Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want BIL and SIL to have the children if we die?

135 replies

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:26

They are really lovely people, but they don’t live locally, meaning if we died DCs would have to undergo a change of school, etc. they also have two young children themselves.

To me, my brother is the better option. He does struggle with self care as he has minor LDs, but could manage with support which could be provided with money he’d get if we died.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
daisy46 · 19/09/2022 18:44

This has to be a reverse. No one can possibly think someone who can't keep his house or himself clean and is sickly is the best option to care for their orphaned children.

Wibbly1008 · 19/09/2022 17:52

alphapie · 10/07/2022 21:07

His LD alone would be reason they would be involved. And not being able to take care of himself would be case closed. If your brother had children of his own he would have SS involvement. They won't allow children to go to an unsuitable home, and that's what this would be, based on how you described it.

And you're likely trying to downplay tbh so it's probably worse in reality.

agreed. Social care would get involved if he has LD and they would assess him. If he needs support it’s likely they would place kids with the family members that didn’t, money will not really come into it as they assess parenting capacity .

TheNoodlesIncident · 14/07/2022 22:38

I think DH views BIL as the better choice because he already has children, while to me that is what makes them not ideal. Understandably they will prioritise their own children.

I think I would side with your DH, who seems to have a better grasp of what's actually needed to bring up children. And your comment above has riled me because it's such a crass assumption. If something happened to my DSis and her DH, then I and my DH would step in for their two children if we were needed. And I can say hand on heart that I would look after their two as if they were my own. The individual needs of each child, mine and theirs, would be considered of equal importance. How could you do otherwise, especially since they would be grieving?!

And FTR, I have autism too, as does DSis. We are both capable of self-care and raising and caring for our vulnerable dc. If your DB is more haphazard in his lifestyle, he is NOT best placed to raise your dc in lieu of you. Hopefully it won't come to that!

PurpleDaisies · 14/07/2022 22:10

look twice when you crossing the road and always drive below the speed limit you’ll be fine.

I don’t think that’s a foolproof plan.

Nothappyatwork · 14/07/2022 22:05

Given that neither of your options sound ideal you’re just gonna have to go with the plan that I have which is simply not to die while the children are under 18 honestly it really is the best way, look twice when you crossing the road and always drive below the speed limit you’ll be fine.

Qrow · 14/07/2022 21:59

This reply has been deleted

Deleted by MNHQ

GetThatHelmetOn · 12/07/2022 15:57

Another thing to consider is that by sending your kids to your brother they may end up being your DB’s caters much to the detriment of their own youth and career oportunities.

Mommyknwsbest · 12/07/2022 14:14

As someone who experienced the heartbreak and angst of losing a parent, as you've stated, why would you focus more on what may or may not be their comfort and less on what is stable?
Your children would be experiencing emotional and mental turmoil. To throw them into an environment that does not provide stability, quality care, and values that align with yours, is ultimately child neglect.
You have a brother that CHOOSES not to care for himself- providing him with the monetary capabilities and hired help will only encourage further lack of self care. If he does not possess the drive and desire to clean himself, his home, or his living conditions- this will only teach your children that it is ok to follow in that path.
You stated he can "hire a nanny". What if he CHOOSES not to do that?! Then your children are left grieving and neglected.

What if he does hire a nanny, and she turns out to be horrible to your children. With a LD and no children of his own, is he even capable of knowing/understanding the rigorous duty of screening for child care?
Would you really rather your children be raised by a stranger who has no idea of who their parents were, and therefore has no memories or stories to share with them?
Your inlaws may take them out of their comfort zone- but think about what they will receive in return... empathy, understanding, love. They will be able to know that they are wanted- instead of growing up potentially wondering why their lovely home has turned into filth and they were pawned off to hired help, and their uncle quit letting them bathe and has chosen not to cook and they go to bed hungry for the 3rd night in a row.
I don't mean to sound crass, but I couldn't possibly give anyone the benefit of the doubt when it comes to my children... and as a mother, you shouldn't hope someone will change and be responsible enough to care for yours. Your children deserve better than that.

echt · 12/07/2022 01:46

OP, have you ever left your children in the care of your brother? Babysitting? An outing?

Stompythedinosaur · 12/07/2022 01:23

Look, if their parents die, things will be bad for your dc. Their childhood will not be ideal. Against the scale of loss, changing schools is not a big thing. Having a two parent family who are willing and able to support them is much better than one adult who is struggling to care for himself.

knockyknees · 12/07/2022 01:20

think the use of a FT nanny / housekeeper would be what he’d need

So you think your children being looked after by a revolving door of strangers is a better alternative to not moving school to live in a stable home with 2 permanent parental figures instead? Not to mention the DC would probably end up being some sort of child carers towards your brother. Okay.

