Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want BIL and SIL to have the children if we die?

135 replies

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:26

They are really lovely people, but they don’t live locally, meaning if we died DCs would have to undergo a change of school, etc. they also have two young children themselves.

To me, my brother is the better option. He does struggle with self care as he has minor LDs, but could manage with support which could be provided with money he’d get if we died.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:33

People with depression become parents all the time - I’ve had depression myself. I think I’d best hide the thread. This weird insistence that SS are waiting in the wings to take children from their own families is bizarre and wrong.

OP posts:
LivingDeadGirlUK · 10/07/2022 21:32

Is there no one else? You keep saying your brother would need support but you have listed basic hygiene and home keeping as areas he isn't capable in. Would your brother actually WANT to be their guardian? It's very different to giving a helping hand from time to time.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 10/07/2022 21:31

do you not think your brother will ever have children?

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:31

Have to say, for all the muttering about what a ‘weird’ thread this is (it is?) I’m finding the aggression in some of the posts really, really weird.

Yes, MN. People who have autism parent.

OP posts:
Mellowyellow222 · 10/07/2022 21:31

My goodness you must see that your brother is not an ideal candidate to care for young children?

you talk about family support - what support would he have?

he suffers from depression and on occasions can’t keep the house clean and won’t shower. Would he be emotionally robust enough to parent teenagers? Would he be able to talk to schools, navigate their intense grief, deal with their emotions? It sounds like he struggles with his own.

it sounds like a bad idea.

alphapie · 10/07/2022 21:31

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:30

I think DH views BIL as the better choice because he already has children, while to me that is what makes them not ideal. Understandably they will prioritise their own children.

My brother is far from perfect, but we are close and he adores the children. It’s a shame the two can’t be merged in a way.

At any rate it hopefully won’t be needed!

But it doesn't matter who you think is more suitable, in the end it won't be solely your decision (thankfully) they will be assessed and your brother most likely won't be deemed the most suitable

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:30

I think DH views BIL as the better choice because he already has children, while to me that is what makes them not ideal. Understandably they will prioritise their own children.

My brother is far from perfect, but we are close and he adores the children. It’s a shame the two can’t be merged in a way.

At any rate it hopefully won’t be needed!

OP posts:
itsjustnotok · 10/07/2022 21:30

@Veggiesintheground stop!!! Just stop! You’re trying to justify your decision but the more you say the more I wonder if you really are being serious!?. Poor timekeeping, possible depression and an avoidance to keep clean and you’re more worried about moving schools and homes rather than the fact that your children could end up with someone who struggles with the demands on his own life as it stands right now. It comes across as though you just don’t want to consider BIL/SIL and are using any excuse. With 2 kids they know the importance of timekeeping, routines etc. you blatantly seem intent on selecting your brother . The worst thing is you haven’t even bothered to have a conversation with anyone.

Luredbyapomegranate · 10/07/2022 21:24

I’m very sorry for your loss as a child.

SS will make the decision, with input from your kids if old enough, so there’s no point in doing any more than gathering your options. But from your comments saying that you think your bro could parent if he had a partner, which I presume he doesn’t, plus the self care issues would probably make them favour another option.

Does your partner disagree with you? Is that why you’re posting?

scoopoftheday · 10/07/2022 21:24

Does it have to be either or?

Why not friends, cousins, other family members?

My friends were going on a flight and the morning of it she handed me a letter, said their insurance details were in there if anything happened. We'd already had loose discussions about stepping in for each others children if needed, but to have that envelope in my hands was scary.

Thankfully their children are now late 20s and early 30s and I was never needed in that way. But had I been, I'd have stepped up.

Ginger1982 · 10/07/2022 21:22

So you want your brother to care for your children but he'd have to hire someone unknown to them to actually care for them? It sounds like a terrible stress on someone who can't look after themselves properly.

But I can understand where you're coming from. You could argue that if DH and I died, his sister and her family would be best placed to provide a 'family' environment for DS, but our wills already stipulate that my mum will have him in that situation as less would require to change for him.

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:21

@Discovereads that really wouldn’t be a problem.

He isn’t tied to an area for work reasons and actually hates where he lives. But that’s all by the by. I’m not expecting to die. If I did, and DH did, I know my brother would be there like a shot. One thing I will say for him is he’s there when you need him.

Things he struggles with are:

Basic housekeeping - it’s very hard to say whether this is down to depression / lack of motivation. Sometimes he’ll have a really good clean but other times it’s bad.

Autism and sensory issues mean he often avoids showers / baths.

Timekeeping isn’t always brilliant. He has been late for work on occasion.

Physical health not great - very susceptible to viruses and so on and can be a bit of a drama llama regarding them; lots of declarations of having ‘flu’ for a cold and so on.

Anyway, I do have to get on but thanks for the replies.

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 21:21

We all need support when parenting.

Its disingenuous to equate that with the kind of support you’ve said your brother would need.

WishILivedInThrushGreen · 10/07/2022 21:21

Discuss this issue with your family then draw up a guardianship with your solicitor.

I wouldn't use your brother if he has self care issues, but what's your alternative?

Fully appreciate that you want your children to stay where they are but in the event of both of your deaths, the children will have to cope.

You can't keep them in your home after your death, you must know that?

Anyway, unlikely to happen.

Technophobic · 10/07/2022 21:20

How long have you got to make a decision?

PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 21:19

You really think a single man who can’t look after himself properly and has no parenting experience would be better because the children wouldn’t have to share bathrooms or move school?

You’ve even said in another post that you don’t think he’d be a good parent.

This is such a weird thread.

alphapie · 10/07/2022 21:19

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:17

@alphapie I don’t think you seem to understand that SS aren’t interested.

As I said to you above, there are plenty of people who would fall into the category of mild (or not so mild) LDs who do manage to parent perfectly well, often with support from their own families.

Trust me on this, it wouldn’t be a SS matter.

We all need support when parenting. MN forms part of that. Our own families and friends. Childcare. Partners. I don’t parent without support.

What do you mean they aren't interested? You don't seem to understand the process at all.

They will be involved if your children need to be placed into a guardianship situation, that's a fact. As that's the process followed in such cases.

Parents aren't always the best at deciding who looks after children, some have named parents who were abusive to them as children, some will ask people with hidden convictions, this is why there are checks in place.

Just because you are ignorant to the facts don't make them less so

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:17

@alphapie I don’t think you seem to understand that SS aren’t interested.

As I said to you above, there are plenty of people who would fall into the category of mild (or not so mild) LDs who do manage to parent perfectly well, often with support from their own families.

Trust me on this, it wouldn’t be a SS matter.

We all need support when parenting. MN forms part of that. Our own families and friends. Childcare. Partners. I don’t parent without support.

OP posts:
Discovereads · 10/07/2022 21:17

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:10

@alphapie - he has no formally diagnosed LDs.

Im sure you know that LDs covers a vast area, absolutely huge. And that many people with LDs parent just fine without any intervention from SS. Or do you honestly believe every parent with any learning disability is grilled extensively by SS before being permitted to parent?

Its quite disappointing how prejudiced some of these remarks are.

It’s not that your brother has a LD, it’s the fact you said his LDs cause him to be unable to even care for himself independently.

I also noted you implied your brother doesn’t live local to you, as you said he is not tied down to an area like BIL is. Are you seriously expecting your brother to give up his home, his job, and his local area? Do you have any idea how hard this is for a person with LDs- even one who isn’t grieving, and doesn’t have two children to care for ?

imperialminty · 10/07/2022 21:17

This is such an emotive conversation. We don’t have kids yet but my fiancé and I have had very emotional conversations about this - he would want any children to go to his Mum as she is 10 years younger than mine and he reasons that means she’ll be around longer. His Mum lives at the opposite end of the country and my Mum is much closer, but also has much more money to be able to care for them.

We’ve never really come to an agreement on this. I have no advice, but I understand your gut feeling of wanting your kids to stay where they know.

ChubbyButt · 10/07/2022 21:15

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:10

@alphapie - he has no formally diagnosed LDs.

Im sure you know that LDs covers a vast area, absolutely huge. And that many people with LDs parent just fine without any intervention from SS. Or do you honestly believe every parent with any learning disability is grilled extensively by SS before being permitted to parent?

Its quite disappointing how prejudiced some of these remarks are.

It's not "prejudiced" to think someone who can't look after themselves can't look after two children. You said your brother "struggle[s] with self care" - do you think he'll find it easier to care for two children and himself or just himself?

Either you're anticipating that your children are going to provide care for your brother, or that the money intending for your children's care is going to subsidise your brother instead, or that your children won't be cared for. None of those are good options for your children - and they're the only options based on what you've said.

AssignedSlytherinAtBirth · 10/07/2022 21:15

YABU. A loving, supportive home with kind and caring parent figures who could help them come to terms with what had happened would be the most important thing, rather than being with your DB. It's unfair on him.

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:15

@GibbonsGoatsGibbons to be honest that’s why I’m inclined to go with my brother. My BIL and his wife are lovely people, but living with them would involve giving up their homes, rooms, schools, sharing bedrooms, sharing close personal space with other children they don’t know well, starting at a new school and having to share the available adults with their own children.

I genuinely don’t feel that is best for grieving children. I acknowledge my brother isn’t perfect but what he can offer is some stability and some consistency.

Anyway, thanks for thoughts - interesting as always.

OP posts:
alphapie · 10/07/2022 21:14

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:13

@PurpleDaisies from anywhere really. He’d need support in keeping the house (cleaner) and probably support in childcare (he does work) and so on.

It is something we’d discuss if I did decide that he was our best option. I am very aware that I can’t assume his cooperation except I sort of can … we are close and he’s certainly more helpful on a day to day basis than BIL, and the children know him better and are more comfortable with him.

Again, do you think SS will think a man who requires a team of staff to maintain a standard of living is the most suitable parent for 2 traumatised children over a couple who do not need this?

What planet are you on

alphapie · 10/07/2022 21:13

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:10

@alphapie - he has no formally diagnosed LDs.

Im sure you know that LDs covers a vast area, absolutely huge. And that many people with LDs parent just fine without any intervention from SS. Or do you honestly believe every parent with any learning disability is grilled extensively by SS before being permitted to parent?

Its quite disappointing how prejudiced some of these remarks are.

They are when being assessed to care for newly orphaned children.

Do you think they just hand children over to whoever parents decide? They investigate beforehand because of the situation of their parents dying.

If you both die SS will be involved, they will check the people or person you have nominated to be guardian, if they fail (which your bother will based on what you have written) the children will go to more suitable family members.

That is the process.