Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pay for DD's school trip

212 replies

MamaCathy73 · 10/07/2022 20:15

Hi everyone,

My DD is 14 and her school is doing a ski trip for her year group. This is very expensive (upwards of £1000), and we simply cannot afford it. However, all of her friends are going, and she is making a fuss about not being able to go. It would not be completely impossible for us but it would be putting us at risk, and it would definitely impact our lives. She doesn't seem to have much of an idea about money, and she is very frustrated with DH and me.

What should I do?

OP posts:
AnnaMagnani · 10/07/2022 22:18

It's a life lesson and an important one.

At 14 she needs to start learning about the meaning of money, and that she is part of a family - what she does has impacts on others.

It is highly unlikely that ALL her friends are going, this smacks of the classic teen argument of 'everyone else is allowed to insert object of desire here' Places are limited and besides, other families won't be able to afford it either.

Skiing is dreadful thing to save for as well, even if you afford the holiday there's the kit too.

Say no, stick to it and start thinking about ways to engage her with money:

being a bit more open about family finances and things you are cutting back on with cost of living crisis
handing her over a budget so she has to pay for some of her expenses herself, maybe a clothes budget

At her age I knew full well not to put myself in for school trips as we couldn't afford it, my mum was mending my uniform to try and make it last and I knew that making the mortgage payments was a struggle. She's old enough to know.

00100001 · 10/07/2022 22:16

Northernblueberry · 10/07/2022 21:45

That was 30 years ago. Things and safety standards has changed a bit since then. 😂

to be fair, my lad (19) was earning money mowing lawns, washing cars , walking dogs etc when he was 12+ mostly through people through church, or neighbours etc. But he did alright.

Flubber88 · 10/07/2022 22:14

HeddaGarbled · 10/07/2022 20:19

Stay firm. Be sympathetic but honest. She’ll be cross for a bit but she’ll get over it, and it’s an important life lesson.

This

Dexionmagic · 10/07/2022 22:13
  1. She won’t be the only one not going.
  2. 14 isn’t too young to have lessons about family, your family, finances.
  3. It’s unlikely that a school will offer subsidised places for a trip such as this. History, Geography etc trips - more likely.
Genericusername1234 · 10/07/2022 22:13

My state school ran ski trips and as a result lots of kids (including me) got to go skiing who would never otherwise have been able to.
It is a shame for the kids that can’t go but it’s great that state schools are still doing this. Why should skiing just be for private schools?

If it was me, I’d probably try to find a way for her to go, because it was such a good experience for me and I’d want her to have that too. But if you really can’t afford it then she’ll have to understand that. As pp said, saving for next year could be a compromise.

Babyroobs · 10/07/2022 22:11

My dd is going on one at a similar cost in excess of 1k. It is a lot of money. We can only afford it because she is our youngest and could not have done it with the older 3. You will just have to explain that you cannot afford it. It is hard for them though when they are the only one not going. Does the school have any kind of fund for lower earning parents to access?

BoJoGoGo · 10/07/2022 22:08

We struggled to send our daughter on her school trip when she was 15, and she wouldn't be able to tell you anything about it now!
This surprises me , I remember so much about my last year in primary school trip to The Isle of Wight and first year at secondary school trip to Jersey. In fact I went back there last year for the first time and bored my DH with stories about things that happened on the different day trips. I’ll always remember arriving and being fascinated how it almost felt abroad and lots of the street names were in French but some of the houses looked like ones in England.
Thinking about it I remember loads from my Brownies trip to Eastbourne too.

Freehugs · 10/07/2022 22:05

It’s a shame she feels so frustrated. It can easily pull on your heart strings, and make you feel like your are depriving your child of something. In the grand scheme of things not all of her friends will be going. Generally spaces are limited. There will be other parents who cannot afford it, there will be some that put themselves in debt to pay for it, others who can afford it and some who can afford but still won’t want to spend that amount of money on a school trip.

If you can’t afford it say no, and you will just have to ride her frustrated attitude out knowing that you will be financially stable in the long term - and that is you being a good sensible parent putting you ability to provide first.

As already suggested, maybe a summer job could teach the value of money.

One of my dc walks dogs and sells things on fb market place to earn extra cash.

Dolphinnoises · 10/07/2022 22:02

No - it’s actually quite important that you model living within your means here. I guess there will be one next year? Suggest she saves up for it, and you will put in the final £200 (or whatever). Not doing something because you can’t afford it is exactly what should happen

NothingSurprisesMeAnymore · 10/07/2022 22:00

In 1965 I just accepted that I would not be able to go on the class skiing trip as I knew my parents could not afford it; it was a question of them paying the rent and feeding the family - I was one of two in the class that could not go. My school friends didn't question it, and there was no pressure or bullying from what I remember, although I recall inwardly feeling resentful when they were talking about the trip. I think this was a good grounding for not expecting to have expensive holidays. I listen to friends now talking about how they expect to have two or three holidays per year, and I'm just astounded by their sense of entitlement tbh. Maybe it's me inheriting my parents' working-class ethics or years of making do, but I can't put a holiday at the forefront of my to-do list. I'd speak to your child about the expense and your budget - and suggest you all save together for a lovely family trip because if she goes, she won't remember much of it in years to come! We struggled to send our daughter on her school trip when she was 15, and she wouldn't be able to tell you anything about it now!

