Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want BIL and SIL to have the children if we die?

135 replies

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:26

They are really lovely people, but they don’t live locally, meaning if we died DCs would have to undergo a change of school, etc. they also have two young children themselves.

To me, my brother is the better option. He does struggle with self care as he has minor LDs, but could manage with support which could be provided with money he’d get if we died.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:13

@PurpleDaisies from anywhere really. He’d need support in keeping the house (cleaner) and probably support in childcare (he does work) and so on.

It is something we’d discuss if I did decide that he was our best option. I am very aware that I can’t assume his cooperation except I sort of can … we are close and he’s certainly more helpful on a day to day basis than BIL, and the children know him better and are more comfortable with him.

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 21:12

Its quite disappointing how prejudiced some of these remarks are

Its not prejudice. It’s judging on the information you’ve given that he would need support to look after your children if they went to him.

GibbonsGoatsGibbons · 10/07/2022 21:12

You need to think about who would be best placed to care for traumatised & grieving children & love them through potentially harmful behaviour. all while (presumably) grieving themselves

From your description your brother would struggle

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:10

@alphapie - he has no formally diagnosed LDs.

Im sure you know that LDs covers a vast area, absolutely huge. And that many people with LDs parent just fine without any intervention from SS. Or do you honestly believe every parent with any learning disability is grilled extensively by SS before being permitted to parent?

Its quite disappointing how prejudiced some of these remarks are.

OP posts:
GetThatHelmetOn · 10/07/2022 21:10

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:33

@AllFreeOwls - not quite. I think the use of a FT nanny / housekeeper would be what he’d need. There would be a fairly substantial sum.

I am certainly not planning to speak to anyone and outline my misgivings about the care they might provide if we died, I don’t think that’s a great idea.

This is not the movies, it is not like your executor will contact your selected relative to let them know they have inherited your children.

You need to talk to them, check that they agree after discussing the implications or look for someone else if they don’t.

Also, what makes you think that nannies, who are employed and can come and go as their circumstances/expectations change are going to be ok with becoming the primary carer of your kids with an unreliable adult as their boss???

AllFreeOwls · 10/07/2022 21:08

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:33

@AllFreeOwls - not quite. I think the use of a FT nanny / housekeeper would be what he’d need. There would be a fairly substantial sum.

I am certainly not planning to speak to anyone and outline my misgivings about the care they might provide if we died, I don’t think that’s a great idea.

I'm not saying you need to outline your misgivings, but I would have thought checking that either of those parties are willing and able to step in if necessary would bea sensible idea.

If I'm reading this correctly you seem to have decided that your DB will move into your house and bring up your children. He deserves the opportunity to be consulted on this.

However you seem to have decided that you are not bring unreasonable and not open to the possibility he may not be the best choice.

PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 21:07

There is no reason whatsoever on the surface why my brother wouldn’t be suitable or why SS would intervene or question this decision

You’ve said he struggles with some self care and would need support to parent. That would be an issue SS would be concerned about.

what is this support you keep talking about and where do you think it would come from?

alphapie · 10/07/2022 21:07

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:03

No one is getting ‘worked up.’ I’m simply wondering what others think. I realise that you don’t know the characters involved.

There is no reason whatsoever on the surface why my brother wouldn’t be suitable or why SS would intervene or question this decision

His LD alone would be reason they would be involved. And not being able to take care of himself would be case closed. If your brother had children of his own he would have SS involvement. They won't allow children to go to an unsuitable home, and that's what this would be, based on how you described it.

And you're likely trying to downplay tbh so it's probably worse in reality.

CorvusPurpureus · 10/07/2022 21:06

Ok, well, it's a worry.

When my dc were tiny, the options would have been: my db (we aren't close); my dbil & dsil (no kids of their own); my bff & her dh (reciprocal agreement, both families had young kids).

In the last decade ALL of those people have experienced huge changes in their family situations. Divorces, new marriages, new babies etc etc. Sadly, I would no longer trust my oldest friend with a house plant, given her choice of second husband.

The thing you really need to be aware of is that your wishes are not the end of the process here.

Assuming db AND dbil/dsil both express willingness to take on your dc, social services will decide who is best able to look after them. Your opinion will not be all that important, because, well, you'll be dead.

If you can agree whilst you're alive on an option with the dc's dad AND the putative guardian(s), then yes, that is probably what will happen. No guarantees, though.

How likely are you & their father to perish unexpectedly together & within the next few years, though? RTAs aside, a far likelier scenario is one of you surviving & parenting as a widow, so I would focus on the financial ramifications of that.

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:05

It’s not strictly accurate that he ‘can’t’ look after himself, more that he doesn’t. I can’t say it’s a choice as that’s misleading but if he had a partner I think he’d be able to parent reasonably well with support. It’s the support he would need.

OP posts:
Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:03

No one is getting ‘worked up.’ I’m simply wondering what others think. I realise that you don’t know the characters involved.

There is no reason whatsoever on the surface why my brother wouldn’t be suitable or why SS would intervene or question this decision

OP posts:
RandomMess · 10/07/2022 21:02

I had guardianship pass over to friends on the understanding that I did not expect them to raise my 3 DC but expected them to make the best decision for me DC at the time which could well have been adoption/long term foster care.

