Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being a duel citizen...

112 replies

Truestar8 · 11/07/2022 13:36

Is being a dual citizen a position or a negative. For example, holding a British passport and a American passport? I'm thinking being a dual citizen would give more opportunities and choices in life.

What are your thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hoppinggreen · 12/07/2022 13:01

Excellent @BlackLambAndGreyFalcon
fingers crossed I get the same treatment

BlackLambAndGreyFalcon · 12/07/2022 12:55

Hoppinggreen · 11/07/2022 19:44

That’s interesting
We are off to Germany soon and I am hoping to get waved through both entering and leaving by hanging onto my German passported family

It was actually in Germany and my DD and DH are German!

mjf981 · 12/07/2022 12:38

I have 3 citizenships. The only PITA part is having to renew passports regularly and the expense that goes along with it.

bellabasset · 12/07/2022 12:12

My df was born in Leitrim so I'm an Irish citizen by birth and were I younger and travelling I would certainly get an Irish passport.

Skydaze · 12/07/2022 12:02

Dual US/NZ here (birth/naturalisation) and in queue to dump US citizenship due to crazy tax laws, unnecessary and punitive reporting to US, unreasonable search & seizure of our financial and personal information through FATCA, crap protection of said personal data, being treated like a criminal due to residing outside the US, and banking / financial investment restrictions and invasive control that mainland Americans would be in an uproar about if they were subject to these laws. I could see that dual citizenship would be nice for countries that are actually reasonable about it - the US is not, so only worth it if you plan to live there, have close family there or want to travel extensively. Just educate yourself about the pitfalls first so you know what you're getting into. You have to buy your way out if you end up not liking it.

TooBigForMyBoots · 12/07/2022 11:41

It's not cheap or easy to get to the ECHR. It's particularly difficult if you are stateless, homeless, skint and unable to work. You're going to find it hard to get somewhere to sleep, nevermind a team of International Human Rights Lawyers around you.

SerendipityJane · 12/07/2022 07:51

This policy is against international law though.

I believe the UK has signalled that international laws are for other countries these days

I think if the affected people were able to get before the European Court of Human Rights the UK Government would be found in breach of its international human rights obligations.

To which the UK response would be "So what ?"

Hoppinggreen · 12/07/2022 07:43

FinallyHere · 12/07/2022 07:24

First thing I did after hearing the results of the Brexit referendum was to finally apply for an Irish passport.

Demand for Irish passports shot up as lots of people did likewise.

Having joint UK/EU passports makes up for some of the losses caused by Brexit.

DH applied for his EU passport before Brexit just in case. It was actually the lady at the consulate who suggested we apply for the DC as we had no idea they would be eligible

JustSmallFry · 12/07/2022 07:29

JennieTheZebra · 11/07/2022 13:54

Generally I’m glad of mine and I would never ever give it up, but right now it’s a bit of a pain. I’m dual German/British, and as my other citizenship is EU, I, up until recently (thank you Brexit!) obviously automatically had the right to live here and, due to this, I’ve only ever held a German passport, even though I’ve lived in the UK since I was 10; there was never really any need to apply for a British passport so I didn’t. Now, my German passport no longer counts for anything. I can’t prove right of residency, right to work, anything. I recently started a new job and getting that paperwork proved was a nightmare. I even got declined from student finance as I can’t prove legal residency-I’ve lived here 32 years! Everyone says to apply for a EU residency number but as I’m British I can’t. I’m now hurriedly applying for a British passport so I’ve got sucked into that quagmire…
So, yeah, most of the time dual citizenship is a good thing, but not always.

To be fair that’s a problem that’s related to the UK way of doing things, not to dual citizenship

Bubblebubblebah · 12/07/2022 07:28

Penfelyn · 12/07/2022 03:09

It always annoys me when people gain citizenship (usually because their great something was from that country) just for the passport. More often than not they know NOTHING about the culture, don't even speak the language, and most definitely won't pay any taxes. They're basically fake citizens.

Obviously not including people who actually care about their roots and actually bother to learn the language and culture, but those are a tiny minority.

This is one reason I never want another citizenship, I'm happy with mine, I like our culture and our language (though I also speak other languages), and I'd feel like such a fraud if I had a passport from another country.

Do you mean just those eligible by heritage? Because... Hella lot of people can't gain citizenship like that. They actually have to reside in the place and pass tests etc

FinallyHere · 12/07/2022 07:24

First thing I did after hearing the results of the Brexit referendum was to finally apply for an Irish passport.

Demand for Irish passports shot up as lots of people did likewise.

Having joint UK/EU passports makes up for some of the losses caused by Brexit.

Brimborium · 12/07/2022 06:53

Sorry my previous post was a reply to the pp who said they would feel like a fraud/fake citizen

Brimborium · 12/07/2022 06:52

Don’t understand this either. I’ve lived in an EU country for twelve years. When Brexit happened, if I hadn’t applied for EU citizenship through my grandmother (of a country I’ve been to once and don’t speak the language) I would have had to apply for a visa and jump through all the other hoops that my British friends who live here are now having to do. The stress and hassle it has caused for them is huge. Why would I knowingly deny myself the opportunity and what difference does it make to anyone else? Nationality (unless you naturalise) is an accident of birth. I didnt choose to be British and I certainly didn’t vote for Brexit. I will fulfil the obligations of both my citizenships - so if there were obligations to pay tax, I would do it, although I don’t think many countries do this other than USA, plus I obviously pay tax in the country I live in (which I am not a citizen of). I am happy my children will be able to take advantage of the opportunities I had to live and work anywhere in the EU really easily and feel sad for those who don’t have this option anymore.