At this point I'm really hoping this is a wind-up, because no caring parent would wish this on their child/ren.

bellac11 · 11/07/2022 18:40

Who knows if this thread is real or not, but just in case it is and just in case others have a similar predicament, what would happen is that in the process of the courts needing to make a decision about how to confer PR for the children, they would approach CAFCASS/SSD to prepare reports.
The report would need to take account of the childrens needs and the parenting capacity of the applicant.

Of course parents with LD parent, but given the choice of options within the family of tried and tested parents who dont have concerns about their parenting capacity compared to someone who has struggles with his own care, it would be difficult to find in the favor of the latter.

Of course the children's own wishes and feelings will be paramount but that has to be balanced in with their best interests, the two are not always the same

The courts also dont expect parents to be perfect, there are children all over the country living with parents whose houses arent great, whose self care arent great, who may use substances, who have poor MH and LD and those children are just about managing to have the majority of their needs met, with lots of community support.....the problem is, those children are already with those parents, they hold PR. If you had that option but where you are looking for that person to take the care of children, why would you do that if you had 2 other options?

Of course this is all hypothetical and hopefully not necessary and OP and her partner will live long lives.

RedHelenB · 11/07/2022 13:38

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 20:26

They are really lovely people, but they don’t live locally, meaning if we died DCs would have to undergo a change of school, etc. they also have two young children themselves.

To me, my brother is the better option. He does struggle with self care as he has minor LDs, but could manage with support which could be provided with money he’d get if we died.

AIBU?

As an outsiderI think yabu. Your ils already have a family they will be able to be with their cousins., Changing schools is not the end of the world.
Practically, where would the support you brother needs to be a parent come from?

Polichinelle · 11/07/2022 12:43

I think that would be a terrible choice but given that this scenario is very unlikely, I would not worry too much. How old are the children now?

MoodyTwo · 11/07/2022 07:54

I don't think you decide, they get taken into the state and social services and a court would decide. Your Brother wouldn't get a sniff

Namenic · 11/07/2022 00:32

OP - what if your kids have medical problems or become withdrawn/depressed as teens? If your DB struggles with hygiene and running a house, it might be hard for him to parent kids who also struggle? What if they needed to go to medical appointments, school meetings etc - I don’t know him, but you did mention him havi by some difficulties with timekeeping.

for what it’s worth, one of my relatives was one of 7 kids and the dad died and mum couldn’t cope, so kids were sent to different relatives, shared rooms, moved around. They had some difficult times but also some good ones and are close to the cousins they stayed with.

Tablechairtable · 11/07/2022 00:16

Are you able to ask your brother how he would feel about it? He may not want the responsibility. I'm assuming its because your considering putting a caveat in your will about proposed care for your dcs. If he doesn't then there's your answer. I would be concerned for them all if he can't always function with personal care. How would he cope with the teenage years for instance, let alone younger.

ToastedCrumpetwithCheese · 11/07/2022 00:01

I also get your concerns about the children moving away. Our children would move away if they were orphens as our guardians live 1.5hrs aways and would stay in their location due to work. Our eldest is only a couple of years away from GCSEs so moving wouldn't be great for her at all (plus she's a teenager and all her friends are here).

But... she would be loved, well cared for, have guidance, input and aspirations. Along with her brother they would gain 3 siblings and have to share the attention and time (and maybe bedrooms). But they would also have 'new' parents and that's what they will need; the stability of parents to give them a constant (new) normal, parents to look after them and to discipline them, to teach them, to allow them to be children, to support them in their grief and anger.

Murdoch1949 · 10/07/2022 23:57

I think your brother is a strange choice, unless I've missed the fact that he has brought up children. You need to consider the best for your children, and they would need experienced parenting, which does not sound like your brother. Any idea whom they would choose? Has your brother ever had them for a weekend?

BlackandBlueBird · 10/07/2022 23:52

@SaggyBlinders I could have written your post almost word for word. Ultimately I did move away to be with family overseas and it was the best thing that could have happened to me.

Rachie1973 · 10/07/2022 23:48

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:17

@alphapie I don’t think you seem to understand that SS aren’t interested.

As I said to you above, there are plenty of people who would fall into the category of mild (or not so mild) LDs who do manage to parent perfectly well, often with support from their own families.

Trust me on this, it wouldn’t be a SS matter.

We all need support when parenting. MN forms part of that. Our own families and friends. Childcare. Partners. I don’t parent without support.

It would be an SS matter. Kids aren’t chattel and they aren’t simply handed over. You don’t become a legal guardian because the ‘d parents say so’. They’d need formal court orders to give them PR etc. SS would be standard involvement.