DockOTheBay · 10/07/2022 21:59

A 14 year old is old enough to understand that £1000 is a lot of money and you can't afford it.
I'm sure "all" her friends aren't going. In my fairly large school with 280 children in each year group, we take about 20 of them on the ski trip. The vast majority don't come either because they can't afford, don't want to pay or don't get chosen for a space. She won't be the only one.

flowerycurtain · 10/07/2022 21:57

@Isahlo i hope you enjoy every second of your well earned holiday.

DuckBilledPlattyJoobs · 10/07/2022 21:54

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 10/07/2022 20:25

Can the school help out at all?

Our school trip always seem to come with a “please speak to the school if you really can’t afford this” message, for those who absolutely don’t have the money.

This

Isahlo · 10/07/2022 21:54

Throwawaytoday · 10/07/2022 20:25

If you can't afford to pay for something twice, you can't afford it (not withstanding property I guess).

Many parents won't be able to afford it, there is no shame in that.

What a bonkers notion? We’ve saved £1000 for our family holiday, and spends (lodge for 5 days @£300 eurotunnel and fuel @£250, £350 spends and £100 contingency
we can only afford it once but we have worked very hard with extra jobs, dh and i eating jacket spuds for weeks on end, walking 3 miles to do the weekly shop and then loading backpacks and the buggy to get shopping home to save the fiver each week on petrol and parking etc etc

are you suggesting I need £2000 to be able to afford this? 🥴

Bobbybobbins · 10/07/2022 21:52

At my school we used to run a ski trip (I went as one of the staff one year). It was the only trip where financial help wasn't offered and was also the only trip run in the school holidays. I don't think we would fill it now with the increase in the cost of living,

PoleFairy · 10/07/2022 21:52

She should have an idea about money tbh and this should be a learning for her. I remember being 14 and I didn't even take the letter home as I knew it would be a stretch for my parents. And we were pretty well off (didn't want for anything and had a foreign holiday most years) but I was smart enough to know they could pull £1000 out their arse

IrisVersicolor · 10/07/2022 21:48

I wanted to on on the school ski trip all the way through school but my parents couldn’t afford it. It’s not that big a deal.

Northernblueberry · 10/07/2022 21:45

saleorbouy · 10/07/2022 21:38

For those who say she can't earn enough at her age, that's not true.
At her age I easily earned £75 - 100 per/week mowing lawns, cutting hedges and gardening and that was for £5.50 per/hr in the mid 90's.
I'm sure she could earn £10per/hr with a little entrepreneurship and dedication.

That was 30 years ago. Things and safety standards has changed a bit since then. 😂

Northernblueberry · 10/07/2022 21:43

Does your daughter know how to ski op?

mycatisannoying · 10/07/2022 21:43

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 10/07/2022 20:23

When the email came through about the ski trip at my DS's school I told him how much it was and why I couldn't afford it and he said that's fine mum I wouldn't want you to spend that much. Why does she have such little idea about money?

Well-done for raising the perfect son. Unfortunately some of us mere mortals have to contend with the typical, more self-centred breed!

DelphiniumBlue · 10/07/2022 21:42

It sounds as if you are saying you could actually afford it at a pinch, bearing in mind you don't have to pay it all at once.
Maybe DD can contribute something?
It's a really great experience for her to have, especially if you won't be taking her skiing yourself- it's much cheaper for her to go with school than for the whole family to go.

Discovereads · 10/07/2022 21:40

saleorbouy · 10/07/2022 21:38

For those who say she can't earn enough at her age, that's not true.
At her age I easily earned £75 - 100 per/week mowing lawns, cutting hedges and gardening and that was for £5.50 per/hr in the mid 90's.
I'm sure she could earn £10per/hr with a little entrepreneurship and dedication.

Yeah, health and safety wouldn’t allow that now, thirty years on. Too many ways to accidentally injure yourself with a lawn mower, hedge clipper, etc.

Puffalicious · 10/07/2022 21:40

OP, these are life lessons. Perhaps explain to her- with a piece of paper and a pen- what your outgoings are. Often when it's in black and white it hits home. I know my DS1- very bright, thoughtful child- was shocked at age 16 at the amount of direct debits I have. It just came up.in conversation about the price of living and he was truly shocked.

Can I also say the costs will just rise- ski holidays require expensive clothing if you can't borrow it.

flowerycurtain · 10/07/2022 21:40

My parents said no to a similar ski trip when I was at school.

Aged 14 I put together a "business plan" of how I could earn the money to go. And I did. Grass cutting for my family and for neighbours. Regular babysitting gigs,
worked at a little chef. They said I could go if I saved it all up and I managed it. Huge life lesson learnt.

However like a pp said it's virtually impossible to get a job under 16 anymore. It really annoys me how flipping hard it is. I'd love to employ a few more 14/15 year olds who are keen in our industry but the work permit is such a faff it really puts me off.

ther

saleorbouy · 10/07/2022 21:38

For those who say she can't earn enough at her age, that's not true.
At her age I easily earned £75 - 100 per/week mowing lawns, cutting hedges and gardening and that was for £5.50 per/hr in the mid 90's.
I'm sure she could earn £10per/hr with a little entrepreneurship and dedication.

Swipe left for the next trending thread