Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH hit our 2 year old.

209 replies

Froghottub · 11/07/2022 00:20

I’ve name changed for obvious reasons….

So as the title says really and I just don’t know what to do.

DH is having a particularly bad time at the moment following a bereavement and various other stressful things happening.

Today our 2 year old was having a generic tantrum over not getting his own way basically. DH was dealing with it and I was upstairs. I could hear DS getting upset and asking for me. After a couple of mins when he wasn’t calming down I could hear DH was getting cross and telling him off. DS was just getting more wound up at being told off so I went down to help.

As I walked into the room I saw my DH hit DS on the head. It was like a slap to the top of his head. I picked DS up and told DH to leave. An argument ensued but he eventually left the room.

I am absolutely against any form of physical punishment and it’s a very firm boundary for me and one we have never ever disagreed on before.

i have left with DS and I’m at family staying there for tonight at least.

whilst DH had said sorry to DS he’s also been argumentative, has blamed it on me, been gaslighting me and has even tried to blame DS for being ‘aggressive’. This incident was nothing beyond a typical toddler tantrum of which there are and have been many.

he admits it was wrong but isn’t taking responsibility or grasping that this is a huge thing for me.

My gut reaction is that our relationship is over, BUT, I know full well he legally has a legitimate defence that DS was being naughty and therefore he chastised him. Whilst I don’t agree with his actions I don’t suppose a court (civil or criminal) will do anything about it. If I leave him, he’ll still get contact or maybe even 50/50 with DS and then I’ll have no involvement or knowledge of how he’s treated or what’s happening whilst he’s there.

if I stay I’m condoning abusive behaviour and teaching my child that being assaulted is okay and I just can’t stomach that.

what on earth do I do for the best? Am I over reacting?

DS loves his dad and I know DH loves him. Of course I want them to have a good relationship but how can I trust someone who loses their temper and hits a child to keep the most precious thing in the world safe.

My head is spinning. Although it doesn’t change the situation at all a further consideration is that I’m 33 weeks pregnant .

I guess my AIBU is
YABU - you’re over reacting and need to calm down and resolve this
YANBU - This is too far

OP posts:
dunBle · 11/07/2022 03:41

While I'm not in the "never, ever, hit your child" camp, I am very much in the "never, ever, hit your child round the head" camp, especially as I don't know how much force is required to inflict a whiplash injury on a small child. If he was horrified at snapping like this, and willing to work on whatever had led to the situation, that would be one thing, but at the moment it doesn't sound like he is. If you can find a way to get him to take this as seriously as you do (perhaps @BreadInCaptivity's suggestion will work) then you may be able to work through this, but not if he digs his heels in further.

Ottersmith · 11/07/2022 01:40

BreadInCaptivity · 11/07/2022 01:10

Despite the numerous posts saying contact SS you are correct OP and if you separate it's very, very unlikely your DH would be denied contact.

As such I'm going to stick my neck out with a response that might not be popular.

If you want to control the narrative as it currently is you need to stay with your DH and not LTB - well not "right now".

That doesn't mean ignoring what's happened. Firstly I'd stay with relatives for as long as you are able. Not a few days, but weeks/months. Your DH can see your child but under your supervision.

He needs your (prolonged) physical absence to realise how serious this situation is.

In return he agrees to attend anger management and more general counselling/therapy. If he does not agree then you say you will start divorce proceedings.

If he does agree then he gives you full disclosure on his therapy/counselling progress and you jointly agree a reconciliation plan that has very clear red lines. Basically this is a one time only deal.

Can you both recover from this? I don't know, but I have seen it happen many times (with hard work from both parents) and seem more than equal failures.

What I can say is giving it go on the basis you might be successful is a far better outcome than one where you are sat at home every other weekend worrying about your child when they are with their father, knowing he's done nothing to address his issues.

This is a good idea.

Penfelyn · 11/07/2022 01:39

I'm gonna offer a different perspective.

