Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found out devastating news about house we are about to buy, Should we pull out?

444 replies

Welikethemoon · 11/07/2022 11:53

We were all set to move, got everything in place, went for second viewing to show our daughters thier new house for the first time. Owner was there so I asked her about the flood risk which has come up as surprisingly high on the survey. She looked shocked and said she thought we knew it had been flooded twice in last 10 years but flash flood rain water run off and also before she moved in. She had instructed estate agent to tell everyone who viewed. We have had the offer accepted since April, estate agents just told me, sorry they "forgot" to tell us. Now don't know what to do. Thus was supposed to be our "forever" home, that had everything we needed. I have a very specific list of things I wanted and this ticks all the boxes, there us nothing else currently on the market that comes close. It's a significantly bigger mortgage than current place. I don't want to move again after this. Seller has said she has put in extra drainage since the last flood, but it hasn't been tested in similar conditions since so no guarantee it would work. Plus with climate change its more likely to happen.
Husband still wants to move, I'm not so sure. What would you do? AIBU to pull out now, risk losing our buyers and wait for a better house to come on the market?

OP posts:
Gremlinsateit · 11/07/2022 14:25

@MaitlandGirl yes Gillieston Heights of course! I was shocked to see the new estate stretching down towards the flood plains. The flooding over the road at Testers Hollow was a standing joke when I was a kid.

woolwinder · 11/07/2022 14:24

Pull out. Do not proceed.

Muminabun · 11/07/2022 14:24

Go ahead and buy and enjoy your dream home. It has only flooded twice in ten years. Get details of what the current buyer has done in terms of drainage and insurance. Then engage a drainage consultant and find out how to flood proof. Deduct this cost from your final offer. You then know that you have done all you can and that the house is sellable. If it was a stepping stone house then no but if it is a dream home and the problem can be rectified then go for it and make sure you get it at a cheaper price.

Ski4130 · 11/07/2022 14:22

Could you get an engineer to do a specific FRA taking into account the new drainage that’s been installed? I work in this industry (civil engineering) though not as an engineer, and the general consensus when there’s a high risk of flooding shown on a flood risk assessment is that they wouldn’t touch the property with a barge pole.

it may never flood again, it may flood every time there’s high rainfall, I’m not sure I could relax knowing I’d have to move everything upstairs every time there’s heavy rain.

WellTidy · 11/07/2022 14:21

Even if you can get yourself comfortable on this, I think you will struggle to sell when the time comes.

Our previous house had a tiny, tiny stream beyond the end of the garden. It meant that the house was on a flood plain. We could get insurance, albeit not a huge choice of insurers, but we could get it. The area hadn’t flooded for decades. It really wasn’t an issue.

But when we came to sell, three buyers pulled out after we’d accepted their offers because they were nervous about the potential for flooding. And that was for an area that hadn’t flooded for decades and was really unlikely to. And this is a house in an area which is really really desirable due to location and amenities.

RedCardigan · 11/07/2022 14:21

We are in a similar place to another poster that we had bad flooding caused by a frame, they dug a drainage ditch and problem solved completely, but will still show a having flooded If anyone searched for the next 10 years.

MaitlandGirl · 11/07/2022 14:21

@Gremlinsateit Gillieston Heights by any chance? That’s totally cut off!! The highway is flooded from Bunnings to the Melbourne St traffic lights, up around the Showground is flooded and further out in Singleton and Broke it’s decimated.

OP - there will be another house. One that you can enjoy and not live in fear of having police banging on your door in the middle of the night telling you to evacuate. It’s just not worth it.

coodawoodashooda · 11/07/2022 14:20

You must be very disappointed. Especially as you were going to show your kids. Imagine it was a computer. You wouldn't want one that worked even although something had been split on it. This is such a bigger and more expensive problem than that.

RedCardigan · 11/07/2022 14:20

Was it the garden that flooded, or the garage or the actual house? How long for and how deep? What has she done since then in details so she thinks it’ll be ok? I’d take legal action against the estate agent for any costs if you pull out for not telling you when requested.

Glittertwins · 11/07/2022 14:19

Pull out. Similar thing happened to my brother. They were arranging insurance (no mortgage) and discovered that the property was uninsurable. Neighbouring houses all okay. They pulled out of that and have stayed in their original house.

antelopevalley · 11/07/2022 14:18

GetThatHelmetOn · 11/07/2022 14:16

I don’t know in your area but in mine, the map of areas likely to flood has increased considerably over the last 15 years. A lot if riverside properties that before attracted very high prices have become quite affordable in the last 5 years. There’s a reason for that.

I have been amazed at some of the riverside properties built which are obviously at risk of flooding.

Cyclebabble · 11/07/2022 14:16

Hi OP, I am insurer by trade. On the flood risk it is worth getting some quotes to see what this would be like. Given there is an industry scheme to mitigate very high premiums this might not be quite so bad as you are thinking. I would also ask what remedial work had been undertaken locally to prevent a reoccurrence or to mitigate flood risk. All of this being considered I would be very cautious. Flooding claims are very expensive and usually disruptive. 30cm of flood water can devastate a building- all electrical appliances gone, soft furnishings gone and drying out the building can take months.

