Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH hit our 2 year old.

209 replies

Froghottub · 11/07/2022 00:20

I’ve name changed for obvious reasons….

So as the title says really and I just don’t know what to do.

DH is having a particularly bad time at the moment following a bereavement and various other stressful things happening.

Today our 2 year old was having a generic tantrum over not getting his own way basically. DH was dealing with it and I was upstairs. I could hear DS getting upset and asking for me. After a couple of mins when he wasn’t calming down I could hear DH was getting cross and telling him off. DS was just getting more wound up at being told off so I went down to help.

As I walked into the room I saw my DH hit DS on the head. It was like a slap to the top of his head. I picked DS up and told DH to leave. An argument ensued but he eventually left the room.

I am absolutely against any form of physical punishment and it’s a very firm boundary for me and one we have never ever disagreed on before.

i have left with DS and I’m at family staying there for tonight at least.

whilst DH had said sorry to DS he’s also been argumentative, has blamed it on me, been gaslighting me and has even tried to blame DS for being ‘aggressive’. This incident was nothing beyond a typical toddler tantrum of which there are and have been many.

he admits it was wrong but isn’t taking responsibility or grasping that this is a huge thing for me.

My gut reaction is that our relationship is over, BUT, I know full well he legally has a legitimate defence that DS was being naughty and therefore he chastised him. Whilst I don’t agree with his actions I don’t suppose a court (civil or criminal) will do anything about it. If I leave him, he’ll still get contact or maybe even 50/50 with DS and then I’ll have no involvement or knowledge of how he’s treated or what’s happening whilst he’s there.

if I stay I’m condoning abusive behaviour and teaching my child that being assaulted is okay and I just can’t stomach that.

what on earth do I do for the best? Am I over reacting?

DS loves his dad and I know DH loves him. Of course I want them to have a good relationship but how can I trust someone who loses their temper and hits a child to keep the most precious thing in the world safe.

My head is spinning. Although it doesn’t change the situation at all a further consideration is that I’m 33 weeks pregnant .

I guess my AIBU is
YABU - you’re over reacting and need to calm down and resolve this
YANBU - This is too far

OP posts:
knittingaddict · 11/07/2022 08:17

Even decades ago physical discipline did not include hitting on the head. I'm sure some people did but it wasn't an accepted thing. A slap on the leg or bottom was fairly common.

Obviously times have changed and all physical chastisement is generally frowned on (quite rightly). A slap anywhere near the head would be a complete no no for any reasonable person. It looks like hitting out in anger and that's what it is. I would have zero tolerance with anything like that.

alphapie · 11/07/2022 08:17

parenthood1989 · 11/07/2022 08:14

Heck there have been posts before from mothers saying they lashed out and feel terrible and 90% of the comments are 'we all snap' 'you feeling terrible shows you're not a bad mum' etc.

There are posts here saying similar. It's not ok.

The % difference when it's mum vs dad is quite bemusing, if not totally expected on here.

The OP hasn't even said what this slap was, posters are already using the term hit round the head, a slap is lighter than being 'hit' for example.

When it's dad posters will make it sound worse and go off on one, when it's mum posters will minimise and tell them it's ok petal.

ladydoris · 11/07/2022 08:17

HMSSophia · 11/07/2022 08:13

This. God knows we're not all perfect. Be a loving supportive adult and help your DP as well as your child.

I double down.

parenthood1989 · 11/07/2022 08:15

Be a loving supportive adult and help your DP as well as your child.

Ah yes, the poor poor man. Do be a good wife now OP Hmm

Ryah76 · 11/07/2022 08:15

I don’t agree with physical violence, particularly against children. However, whilst I think you have done the right thing setting boundaries and leaving- I think it’s worth you and your husband really talking about what happened and even seeking counselling.
Again I don’t agree with violence, but you state that he is grieving and is acting out of character- it sounds like he needs help addressing both his grief and loss of control.

parenthood1989 · 11/07/2022 08:14

Heck there have been posts before from mothers saying they lashed out and feel terrible and 90% of the comments are 'we all snap' 'you feeling terrible shows you're not a bad mum' etc.

There are posts here saying similar. It's not ok.

HMSSophia · 11/07/2022 08:13

007DoubleOSeven · 11/07/2022 00:56

Yes, what he did was unacceptable.

Yes, I agree that from your description there's no case in law.

You don't seem convinced that you want to divorce and I understand why, so what you need to do now is take a step back. Give both you and your dh time to cool off as far as reacting to this incident goes.