As a child I got occasionally slapped/spanked for misbehaviour. I can say confidently that :

  • I always deserved it
  • I always knew why I was being slapped/spanked and I usually knew I'd crossed a line before it happened
  • I was not hurt (except my pride) but overall it was much better to be parented like this than being given no guidance/boundaries
  • My parents splitting up over this would have harmed me far more than the occasional, deserved slap.
For context I have children of my own and I do not use any kind of physical punishment with them, because I like to think it's possible to enforce the same boundaries without slapping, though I can't say I haven't been tempted a couple of times ! But having lived through it I don't think it is the dealbreaker that other people make it out to be.

A light slap that didn't even leave a light mark isn't the end of the world if things are otherwise good. I'd be more concerned about the deflecting afterwards, though your (pretty extreme) reaction couldn't have helped.

I'm not saying you need to accept physical punishment by the way. You get to decide how you want to parent, and if the two of you can't agree on that, there is no coming back really. So you deal with it as you would any other parenting disagreement. State your boundaries and tell him you'd consider walking away if you two can't agree and if he doesn't stick to it.

If it does happen again you'd have to choose between accept it or leave.

Hawkins001 · 11/07/2022 01:38

Firstly omg 😲, then all the best and positivity op.

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 11/07/2022 01:36

007DoubleOSeven · 11/07/2022 00:56

Yes, what he did was unacceptable.

Yes, I agree that from your description there's no case in law.

You don't seem convinced that you want to divorce and I understand why, so what you need to do now is take a step back. Give both you and your dh time to cool off as far as reacting to this incident goes.

The more you threaten divorce and call him an abusive parent, the more he will double down and refuse to see that he was wrong. The way to deal with this is not to immediately jump to (what he may see as an) extreme reaction.

Tomorrow, when you've both had some sleep (because it's too late, too hot and he's already too wound up, and youre probably both too tired now) you can discuss the incident rationally.

I don't believe SS will want to see a family break up over this and as you say, his behaviour wasn't severe enough to break the law (which even in the UK permits only a very narrow definition of physical chastisement).

If you're looking for another resolution to this apart from 1) ignore or 2) divorce then its this:

Talk calmly to each other. Take out the emotion in your response, you'll only cause an equally strong emotional reaction in him.

Explain both sides. Let him have the space to feel secure enough to admit what he did was wrong.

Ideally, he'll agree it should never happen again. A parenting course - for both of you - might be really helpful here.

He lost control because he lacked the tools to deal with the situation. If you're confident this was an aberration and he is a good man otherwise, then you can both learn from it instead.

You'll hopefully have a stronger marriage, be better parents and maintain / rediscover respect for each other as a result.

A hard line on physical punishment doesn't have to mean the end of everything.

Good luck

I agree with this. If this was broadly out of character for your DH, he is typically an involved, competent and patient father, and he was in the midst of grieving, then I would probably be willing to give him another chance AS LONG AS he comes to see the incident as serious and takes firm steps to learn better coping tools.

When we had three kids under 4, including a newborn, we were having sleepless nights, my DH was truly miserable at work reporting to an absolute tyrant, his beloved DGF died unexpectedly and DH could not travel back to the UK for the funeral due to COVID restrictions. While DH is normally the most level-headed person you’ll ever meet, and an absolutely stellar parent, he went through a few weeks of being quite short tempered with us (mostly with passive aggressive comments). One evening when I was feeding the baby, DC2 was being absolutely wild at bedtime, and running around naked half an hour after DH had finished the bedtime routine. He was keeping up his older sister. After much back and forth negotiation, and no progress towards bed, DH slapped DC’s arm, quite hard. He didn’t leave a mark, but the sound made my blood run cold.

I immediately took over and put DC2 to bed, and told my DH to get out of the house and calm the down.

I kept a very close eye on him for the next few days. A couple of evenings later, I got my DSis and DM to look after the kids one evening and I went out for a relaxed meal with DH. In neutral territory, after a couple of days to let the dust settle, I told him very clearly that I wasn’t going to put up with his snappy remarks anymore and that if he ever hit one of our children again, that would be the immediate end of our marriage.

He listened. He promised me it would never happen again. I told him a promise wasn’t enough - he needed to find a new job within 6 months, because his work was such a giant stressor; I was expecting at least 3 job applications per week starting the next day; and he needed to start counselling within two weeks.

He implemented both those things, by the deadlines set. He didn’t mess about. Honestly, the therapy helped him in ways I think he never expected. He stuck with it for way more sessions than I would have enforced.

It’s been over a year since the incident now, and we’ve faced lots more challenging situations together but he has never again lost his cool - not even once.

Hitting your DC is very serious, but I don’t think it necessarily has to be the end of your family unit - IF your DH takes responsibility and sorts himself out.

user1471457751 · 11/07/2022 01:30

Social services will not intervene for a child being clipped round the head, especially with the OP saying it wasn't hard enough to hurt. They don't even have the staff for serious cases of prolonged abuse and neglect. I swear some posters live in an alternate reality some times.

What the OPs husband did was wrong. But we all know the response would be different if he were a woman. If it was a mother who was going through a bereavement, other stressful things and, when being headbutted by her toddler, gave him a clip round the ear. Everyone would be telling her she's not a horrible mum and she just needs help.

ThreeLittleDots · 11/07/2022 01:27

We didn't think my stepson"s dad had hurt him before, but following what we thought was a one-off hit, nspcc advised us to take the baby to A&E, where he had x-rays and a multitude of old fractures were discovered. Hitting a baby isn't normal. You must tell the authorities.

007DoubleOSeven · 11/07/2022 01:25

understand your predicament, if you leave him then he’ll be on his own with your children, and in the back of your mind, you’ll always be worrying and wondering how he’s treating them.

This is partly why I think opting to save the relationship is better. It would need to include parenting course etc and you'd know if/that his parenting has improved.

Aussiegirl123456 · 11/07/2022 01:22

Oh goodness, your poor son and poor you.
I understand your predicament, if you leave him then he’ll be on his own with your children, and in the back of your mind, you’ll always be worrying and wondering how he’s treating them.

Has he done this before?
Is he having counselling for his stress from the bereavement?
Could he attend a parenting class or anger management class - or both?

Honestly, well done for walking out with your child. A 2 year old should not be punished physically for being a toddler. You didn’t over react.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 11/07/2022 01:15

Well done on your getting your DS and yourself out of there. And stay out. Or get him out.

His gaslighting/behaviour afterwards tells you that he knows it was wrong but he's trying to cover it up.

Have you asked him if he's ever done while you HAVEN'T been there?

This is over. Protect your son. Bollox to all the 'oh but if he attends anger management/therapy' stuff. Divorce him.

If he can lose his temper around a two-year old, what will happen as they get older?

Mowws · 11/07/2022 01:13

"Im not sure I’d want DS to lose his relationship with his dad which is generally loving and good over this, but I want to keep him safe and never in that situation again. I’m not sure there’s a resolution to this"

Your son is at the age/ coming up to the age where he won't be able to keep a secret, he will blurt out every little thing. Make it clear to him that you want to know if he ever feels scared in the house, and he will.

If you want a resolution, it's communication with your husband. It sounds like this was out of character for him. Could he benefit from some counselling for whatever he's got going on in his life?

I agree with a previous poster, I think this is salvageable if you both want it to be.

