Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found out devastating news about house we are about to buy, Should we pull out?

444 replies

Welikethemoon · 11/07/2022 11:53

We were all set to move, got everything in place, went for second viewing to show our daughters thier new house for the first time. Owner was there so I asked her about the flood risk which has come up as surprisingly high on the survey. She looked shocked and said she thought we knew it had been flooded twice in last 10 years but flash flood rain water run off and also before she moved in. She had instructed estate agent to tell everyone who viewed. We have had the offer accepted since April, estate agents just told me, sorry they "forgot" to tell us. Now don't know what to do. Thus was supposed to be our "forever" home, that had everything we needed. I have a very specific list of things I wanted and this ticks all the boxes, there us nothing else currently on the market that comes close. It's a significantly bigger mortgage than current place. I don't want to move again after this. Seller has said she has put in extra drainage since the last flood, but it hasn't been tested in similar conditions since so no guarantee it would work. Plus with climate change its more likely to happen.
Husband still wants to move, I'm not so sure. What would you do? AIBU to pull out now, risk losing our buyers and wait for a better house to come on the market?

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 11/07/2022 19:07

ThreeLittleDots · 11/07/2022 18:20

Did the mortgage company do a desktop survey or an actual visit? I doubt the mortgage company are aware of the previous claims. Ring them and find out.

Good point - a lot of people assume that a physical survey will be carried out if a mortgage is required. It’s not. Our last buyer needed a mortgage and we expected to be contacted about a surveyor. It was done online.

Rosscameasdoody · 11/07/2022 19:04

Welikethemoon · 11/07/2022 17:23

We haven't had this form yet, we will be sure to look out for it, thank you

The offer was in and accepted in April, it’s now July, and you should have had the TA6 by now - it’s usually one of the first things you receive. I noticed upthread that you said you hadn’t had much experience as a house buyer, so a piece of advice. Keep on at your solicitor - upthread somewhere a poster has provided a link to a timeline for what should be happening and when - take note and start nagging.

Suzannetakesyoudown1 · 11/07/2022 19:00

@GemmaEdKitten the solicitor won’t know unless OP sent them a copy of the survey, I expect they will flag it up when the searches come back.

ZooMount · 11/07/2022 18:56

Absolutely no way

Comefromaway · 11/07/2022 18:50

The OP only got the survey last week. She didn’t sit in the info she asked the seller about it. What should have happened us the solicitor should have flagged it up.

My solicitor flagged up a mineshaft in next door but ones garden which necessitated an extra report.

GemmaEdKitten · 11/07/2022 18:40

Welikethemoon · 11/07/2022 11:53

We were all set to move, got everything in place, went for second viewing to show our daughters thier new house for the first time. Owner was there so I asked her about the flood risk which has come up as surprisingly high on the survey. She looked shocked and said she thought we knew it had been flooded twice in last 10 years but flash flood rain water run off and also before she moved in. She had instructed estate agent to tell everyone who viewed. We have had the offer accepted since April, estate agents just told me, sorry they "forgot" to tell us. Now don't know what to do. Thus was supposed to be our "forever" home, that had everything we needed. I have a very specific list of things I wanted and this ticks all the boxes, there us nothing else currently on the market that comes close. It's a significantly bigger mortgage than current place. I don't want to move again after this. Seller has said she has put in extra drainage since the last flood, but it hasn't been tested in similar conditions since so no guarantee it would work. Plus with climate change its more likely to happen.
Husband still wants to move, I'm not so sure. What would you do? AIBU to pull out now, risk losing our buyers and wait for a better house to come on the market?

This would come up in surveys, anyway. It's annoying but not devastating. Part and parcel of house buying.
You're lucky to find out relatively early. Don't buy it. I feel sorry for the person trying to sell.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 11/07/2022 18:39

Comefromaway · 11/07/2022 18:33

Unless things have changed in two years the form is not completed before putting it onto the market. The buyers solicitor sent us the form via our solicitor at around the time that searches were made. It had to be returned, completed before exchange.

I have had the same experience as @Comefromaway When we sold my Dear Mum's cottage after her death, we were sent that form to fill in after we had accepted an offer for her house.

Comefromaway · 11/07/2022 18:33

Bertieboo82 · 11/07/2022 16:13

The form is completed before putting it on the market. To the agent.

so if not been provided by agent, then there is an issue

but if has been - it was on the OP

and given she saw “high flood risk” on the survey and essentially just shrugged her shoulders, I suspect it slipped through the net

Unless things have changed in two years the form is not completed before putting it onto the market. The buyers solicitor sent us the form via our solicitor at around the time that searches were made. It had to be returned, completed before exchange.

Suzannetakesyoudown1 · 11/07/2022 18:33

I would think when the searches come back they will reveal the flood risk and the solicitor will be obliged to inform the lender. You will probably find your offer is withdrawn or put on hold pending further investigation. This happened to us when purchasing and we were not borrowing much either (a lower deposit/amount of equity increases your risk to the lender so they will be more thorough). You will probably have the decision made for you.

SeasonFinale · 11/07/2022 18:27

£300 sounds rather low. Was that just buildings insurance or buildings and contents

TheLadyofShalott1 · 11/07/2022 18:23

NoSquirrels · 11/07/2022 12:05

Wasn’t it listed on the sellers information form? Our property suffers flash floods from rainwater run-off and that was listed on the seller’s form. The house itself has never suffer water ingress but the garden does flood. It’s happened once to us in 5+ years, and there have been multiple flooding events nearby in that time. Our house has never flooded, just the garden. We’ve no issues with insurance.

So it depends on how severe the flooding might be, in my opinion. I’m not anxious about our house at all. I’d buy it again.

@NoSquirrels you said that you have had no issues with insurance, but then you haven't had to ask them to pay out any insurance on your actual house? If you had, and you knew about the risk of flooding when you bought the house but hadn't told them, then they could legitimately refuse to pay out at all. If you had told them about any known risks, ie your garden in this instance, they might well have increased your premiums to a very high level.

@Welikethemoon is it possible for you to ask any home insurance providers about how much they would be likely to ask for in premiums, for a house similar in age and build to your potential one, and one that has also had the same amount of flooding as the one you are contemplating?

Also, do you know of any land engineers (sorry, I don't know the correct terminology you this, I don't think it would just come under arquitect, as I think it would have to be a more in depth - no pun intended - study) who could advise you on what, if anything, you could do to stop, or at least drastically reduce any future flooding of the property?

I think the answer to both of those questions could well show you and your 'reluctant to pull out of this sale' DP, that there is no sensible choice, you will need to forgo this house. I think that this is probably why the seller instructed her Estate Agent to tell any potential purchases up front about this problem, as she did not want this to happen at this later stage. She has probably, and presumably, already spent money on her next purchase (unless it is the sale of a deseased person's property).

Good luck OP, I hope that there is a not too expensive way around this problem, and that you do get to buy your - in every other way -very suitable house. 🤞💐

Itisasecret · 11/07/2022 18:22

Welikethemoon · 11/07/2022 18:17

Yes we do, mortgage application is complete and we have an offer

I would be expect them to pull it when they get the solicitors report.

ThreeLittleDots · 11/07/2022 18:21

Any mortgage offer is subject to appropriate insurance in place by the date of exchange, though.

ThreeLittleDots · 11/07/2022 18:20

Did the mortgage company do a desktop survey or an actual visit? I doubt the mortgage company are aware of the previous claims. Ring them and find out.

Welikethemoon · 11/07/2022 18:17

Abitofalark · 11/07/2022 17:55

Having just read your opening post again, you don't actually have a mortgage offer do you? The information that has come to light must surely affect how much a mortgage company would value it at and therefore how much it would lend.

In any case, the new information should also affect how much you would pay for it, resulting in a revised offer downwards by a substantial percentage, even if your husband was mad enough you were to proceed.

Yes we do, mortgage application is complete and we have an offer

OP posts:
IseeScottishhills · 11/07/2022 18:13

I'm quite knowledgable on houses and flooding (having been severely flooded x3 in 4 years) yes you can get house insurance its under written by the government but you have to prove that there has been a house on that site for a period of time which off the top of my head I cant remember, so for example if the house is only a few years old and there had not been a house on that site before you want get insurance. What you will struggle to do is raise a mortgage most lenders wont let you because there is a risk of the house either being very damaged and thus not liveable in for a prolonged period whilst its under going repairs or even worse it may not be repairable thus worth nothing.
Despite being flooded three times in a moment of madness we nearly bought a stunning house in am amazing location, although it hadn't actually ever flooded it was in a high risk area for flooding, on the blurb produced by the estate agent it actually stated cash buyer only because of the flood risk luckily we were out bid for it!! The house we bought instead definitely wont flood.