ToastedCrumpetwithCheese · 10/07/2022 23:41

It sounds like you're convinced your brother is the best choice. He sounds like a lovely uncle who's involved in their lives. However, I would be very concerned that your children will be relying on paid help (nanny and housekeeper) to look after their wellbeing. What happens when the nanny isn't available? There's a huge difference between parents who use a nanny and housekeeper but can effectively parent their children and what you're saying about your brother needing that support to parent your children. Would he have other family support who could be there 24/7 as needed? Could your BIL/SIL provide that help/guidance?

I would really hope that SS would be involved in any guardianship cases. Would your brother cope with SS involvement? If they had concerns, could he work with them to resolve them? Ultimately can he do what's best for the children?

Going back to your BIL/SIL. The decent sum you're giving to your brother to buy in significant support, could that be used by your BIL/SIL to also buy in support to free up their time for all the children? Or allow them to buy a bigger house or drop their hours at work? You mention all the ways your brother could be supported by your money, but not your BIL/SIL. Why would your children be second best to their existing children? What gives you that idea? I know we would give more love/time/support to our guardian children should the worst happen.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 10/07/2022 23:29

AngelinaFibres · 10/07/2022 23:00

He cannot look after his own basic needs. He is never going to be capable of looking after children.

Op says he holds down a job which suggests he’s able to take care of his basic needs. OP describes him as being bad at taking baths/ showers and at not staying on top of cleaning, maybe not the best qualities but not so extreme as to suggest he couldn’t be a good enough patent. I know of parents who are rubbish at keeping on top of housework and I have a family member who has been a foster cater for de axes whose house is always in complete chaos with mess.

Things like having a clean house can be bought by employing a cleaner. Emotional security, love, attentiveness, an interest in the children, consistency, empathetic parenting etc - these are the things that can’t be bought. I think OP needs to look at which of her options can offer the children these qualities when deciding where they should live. DB shouldn’t be discounted just because he has mild learning difficulties, just because he is rubbish at timekeeping and doesn’t like showers doesn’t mean he wouldn’t be able to step up or that he won’t be able to have different rules for the children (I have a friend who hates all veg and mostly lives on chocolate and toast but she still manages to provide healthy nutritious meals for her DC despite not eating well herself) although the fact the kids could stay in their house also isn’t reason enough to put him as a preference above the ILs.

No patent is perfect and I expect if anybody just gave a list of all their weaker qualities here on Mumsnet as OP has done about her brother they would be told they were unfit to patent but in reality it’s impossible to know whether the DB would be capable from the tiny snippets of information OP has shared about his difficulties and how they impact on him and without sharing any of his strengths to give balance.

AngelinaFibres · 10/07/2022 23:00

Veggiesintheground · 10/07/2022 21:15

@GibbonsGoatsGibbons to be honest that’s why I’m inclined to go with my brother. My BIL and his wife are lovely people, but living with them would involve giving up their homes, rooms, schools, sharing bedrooms, sharing close personal space with other children they don’t know well, starting at a new school and having to share the available adults with their own children.

I genuinely don’t feel that is best for grieving children. I acknowledge my brother isn’t perfect but what he can offer is some stability and some consistency.

Anyway, thanks for thoughts - interesting as always.

He cannot look after his own basic needs. He is never going to be capable of looking after children.

Luredbyapomegranate · 10/07/2022 22:38

MolkosTeenageAngst · 10/07/2022 21:52

It’s not true that safeguarding would automatically report somebody with learning disabilities. You know learning disability is a broad term and that some will include things like autism, ADHD, dyslexia etc I’m the term. Just because somebody has a diagnosis of a condition which can fall under the umbrella term of learning disability doesn’t mean that social services will be involved or that the school would flag anything up. I think everybody has read the term ‘learning disability’ and made massive assumptions about what that means and what the DB would be able to do, when it’s completely feasible that he could only be effected in a few aspects of life and that these are things which either wouldn’t impact on parenting or which could be mitigated by having the money to pay for things like a cleaner.

@MolkosTeenageAngst

Jesus, of course the school won’t ‘report’ the uncle for having LDs, how would they even know?

The safeguarding dept in any school would let ss know if 2 pupils had lost both parents, because those kids are now vulnerable.

SS would check out the home and the extended family situation. If other family members did not feel the uncle was a great choice, then yes SS would take that into account, or they might come to that conclusion themselves, and potentially ask the court to review the guardianship order. Although in fact anyone can ask a court to review a guardianship order, it doesn’t need ss.

Which is why a family agreement is a better idea than the OP sticking in her preferences, which suspects her DP doesn’t agree with.

Swipe left for the next trending thread