The more you threaten divorce and call him an abusive parent, the more he will double down and refuse to see that he was wrong. The way to deal with this is not to immediately jump to (what he may see as an) extreme reaction.

Tomorrow, when you've both had some sleep (because it's too late, too hot and he's already too wound up, and youre probably both too tired now) you can discuss the incident rationally.

I don't believe SS will want to see a family break up over this and as you say, his behaviour wasn't severe enough to break the law (which even in the UK permits only a very narrow definition of physical chastisement).

If you're looking for another resolution to this apart from 1) ignore or 2) divorce then its this:

Talk calmly to each other. Take out the emotion in your response, you'll only cause an equally strong emotional reaction in him.

Explain both sides. Let him have the space to feel secure enough to admit what he did was wrong.

Ideally, he'll agree it should never happen again. A parenting course - for both of you - might be really helpful here.

He lost control because he lacked the tools to deal with the situation. If you're confident this was an aberration and he is a good man otherwise, then you can both learn from it instead.

You'll hopefully have a stronger marriage, be better parents and maintain / rediscover respect for each other as a result.

A hard line on physical punishment doesn't have to mean the end of everything.

Good luck

This. God knows we're not all perfect. Be a loving supportive adult and help your DP as well as your child.

alphapie · 11/07/2022 08:11

user1471457751 · 11/07/2022 01:30

Social services will not intervene for a child being clipped round the head, especially with the OP saying it wasn't hard enough to hurt. They don't even have the staff for serious cases of prolonged abuse and neglect. I swear some posters live in an alternate reality some times.

What the OPs husband did was wrong. But we all know the response would be different if he were a woman. If it was a mother who was going through a bereavement, other stressful things and, when being headbutted by her toddler, gave him a clip round the ear. Everyone would be telling her she's not a horrible mum and she just needs help.

This

Heck there have been posts before from mothers saying they lashed out and feel terrible and 90% of the comments are 'we all snap' 'you feeling terrible shows you're not a bad mum' etc.

ladydoris · 11/07/2022 08:10

I had.

ladydoris · 11/07/2022 08:10

You have a gut feeling. The terrible twos is no joke and he has to handle it. I have teenagers and a toddler, I have to explain to them how they have to behave around a 2 years old. If they can do it, so can he. If he does not recognize his wrong and take classes then you are in for troubles. It's a light word.

Summersolargirl · 11/07/2022 08:08

Porcupineintherough · 11/07/2022 07:39

I personally wouldn't leave a good marriage with a good father to my child over a slap, but you are free to leave at any time for any reason. If you want your dh not to slap your son though then, married or not, you need to talk to him.

Can you explain further. Which one of you are you ok with getting a slap? You or your infant child? Or maybe both?

also what part of that makes you think the person is a good father or husband? Good fathers and husbands don’t slap their wives or infant children.

speakout · 11/07/2022 08:07

I am glad I live in a part of the UK that sees assaulting a child as a criminal act.

billy1966 · 11/07/2022 08:06

Dragonsmother · 11/07/2022 06:20

OP you have made a lot of life changing decisions in just a matter of hours.

It sounds like you have been unhappy with DHs behaviour for some time and today was the final straw.

Spend a few days away and get some clarity on how you want to deal with this. As you mention you have legal knowledge. Put that aside. Do you want to be in a family with DH? If yes then he needs to get help, he needs to learn how to manage with your DS.

if you don’t want to be with him I think you know what your next step is…..

OP,
You handled things well.
I agree with above.
I think you have been unhappy for a while.

His denial/gaslighting is very sinister IMO.

I don't think it is normal to slap a 2 year old on the head.

He is so small.

I agree with the suggestion you need to take space, don't rush back.

It sounds a vulnerable situation with a new baby and an angry man.

I highly recommend you flag this with your HV and GP.

It appears something has changed in your relationship.

Protecting yourself is the best call.

Marvellousmadness · 11/07/2022 08:04

If you really wanna leave your dh over this: off you go.

FlatWhiteLover · 11/07/2022 08:04

I would try and salvage this marriage if he can admit that physical punishment was the wrong course of action, and is willing to take anger management / parenting classes. So far its a one off in difficult circumstances and if he has your support he is more likely be willing to work on his behaviour. But if it happens again I would be out, and be getting SS involved.

