Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH hit our 2 year old.

209 replies

Froghottub · 11/07/2022 00:20

I’ve name changed for obvious reasons….

So as the title says really and I just don’t know what to do.

DH is having a particularly bad time at the moment following a bereavement and various other stressful things happening.

Today our 2 year old was having a generic tantrum over not getting his own way basically. DH was dealing with it and I was upstairs. I could hear DS getting upset and asking for me. After a couple of mins when he wasn’t calming down I could hear DH was getting cross and telling him off. DS was just getting more wound up at being told off so I went down to help.

As I walked into the room I saw my DH hit DS on the head. It was like a slap to the top of his head. I picked DS up and told DH to leave. An argument ensued but he eventually left the room.

I am absolutely against any form of physical punishment and it’s a very firm boundary for me and one we have never ever disagreed on before.

i have left with DS and I’m at family staying there for tonight at least.

whilst DH had said sorry to DS he’s also been argumentative, has blamed it on me, been gaslighting me and has even tried to blame DS for being ‘aggressive’. This incident was nothing beyond a typical toddler tantrum of which there are and have been many.

he admits it was wrong but isn’t taking responsibility or grasping that this is a huge thing for me.

My gut reaction is that our relationship is over, BUT, I know full well he legally has a legitimate defence that DS was being naughty and therefore he chastised him. Whilst I don’t agree with his actions I don’t suppose a court (civil or criminal) will do anything about it. If I leave him, he’ll still get contact or maybe even 50/50 with DS and then I’ll have no involvement or knowledge of how he’s treated or what’s happening whilst he’s there.

if I stay I’m condoning abusive behaviour and teaching my child that being assaulted is okay and I just can’t stomach that.

what on earth do I do for the best? Am I over reacting?

DS loves his dad and I know DH loves him. Of course I want them to have a good relationship but how can I trust someone who loses their temper and hits a child to keep the most precious thing in the world safe.

My head is spinning. Although it doesn’t change the situation at all a further consideration is that I’m 33 weeks pregnant .

I guess my AIBU is
YABU - you’re over reacting and need to calm down and resolve this
YANBU - This is too far

OP posts:
Dogtooth · 11/07/2022 10:19

I think you're overreacting. It's definitely not ideal or desirable and you should discuss it and find a way to manage things in future. But it would be bonkers to consider breaking up an otherwise happy relationship with an otherwise kind and reliable father, just for this. Particularly when you're about to have a baby.

DH needs to recognise he crossed a line and he should work on noticing his own signs of stress and finding a way to manage it by taking a deep breath or stepping away for a moment or whatever.

Theglowofcandles · 11/07/2022 10:18

You say he has a defence.. he has no defence.. none whatsoever. If he can hit him sged only 2 imagine what he will be like when your son is older. I bet it's not the first time either.

SheepingStandingUp · 11/07/2022 10:15

Froghottub · 11/07/2022 00:30

I wont go into details as I don’t want to be identified but I have a professional knowledge of the law and it is legal, as long as it doesn’t leave an injury or more than transient pain. It’s fucking awful, but it’s not illegal (sadly). I’m not justifying or defending it but I’m being realistic about the outcome of reporting it.

if I leave this man then I’m going to end up sharing my son 50/50 with him and that feels worse than sharing a house with him whilst I can know what’s going on for atleast a good proportion of the time.

I thought, to be lawful it also had to be in soft flesh ie bottom, which a head isn't?

Sweatinglikeabitch · 11/07/2022 10:05

I think the more concerning part is his behaviour afterwards. He refused to back down. He has blamed a 2yo for getting hit in the head by an adult. If the adult can't regulate his emotions well enough to prevent hitting a toddler, how you expect a toddler to regulate his emotions well enough to prevent headbutting an adult?

The fact he hasn't just instantly backed down, apologised and left is the concerning part for me. You say he doesn't think it's right, but from his behaviour it sounds like he thinks he DID have the right to hit a toddler. I think I'd tell him he needs to do a parenting course to learn how to handle his toddler properly if he wants his family back.

CoastalWave · 11/07/2022 09:54

Spanielsarepainless · 11/07/2022 09:02

I would say you are probably over-reacting. I am of a generation where corporal punishment was starting to be phased out in school, and I certainly was physically punished by both parents (not often and not at the same time). I can't see what you would gain by splitting up. Your children would be the losers longterm. You both need to calm down.

First sensible comment I've read.

Lay the law down, ensure he knows this is beyond acceptable, work through this.

