Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend didn't ask me to be godmother ....

107 replies

ashelyf · 11/07/2022 09:40

Hiya hope everyone is enjoying the sunshine.
I'm trying my best not to be hurt /upset about this but here goes.
My closest friend of 20 years has a son,who is 4 years old.
My friend is Spanish but has lived in this country longer than she's lived in Spain but her family only really speak Spanish.
She doesn't have a big circle of friends just me and this other lady (who is also Spanish and is friends through work with my friends partner)
We chat most days and she rings me when she wants a rant etc
Yesterday her other friend posted a pic on Facebook of my friends son sat with balloons holding a card asking her to be godmother.
Bare in mind a month ago my friend whilst chatting told me she hadn't seen this friend in a year and she couldn't be bothered with her as she wasn't chatting much and short replies.

Now the other sucker punch ..she hasn't even invited me to the christening.
She has spoke about it to me,never told me a date and just said we are keeping it small with only 16 guests.

I take interest in her son,always ask her to go to the farm /circus together but she always says he will be bored as I have no kids yet.
I buy him birthday /Xmas presents -thoughtful things he will like
Randomly get him pjs or whatever I see
Easter eggs etc
So it's not like I show no interest.

So how can she pick this other girl over me when just the other month she was saying she didn't have time for her etc
I'm honestly so hurt -aibu?

I'm not going to mention it to her because obviously it's her choice and maybe her partner feels more comfortable as her other friend speaks Spanish etc and his English isn't great.

OP posts:
Collaborate · 11/07/2022 12:47

DenholmElliot1 · 11/07/2022 09:46

If they're catholics they'll be needing catholic godparents. Non-catholics wouldn't necessarily be aware of this.

I am an athiest CofE who is a godfather to my Catholic nephew.

Anothernamechangeplease · 11/07/2022 12:43

Can't you have more than one godmother? I thought some people have two. Perhaps she's still planning to ask?

Aprilx · 11/07/2022 12:34

My automatic assumption is that she chose the other friend as godparent as she is also Spanish and they are having a family and godparents only event. Nothing else to this.

knockyknees · 11/07/2022 12:17

My sister didn’t have me as a godparent but she did have two of our other siblings. I had always thought me and her were much closer. One loves further away and there’s a big age gap with the other. I was hurt, so I asked her, and she said she was confident I’d always be a massive part of her children’s lives but she wanted to ensure the other two were too

What dumb "logic" your sister has/had. That's like teachers who reward the naughty kids in a class and ignore the well behaved ones. What a shitty and not very intelligent thing to do.

CPL593H · 11/07/2022 12:10

GreatStuff67 · 11/07/2022 11:14

Hi OP. I'm Scottish, DH is Spanish. We live in Scotland. From my point of view I'm thinking it's almost certainly because the other friend is Spanish. We raised our DC bilingual. It's hard work when, living here, they're mostly surrounded by the English language, so we did all we could to have more Spanish speaking people in their lives.

Also, even with the language aside, it was important to us both that they had a stronger connection to the Spanish culture. Even just things like the main day at Christmas is actually in January, growing up knowing Spanish songs, food etc.

Also, my experience of Spanish Catholicism is it's very... strict? That's not the right word. Taken seriously? So even if your friend only wants DC christened so they can go to a Catholic school I wouldn't be surprised if her husband and his family wanted to this the 'proper' way, which is family and godparents only (at least, from the Spanish christenings I know about). Of course this can depend on the family but as a PP said they tend to not be as everyone come/big party as here.

And, your friend's DH knows the Spanish friend too. He'd probably want to pick people he knows.

I get why you're upset about not being picked, but my guess is there's more to it than just your friend overlooked you. I wouldn't be cutting her off or anything like that over it.

I really think @GreatStuff67 is on the mark with possible reasons.

JellyBellyNelly · 11/07/2022 11:41

Mally100 · 11/07/2022 10:23

Well that was a really shitty way to brush you off. It doesn't even make sense. She gave the lesser interested siblings an important role and how would that benefit her child? And to not even discuss this with you but just do it?

I agree. It’s a very strange way of thinking but if the poster is ok with it then that’s all that matters.

Blowthemandown · 11/07/2022 11:39

@ashelyf is it to do with the more serious aspect of ‘who will parent if the parent can no longer do so’? Maybe she doesn’t want to put that potential burden on you. Does the other person have kids already?

DogInATent · 11/07/2022 11:35

My friend is Spanish but has lived in this country longer than she's lived in Spain but her family only really speak Spanish.
Are you implying she's not Spanish enough to have a culturally Spanish christening service? I'm guessing you don't speak Spanish, and the invited comadre's Spanish-Catholic background may be important to your friend and her family for this role.

So how can she pick this other girl over me when just the other month she was saying she didn't have time for her etc
I'm honestly so hurt -aibu?
Are you sure you're mature enough to be a godparent?

perimenofertility · 11/07/2022 11:34

She's not into the friendship as much as you are. Buying random presents like "pyjamas when you see them" is over the top - don't do that. You're inviting her out places and she's turning you down. She hasn't invited you to the christening. It's hurtful but it sounds like this isn't the close friendship you imagine it to be.

VickyEadieofThigh · 11/07/2022 11:23

toomuchlaundry · 11/07/2022 10:27

How many people’s godparents do anything apart from send presents for birthday and Christmas?

Interesting question! I am godmother to my much-loved brother's eldest daughter (she's 21 now) and have invested a lot of time - and money (I've contributed to her university fees, for example) - in her. But I've done the same for her younger sister, will contribute the same amount to her university fees when she goes and would have done all of it had they not asked me to be godmother/got them christened, frankly.

