Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH hit our 2 year old.

209 replies

Froghottub · 11/07/2022 00:20

I’ve name changed for obvious reasons….

So as the title says really and I just don’t know what to do.

DH is having a particularly bad time at the moment following a bereavement and various other stressful things happening.

Today our 2 year old was having a generic tantrum over not getting his own way basically. DH was dealing with it and I was upstairs. I could hear DS getting upset and asking for me. After a couple of mins when he wasn’t calming down I could hear DH was getting cross and telling him off. DS was just getting more wound up at being told off so I went down to help.

As I walked into the room I saw my DH hit DS on the head. It was like a slap to the top of his head. I picked DS up and told DH to leave. An argument ensued but he eventually left the room.

I am absolutely against any form of physical punishment and it’s a very firm boundary for me and one we have never ever disagreed on before.

i have left with DS and I’m at family staying there for tonight at least.

whilst DH had said sorry to DS he’s also been argumentative, has blamed it on me, been gaslighting me and has even tried to blame DS for being ‘aggressive’. This incident was nothing beyond a typical toddler tantrum of which there are and have been many.

he admits it was wrong but isn’t taking responsibility or grasping that this is a huge thing for me.

My gut reaction is that our relationship is over, BUT, I know full well he legally has a legitimate defence that DS was being naughty and therefore he chastised him. Whilst I don’t agree with his actions I don’t suppose a court (civil or criminal) will do anything about it. If I leave him, he’ll still get contact or maybe even 50/50 with DS and then I’ll have no involvement or knowledge of how he’s treated or what’s happening whilst he’s there.

if I stay I’m condoning abusive behaviour and teaching my child that being assaulted is okay and I just can’t stomach that.

what on earth do I do for the best? Am I over reacting?

DS loves his dad and I know DH loves him. Of course I want them to have a good relationship but how can I trust someone who loses their temper and hits a child to keep the most precious thing in the world safe.

My head is spinning. Although it doesn’t change the situation at all a further consideration is that I’m 33 weeks pregnant .

I guess my AIBU is
YABU - you’re over reacting and need to calm down and resolve this
YANBU - This is too far

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
007DoubleOSeven · 12/07/2022 08:44

@ScrollingLeaves oh, thank you

Ownedbymycats · 11/07/2022 23:25

I was brought up in an environment where slapping and beating was almost instinctive.My own children have never been slapped and I've always observed that it's about breaking the cycle and not instinctively lashing out. For that reason I'd be genuinely surprised that your husband would, for the first time in two years, lash out and hit your child. I'd genuinely question if he's never hit him before.When you make the conscious decision not to slap it's not a simple mistake or momentary loss of control which leads you to hit your child.
Assuming your husband has hit the child because he's under pressure, grieving etc I'd expect him to be in pieces but he's showing no contrition, to the extent that he's even refused to leave the family home.As you say your child is the most precious thing in the world and you may have to share custody with him but I'd be doing so with the benefit of a police and social service detail that he's already hit the child.

ScrollingLeaves · 11/07/2022 23:22

007DoubleOSeven
Your advice is so full of thought and insight I think. Anyone could benefit from it imo.

alphapie · 11/07/2022 19:34

thedancingbear · 11/07/2022 18:27

Having a defence to a crime does not however mean that no crime was committed

Yes it does.

However I expect that walloping a child across the head is a very grey area as 'reasonable chastisement' is concerned. If I were a magistrate, then I would need a lot of convincing that that fell within the defence.

Who walloped a child across the head?

A slap on the top of the head is very different

Higgeldypiggeldy35 · 11/07/2022 18:54

007DoubleOSeven · 11/07/2022 00:56

Yes, what he did was unacceptable.

Yes, I agree that from your description there's no case in law.

You don't seem convinced that you want to divorce and I understand why, so what you need to do now is take a step back. Give both you and your dh time to cool off as far as reacting to this incident goes.

The more you threaten divorce and call him an abusive parent, the more he will double down and refuse to see that he was wrong. The way to deal with this is not to immediately jump to (what he may see as an) extreme reaction.

Tomorrow, when you've both had some sleep (because it's too late, too hot and he's already too wound up, and youre probably both too tired now) you can discuss the incident rationally.

I don't believe SS will want to see a family break up over this and as you say, his behaviour wasn't severe enough to break the law (which even in the UK permits only a very narrow definition of physical chastisement).

If you're looking for another resolution to this apart from 1) ignore or 2) divorce then its this:

Talk calmly to each other. Take out the emotion in your response, you'll only cause an equally strong emotional reaction in him.

Explain both sides. Let him have the space to feel secure enough to admit what he did was wrong.

Ideally, he'll agree it should never happen again. A parenting course - for both of you - might be really helpful here.

He lost control because he lacked the tools to deal with the situation. If you're confident this was an aberration and he is a good man otherwise, then you can both learn from it instead.

You'll hopefully have a stronger marriage, be better parents and maintain / rediscover respect for each other as a result.

A hard line on physical punishment doesn't have to mean the end of everything.

Good luck

I think this is very good advice. Also to add that when i had pnd i was much more irritable and really struggled to deal with the tantrums. Antidepressants really helped me. Its no excuse but he's been through a lot, could he be depressed?