LunaLights · 11/07/2022 01:13

OP, what will happen when your 2 year old has a tantrum (a normal developmental occurrence) and there is also a newborn in the situation?
What sort of reaction would their father have to each of the children if he can’t see why his behaviour is so concerning and wrong?
You cannot say it hasn’t happened before - you wouldn’t know it happened this time if you had not seen it yourself! If he thinks he hasn’t done the wrong thing, it may well have happened multiple times before, and it will probably happen again.
He needs to not only be held accountable, but also to learn appropriate parenting, anger and frustration management, and to undertake that he will never, ever raise a hand to your child/children in anger or physical punishment.
I don’t know the answer to what you need to do, except that you need to protect your DS and your baby when they are born…

BreadInCaptivity · 11/07/2022 01:10

Froghottub · 11/07/2022 00:45

I’m in England. It’s not illegal. There’s no ‘evidence’ other than my word against his that it happened. That applies today, tomorrow or next week.
DS does not have the vocabulary or understanding to describe what happened.

I don’t think DH would lie. I don’t think he thinks it’s right. I think he lost his temper when DS was having a tantrum but I know full well no court. Social worker or anyone else is going to support him having zero contact with his child over this.

Im not sure I’d want DS to lose his relationship with his dad which is generally loving and good over this, but I want to keep him safe and never in that situation again. I’m not sure there’s a resolution to this.

Despite the numerous posts saying contact SS you are correct OP and if you separate it's very, very unlikely your DH would be denied contact.

As such I'm going to stick my neck out with a response that might not be popular.

If you want to control the narrative as it currently is you need to stay with your DH and not LTB - well not "right now".

That doesn't mean ignoring what's happened. Firstly I'd stay with relatives for as long as you are able. Not a few days, but weeks/months. Your DH can see your child but under your supervision.

He needs your (prolonged) physical absence to realise how serious this situation is.

In return he agrees to attend anger management and more general counselling/therapy. If he does not agree then you say you will start divorce proceedings.

If he does agree then he gives you full disclosure on his therapy/counselling progress and you jointly agree a reconciliation plan that has very clear red lines. Basically this is a one time only deal.

Can you both recover from this? I don't know, but I have seen it happen many times (with hard work from both parents) and seem more than equal failures.

What I can say is giving it go on the basis you might be successful is a far better outcome than one where you are sat at home every other weekend worrying about your child when they are with their father, knowing he's done nothing to address his issues.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 11/07/2022 00:58

While I was reading your OP I was willing to be slightly more understanding given he's obviously grieving and possibly not his normal self but hitting him across the HEAD??! I was expecting a tap on the hand or nappied bottom.

007DoubleOSeven · 11/07/2022 00:56

Yes, what he did was unacceptable.

Yes, I agree that from your description there's no case in law.

You don't seem convinced that you want to divorce and I understand why, so what you need to do now is take a step back. Give both you and your dh time to cool off as far as reacting to this incident goes.

The more you threaten divorce and call him an abusive parent, the more he will double down and refuse to see that he was wrong. The way to deal with this is not to immediately jump to (what he may see as an) extreme reaction.

Tomorrow, when you've both had some sleep (because it's too late, too hot and he's already too wound up, and youre probably both too tired now) you can discuss the incident rationally.

I don't believe SS will want to see a family break up over this and as you say, his behaviour wasn't severe enough to break the law (which even in the UK permits only a very narrow definition of physical chastisement).

If you're looking for another resolution to this apart from 1) ignore or 2) divorce then its this:

Talk calmly to each other. Take out the emotion in your response, you'll only cause an equally strong emotional reaction in him.

Explain both sides. Let him have the space to feel secure enough to admit what he did was wrong.

Ideally, he'll agree it should never happen again. A parenting course - for both of you - might be really helpful here.

He lost control because he lacked the tools to deal with the situation. If you're confident this was an aberration and he is a good man otherwise, then you can both learn from it instead.

You'll hopefully have a stronger marriage, be better parents and maintain / rediscover respect for each other as a result.

A hard line on physical punishment doesn't have to mean the end of everything.

Good luck

CornishTiger · 11/07/2022 00:53

OP you know this wouldn’t cease contact.

I understand your reasons for thinking about remaining to parent together. Can you remain in this relationship. You know whether this is a “not the type of man but is under extreme stress” or a “always had potential for this” situation.