Phobiaphobic · 11/07/2022 09:54

user1471457751 · 11/07/2022 01:30

Social services will not intervene for a child being clipped round the head, especially with the OP saying it wasn't hard enough to hurt. They don't even have the staff for serious cases of prolonged abuse and neglect. I swear some posters live in an alternate reality some times.

What the OPs husband did was wrong. But we all know the response would be different if he were a woman. If it was a mother who was going through a bereavement, other stressful things and, when being headbutted by her toddler, gave him a clip round the ear. Everyone would be telling her she's not a horrible mum and she just needs help.

This.

Anothernosebleed · 11/07/2022 09:46

Report him OP. You act as if you’re so clued up on the police and SS doing nothing but you’re missing the whole point of SS support. Tell them what happened. Tell them you want a section 17 enquiry because you no longer believe your DS to be safe in the care of his father because you have witnessed him physically assaulting your child.

Beseen22 · 11/07/2022 09:42

Do you have a decent HV? Can you call them for a meeting? They are trained in child protection but can also can physically assess your DS and will know the local support available. They can also flag up that you might need a bit extra support in the next few weeks when the baby comes. You seem very clued up and admittedly there is probably no law broken but there are some serious concerns. He is not apologetic and rushing to say 'oh I lost my shit, ill never do that again'. He's going through a lot. But this is an event that you can't move forward through and just say oh he's having a tough time. If he is so stressed that he has hit his child across the head then he needs to access whatever support he can so that it doesn't happen again.
What happens in 7 weeks when you are in over night at the hospital and he has your toddler on his own for 2 days. Emotions and stresses will be even higher then. I would find it very difficult to trust him.

I grew up in a hothead family and was smacked a lot but I don't really buy in to the whole 'I was smacked and I'm fine' chat. My parents had quite clearly lost control and were hitting me to get out their anger. My DH was also smacked but it was in a much more controlled manner, would be done later when no one was yelling their head off. I can kind of see why the later might be used but I think in this day and age there are better ways to parent. My DH and I have a tag out rule that if we notice the other parent getting angry unreasonably we jump in and tell them to have a break and take over the parenting. Parenting can be tough, especially if we have other stress factors in life but we need to have controls in place.

Mydogatemypurse · 11/07/2022 09:39

The same thing happened to me. We had already split up and it was on a contact visit.
My concerns were that it was excessive on dads behalf when chastising. Although personally i dont agree with or want ANY physical chastising and believe as an adult who is emotionally mature should be able to control themselves its not required. Plus it concerned me that his anger was at that level. There is also the issue of setting an example and ensuring the child doesnt model that behaviour when dealing with conflict.
As a parent with PR you have valid concerns to stop contact i did on the basis that until i see him getting help then im not convinced it wont happen again (he was violent to me too)
I stopped contact told the police and told social services and school what i was doing. They were incredibly supportive and agreed with my decision to keep them safe with me. There wasnt a role for ss as they were safe with me. Then dad applied to family court for contact. I told court i want them to have a relationship with their father but not until he evidences taking responsibility and getting help (he blames me and has actually asked for an apology from our son! For his bad behaviour and making him act that way) the kids have remained with me with no contact until court tell him what he needs to do to get contact... likely a parenting and anger management course. Its kind of out of my hands now. Its been very upsetting and unsettling but their safety comes first. You will be ok. Dont assume no one will help. They will.

WITL · 11/07/2022 09:38

This might not be the first time he has hit your son

I would record him admitting it - maybe have a friend on zoom etc and record the meeting and then phone and ask him on speaker phone etc

but really he will have contact to your son - mine does and has but for the sake of the child involve the police - but it will be the end of your marriage and a court blood bath - mine was

ScrollingLeaves · 11/07/2022 09:30

If you stay with him, you are effectively agreeing to stay in a situation where you are agreeing to police his behaviour 24/7, are you able to do this?

Leaving may not necessarily solve this. OP needs legal advice about this. If she leaves, would what her husband did mean her DS could be properly protected from his father in the future? Or not?

We hear all the time that courts often order children to see abusive fathers, where their mothers won’t even be there for 1hr out of 24. This is the dilemma.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 11/07/2022 09:27

Froghottub · 11/07/2022 00:30

I wont go into details as I don’t want to be identified but I have a professional knowledge of the law and it is legal, as long as it doesn’t leave an injury or more than transient pain. It’s fucking awful, but it’s not illegal (sadly). I’m not justifying or defending it but I’m being realistic about the outcome of reporting it.

if I leave this man then I’m going to end up sharing my son 50/50 with him and that feels worse than sharing a house with him whilst I can know what’s going on for atleast a good proportion of the time.