This is coming from experience of having divorced parents, my dad use to clip me round the ear / smack me when I was staying with him for minor things. I never told my mum until after my dad died (when I was a teenager) because I was too scared (although my parents separated unrelated to any abuse).

parenthood1989 · 11/07/2022 08:03

Porcupineintherough · 11/07/2022 08:01

@parenthood1989 I disagree Perfect parents may never slap or shout at or shame their child but it's been known for good parents to do so in a moment of weakness.

Good parents in a moment of weakness?

Good parents do not hit children. Not even in a moment of weakness. What a pathetic excuse for violence.

Catskidsandcoffee · 11/07/2022 08:03

OK there's a lot of "hitting the child around the head" commentary here when in reality OP stated "it was like a slap to the top of the head" that left no mark. Now I'm not diminishing what has happened but neither do I think it needs catastrophising. There isn't a single parent out there who has not been completely and utterly frustrated at their child for whatever reason and that's under normal circumstances let alone when not in their right frame of mind.
The real issue is OPs DHs refusal to take any responsibility for his actions and to then double down on that stance and blame the children. This is what you need to afford because if he cannot see that then it will happen again and then it has the potential to escalate.
I would meet up in a neutral space and talk calmly about what happened, no threats about divorce or SS or supervised access, just talk. Be his wife and encourage him to talk about everything he is going through, and if not to you then someone because he is clearly not coping very well and right now he needs support.

TheGreatBobinsky · 11/07/2022 08:02

He hit a 2 year old around the head? What is he going to do when that 2 year old gets older and exhibits more challenging behaviour? This is not the same as a light slap on the hand/back of the legs (which I still don't agree with but wouldn't be horrified if I did see someone else do it to their child). The head is the most dangerous place to smack, if this doesn't get nipped in the bud now it will escalate so well done for getting out!

I wouldn't want to salvage the relationship after that, you will spend the rest of your life panicking about leaving them alone together in case it happens again. Every time your DH goes through a bad patch you and your child will have to tiptoe around him just in case he snaps again?

No two year old has the cognitive reasoning skills to understand why someone is hitting them, so no they don't know why they are being hit and they certainly don't know that they deserved it. The very fact that an adult thinks a child (or toddler in this instance) might deserve to be physically assaulted is proof that hitting children does in fact do damage.

Porcupineintherough · 11/07/2022 08:01

@parenthood1989 I disagree Perfect parents may never slap or shout at or shame their child but it's been known for good parents to do so in a moment of weakness.

Summersolargirl · 11/07/2022 07:57

I can’t imagine being with a human who assaults an infant. There is an element of justification in your post,,well he’s had a hard time etc, and it reads to me like you’re trying to justify why you are going back and putting your son in harms way again

personally I’d be out. And the fact it’s not illegal in England is irrelevant, it is in many countries of the world. It wouldn’t have stopped him hitting this little boy.

Doingmybest12 · 11/07/2022 07:51

A hit around the head on a 2 year old is not reasonable chastisement. It is not the same as a tap on the hand or a light snap on a clothed thigh/nappied bottom while renaining in control. Bereavement is not an excuse for what he did.

Thejoyfulstar · 11/07/2022 07:49

I was your husband, kind of. When my son was 3 I was going through an incredibly stressful time and smacked him on the leg. I was appalled at myself and it never happened again (he is 7 now). I regretted it instantly. I cannot believe I did that but was under a huge amount of pressure at the time and wasn't myself. I admitted it to my husband immediately, who wasn't pleased but understood my situation. One of my relatives is a social worker and I told her too. She knew it was out of character and was supportive. The thing is, I instantly knew I shouldn't have done it and would never let myself get so wrapped up in my own stress ever again.

frozenorangejuice · 11/07/2022 07:47

Leave him. He hit your child - and on the head no less. While you were in the house! What has happened while you haven’t been there?What do you think he might do with your newborn when he/she can’t be settled by him? Can you honestly in your heart say you can leave your kids alone with him knowing he has done this? So sorry for your situation OP, but it’s not of your making - it’s his. He needs to go.

maddening · 11/07/2022 07:47

I would try and get some communication in writing, eg email, where you lay out what you saw and so he confirms that is what he did.

I would make staying dependent on him taking an anger management course and getting therapy for his bereavement and stress.

Make it clear that he has crossed a boundary, no physical punishment is acceptable in the future and his addressing his anger issues to ensure that he does not lash out in anger at his children is imperative.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/07/2022 07:46

Until you husband shows true remorse and getting help for his other issues then you can’t leave your son with him.

As for calling social services on your family MN are naive at best and damn right stupid at worst.

Swipe left for the next trending thread