FabFitFifties · 11/07/2022 18:30

I completely understand where you are coming from OP, in terms of not wanting to increase the risks for your son, by having to allow unsupervised contact. It's a very difficult situation. Hitting a 2 year old around the head is very serious. Look to the future. What might he do to a back chatting, much less cute, teenager? Would he be fair game for physical or emotional abuse? From what you say about his failure to accept your concerns, and his behaviour in arguments with you, I'd say future emotional abuse could be on the cards. I doubt you could be happy with your husband now - something dies inside you, when these things happen. The arrival of a new baby is a typical time for these behaviours to escalate too.

thedancingbear · 11/07/2022 18:27

Having a defence to a crime does not however mean that no crime was committed

Yes it does.

However I expect that walloping a child across the head is a very grey area as 'reasonable chastisement' is concerned. If I were a magistrate, then I would need a lot of convincing that that fell within the defence.

RobertJohnsonsShoes · 11/07/2022 18:26

Reporting it isn't just about this incident. It might be worthwhile to have it recorded formally for any future issue.

CharlotteOH · 11/07/2022 18:17

OP you have misunderstood the law. In England it is ALWAYS illegal to hit a child. There MAY be a defence of ‘reasonable chastisement’ taking into account such matters as (a) the age of the child; (b) the place on their body where the child was hit; (c) whether the hitting hand was open-handed or a fist, and (d) the amount of force applied. Having a defence to a crime does not however mean that no crime was committed.

Examples on government websites specifically state that an open-handed gentle blow to a child’s bottom might be considered reasonable, but the same gentle open-handed blow to the child’s HEAD would be the criminal offence of assault.

Bearing in mind here that the child is a baby and the blow was to the head, it does not satisfy the test of being reasonable and therefore your husband has committed the criminal offence of assault against your baby and he does not have a valid defence.

What you do next is up to you, but certainly I would inform the police and social services so that this incident is on record. Whether you stay with him or not there may be further issues.

When making the report, I would stress that the blow was to the baby’s head. If police fail to take that seriously, then they have incorrect knowledge of the law (quite common with police incidentally). But my guess is that they will take it seriously and at least give your DH a caution, which hopefully will make him less likely to assault babies in future.

What would I do? I’d make sure I had a written record (text message? Email?) from DH in which he admits that he hit the baby in the head. Then I’d show that to the police and divorce him asap and go for 100% custody and occupancy, which I would likely get. I know women who have achieved 100% custody in situations less serious than this, and the husband wasn’t allowed back to the child’s house despite being joint owner. It’s all about who has the best lawyer, frankly.

The worst possible thing you could do would be to ignore this.

I wish you well.

Lunarpsychobitch · 11/07/2022 18:15

I honestly couldn't justify a way back after this or trust him. How do you know it's the first time? It might just be the first time he's been caught...
So sorry you're going through this :(

User310 · 11/07/2022 18:12

@CanaryShoulderedThorn

It would be a lot less though and it’s not really for 16 years, it’s more whilst OP,s child is small and vulnerable with no voice.

CanaryShoulderedThorn · 11/07/2022 18:09

Nanny0gg · 11/07/2022 16:20

He'll have unsupervised access if she leaves him

The OP is most definitely between a rock and a hard place.

He will also have unsupervised access if she stays. She can't be there 24/7 for the next 16years.

User310 · 11/07/2022 18:09

There is absolutely no way I would leave in this situation.

I would hope and prey it was a one off, I would absolutely make my position clear and assure my husband I would leave the country if I had to if he ever did anything remotely violent against my child again.

I really don’t think leaving your two year old alone (access) with a dad that loses his temper ‘is having your child’s back’. Having your child’s back, is being present and available to protect them if the need arises (this isn’t a situation where the OP is in danger and it is not a regular occurrence for child).

for those who think social services are going to stop contact over one slap, you are deluded!! There are children under strict supervision from SS who are being killed by their parents.

CanaryShoulderedThorn · 11/07/2022 18:07

How are you feeling now OP? Hope you are ok and have got things sorted in your mind.

TrashPandas · 11/07/2022 17:10

You're right Nanny0gg. But for people who are abused as children, the trauma from their non-abusive parent standing by and letting it happen can be almost as bad as the trauma from the abuse itself. Now if this is a one off then the child will likely have no memory of it at all, but if (as seems likely) the husband will do it again... the OP will need to answer questions from her son in the future.

Nanny0gg · 11/07/2022 16:20

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 11/07/2022 01:15

Well done on your getting your DS and yourself out of there. And stay out. Or get him out.

His gaslighting/behaviour afterwards tells you that he knows it was wrong but he's trying to cover it up.

Have you asked him if he's ever done while you HAVEN'T been there?

This is over. Protect your son. Bollox to all the 'oh but if he attends anger management/therapy' stuff. Divorce him.

If he can lose his temper around a two-year old, what will happen as they get older?