Chikapu · 10/07/2022 21:00

How are you so sure your brother would want the responsibility of them? If he can't look after himself then it would be massively unfair on them to live with him.

alphapie · 10/07/2022 21:00

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:48

They are lovely people but I don’t know them particularly well and I do think trying to parent four children, two of whom will have lost everything, is too much. That’s about the gist of it really. I’m a bit lost as to what’s odd about that - it’s not something anyone really wants to think about but I do believe my brother can offer more stability if only because he isn’t tied to an area in the way BIL is.

You are aware you don't just get to decide this and it's set in stone right? Social services would be involved and they wouldn't allow children to be placed with someone who can't look after themselves when more suitable family is available.

So there isn't much use getting to worked up over this

Augend23 · 10/07/2022 21:00

I don't think not being tied to a particular area is a bad thing - the deal was always that my uncle who didn't have kids (and then me once I was 18), would be guardian for the children (including me pre-18) precisely because we could move wherever was best for the children. My other uncle has kids but/so wouldn't have been able to give up his current life for us.

However, I think it is made different by the point that they struggle with self care - though it really does depend on the specifics of what you mean by this. They would have lost their sibling too at this point and that might make them worse. If what you mean is - a bit disorganised and not great at keeping on top of the house then you're right that could be remedied with a housekeeper. If you mean can't manage their own medications/financial affairs, that's a totally different ball game

I have no learning difficulties but I do struggle to keep on top of the house - so I pay someone to facilitate that for me. I don't always find it easy to be organised enough to pick out what I'm cooking - so I have automated my shopping lists so I can just click two buttons and a week's worth of food turns up. Would your brother be able to put in place the mechanisms to manage things that weren't his strengths himself, or would he need someone else to? That would be the key question for me. He'd be having to be strong for multiple people and that can be a hard task for anyone - especially someone on their own who doesn't have a partner (whose family hasn't just hypothetically died) to lean on.

alphapie · 10/07/2022 20:58

YABU big time, also I highly doubt social services would allow this to happen anyway.

They'd be removed and given to more suitable family members

Fenella123 · 10/07/2022 20:56

OP, presumably whoever you're considering as guardians don't have two spare bedrooms NOW. They would most likely have to use some of the money you and DH bequeathed to buy a house to adequately house your DC plus their existing family. There would be no reason why the DC's bedrooms couldn't be very similar to their original bedrooms.
Could you even fund an extra room so that your DC could keep more things from their old home than just a suitcase or two of mementos?

Seriously - good for you for considering this.

Yes, it's very unlikely, especially these days, that kids will lose both parents at once. But I do know someone who lost both their parents within a year in their early teens. They ended up in the indifferent and questionable care of male relatives who didn't want them, the effects were lifelong.

Love and stability are what you're looking for, and TBH why are you not looking at close local friends who have a similar parenting style?

2pinkginsplease · 10/07/2022 20:54

I think you need to go back to the drawing board. By the sound of things your brother would need a lot of support to care for your children. If he can’t look after himself properly having 2 bereaved children will be difficult.

we have 4 siblings between us and our children wouldn’t have been going to any of them, my best friend and her dh would be the ones stepping up and caring for our children.

ChubbyButt · 10/07/2022 20:53

You've said your brother would only cope because of the money your death would provide in terms of additional childcare etc so surely the exactly same would apply to SIL and BIL - or would you somehow intend to prevent that if they were the guardians?

PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 20:53

Don’t you think they’re good parents to their children?

ChubbyButt · 10/07/2022 20:51

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:48

They are lovely people but I don’t know them particularly well and I do think trying to parent four children, two of whom will have lost everything, is too much. That’s about the gist of it really. I’m a bit lost as to what’s odd about that - it’s not something anyone really wants to think about but I do believe my brother can offer more stability if only because he isn’t tied to an area in the way BIL is.

Surely two currently functioning parents of two children are far more likely to cope with an additional two children than a single man with learning difficulties who can't look after himself? Even just mathematically, either option is two children per adult, but one option that adult has learning difficulties and struggles with self-care and the other option that's not the case.

Your proposal makes zero sense at all.

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:49

To be clear here @Kite22 i don’t think anyone in this scenario will be a ‘good parent.’ it is ‘which option is the least worst.’

OP posts:
Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:48

They are lovely people but I don’t know them particularly well and I do think trying to parent four children, two of whom will have lost everything, is too much. That’s about the gist of it really. I’m a bit lost as to what’s odd about that - it’s not something anyone really wants to think about but I do believe my brother can offer more stability if only because he isn’t tied to an area in the way BIL is.

OP posts:
DockOTheBay · 10/07/2022 20:48

Your brother would also be grieving your loss and having to look after children in that state could be overwhelming.

Kite22 · 10/07/2022 20:46

I'm not sure AIBU is the best place to ask this.

But, as you have, I think - from the little you have told us - that you are proposing something very strange.
Why would you think that someone who is not even able to take care of themselves would make a good parent for two small traumatised dc ? Confused

There is nothing about that decision that makes sense.