It is a difficult one, but you do not know at this point if the contact will be 50/50.

The family court is a potentially difficult thing to navigate that is completely true.

However, you have reached a fork in the road here. Either you ignore it, in which case if it escalates you will be blamed for it (and your child will continue to suffer) - or you report it NOW - and initiate seperation/divorce.

There is no middle way on this one. You are going to have to be courageous and defend your child. Your child's relating to their father has already changed.

TheSoundOfLunch · 11/07/2022 09:27

Jesus, stop saying he was “chastising” the child for his “bad behaviour”.

No behaviour in a 2yo is “bad”.
Hitting is not “chastising”.

Fuck this pisses me off more than what you say your husband did, you trying to provide some sort of “perspective”.

The only perspective here is that a small child was being a small child and a huge grown up whacked that small child to alleviate their frustration.

Tbh I think the law is irrelevant here. What matters is that you and he are parents to this tiny person and it is your responsibility to care for them and keep them safe. Do that.

In all honesty, so think it very likely that your husband, presumably to be ex given your very strident reaction, is more than capable of rehabilitation if he commits to getting support for managing anger.

You both need to take a step back and look at solutions.

Tiatoo · 11/07/2022 09:23

OP, well done on you for temporarily leaving until the situation has calmed down. You aren’t overreacting in the slightest and I’m really sorry this is happening to you and your little one.

There isn’t a right or wrong answer here, you are right about what the courts would think. However, why did he hit your toddler on the head? Why not back of leg etc? (Not that I agree with smacking). At the VERY LEAST please have a chat with the health visitor, they are very experienced in these type of issues and will refer to SS if they deem appropriate (quite possible).

Everyone experiences parenting failures from time to time but this is pretty significant, is you husband willing to engage with the health visitor or social services? Admit that he is struggling? Does he understand about normal toddler behaviour? If he walks away and calms down during your arguments why wasn’t he able to do the same/swap with you with your toddler? Him working on his issues is the best of all scenarios for your toddlers relationship with him and your family and relationship overall.

This is salvageable and could improve things even, but it’s entirely dependent on whether he truly accepts the issue is his alone and not you or your toddlers behaviour. There are some red flags you’ve mentioned about his behaviour during arguments though, and these would be worth exploring with the health visitor too. They are there to support all of you as it’s in your child’s (and soon to be children's) interest.

ScrollingLeaves · 11/07/2022 09:19

they [social services] can’t do anything about it, it won’t stop him getting contact and then I’ll have to send him off for several days a week and sit at home worrying what’s going on.

I think you are right: You can leave your DH, but that does not mean your child can.

It’s possible but probably not guaranteed that courts would make an order that at first meetings would be supervised. Could you see a good Family solicitor to get real advice as soon as possible?

What is particularly bad is that your DH hit
him on the top of the head. That is dangerous, and It somehow also seems like there was an intent to really hurt. As you saw, you’ll know best and should trust yourself to know. Your DH could well have that aggression in him.

Also, does he believe in physical ‘chastisement’? Would that be his parenting method in the future? Why hadn’t he said he is sorry? I think it is not legal in the U.K.

Should you tell SS? I am not sure what other posters think, but I think as your DH hit him on the head you should. It would be to protect your DS in the future should there be a question of having to leave your DS alone with him.

Also, when did it happen? Take DS to see a GP to check him for signs of head injury. This is important too.

If you want to stay with your DH, does he really love your son? How does he treat you, truthfully? His not apologising does not seem to point to someone who is very nice.

Was this action on his part completely out of his normal character? If you think he is normally kind and loving, and this certainly was out of character, you could insist on not going back until he has been to a special sort of parenting class; anger management; bereavement counselling; and seen a GP for depression.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 11/07/2022 09:16

Froghottub · 11/07/2022 00:26

Social services won’t do anything. He will say that he was chastising them and he hasn’t injured him and it was lawful. Whilst I’m sure social services find it as abhorrent as I do they can’t do anything about it, it won’t stop him getting contact and then I’ll have to send him off for several days a week and sit at home worrying what’s going on.

the threshold to stop contact is so high this wouldn’t even register on the scale. I don’t know how to manage this.

A controlled smack on the bum could be considered chastisement (illegal in Wales mind, thank goodness).

A smack on the head is physical abuse/assault and is illegal in every part of the U.K.

Whatever00 · 11/07/2022 09:12

Can you ask him to take a parenting for toddlers course and to assure you that he never hits DC again. Be very clear that if he hits again you will divorce him.