He'll have unsupervised access if she leaves him

The OP is most definitely between a rock and a hard place.

ladydoris · 11/07/2022 15:24

Was it a minor event? Women are often fussed about when they get upset. Would you normally leave your house in the middle of the night for a "minor incident." Knowing what you know about the law but nevertheless taking the step to remove yourself from the situation? Methink you were so in shock that you cannot admit to yourself what really occured. Even if it was minor it stopped being minor the minute he opened his mouth. Again. My grandma left my grandpa 70 years ago for a "smack" on her dear child. 70 years ago corporal punishment was everywhere even at schools. She had a hunch. She was right. You have a hunch OP, trust yourself. Take actions that are relevant but in this situation were you were gaslighted make sure that you trust your gut instinct. All the best OP.

alphapie · 11/07/2022 15:16

RealBecca · 11/07/2022 15:11

I'd split on the basis that

  1. DS will know you were in his corner
  2. If you dont then his excuse has been validated and could escalate, especially as he is justifying it so could become a tip of an iceberg.
  3. He isnt saying he wants to avoid that style of discipline on the future. He says it was acceptable because XYZ and you disagree.

Report so the concern is on file. Then find an angle to minimise time he spends with DS alone. Perhaps you give him Saturday for days out (where he cant react that way in public) or tea with your son with you upstairs or out with grandparents or macdonalds. Try not to let on you are doing it and make it appear you are giving him what he wants by way if access. But having less time with DS means he has less time to react and he may do better playing disney dad and avoiding tantrums.

The issue is with your last paragraph is Op has no control over this, her DH can and most likely would go for 50:50 and get it. She can't control that he only gets their child for a day out in public.

RealBecca · 11/07/2022 15:11

I'd split on the basis that

  1. DS will know you were in his corner
  2. If you dont then his excuse has been validated and could escalate, especially as he is justifying it so could become a tip of an iceberg.
  3. He isnt saying he wants to avoid that style of discipline on the future. He says it was acceptable because XYZ and you disagree.

Report so the concern is on file. Then find an angle to minimise time he spends with DS alone. Perhaps you give him Saturday for days out (where he cant react that way in public) or tea with your son with you upstairs or out with grandparents or macdonalds. Try not to let on you are doing it and make it appear you are giving him what he wants by way if access. But having less time with DS means he has less time to react and he may do better playing disney dad and avoiding tantrums.

alphapie · 11/07/2022 15:08

PatientlyWaiting21 · 11/07/2022 15:02

Where do you stay? It’s illegal to hit a child in Scotland, and I think England is also bringing in the same laws do your husband doesn’t have a leg to stand on.

The OP has already said they're in England, so her DH has a leg to stand on.

Unless you think laws are brought in and then everyone who has ever committed the new crime is arrested and charged after the fact

PatientlyWaiting21 · 11/07/2022 15:02

Where do you stay? It’s illegal to hit a child in Scotland, and I think England is also bringing in the same laws do your husband doesn’t have a leg to stand on.

Aquilegia23 · 11/07/2022 14:58

georgarina · 11/07/2022 10:58

Your DH is grieving and overwhelmed. He lightly slapped the top of your 2yo's head, not hard enough to hurt.

It's obviously not a good thing to do, but to talk about splitting up and SS and zero contact is insanity.

This sounds like a good starting point for your DH to work on anger management and staying calm, maybe parenting classes? But to act like he's some unforgivable monster for this is way OTT.

I agree with this. A complete overreaction on the part of OP. Only on Mumsnet do women leave a partner because of a minor incident. It wasn't a great reaction to being head butted but it's not a LTB scenario.
Move on. If it's a regular occurrence then that's different, but as far as I can see it was a one off. The husband probably tried to turn it against the OP out of guilt.

alphapie · 11/07/2022 14:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FrancescaContini · 11/07/2022 14:46

alphapie · 11/07/2022 14:24

@FrancescaContini your ignorance isn't my issue tbh, as many other posters have detailed, this is not a police or SS matter, nothing will be done as he hasn't broken the law, and SS won't be able to see a long term risk of harm as the mother is a protective factor.

Just because you don't understand what's legal and what's not doesn't change the facts in this case.

I find you very arrogant. I also dislike how you’ve minimised what the father did to his small child: you use the word “hit” as you dislike “whacked” and “walloped”.

Hitting a child on the head is…hitting a child on the head. In what circumstances could this be considered “reasonable”, as per your previous post?

Are you an apologist for adults physically assaulting small children?

ThreeLittleDots · 11/07/2022 14:38

I agree with FrancescaContini

It is never reasonable to hit anyone on the head. It is not pointless telling the child's HV, GP, NSPCC or even SS directly, as whilst the act was not illegal or actionable, from a child protection perspective the mother needs to be seen to be taking it seriously as she has already done by removing the child from the father.

Nobody knows how hard the hit / slap was. Nobody knows if this was an initial incident. Nobody knows if it will happen again.

If there were any further instances, SS may deem the mother to not be putting the child's needs first, especially if they felt in any way that she didn't take the first incident seriously.

I'm speaking from lived experience of knowing a child that was temporarily removed from her mother because the mother wanted to continue the relationship with the person who hit her child. We all thought it was the first time, but she had many old fractures that showed up on x-ray.