Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want BIL and SIL to have the children if we die?

135 replies

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:26

They are really lovely people, but they don’t live locally, meaning if we died DCs would have to undergo a change of school, etc. they also have two young children themselves.

To me, my brother is the better option. He does struggle with self care as he has minor LDs, but could manage with support which could be provided with money he’d get if we died.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Changechangychange · 10/07/2022 22:28

MiniPiccolo · 10/07/2022 22:27

Having read the full replies from OP I can only assume this is another windup thread, tbh.

I am wondering that myself tbh.

MiniPiccolo · 10/07/2022 22:27

Having read the full replies from OP I can only assume this is another windup thread, tbh.

MiniPiccolo · 10/07/2022 22:22

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:26

They are really lovely people, but they don’t live locally, meaning if we died DCs would have to undergo a change of school, etc. they also have two young children themselves.

To me, my brother is the better option. He does struggle with self care as he has minor LDs, but could manage with support which could be provided with money he’d get if we died.

AIBU?

Reverse???

Changechangychange · 10/07/2022 22:21

if he had a partner I think he’d be able to parent reasonably well with support

So he needs either a partner to do all the housework and childcare, or to pay for a nanny-housekeeper to do all the childcare.

OP, you clearly know that your brother cannot do this unless there is somebody else, either a partner or paid help, to do the actual parenting for him. That isn’t guardianship - your children could live in the house by themselves with 24/7 paid care (maybe not legally, but from a practical perspective there would be no difference).

Also you say there would be “a lot of money” - do you know how much a 24/7 live in nanny-housekeeper costs? Until the youngest is 18? On top of your children’s living costs. Do you seriously have a million quid or more in your estate, aside from the house, after inheritance tax?

And what happens then, your brother and the housekeeper get the boot so your children can sell the house and use their inheritance? Or your brother keeps the house and continues using your money to pay for his care, and it’s your children unceremoniously dumped out into the world to fend for themselves?

Changechangychange · 10/07/2022 22:12

OP, do you think that this would kill two birds with one stone? Your brother would be looked after by your children and they’d stay in their home?

Realistically if your brother would have to hire in a housekeeper and childcare because he couldn’t keep house or look after the children himself, what exactly is he bringing to the table? And if he isn’t paying for a cleaner now, why would he once your children are living with him? Realistically, they would either end up doing all the housework themselves, or they would be living in squalor along with him (you say his house is “pretty bad”).

Your children would need a huge amount of emotional support, not to become his carers. I can see lots of advantages from his perspective, but honestly none from your children’s.

GoodThinkingMax · 10/07/2022 22:11

Gosh, you are being SO unreasonable. You’re prepared to limit your DC’s lives by having their guardianship given to someone who has problems with self-care???

What about someone looking out for their educational opportunities, extra-curricular activities, socialising and so on. Children can move (are you going to live where you live now, forever???) Someone who can’t look after himself is not going to give your DC the best start in life …

PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 22:03

I’m not saying her DB will be the best option, but the fact most people on this thread have written him off as an option without knowing almost anything about him other than the fact he has been described as having some mild learning disabilities comes across as disablist to me.

The op has said he struggles with his own self care. This is not just because of the LD label.

It is seriously mischaracterising the thread to say that all the op has told us about him is that he has mild LD.

youcantparktheresir · 10/07/2022 22:00

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:05

It’s not strictly accurate that he ‘can’t’ look after himself, more that he doesn’t. I can’t say it’s a choice as that’s misleading but if he had a partner I think he’d be able to parent reasonably well with support. It’s the support he would need.

If he doesn't look after himself now, he's not going to be able to safely look after 2 children.

A nanny or housekeeper or not, it won't work.

This whole idea is utterly ridiculous and you said above you don't tend to talk to said family members about your wishes... I suggest you do god forbid something happened to you and your partner. Your brother may not want full custody of 2 children when he doesn't look after himself.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 10/07/2022 21:59

PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 21:53

This post is incredibly disablist! There is no reason why a person with depression, autism or some form of learning disability automatically cannot care for children. There are so many factors that come into being able to be a good parent and everybody with a disability or difficulty experiences them differently, some people with autism or depression absolutely couldn’t parent a child but others could parent children well with support and others could parent without any specific or extra support.

Have you read the thread? Look what the op has actually said about her brother. This isn’t just the autism/depression/LD label. It’s what she’s said about him. She’s even said herself that she doesn’t think he’d be a “good parent”.

