Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want BIL and SIL to have the children if we die?

135 replies

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:26

They are really lovely people, but they don’t live locally, meaning if we died DCs would have to undergo a change of school, etc. they also have two young children themselves.

To me, my brother is the better option. He does struggle with self care as he has minor LDs, but could manage with support which could be provided with money he’d get if we died.

AIBU?

OP posts:
altiara · 10/07/2022 20:46

From these choices, I would chose BIL/SIL as you’ve said they’re lovely people - I am also going to assume that they are good parents that share similar values as you’ve not mentioned they haven’t versus a non-parent that can’t look after themselves but you think they would step up if they had your children. I’d actually think the opposite, the responsibility may not be right for your brother even with some help around the house.

PinkBuffalo · 10/07/2022 20:44

Yabu
This sounds odd
my sister died suddenly very young leaving her very young daughter
I probably similar to you brother “additional needs” putting it mildly
My sister knew this and when she was admitted to hospital had her friend (with kids) take her little girl to stay with them and she now lives with her dad
I was SO relieved and grateful her friend had her little girl. Especially as she was a mum so could look after appropriately. I love my niece immensely but would have no idea how to look after her especially as I was heavily shocked myself and in no state to look after myself at the time

DockOTheBay · 10/07/2022 20:43

I agree that you're letting your own experience cloud your judgement. I understand that you would have liked to stay in your own home but it is not the most important thing.

bellac11 · 10/07/2022 20:42

If this is serious OP, what effect do you think it might have on them if they lose their parents, then have substandard, confusing care by someone with LD and then get moved by social services/the family courts to your in laws after all that

More instability and a confusing experience of being parented.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 10/07/2022 20:42

Obviously YABU.

IncompleteSenten · 10/07/2022 20:41

I don't think it's as simple as that. Social services may decide that your brother is not an appropriate choice.

chipsandpeas · 10/07/2022 20:41

assuming this is true and not a reverse, your wishes of who gets your children is just a preference, not a guarantee - if its felt your DB cant care for them he might not get them, chances are social work will get involved and decide who gets the children

Fladdermus · 10/07/2022 20:41

Your plan is fair to neither your children or your brother and you run the risk of your children ending up in care.

Discovereads · 10/07/2022 20:41

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:34

@Bussty thats absolutely not why I want my brother to step in.

My mother died as a child and I lost everything - my home and room and stability. I don’t want that for my children, strangely enough. I can’t completely make it OK for them, but I know my preference would be to stay in my own home.

I’m so sorry you lost your mum as a child. I don’t think staying in your old home could have made it less traumatic though because it’s such an overwhelming loss all by itself. And have you really deeply thought about how your DC would feel about your brother moving into their house, sleeping in your bedroom, sitting on your sofa? It won’t feel like their home to them because you won’t be there.

RandomMess · 10/07/2022 20:40

It doesn't have to be family!

What about good friends that would be able to move locally?

NotMyDayJob · 10/07/2022 20:39

My understanding is (and it might be wrong so happy to be corrected) is that regardless of your wishes social services will have a view and they may deem your brother with mild LD who can't look after himself properly unsuitable.

I am truly very sorry for your loss as a child, but I'm suggesting gently it's clouding your view on this issue

Quartz2208 · 10/07/2022 20:39

yes of course you are - changing school is nothing. People do it all the time - if the worse does happen (and lets hope it doesnt) then the stability of your SIL and BIL and cousins will be of paramount importance.

As opposed to your brother will lack of self care

wibblywobblybits · 10/07/2022 20:39

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:26

They are really lovely people, but they don’t live locally, meaning if we died DCs would have to undergo a change of school, etc. they also have two young children themselves.

To me, my brother is the better option. He does struggle with self care as he has minor LDs, but could manage with support which could be provided with money he’d get if we died.

AIBU?

Are you being serious? You'd rather they went to your brother who can't even clean himself than your brother and sister in law - just because they live further away? What planet are you on

CredibilityProblem · 10/07/2022 20:39

This sounds like the set up to a 1950s children's novel.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 10/07/2022 20:38

Will your brother be ok safe guarding them? Keeping an eye out for social pressure as they hit their teen years? Teaching them financial planning? Explaining puberty and sex? Discussing appropriate relationships?

DockOTheBay · 10/07/2022 20:38

I definitely don't think a man with learning difficulties who struggles with self care would be a suitable guardian. Would he be emotionally available to help the children through such a difficult time? Would he have a choice in the matter and understand what he is signing up to - what he is REALLY signing up to e.g. the possibility of two children going through awful grief and being responsible for them for life.

I think your brother and sister in law sound like a much better prospect, for a start there are two of them to share the burden, they are already parents and are able to look after children.

Bussty · 10/07/2022 20:38

Not to mention, you don't actually get to decide - if you die, the court decides and they don't have to do what you want them to. It's highly unlikely they'd place your DCs with your brother over SIL and BIL even if you did say you wanted that.

Floella22 · 10/07/2022 20:37

Me and dh have plenty of siblings between us.
I wouldn’t have left dc with any of them.
We appointed my bf and her dh as guardians if we died because their values and the way they were raising their own dc was most in line with ours.

Johnnysgirl · 10/07/2022 20:37

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:26

They are really lovely people, but they don’t live locally, meaning if we died DCs would have to undergo a change of school, etc. they also have two young children themselves.

To me, my brother is the better option. He does struggle with self care as he has minor LDs, but could manage with support which could be provided with money he’d get if we died.

AIBU?

Is this a serious post? Hmm

Bussty · 10/07/2022 20:37

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:34

@Bussty thats absolutely not why I want my brother to step in.

My mother died as a child and I lost everything - my home and room and stability. I don’t want that for my children, strangely enough. I can’t completely make it OK for them, but I know my preference would be to stay in my own home.

If you say so... 🙄

If you and your DH die (touch wood) then your DCs won't have stability, will they? How does being looked after by someone who won't look after you properly provide "stability" in any way, shape or form?

Discovereads · 10/07/2022 20:36

I think then losing everything familiar to them - their home, school, neighbours, bedrooms - would be hugely traumatic on the top of an already traumatic event. And having to share their home with their cousins, who they aren’t close to because of the distance.

You really cannot know this. Many orphans actually like having a fresh start in a new place with no familiar places to cause distressing memories. Like seeing the same school gate your mum or dad picked you up by or playground you played on…is a constant reminder of your loss.

PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 20:35

You can’t actually be serious?

TeenDivided · 10/07/2022 20:34

It doesn't sound to me as if your DB would be able to cope with 2 bereaved children.
What about wider family or friends?

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:34

@Bussty thats absolutely not why I want my brother to step in.

My mother died as a child and I lost everything - my home and room and stability. I don’t want that for my children, strangely enough. I can’t completely make it OK for them, but I know my preference would be to stay in my own home.

OP posts:
Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:33

@AllFreeOwls - not quite. I think the use of a FT nanny / housekeeper would be what he’d need. There would be a fairly substantial sum.

I am certainly not planning to speak to anyone and outline my misgivings about the care they might provide if we died, I don’t think that’s a great idea.

OP posts: