Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sisters new puppy

110 replies

OhSwe3tBaby · 11/07/2022 08:00

I gave birth on Wednesday after a very hard pregnancy. Then on Friday out of the blue my sister buys a new puppy. My sister still lives at home with my parents. This is my seccond child, I moved out of my parents a few years ago.

Yesterday I went round my mums for the afternoon, all my siblings were there with their children too, playing in the pool and we ordered some food, sat in the garden. I got there later than others and when I arrived my sisters new puppy is sat on the only shaded chair around the table, I had to move a chair away from the table to sit with my newborn in the shade. The whole time we were there the topic was about the new puppy and only a few family members had brief holds with my newborn but all seemed to fuss and hold the puppy for alot longer.

I just feel like my newborns limelight of beeing new to the family has been stolen by my sisters new puppy and it was selfish of her to get a new puppy the week I give birth. She had also previously offered to take a few days off after I gave birth and my partner had gone back to work to help me and when I mentioned it she said she's taking a few days off over the next few weeks to be at home with her new puppy and I can come round to her if I wanted.

OP posts:
Jimmyneutronsforehead · 11/07/2022 10:37

YABU. Babies are boring. They eat, shit, cry and sleep.

Of course your family love your baby. Having an exciting, energetic puppy there doesn't change that.

It's just babies are like potatoes with emotions and puppies are like a bundle of fun.

ImAvingOops · 11/07/2022 10:34

I get it OP. You have just created a whole new person and it would be nice if your family showed some interest. And looked after you a bit - it's exhausting and painful and new mums should be spoilt and fussed over.

I do think the date wasn't in your sisters control though, so don't be thinking she did it on purpose. And she does have to stay home with the puppy - it's needs are not dissimilar to a newborn baby's. It's just poor coincidence of timing.

Musti · 11/07/2022 10:29

I love babies (I have 4 of my own) but unless they’re my own newborns, I would find puppies far more fun and cute than a newborn. Congratulations, the puppy will grow up in a few months whereas your baby will have a cute toddler/child pager for years and will end up with loads of attention. Your baby isn’t aware now anyway so it doesn’t matter.

SarahSissions · 11/07/2022 10:28

You don’t really choose when to get a new puppy. Its not like going to Tesco, she will have brought it home in Friday because that was 8 weeks after it was born. Get a grip.

FictionalCharacter · 11/07/2022 10:26

YABU, but people are being unnecessarily harsh on this thread. Congrats on your new baby!
Someone should have moved the puppy off the chair though. It’s not OK to leave a dog sitting on a chair when you need a seat, that’s just rude.

HELLITHURT · 11/07/2022 10:24

Yes YABU, but it's early days and understandable!

spiderlight · 11/07/2022 10:19

The date when a puppy comes home isn't generally in the new owner's hands. If the puppy is from a responsible breeder, she might have been on a waiting list for months or even years, and then the pups' breed, age and development will determine when the breeder lets them go, so it probably won't have been a deliberate decision to upstage you. Somebody should have sorted you out a seat in the shade as soon as you arrived though!

Irishfarmer · 11/07/2022 10:19

I'm expecting my first this week, I think I would feel the same. Even though we know really that no one is as interested in our baby as we are. I genuinely think my FIL will still be more interested in our dog who he adores!! Until the baby is old enough to interact with him properly.

I would have been really unimpressed with them not moving the puppy off the shady chair for me though. Surely pup could have sat on someone's lap or under the table. Emotions are high but I would try put it out of your mind.

Congrats on the baby

Fairislefandango · 11/07/2022 10:18

Babies are only endlessly fascinating when they're your own! Once people have cooed briefly at the new arrival, a newborn isn't very interactive. Puppies on the other hand...

Sunnytwobridges · 11/07/2022 10:11

StrangeCondition · 11/07/2022 08:06

Yeah, I would've been more interested in the puppy but then I don't like babies.

😂 Me too.

moreshitandnofuckingredemption · 11/07/2022 10:06

TheOrigRights · 11/07/2022 09:23

OP, I would have sat with you in the shade with your precious new baby. I'd rather cuddle a baby than play with a puppy, and also acknowledge that as fun as a new pup is (especially for children) I would be aware that YOU need some care and love having just given birth.
I'm sorry you're getting such a hard time on here - people are almost sneering at you as if you are ridiculous to expect your family to celebrate the arrival of your baby. Take care of yourself xx

Completely agree with this, I think the sneering you're getting on here is really unkind. Congratulations on your baby 💐

Mariposista · 11/07/2022 09:58

This has given me a bit of a giggle. Jealous of a puppy? Oh dear…

Felicity42 · 11/07/2022 09:55

You went to your mum's and felt that you were suddenly on your own with your baby at a time you feel overwhelmed and could have done with some fussing over.
Having a second baby is hard work. I can see how you'd be annoyed if your sister said she'd be free to help but now has a puppy. But your mum can mind the puppy while your sister helps you. But you need to ask if you need help otherwise people won't realise. Best of luck with the baby. The first 6 weeks are absolutely crap anyway that's for sure but it will get better.