CanaryShoulderedThorn · 11/07/2022 09:05

alphapie · 11/07/2022 08:40

@FrancescaContini you might disagree, but you're wrong.

There is no mark, and the DH will argue reasonable punishment. Posters are dramaticising things buy saying 'walloped round the head' 'hit round the head' it was a slap on the top of the head. Very different when it comes to what is 'reasonable' or not

No mark, does not mean no injury.
A slap is enough to cause whiplash or a head injury in a young child.
A baby shaken to death would gave no marks on it.
Contact SS OP and get this on record, when your child has a broken limb or school pick up on bruising, at least the bastard will have form for it and won't be easily able to try to blame it on you. If you don't report and do nothing, you are complicit.
If you stay with him, you are effectively agreeing to stay in a situation where you are agreeing to police his behaviour 24/7, are you able to do this? What about when you go to work?
Ring your local women's aid and get some RL advice.

bathsh3ba · 11/07/2022 09:03

Personally, I wouldn't have walked out over one slap to the head, assuming it didn't cause injury, and it was the first time it had ever happened. I would however consider leaving on the basis of his response to it, which seems to make it more likely it could become a pattern of behaviour, which is much more serious, or escalate. I think I would be giving an ultimatum that he gets help with his stress/mental health or you'll be filing for divorce. I don't think you can stop him seeing the child though, what he did just doesn't legally meet the threshold, as you said. I mean obviously he might choose not to see the child, and you could choose not to let him without a court order, but if he applies to court he will get shared custody.

Spanielsarepainless · 11/07/2022 09:02

I would say you are probably over-reacting. I am of a generation where corporal punishment was starting to be phased out in school, and I certainly was physically punished by both parents (not often and not at the same time). I can't see what you would gain by splitting up. Your children would be the losers longterm. You both need to calm down.

KingofLoss · 11/07/2022 09:01

I'm kinda appalled tbh that you've already decided your son isn't worth the protection and overview of the law.

You HAVE to report this to social services. You simply have to. Say you split, and DS has time with his father unsupervised. Professionals need to be aware of this incident so that if injuries or concerns present themselves there's a picture and a pattern being built up.

If anyone physically hurt my child you'd better believe it'd be reported to every possible avenue, even if police and SS say that at this time there hasn't been a law broken it has to be on their radar. Your husband has to experience consequences and know that he can't go around attacking his toddler without there being consequences.

BlackSwan · 11/07/2022 09:00

Don't downplay what's happened here because in your view the 'law allows it'. The best predictor of future behaviour is past behaviour. You have an abusive partner who hit your child on the head. If you don't report & do what you can to get your baby son out of harm's way, you're complicit in any abuse going forward.

CallOnMe · 11/07/2022 08:59

Did you discuss smacking before you had DC?
Many parents use it as part of their parenting.

What would upset me the most out of this situation is that it was done out of anger instead of discipline.

There we’re two of you in the house and he could have walked away or asked you to swap so he can calm down.

Toddlers are very difficult.
Going forward you need to know that if he ever is getting to the point of lashing out again then he needs to walk away and take a couple of minutes before returning.

I am against smacking as I wouldn’t smack my dog and expect it to understand, so why would I expect a toddler to understand.

However, I have smacked my DD in a similar way to your DH.
She went through a biting phase and sank her teeth into my leg really hard and I smacked her across the head as a reaction to get her off me like you would when you squat a fly out of the way type thing - she wasn’t injured at all.

That incident made me realise I’ll never hit her again and I need to find a different way to deal with things.
Your DH could feel the same and it could make him less likely to smack him in the future.

knittingaddict · 11/07/2022 08:56

alphapie · 11/07/2022 08:40

@FrancescaContini you might disagree, but you're wrong.

There is no mark, and the DH will argue reasonable punishment. Posters are dramaticising things buy saying 'walloped round the head' 'hit round the head' it was a slap on the top of the head. Very different when it comes to what is 'reasonable' or not

I'm very surprised by your posts.

I'm from a generation that was smacked and that smacked. I only smacked my children a literal handful of times and always on the leg and never leaving a mark. Looking back I regret doing even that. My parents would never have slapped us around the head and I certainly wouldn't have dreamt of doing it to mine.

The only "slapping" I can think of that ok is that light fake slap that you might do in a light hearted way. That is the only hit/slap around the head that is at all ok. This is not that.

ddl1 · 11/07/2022 08:56

Even at a time when smacking children was more accepted than now, hitting a small child over the HEAD would not have been considered as reasonable. One could do a lot of damage that way,

Swipe left for the next trending thread