GreatStuff67 · 11/07/2022 11:14

Hi OP. I'm Scottish, DH is Spanish. We live in Scotland. From my point of view I'm thinking it's almost certainly because the other friend is Spanish. We raised our DC bilingual. It's hard work when, living here, they're mostly surrounded by the English language, so we did all we could to have more Spanish speaking people in their lives.

Also, even with the language aside, it was important to us both that they had a stronger connection to the Spanish culture. Even just things like the main day at Christmas is actually in January, growing up knowing Spanish songs, food etc.

Also, my experience of Spanish Catholicism is it's very... strict? That's not the right word. Taken seriously? So even if your friend only wants DC christened so they can go to a Catholic school I wouldn't be surprised if her husband and his family wanted to this the 'proper' way, which is family and godparents only (at least, from the Spanish christenings I know about). Of course this can depend on the family but as a PP said they tend to not be as everyone come/big party as here.

And, your friend's DH knows the Spanish friend too. He'd probably want to pick people he knows.

I get why you're upset about not being picked, but my guess is there's more to it than just your friend overlooked you. I wouldn't be cutting her off or anything like that over it.

WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 11/07/2022 11:10

Is it because they want a couple to be god mother and father?

Mariposista · 11/07/2022 11:05

OP I have lived in Spain for 10 years, and know a lot of Spanish people both there and in the UK. They are lovely people, but believe me, they will always gravitate towards each other. Having friends from other cultures is a rarity (I have been lucky). They and to prioritise their own.

RollingInTheCreek · 11/07/2022 10:54

DenholmElliot1 · 11/07/2022 09:46

If they're catholics they'll be needing catholic godparents. Non-catholics wouldn't necessarily be aware of this.

I'm godmother to 2 catholic children and I am CoE so not sure if that's right.

OP it's ok to be hurt and upset. With all these things ultimately its up to the parents and you have to accept that but it's ok to be sad and it's ok to pull back on the friendship.
Also don't feel you need to get the child stuff all the time. I was one of the first to have kids and friends would often get them little gifts- it's very sweet but really unnecessary! I always told my friends to save their money for themselves :)

10HailMarys · 11/07/2022 10:44

I'm not going to mention it to her because obviously it's her choice and maybe her partner feels more comfortable as her other friend speaks Spanish etc and his English isn't great.

It will definitely be a language thing, I think. I assume the child is being brought up as bilingual and they want them to have close links with Spanish-speaking people growing up, especially if their family speaks mostly Spanish and her partner's English isn't the best. I honestly wouldn't worry about this; I don't think it's a snub.

sandgrown · 11/07/2022 10:42

If it helps OP. When I married I moved 70 miles away from my best friend but we stayed in touch and met up whenever I went home . She was a witness at my wedding and I asked her to be godmother to my son. Fast forward a few years and my husband had an affair and left me so I may not have contacted her as often while I got my life together. I went home to see my mum and called at her parents where she was living . Her son’s christening party was in full swing ! They invited me in but I was so hurt and embarrassed I made an excuse. I felt really unwanted and was already in a bad place due to the separation. I got over it though and we are still friends at a distance as she has moved to Australia.

UrsulaBursula · 11/07/2022 10:41

Even if she couldn’t make you Godmother for religious reasons; she could at least invite you to the christening.

You are friends after all

UrsulaBursula · 11/07/2022 10:40

I would be incredibly hurt. Like you said - ultimately it’s her decision; but seeing how close you are- I would ask the exact reason why she didn’t pick you. At least if it’s based on the religious aspect; you know that’s the reason and not something else.

No harm in asking and as your friend I would expect her to tell you the reason why.

Irishfarmer · 11/07/2022 10:37

toomuchlaundry · 11/07/2022 10:27

How many people’s godparents do anything apart from send presents for birthday and Christmas?

Mine were/ are very good to me. My God mother in particular helped me through some awful stuff.

I plan on being the same for my God-daughter.

I would be a bit put out OP, but as you said their choice so I'd just leave it at that. A close family member said I would be their next child's GM but they have chosen someone else. I was a bit put out but I think it is possibly because I am due my 1st this year and many they think I won't be invested enough, I've never asked.

butterflied · 11/07/2022 10:37

Not inviting you is the kicker. It's all hurtful, and I'd cool the friendship.

easyday · 11/07/2022 10:34

She's going to have to do more than get the child christened if she's using it to get in to school. Here they ask the priest to confirm you are a regular attending member of the parish!
Their may be many reasons, and the Spanish speaking bit may factor in. Let it go.

Tageis · 11/07/2022 10:31

One of my two closest friends told me that she was hurt that I hadn't asked her to be Godmother. It hadn't occurred to her that we wouldn't pick a Godparent who doesn't go to church. She's an honest person and we wouldn't have put her in the position of having to take vows she didn't mean.

WonderingWanda · 11/07/2022 10:28

BMW6 · 11/07/2022 09:58

Perhaps she was chosen as she is also Spanish, and if the child's parents died she'd want her child to be raised in Spain by the Soanish godmother and her family?

I agree with this, I suspect it's cultural rather than religious if you are all Catholic. Sorry that you feel hurt but I wouldn't let it come between you.

toomuchlaundry · 11/07/2022 10:27

How many people’s godparents do anything apart from send presents for birthday and Christmas?

Mally100 · 11/07/2022 10:23

ReeseWitherfork · 11/07/2022 10:12

My sister didn’t have me as a godparent but she did have two of our other siblings. I had always thought me and her were much closer. One loves further away and there’s a big age gap with the other. I was hurt, so I asked her, and she said she was confident I’d always be a massive part of her children’s lives but she wanted to ensure the other two were too.

Well that was a really shitty way to brush you off. It doesn't even make sense. She gave the lesser interested siblings an important role and how would that benefit her child? And to not even discuss this with you but just do it?