TheBikiniExpert · 12/07/2022 06:02

I recently gained dual citizenship of Italy/UK. Took 4 years but so far it's been only positive.

nicemarmot · 12/07/2022 05:58

ISAs and some other investments that are normal in the UK are not great if you’re a dual us citizen. There is a very long waiting list at the moment to relinquish US citizenship.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 12/07/2022 05:55

Penfelyn · 12/07/2022 03:09

It always annoys me when people gain citizenship (usually because their great something was from that country) just for the passport. More often than not they know NOTHING about the culture, don't even speak the language, and most definitely won't pay any taxes. They're basically fake citizens.

Obviously not including people who actually care about their roots and actually bother to learn the language and culture, but those are a tiny minority.

This is one reason I never want another citizenship, I'm happy with mine, I like our culture and our language (though I also speak other languages), and I'd feel like such a fraud if I had a passport from another country.

I don't get this at all! Why would it concern you, let alone annoy you? Lots of people like this applying for Irish passports at the minute, to hang on to FOM. I say good luck to them! If you are keen enough to jump through the hoops to prove eligibility, good luck to you, it's no skin off my nose. I had to jump through a few hoops myself to get my Aussie citizenship (and spend a lot of cash!), and every Aussie I know was delighted for me when I got it. There are of course always a contingent of 'Fuck off we're full types', but I'm not friends with people like that.

WendellGeez · 12/07/2022 05:08

I found out I might be eligible for Italian (EU) citizenship and was so excited. Unfortunately as my Italian grandfather died before I was born I didn't qualify.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 12/07/2022 04:58

I could claim UK and Irish passports from birth, which is one of the few advantages of being from NI. I've held both at various times. My husband was born in Oz, although he also has an Irish passport, so I now also have an Aussie passport too I'd sell off the UK one if I could, after Brexit it's of no use to me. My son has triple citizenship too, which will be handy for him if he wants to work abroad.

Penfelyn · 12/07/2022 03:09

It always annoys me when people gain citizenship (usually because their great something was from that country) just for the passport. More often than not they know NOTHING about the culture, don't even speak the language, and most definitely won't pay any taxes. They're basically fake citizens.

Obviously not including people who actually care about their roots and actually bother to learn the language and culture, but those are a tiny minority.

This is one reason I never want another citizenship, I'm happy with mine, I like our culture and our language (though I also speak other languages), and I'd feel like such a fraud if I had a passport from another country.

BritWifeInUSA · 12/07/2022 03:04

Coffeaddict · 11/07/2022 16:19

Depends on the country. I have Irish and UK citizenship which is handy as I have eu membership.
I m entitled to USA citizenship but have never claimed it as previously mentioned you will be liable to pay a tax to a country that you don't ( and possibly have never) reside in.

You don’t “claim” US citizenship. Per US law, if you are a citizen at birth or become a citizen through the Naturalisation of your parent, then you are a US citizen automatically, whether you want to be or not. There’s no claiming involved. The only way to not be is to officially renounce. There’s no such thing as being “entitled” to US citizenship and not being a citizen. If you meet the requirements, you are a US citizen, it’s not optional.

You can be eligible for US citizenship but choose not to apply for it and just remain a GC holder for life (you have to be GC holder for a set period of time before you can naturalize).

BritWifeInUSA · 12/07/2022 02:55

I have UK (through birth) and US citizenship (through Naturalisation). I also have Irish citizenship through my father but I’ve never applied for an Irish passport as I’ve never needed to. I don’t even consider that I’m an Irish citizen but that’s more because of how I don’t want any connection to my father.

I have no intention of leaving the US or owning property or bank accounts overseas do the tax issue doesn’t concern me. The threshold is reasonably high when MFJ anyway.

I don’t see any advantages or disadvantages.

Bubblebubblebah · 12/07/2022 00:16

Citizenship in UK needs to come down on price. Talk about shrinkflation of a product😂
I believe it is the most expensive one in Europe? Even without the access to EU....

RustyShackleford3 · 12/07/2022 00:03

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 11/07/2022 15:01

I think you should only be allowed to have one nationality / passport, but this is mainly because I can't automatically have multiple ones so it's not fair! Sad

Why can't you?

I got mine and my children's second passport by becoming employable in the country I wanted to move to (all you have to do is look on their immigration website to see what jobs they will give out work visas for), saving loads of money and working really hard, being an involved member of the community I moved to, and then jumping through a shit load of expensive hoops in order to get in.

It was hard work but it was very worth it. Not everyone who has a second passport got handed one just because a parent or spouse helped them get a leg up. There are plenty of immigrants in this world who got passports with hard work and determination.

MrsHughesPinny · 11/07/2022 23:55

If you mean specifically the US, it can get very costly because you have to file taxes in the US even if you are living/working in another country. I chose not to take US citizenship because I don’t plan on living here forever.

Iflyaway · 11/07/2022 23:10

I have to abide by all of that country's laws which until fairly recently included national service.

The world over you have to abide by "all of that country's laws". Whether a citizen or visitor.

Yep. NL still has national service. You just get an official letter at age 18. Men and women. there would be a riot on if they implemented it

Swipe left for the next trending thread