Aquamarine1029 · 11/07/2022 00:51

DH has never hurt or assaulted me or been violent in any way.

Ok. Then you say...

He loses his temper during arguments and things can get a bit verbally heated...

There it is. You clearly have different boundaries than I do. "Losing your temper" and being verbally abusive is just a different form of violence. It's a "tool" abusive people use to control their target. This is not a dynamic I would ever tolerate, and I've been married for over 25 years.

Froghottub · 11/07/2022 00:45

I’m in England. It’s not illegal. There’s no ‘evidence’ other than my word against his that it happened. That applies today, tomorrow or next week.
DS does not have the vocabulary or understanding to describe what happened.

I don’t think DH would lie. I don’t think he thinks it’s right. I think he lost his temper when DS was having a tantrum but I know full well no court. Social worker or anyone else is going to support him having zero contact with his child over this.

Im not sure I’d want DS to lose his relationship with his dad which is generally loving and good over this, but I want to keep him safe and never in that situation again. I’m not sure there’s a resolution to this.

OP posts:
Froghottub · 11/07/2022 00:38

I get that hitting him in the head escalates it but he’s saying DS was ‘head butting him’ and he doesn’t appear to have used excessive force from what I saw. Yes he slapped but it wouldn’t have been hard enough to injure.

it’s less about what he did and more about the fact I don’t want anything like that to ever happen to my child within the safety of our home / family. Of course I acknowledge that DS was behaving badly and it needed to be dealt with but at the end of the day he’s 2, he doesn’t have any control and usually we deal with it by just holding space and then we talk it through after.

this is out of character and out of the blue. I would be very surprised if anything like this happened before and I certainly have never suspected it. There’s been the odd time DH has got cross and either walked away and ignored DS or asked me to take over. Of course I can’t know but this is certainly not normal and not how we parent.

DH has never hurt or assaulted me or been violent in any way. He loses his temper during arguments and things can get a bit verbally heated but he usually walks away / goes out and returns calm and we talk.

DH refused to leave the house. It’s owned jointly. I have no more right to it than he does and I decided it was better to get away from the situation than start more arguments about who was staying / going.

OP posts:
BlackandBlueBird · 11/07/2022 00:38

As for saying a 2 year old was being aggressive... not taking responsibility and blaming the child is almost as bad as doing it in the first place.

This. I think most of us have screwed up as parents at times, maybe not as extreme as hitting, but I’ve certainly done a lot of things I regret, particularly when under times of extreme stress as your husband is now. However I’ve always immediately apologised to my child, recognised that I’ve fucked up, taken steps to improve my self regulation.

Also, if he was getting so stressed, why didn’t he switch out with you? Did he just not recognise it was happening? Whatever happens next, he really needs to work on his anger management.

Lianna93 · 11/07/2022 00:34

@Froghottub OP where are you from? In Scotland it's very much illegal to hit a child & this would 100% be grounds for social work & police intervention.

Wheresthebeach · 11/07/2022 00:34

Call social services. An interview with them should alter your DH’s perception. Ask them about access in the case of divorce.

justasking111 · 11/07/2022 00:32

I think it's illegal in Wales now

TimeToGoUpAGear · 11/07/2022 00:31

Also, if you hadn't walked in you would know. You aren't keeping your child safe by staying as this happened with you in that house.

Having it on record with social services WILL be extremely helpful when it comes to access decisions. If you don't report it tomorrow, there will be zero evidence it happened.

Froghottub · 11/07/2022 00:30

I wont go into details as I don’t want to be identified but I have a professional knowledge of the law and it is legal, as long as it doesn’t leave an injury or more than transient pain. It’s fucking awful, but it’s not illegal (sadly). I’m not justifying or defending it but I’m being realistic about the outcome of reporting it.

if I leave this man then I’m going to end up sharing my son 50/50 with him and that feels worse than sharing a house with him whilst I can know what’s going on for atleast a good proportion of the time.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread