fofftwenty21 · 11/07/2022 20:20

Maybe I missed something further up the thread but if she has asked you for no contact not sure why are you thinking of contacting her?

Whatever her reasons for doing this, ignoring her request and contacting her is unlikely to make anything better.

OP is probably thinking of it because the people who have gone no contact are asking for specific presents and accepting them.

Fofftwenty21 · 11/07/2022 20:20

Maybe I missed something further up the thread but if she has asked you for no contact not sure why are you thinking of contacting her?

Whatever her reasons for doing this, ignoring her request and contacting her is unlikely to make anything better.

phishy · 11/07/2022 20:17

Not only would I not send a birthday present, I’d also stop sending presents to the grandkids.

I wouldn’t reward their bad behaviour.

AMindNeedsBooks · 11/07/2022 20:13

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 11/07/2022 19:39

i wrote something like “'Hi, could you send me a photo of GC when you get a chance?'”
can’t remember the exact wording but not the latter.

If that's the case have you considered, as a PP said, that she may be in an abusive relationship and he's trying to cut her off from family? Do you know much about him?

Ponderingwindow · 11/07/2022 19:57

if she wasn’t still sending cards, I would say that you should respect the NC decision and do the same. Since she has kept a small window open, I would reciprocate. Don’t mention the estrangement in any communication. Keep it very simple. A generic card with a generic birthday wish. Nothing overly sentimental. The kind of thing you could give to a co-worker or maybe even your dentist if you are one of those card obsessed people who gives cards to dentists.

For the kids, I might even start just sending generic gifts for their age or if you trust that the parents won’t take the money, just start sending a gift card or money. One fun way to do it is to send the amount of their age for birthdays. It’s a small amount so It won’t be seen as overly extravagant or buying affection. Since the amount is set by something other than you, it doesn’t give your daughter any ammunition to complain about the specific amount.

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 11/07/2022 19:51

She is Ncwith us and her siblings was Nc with one set of grandparents and Lc / No with my siblings

OP posts:
Minimalme · 11/07/2022 19:51

Just leave her alone. She has made it clear she doesn't want a relationship with you.

And if you genuinely don't know what went wrong, then you either haven't been paying any attention or refusing to listen.

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 11/07/2022 19:49

“To be fair, when you get very few communications, you are going to pay attention to them and scrutinise them more than you usually would.

OP was also trying to paint an accurate picture for us - dd sent a birthday card but it was very curt etc”

this is what I was trying to do.

OP posts:
TooTiredToSleepRightNow · 11/07/2022 19:46

Mally100 · 11/07/2022 15:44

In all these types of threads, there's always the we don't know what we did wrong line, followed by snippets of underlying issues. I always maintain that a child will never go NC with a parent without good reason.

yes my mother is in complete denial and has no idea why I’m low contact with her, to normal people my childhood would be classed as abuse and neglect (even into adulthood) but my mother thinks I’m ungrateful. I have spelled it out a few times but the next day she just forgets so I’ve given up. I have my own kids, I’m so conscious of my behaviour. Both my parents think it’s me (and my sisters) that were the problem. Even to this day.

Janinebutcher79 · 11/07/2022 19:43

As someone who has HAD to go no contact with my mother at times for my own sanity I can’t help but wonder what your daughter would say happened.
have you tried understanding from her point why? I think until you try to you might find this continue

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 11/07/2022 19:41

“My child was always regarded as "the favourite " in my family. Actually not a favourite, but adored from the moment of birth.”

definitely this too particularly from my parents who she still is very much in contact with and visits .

OP posts:
2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 11/07/2022 19:39

i wrote something like “'Hi, could you send me a photo of GC when you get a chance?'”
can’t remember the exact wording but not the latter.

OP posts:
SummaLuvin · 11/07/2022 18:34

I'm surprised no-one has mentioned the daughter is potentially a victim of domestic abuse. Abusive partners wield control by isolating people for this loved ones and support network leading them 100% reliant on them. This is a wild suggestion, but might makes sense if OP is honest about it genuinely coming from nowhere and the fact she has now cut off from siblings.

Hadjab · 11/07/2022 18:09

Mally100 · 11/07/2022 15:44

In all these types of threads, there's always the we don't know what we did wrong line, followed by snippets of underlying issues. I always maintain that a child will never go NC with a parent without good reason.

Some people are self centred fuckers, and think the world revolves around them.

JammyC · 11/07/2022 17:54

Am on the other side of the fence with a looming birthday. Am interested to see how my own mother navigates this. It was her birthday a few weeks back and I too grappled with what to do. In the end I sent her a small but thoughtful gift (something I knew would be ‘her’ and a simple, non gushy card. More effort than a zero effort gift voucher but not a significant gift either so I didn’t go out of my way for it.

I am almost at the point of NC with her but not quite. Deep down I want to rebuild my relationship with her so that’s why I sent something to her. I will be very interested to see how she acknowledges my birthday. If, after my token, she doesn’t send anything at all or just a card with “gift when we see you next” I will be fuming.

so my question is how did she acknowledge the last gift giving for you? Birthday/Easter/Mothers Day? Whatever she sent to you I think you should equal that as a minimum. If you want to go a step further that then that’s your choice.

Chooksnroses · 11/07/2022 17:53

Mally100 · 11/07/2022 15:44

In all these types of threads, there's always the we don't know what we did wrong line, followed by snippets of underlying issues. I always maintain that a child will never go NC with a parent without good reason.

Not always. My child was always regarded as "the favourite " in my family. Actually not a favourite, but adored from the moment of birth. Lives a long way from me. Never visits, and replied to my last newsy email with "Fuck off". Has done this from time to time before and I have tried to make things right. This time I just saved the email and did not reply. However I will never be the bad one. I will send a card and money as usual. I never receive cards from them, and my husband tells me I should stop sending. They have also fallen out with their father from time to time, and their siblings. Just a very difficult person.... and still very much loved.

justfiveminutes · 11/07/2022 17:39

Mally100 · 11/07/2022 16:33

“You sound impossible to please. Picking apart every single communication, to the level of noting that she put "from" rather than "love from" in a card.”

And this is how you spot that there is much more going on. Op isn't being truthful and I'm sure the daughter has very good reason to be NC.

To be fair, when you get very few communications, you are going to pay attention to them and scrutinise them more than you usually would.

OP was also trying to paint an accurate picture for us - dd sent a birthday card but it was very curt etc

It is impossible for us to know whether this is warranted or not but mn usually takes posters at face value. For every neglectful or narcissistic parent (phrase overused on mn imo) there is a narcissistic young person who will never be happy with the way they are parented.

alphapie · 11/07/2022 17:16

I'd send a card in your shoes, but keep it light.

I agree with PP that children don't often go NC without good reason, but the level of 'good' is up to interpretation and children of all ages can sometimes see a situation from a very skewed perspective.

And I say this from experience, having gone Nc with my mother for a year and then seeing some pieces of the puzzle I hadn't considered before which did change my judgement.

Nanny0gg · 11/07/2022 17:15

Mally100 · 11/07/2022 15:44

In all these types of threads, there's always the we don't know what we did wrong line, followed by snippets of underlying issues. I always maintain that a child will never go NC with a parent without good reason.

Can't children be unpleasant people? Why assume it must be the parent?

xogossipgirlxo · 11/07/2022 17:11

2beesornot2beesthatisthehoney · 11/07/2022 17:00

For those who express surprise at us not knowing the reason. We truly don’t and of course have asked her several times. Reached out many times .
it may be the long standing thing that I think she has disliked/ hated her sister from birth ( 10 yeas older)

If you were telling her this and it had an impact on the way you treated her (I could bet on it), I must say I'm not surprised by NC policy. My mum is EXACTLY the same. She thinks she's done nothing wrong, she was good mother etc. and SHE THINKS it's something long standing, but she can't be sure (how can she know if she was such a perfect mother).