Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour has an OW

109 replies

tryingtohelpbutprobabyfailing · 10/07/2022 20:28

My lovely 67 year old neighbour has a wife and 2 children.

At 42 she was diagnosed with severe MS . Had been diagnosed with MS in her 30s..

At age 55 her husband could no longer cope as her problem is with swallowing. She went into a specialist nursing home. He visits everyday without fail. No holiday for ten years as cannot not visit..

Two years ago he met a woman at the home whose husband was in a similar situation. Long story short they have now formed a relationship. Things have now moved in to such a degree that they want to live together.

Kids know if the relationship and are civil, polite but not exactly welcoming . (Kids from both sides - she also has 2) they are all in their 20/30s ..

All are against it - despite both spouses now having very much reduced cognitive function..

I don't know how long her husband has been Ill but my neighbour has been a carer for over 30 years .. lost his 30s 40s 50s and most of his 60s to this disease ..

The kids say NO ! till death do you part ...

I say 'you only have one life and you need to enjoy it ...

What does MN say ? (In case people don't know - MS (multiple sclerosis) it will NEVER get better ...

OP posts:
EmmaH2022 · 11/07/2022 10:31

tryingtohelpbutprobabyfailing · 10/07/2022 20:41

I haven't actually'butted in' .. my neighbour asked what I thought .. I say that he deserved a happy life .. he has gone beyond what anyone would normally expect..

When he confided in you, I bet he wasn't expecting to end up on a public forum that's regularly used as tabloid fodder.

TitInATrance · 11/07/2022 10:28

It’s not the children’s business, or ours, or yours.

It’s for the people involved to decide, and that does mean he should discuss the situation with his wife.

Itsbackagain · 11/07/2022 10:24

At the age of 50 my DP is currently having to help me a lot due to medical issues. I do not at this point, expect him to find someone who will give him what I can't given we are still active. In the situation you described I think he definitely deserves some freedom and outing and company and this is the only circumstance I would accept 'infidelity'. You don't know what's round the corner so tell him to grab some happiness whilst he can.

WhenIgrowolder · 11/07/2022 10:15

I know I'd want my husband to be happy if I was in the same situation. I wouldn't expect him to put his life on hold for possibly years. Medical advances are great but they keep people alive for too long sometimes when their quality of life is awful.

Your neighbour should not feel guilty at all.

EarringsandLipstick · 11/07/2022 09:45

It IS my 'business' if the party concerned ASKS ME for an opinion .

Yes, your 'business' to offer your opinion.

Not to share it with MN to ask theirs.

Others have said why is if different to all the other MN posts about other people - it's because in this case, OP has no connection with the actual situation - she's completely outside it & only an observer as distinct to sharing something going on in her own life.

Every supportive post is seen as some kind of validation of her neighbour's choice, quite dramatically.

The neighbour isn't doing anything wrong but my heart breaks for the kids.

And I still think it's wrong to post another family's situation on an forum like this without permission or some connection

SallyWD · 11/07/2022 09:22

I think there's nothing wrong with it and I feel very sad that they all find themselves in this situation

tryingtohelpbutprobabyfailing · 11/07/2022 09:19

craftsupplyhoarder · 10/07/2022 22:10

I'd find it very difficult, if I were one of the adult children in this situation, to be happy or welcoming of this new relationship. Personally, I don't think I could bring myself to have a relationship with another man while still married to my husband, even if he were no longer himself. Impossible to say for certain, but that's how I feel now. It feels wrong to me. But ultimately, it's none of your business.

For about the umpteenth time !
It IS my 'business' if the party concerned ASKS ME for an opinion .

I am on an anonymous forum , I've NC and changed some identifying info but not the situation. So if your 'holier than thou ' attitude could take a break for five minutes perhaps you could simply give your opinion to a moral dilemma without adding the entirely pointless 'myob' motif ..

OP posts:
Bunty55 · 11/07/2022 01:20

My neighbour has been married for over 50 years. His wife is lovely and we are fond of them both. i have known them for about 15 years and we have always got on well with both of them She has vascular dementia. It was diagnosed abut two years ago and she is declining but is still able to go to the shops and garden and clean the house.
Its the day to day living that is the tough part. There is no conversation between them. He can't talk to her about anything other than what needs doing in the house etc.
She has been like this for a long time really. If I talk to her I make the conversation easy as she sort of glazes over. We talk about the bins, and pass parcels if they are delivered, and we smile at my grandsons antics.
You could not talk to her about politics or anything that happens on our street - she does not have opinions any more.
I know he struggles. If I knock on their door he will keep me talking about anything after we have discussed the original topic. You can see he is frustrated and probably lonely.
He has said some quite suggestive things to me which he would not say in front of her, and if I thank him for doing something he will always try to hug and kiss me.
He has hinted that he sees other women. I pretend I haven't heard or understood on those occasions, I do not want to know, and I do not want to be made complicit
Every so often he goes off for a couple of days on the premise that he is attending to something for his son. I have a feeling he sees someone on those days away. It is none of my business of course and eventually he won't be able to leave her in the house on her own.
It's not my place to judge and none of my business, but it is all very sad.

Blossomtoes · 11/07/2022 01:15

Plogeggio · 10/07/2022 20:56

All I know is that if I imagine me and my husband being in this situation in 20 year' time, I absolutely would want him to find comfort with someone else, and he would deserve to have someone who was capable of loving him back, so I'd absolutely be okay with this.

This 1000%.