NiceTwin · 11/07/2022 18:03

No, don't but it!!

My nan's house flooded many, many years ago when I was a young child.
Years later I can recall the stench of the water and the thick sludge left behind when the water subsided. Grim.

Abitofalark · 11/07/2022 17:55

Having just read your opening post again, you don't actually have a mortgage offer do you? The information that has come to light must surely affect how much a mortgage company would value it at and therefore how much it would lend.

In any case, the new information should also affect how much you would pay for it, resulting in a revised offer downwards by a substantial percentage, even if your husband was mad enough you were to proceed.

Rosscameasdoody · 11/07/2022 17:53

NumberTheory · 11/07/2022 17:38

Estate agents are legally obliged to disclose any material information that they are aware of. Material information includes anything that might affect a buyers willingness to buy or the price they might be willing to pay, so flooding history would be included.

The TA6 form, however, is not a legal requirement.

TA6 is standard though, and a refusal to complete it would be a red flag to a conveyancing solicitor. A buyer also has redress if a seller completes a TA6 question dishonestly - knew that from a house sale a couple of years ago, but admit I googled whether the EA was responsible for disclosure and the answer came back as not unless the flooding was recent - wasn’t specific about what recent meant.

CornishTiger · 11/07/2022 17:52

Don’t suppose the house is in Cornwall?

amitoooldforthisshit · 11/07/2022 17:49

turn on your heels and walk away!!!!!!! flood insurance is an absolute nightmare and that's if your lucky enough to get it.

SaintHelena · 11/07/2022 17:42

This might be why your offer has been accepted.
I would think it would be possible to make a low offer.
If it is run off water it would possibly be up to the farmer or whoever owns the land to make changes and they won't do that if it's not troubling them.

Amei · 11/07/2022 17:41

Hey OP,

I previously owned a house that flooded. It was from an issue with next door who didn't fix their flooded cellar and eventually it all came through our kitchen wall.

Anyway, even though this wasn't from anything to do with the weather and was never going to happen again, it made it IMPOSSIBLE to sell. Three buyers pulled out, it took from 2017-2021 for it to actually sell and we lost 20% of what we paid for so all I can advise is that if you choose to sell in the future it might be difficult.

Good luck in whatever you choose xx

Rosscameasdoody · 11/07/2022 17:39

NumberTheory · 11/07/2022 17:17

I think you need to at least put the breaks on and investigate.

From what you've said about previous floods, it sounds as though you aren't in a floodplain but the drainage and sewerage systems in that area have been insufficient and poorly designed so that the house ends up with the "overflow" (maybe because the house is lower down than almost everyone else in the area?). So there may be ways to change things so it isn't at risk of flooding but those changes may also be out of your hands because they're up to other landowners and the utility companies.

So if you really love this house, see if you can get an expert in to assess whether the risk mitigation that's been put in place is sufficient (seems unlikely to me but, like everyone else here, I'm just a voice on the Internet) and if there are other things that can be done or a policy that could be bought to protect you. Then renegotiate the price.

I suspect your seller will be furious with the estate agent, we had similar when selling where the estate agent hadn't told potential buyers about a lack of sign off on a conversion that almost squashed our sale and wrecked our onward plans. Fortunately the buyer was in a position to go ahead if we took a small price hit (which was very reasonable). Hopefully your sellers will be equally open to negotiation if you can find a way to square the risks.

I don’t understand that. Checking on the sign off on a conversion is the solicitors’ job not the estate agents. You shouldn’t have had to take even a small hit on the price, because in the event of the sign off not being obtained, the solicitor would have covered it with an insurance policy. We had exactly the same with a garage conversion on the property we sold and it was highlighted in the conveyancing.

ThreeLittleDots · 11/07/2022 17:39

OP, here's a guide as to what your solicitor should have been doing: -

www.conveyancing-cms.co.uk/conveyancing-guide/