Womencanlift · 11/07/2022 09:45

As someone who really really doesn’t like dogs I still think YABU. Your sisters choices to get a puppy shouldn’t be aligned to when you happen to give birth

The thing about the chair, this is when you need to be more assertive and move the dog so you can sit down rather than sit separate from the family

ManateeFair · 11/07/2022 09:43

Mumsnet is full of posts from people who don’t want to let family so much as look at the baby for a fortnight and then get incredibly stressed by the notion of ‘passing the baby round like a doll’ for people to cuddle and throw hissy fits when someone kisses it. By contrast, you are annoyed that people didn’t hold your baby for as long as they played with a puppy. Families really cannot win, can they?

I like babies and I like puppies. But I wouldn’t really want to cuddle a baby for long on a boiling hot day, and a newborn is considerably less interactive than a puppy.

The notion that she was ‘selfish’ to get a puppy the same week you had a baby is just total nonsense. Why on earth would you expect her to plan stuff around you having a baby? She’s your sister, not your partner. You don’t have to schedule your plans around each other.

Chocoqueen · 11/07/2022 09:43

TheOrigRights · 11/07/2022 09:23

OP, I would have sat with you in the shade with your precious new baby. I'd rather cuddle a baby than play with a puppy, and also acknowledge that as fun as a new pup is (especially for children) I would be aware that YOU need some care and love having just given birth.
I'm sorry you're getting such a hard time on here - people are almost sneering at you as if you are ridiculous to expect your family to celebrate the arrival of your baby. Take care of yourself xx

THIS. In spades!!

It's funny, if the OP was posting in a few years time saying how her family prefer DC1 and always ignore DC2 she'd be told to go no contact. It's almost as if those posting are just in it to kick a vulnerable person when she's down.

Congratulations again OP. I'd cuddle your baby over a puppy any day x

Cheeseandlobster · 11/07/2022 09:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Bananarama21 · 11/07/2022 09:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

AnotherForumUser · 11/07/2022 09:36

Sorry but YABU. The world doesn't stop because you've had a baby. Your sister is allowed to get a puppy. She really doesn't have to arrange her life around you. As for stealing your limelight. Please think about how that sounds. She is not the one being selfish here I'm afraid.

MsMarvellous · 11/07/2022 09:28

With kindness, yabu. Certainly on an objective level. But as a new mum who has just given birth I also totally understand. Be kind to yourself.

TheOrigRights · 11/07/2022 09:23

OP, I would have sat with you in the shade with your precious new baby. I'd rather cuddle a baby than play with a puppy, and also acknowledge that as fun as a new pup is (especially for children) I would be aware that YOU need some care and love having just given birth.
I'm sorry you're getting such a hard time on here - people are almost sneering at you as if you are ridiculous to expect your family to celebrate the arrival of your baby. Take care of yourself xx

BeautifulDragon · 11/07/2022 09:22

Congratulations on your new baby!

I mean this kindly, but the fuss you get after having your first baby is generally different to subsequent children. I think this is what you are experiencing and the puppy is just amplifying that. People just assume you know what you're doing and let you get on with it.

It doesn't mean they love you or your baby any less.

Chocoqueen · 11/07/2022 09:14

You're getting a really rough time here OP, mumsnet is a crazy world where no one cares about their family and friends big life events such as babies and weddings which is so unlike real life. And I expect most of those posting would be put out in your situation.

Obviously the puppy should have been moved so you can sit at the table, in the shade, with your newborn. Humans take precedent over dogs.

I think your sister was generous to offer to take time off to help but probably didn't think it through and it's such a big ask I don't think you can be too upset she's backed out (though I do wonder why she offered if she knew she was getting a puppy!).

Congratulations on your baby

Prinnny · 11/07/2022 09:13

😂😂😂 those post birth hormones really make you irrational! I remember crying because I thought the dog didn’t love me anymore because I’d ruined her life with this tiny screaming human!

SpaceFarce · 11/07/2022 09:12

I got there later than others and when I arrived my sisters new puppy is sat on the only shaded chair around the table, I had to move a chair away from the table to sit with my newborn in the shade.

this is where you use your voice and say “I would like to sit here please; puppy can sit in a shaded spot away from the table”.

YABU for all the other reasons everyone else has said.