The OP has has she doesn’t think anyone in the scenario will be a good parent, meaning she also doesn’t believe the ILs will be good parents either. In which case it’s a case of picking the best of two options where neither is perfect, and I don’t think from the very limited information OP has given its possible for anybody here to say which that is. I’m not saying her DB will be the best option, but the fact most people on this thread have written him off as an option without knowing almost anything about him other than the fact he has been described as having some mild learning disabilities comes across as disablist to me.

SaggyBlinders · 10/07/2022 21:57

Sounds like it would be unfair to put it all on your brother, if he struggles to look after himself.

One of my parents died when I was a child, I used to worry about my other parent dying too and who would end up looking after me, so I see why you are concerned about it.

For me, my mum died and everything "stayed the same", we didn't move house and I stayed in school, but of course it wasn't the same. Some of my friends had no idea how to react, and didn't speak to me for weeks/months. Only one of my friends came round in the first few months, one wrote a letter, and the others avoided me because they later admitted that they didn't know what to say. Everyone at school treated me differently. My grown up siblings and the majority of my extended family weren't great. People think grief brings people together but it really doesn't in my experience. My dad really really struggled for the first year, and it wasn't great at home, I became the parent in some ways. I would have loved to have "started over" somewhere new, I used to fantasise about running away and starting somewhere new. I really would have loved a parent figure, so for me, the priority would be the people who would be around my child if the worse happened, rather than the place, but obviously that can't be predicted because who knows how people will actually react.

Children need a lot of emotional support after a bereavement, obviously you know your brother best, but it doesn't sound like he would be able to provide that, based on what you've written in your OP.

BanjoVio · 10/07/2022 21:56

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:21

@Discovereads that really wouldn’t be a problem.

He isn’t tied to an area for work reasons and actually hates where he lives. But that’s all by the by. I’m not expecting to die. If I did, and DH did, I know my brother would be there like a shot. One thing I will say for him is he’s there when you need him.

Things he struggles with are:

Basic housekeeping - it’s very hard to say whether this is down to depression / lack of motivation. Sometimes he’ll have a really good clean but other times it’s bad.

Autism and sensory issues mean he often avoids showers / baths.

Timekeeping isn’t always brilliant. He has been late for work on occasion.

Physical health not great - very susceptible to viruses and so on and can be a bit of a drama llama regarding them; lots of declarations of having ‘flu’ for a cold and so on.

Anyway, I do have to get on but thanks for the replies.

Oh honestly, this sounds like a catalogue of great reasons why this person absolutely should not be in charge of two grieving children. You are getting very defensive to the extent that I wonder why you even asked the question if you’re going to dismiss every valid reply.

PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 21:54

shinynewapple22 · 10/07/2022 21:53

Some strange threads this evening

I agree.

shinynewapple22 · 10/07/2022 21:53

Some strange threads this evening

PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 21:53

This post is incredibly disablist! There is no reason why a person with depression, autism or some form of learning disability automatically cannot care for children. There are so many factors that come into being able to be a good parent and everybody with a disability or difficulty experiences them differently, some people with autism or depression absolutely couldn’t parent a child but others could parent children well with support and others could parent without any specific or extra support.

Have you read the thread? Look what the op has actually said about her brother. This isn’t just the autism/depression/LD label. It’s what she’s said about him. She’s even said herself that she doesn’t think he’d be a “good parent”.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 10/07/2022 21:52

Luredbyapomegranate · 10/07/2022 21:36

They would if your brother is registered as having LDs. The safeguarding officer in your kids’ school would inform ss if your kids’ situation as routine.

Guardianships left in wills can be overturned by the courts on a request from other family members, the kids, or any 3rd party.

It’s not especially unusual for siblings and grandparents on both sides to have a tussle if very sadly both parents do die, so it’s worth discussing it with everyone.

It’s not true that safeguarding would automatically report somebody with learning disabilities. You know learning disability is a broad term and that some will include things like autism, ADHD, dyslexia etc I’m the term. Just because somebody has a diagnosis of a condition which can fall under the umbrella term of learning disability doesn’t mean that social services will be involved or that the school would flag anything up. I think everybody has read the term ‘learning disability’ and made massive assumptions about what that means and what the DB would be able to do, when it’s completely feasible that he could only be effected in a few aspects of life and that these are things which either wouldn’t impact on parenting or which could be mitigated by having the money to pay for things like a cleaner.