Nat6999 · 11/07/2022 01:05

Some people don't understand how having a life limiting disease can change someone. My exh was diagnosed with MS when we had only been married less than 18 months, I was also pregnant with ds. His diagnosis completely changed our future, I had been planning on not going back to work after having ds, exh had to stop work as the job he did he could have killed someone if he had a spasm, overnight I became a carer which at 37 wasn't something I had been planning in the near future. Our lives became a long list of appointments, we couldn't plan anything as we didn't know when he was going to have a relapse. For the first time we were having to rely on state benefits, we had no security. Exh had gone from being fit & doing a hard manual job to being unable to dress himself or walk, he had emotional meltdowns, one day he was trying to put something on a shelf in our utility room, his brain wouldn't tell him to put it on the top shelf which was empty, he threw everything off the shelf out of the door & collapsed on the floor crying. I was having to cope with a new baby, pnd & a 42 year old toddler, right down to him wetting himself & being unable to get to the toilet. It took him having a massive relapse & being admitted to hospital for me to admit to myself I couldn't cope & I left him 6 weeks after he was discharged.

userxx · 11/07/2022 00:42

Tricky situation. Sometimes you have to find happiness where you can, life is short.

AcrossthePond55 · 11/07/2022 00:34

I think my personal feeling is that I wouldn't judge the 'healthy' spouse in this situation for seeking 'companionship', but I think that as long as there are children (even adult children) of the 'ailing' spouse who object, living together should be off the table. It just feels, I don't know, too 'in their faces' with their mother so terribly ill. I know I wouldn't move someone in in your neighbour's situation.

In actuality, if the neighbour asked me if his companion should move in, I'd keep my mouth shut and not offer an opinion. I'd just tell him that it is a decision he must make on his own without the opinions of others clouding his own thoughts and feelings. Sometimes we just have to stand on our own two feet.

MeanderingGently · 10/07/2022 23:52

Personally, I'm another one who thinks marriage vows don't cease when someone becomes unwell.
I can't understand why having an OW is seen as "being OK" when one person is in care....surely that's the point where the ill spouse needs support?

I can, however, see that it may seem different when the illness has gone on for years, or if the ill spouse no longer even knows who their partner is. And the caring spouse certainly needs support, and may well find things easier if there's someone who is going through the same situation, and who can therefore understand.

But I think I would feel betrayed if I thought my partner was seeing someone else while I was living my last days in care. And if I were an adult child and this were my parents, I'd be horrified.

If a neighbour had asked me such a question, I would be saying that these were my own views, but I couldn't speak for anyone else as the situation is not only sad but complicated. Neither would I be prepared to somehow 'validate' another's views nor appear to be giving some sort of permission, by saying whether I thought it OK or not.

justasking111 · 10/07/2022 23:39

I'm just grateful I haven't had to face this yet. Our parents died suddenly. So an easy passing for them.

I have seen adult children turn very nasty when a widowed parent gets a second chance at happiness. It's truly unpleasant

bloodyplanes · 10/07/2022 23:38

The kids need to grow up and let their parents have a little bit of happiness.

entropynow · 10/07/2022 23:34

Ownedbymycats · 10/07/2022 23:25

How easy for the children to say marriage is until death.Life is complicated and I've a close relative with MS so know how awful an illness it is.
Presumably they're not doing any harm and are supporting their sick partners. Perhaps their relationship will give them the perspective and strength to mantain this support.

So do I. My uncle was nothing but supportive and loving to his wife of nearly 50 years, whom he married after diagnosis. He never so much as complained

Littleraindrop15 · 10/07/2022 23:33

YOLO means you only live once x

wellhelloitsme · 10/07/2022 23:32

OP however well intentioned you might be, please please please don't show his kids this thread.

Please. Them being adults makes no difference.

You can show him if he's happy you've made it.

This was not their decision and people's responses shouldn't be their burden or add to their already difficult experience of loyalty to both parents being challenged.

Please tell us you won't show them?

entropynow · 10/07/2022 23:31

tryingtohelpbutprobabyfailing · 10/07/2022 20:35

My neighbour has asked me 'am I a 'cad' ' (old fashioned word but I understand the meaning .. he wants to o or if what he wants is 'ok'

Yes, he is. But apparently dipping your wick is more important than keeping your promises on mn

Ownedbymycats · 10/07/2022 23:25

How easy for the children to say marriage is until death.Life is complicated and I've a close relative with MS so know how awful an illness it is.
Presumably they're not doing any harm and are supporting their sick partners. Perhaps their relationship will give them the perspective and strength to mantain this support.

DarkShade · 10/07/2022 23:06

Jesus Christ I've just read that update - OP for the love of God do not show the kids this thread.

It's about their mum. They really really don't care what MN thinks.

DarkShade · 10/07/2022 23:05

It's only unfaithful if the wife would mind. That is the question he should ask. I would not at all mind of DP had a new relationship in these circumstances. I wouldn't want to limit my partner in that way. Love should be a strength, not a cage.

Nancydrawn · 10/07/2022 22:35

Do not show them this thread.

If this were my mother, and my neighbour had been posting about it on the internet and then rushed over to tell me that my feelings were invalid because she had shared personal details on an internet forum, I would not be comforted. I would be incensed.

ManateeFair · 10/07/2022 22:23

It’s nobody’s business but theirs.

ThinWomansBrain · 10/07/2022 22:22

The neighbour asking for OPs reassurance does involve her?
As a philosophical "where do you stand on this?", I think it's an interesting question - and frankly I'd rather this that someone lazily posting a link to the daily fail (especially where it is just a link and no personal input or thoughts from the poster) and hoping that everyone will have a bun fight.

Must be a horrendously difficult situation for your neighbour, particulalry with the attitude of his arsey selfish children - in your position OP I would show some empathy and support.