This is a material omission from the vendor's estate agents. In the first instance I would note a formal complaint to them and their trade body and I might also take some time to visit a solicitor and consider further legal options.

Personally, I do not believe that n Estate Agent forgets to tell a customer about a flood risk on an otherwise perfect property.

for future reference, you can get some information on flooding risk on the Environment Agency's website.

Gremlinsateit · 11/07/2022 14:16

Gremlinsateit · 11/07/2022 14:15

Oh yes, it looks awful. Last time I was in the area, I was concerned to a lot of new housing built in an area that was always flood-prone when I was a kid. You would have thought they had learnt after ‘55.

To see - and that was to @MaitlandGirl

GetThatHelmetOn · 11/07/2022 14:16

I don’t know in your area but in mine, the map of areas likely to flood has increased considerably over the last 15 years. A lot if riverside properties that before attracted very high prices have become quite affordable in the last 5 years. There’s a reason for that.

Gremlinsateit · 11/07/2022 14:15

Oh yes, it looks awful. Last time I was in the area, I was concerned to a lot of new housing built in an area that was always flood-prone when I was a kid. You would have thought they had learnt after ‘55.

KittyEmK · 11/07/2022 14:15

Could you get an engineer to do a calculation for you, based on newly installed drainage?

kaleidoscope123 · 11/07/2022 14:15

Where I live any of the houses effected by flooding are reduced by at least 50%. Even then you need expensive home insurance and it’ll be a struggle to sell. My main search criteria was anywhere effected by flooding we don’t touch.

Even ‘surface’ water is contaminated, it’s a huge job to clean up a house effected by flood damage. Nevermind your electrics etc. there’s some houses that have stone floors and walls at ground floor with electrics high up but I still wouldn’t touch them. Moving all furniture and belongings from gf to first floor at a flood warning is not a way to live.

Justkidding55 · 11/07/2022 14:14

Worth also considering according to the environment agency “high risk” is defined as being around 3.3 percent chance a year. So 97 plus percent chance no flood. I looked up a random local road near me and it was surprisingly in the high risk of surface water flooding. It’s never had any issues at all and I’ve been here 9 years. The houses are gorgeous and it’s a very popular road so I was suprised.

MaitlandGirl · 11/07/2022 14:12

@Gremlinsateit just up the road - this is what we’re dealing with.

Found out devastating news about house we are about to buy, Should we pull out?
crosstalk · 11/07/2022 14:11

Climate change or not, it can also be housebuilding removing areas of land drainage, people concreting over front and back gardens .... roads built across natural drainage areas, farmers not having the manpower to clear gullies or ditches, the EA and Highways agencies not clearing culverts.

HappyGa · 11/07/2022 14:09

No, twice in 10 years is a LOT and it will get worse z you’ll struggle to get insurance and are you sure the previous flooding has caused underlying problems??

VickyEadieofThigh · 11/07/2022 14:08

Overanxiousmummy · 11/07/2022 12:56

Personally I wouldn't risk it, but if you decided to go ahead you should definitely check insurance availability and cost and you should think about a lower purchase price. Imagine you had found out at the start would you have offered, if not then pull out, it's the agents fault

This is the burning question. I suspect you wouldn't have offered at all if you'd known up front but if you are thinking of proceeding, you need to drop the offer, in my opinion.

I wouldn't buy a house that has been subject to flooding and the risk is still there.

Pumasonsatsumas · 11/07/2022 14:07

You need more information - was the property damaged, how badly, what measures have been put in place and ideally get a professional to give a view on whether they will be effective. Then armed with your information you argue for a discount, if you decide to proceed at all. It's not necessarily a deal-breaker

3luckystars · 11/07/2022 14:07

Pull out. That was a lucky encounter!!

TheNoodlesIncident · 11/07/2022 14:04

@Welikethemoon You're not that far along at all. I thought you had exchanged contracts by what you implied, but you've only just started really. Your mortgage company may not be willing to lend you the asking price on a house that has a history of flooding. The sale price should have reflected that, it's surprising that it doesn't considering it will come to light! You will probably struggle to get insurance cover - which is a part of the contract with the mortgage company - that will cover the buildings against the flood risk (and I'd expect a huge excess to apply). These are two huge issues.

I'm surprised that the vendor hasn't had her own reports regarding the flood prevention measures taken. I'm sure I would if I were in her position. In the forms which are part of the contract between the vendor and the buyer, the question "Has the property ever flooded?" is directly asked, so you would have found out about then if not before.

In your position, I would pull out before I spent any more. Your buyers may wait for you to find another property or you could try to move into rented in the meantime (not that that's easy) in order to keep the process going. The vendor would have to reduce the price substantially before I would reconsider tbh, and even then it's still a huge risk and every time it rained hard...