Quartz2208 · 10/07/2022 21:52

This is highly likely be a SS issue though - because in this situation your children have lost both parents it isnt the same as if your brother was a parent himself.

At DD and DS school there was a situation where the mum was killed by the father and custody was given to the Aunt and Uncle (complicated by them coming over from another country) the level of involvement of the school and SS was high (and very much welcomed by the Aunt and Uncle) and continued for a good year 18 months afterwards until they were officially adopted. The school still helps a lot now

CorvusPurpureus · 10/07/2022 21:49

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:33

People with depression become parents all the time - I’ve had depression myself. I think I’d best hide the thread. This weird insistence that SS are waiting in the wings to take children from their own families is bizarre and wrong.

They have to sign off on the best placement for children in their care.

So if you, your dh & your db all agreed that he would be moving into your home & looking after the dc, & no other family members raised concerns about his capacity to cope, then it is quite likely that that is what would happen, & SS involvement would be fairly 'light touch'.

What people are trying to explain to you is that a) it isn't simply your decision - it's not like choosing who gets your golf clubs or great aunt Ethel's pearl earrings ffs & b) it's possibly not the best option, because your db sounds like he would find it a struggle.

He might be better placed as the awesome uncle who takes them out/has them to stay regularly (& if you can't picture him coping brilliantly with that role...definitely have a hard think about the fact that he's not going to be able to step up as a full time parent).

Changechangychange · 10/07/2022 21:49

@MolkosTeenageAngst if OP had just said her brother had autism or depression that would be one thing. She says he struggles with his own self care though.

Now it’s possible she meant wanky new age “self care”, meaning he sometimes misses out his mindfulness practice, but most of us assume she means he isn’t independent with ADLs/iADLs, and yes that does mean he wouldn’t be a great solo parent for two bereaved children, when there is a far less complicated option apparently willing and available in her BIL and SIL.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 10/07/2022 21:45

This post is incredibly disablist! There is no reason why a person with depression, autism or some form of learning disability automatically cannot care for children. There are so many factors that come into being able to be a good parent and everybody with a disability or difficulty experiences them differently, some people with autism or depression absolutely couldn’t parent a child but others could parent children well with support and others could parent without any specific or extra support.

OP, you know your DB and you know your BIL. If you feel that DB is a better option then that’s completely reasonable, I don’t think already having children automatically makes somebody a better option and I can see why you would want to consider things such as whether your children would need to move out of their home when weighing up the better option.

Changechangychange · 10/07/2022 21:45

Trust me on this, it wouldn’t be a SS matter

By what process do you think your brother (or BIL/SIL) gets parental responsibility for your children? Of course it’s a social services matter, it would be for any kinship adoption.

Arnaquer · 10/07/2022 21:38

Are you actually dieing?

Luredbyapomegranate · 10/07/2022 21:36

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:17

@alphapie I don’t think you seem to understand that SS aren’t interested.

As I said to you above, there are plenty of people who would fall into the category of mild (or not so mild) LDs who do manage to parent perfectly well, often with support from their own families.

Trust me on this, it wouldn’t be a SS matter.

We all need support when parenting. MN forms part of that. Our own families and friends. Childcare. Partners. I don’t parent without support.

They would if your brother is registered as having LDs. The safeguarding officer in your kids’ school would inform ss if your kids’ situation as routine.

Guardianships left in wills can be overturned by the courts on a request from other family members, the kids, or any 3rd party.

It’s not especially unusual for siblings and grandparents on both sides to have a tussle if very sadly both parents do die, so it’s worth discussing it with everyone.

PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 21:36

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:33

People with depression become parents all the time - I’ve had depression myself. I think I’d best hide the thread. This weird insistence that SS are waiting in the wings to take children from their own families is bizarre and wrong.

It’s not the same.

People who have children are not screened in the same way that potential adoptive parents are.

PurpleDaisies · 10/07/2022 21:35

Yes, MN. People who have autism parent.

Obviously. But this is about SS deciding where two orphaned children will be placed and your posts have raised issues that would be big problems.

Changechangychange · 10/07/2022 21:35

What you are basically proposing is that your children become child carers for your brother.

Have a quick look at educational/life outcomes of child carers - they are highly disadvantaged and many drop out of education completely at a young age. Do you have a girl? It will probably be her who has to sacrifice the rest of her life caring for her uncle, out of guilt knowing it was what you wanted for her.