Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pay for DD's school trip

212 replies

MamaCathy73 · 10/07/2022 20:15

Hi everyone,

My DD is 14 and her school is doing a ski trip for her year group. This is very expensive (upwards of £1000), and we simply cannot afford it. However, all of her friends are going, and she is making a fuss about not being able to go. It would not be completely impossible for us but it would be putting us at risk, and it would definitely impact our lives. She doesn't seem to have much of an idea about money, and she is very frustrated with DH and me.

What should I do?

OP posts:
OldFan · 11/07/2022 00:22

that was for £5.50 per/hr in the mid 90's.

@saleorbouy Maybe it depends on the area but at 15, my Saturday job in a shop in '92 earned me £11 for the whole day. 😂

Blobblobblob · 11/07/2022 00:21

This is an opportunity to sit her down and explain the household budget to her, she needs to learn about these things anyway and it might help her to understand.

BungleandGeorge · 11/07/2022 00:12

Well teens are selfish aren’t they, if you’re living without frills she’ll understand deep down.

Sunnytwobridges · 11/07/2022 00:09

It would be a no for me and I wouldn’t feel guilty about it either. She won’t be happy but she will get over it.

Murdoch1949 · 11/07/2022 00:02

Explain the situation, say No, and stick to it. You could offer her the option to fund half herself if that would be possible. None of my children went skiing, 4, even though we were professional parents.

Mummyofmaniacs · 10/07/2022 23:56

I find two things quite worrying in this thread... The first being that so many people are trying to guilt the OP into spending money she has clearly stated she does not have, sending DD on an expensive holiday by quoting little anecdotes about how they remembered it all their lives...The second is that nobody has questioned why, at 14, the DD has so little knowledge about finance that she is unable to comprehend the simple fact of not having enough money.

saraclara · 10/07/2022 23:54

Fired? Fussed.

saraclara · 10/07/2022 23:54

Alivekicking · 10/07/2022 23:40

A skiing trip isn't a necessity. It's wrong to ask the grandparents to pay for that, they're not a bloody piggy bank.

It's the non essential stuff that some grandparents want to help with. As mine did.

I wasn't remotely spoiled and didn't have a lot of stuff. My grandparents weren't the cosy sort who handed out treats or fired over me. But they did know that I was passionate about other countries and cultures from being a tiny child. When I visited them I'd get out their atlas and their encyclopedia of the world out, and that's how I passed my time while the grown ups talked.

So yes, when I was 15 and my school decided to offer tl an educational Mediterranean cruise on one of the BI 'school ships', and my gps knew my parents couldn't afford it, they stepped in. I'd never been abroad before (this was 1970) and that trip was transformational for me.

And that was it. Life went back to normal. No spoiling, no treats, just gentle life. And I've been an inveterate traveller ever since.

Alivekicking · 10/07/2022 23:40

A skiing trip isn't a necessity. It's wrong to ask the grandparents to pay for that, they're not a bloody piggy bank.

rnsaslkih · 10/07/2022 23:36

Has she got any grandparents able to chip in?

If not, then I would tell her that it isn't affordable.

EntertainingandFactual · 10/07/2022 23:31

Discovereads · 10/07/2022 20:24

Many schools offer bursaries to low income families for school trips. You could call the school and ask? If not, you have to tell your DD that you cannot afford the trip. As she is 14, it’s probably a good age to sit down with her (when she’s over being upset and a drama llama) and share the family budget with her. If she sees your monthly income and outgoings, she’ll understand better that you truly cannot afford the trip and learn from you how you determine what you can or cannot afford as an adult.

The problem is, there are many families who do not qualify for help because on paper at least, they earn what is considered to be an ok wage.
Due to the cost of living many people find that every penny they earn is accounted for.

Dixiechickonhols · 10/07/2022 23:02

whattheduece · 10/07/2022 22:46

Babysitting yes. Child supervision? A tricky one to offer this - anything over two hours a day a day NOT at the parents house the person must be ofsted registered.
I say this as a registered childminder.

This is mother’s help so ok as the mum is there the teen isn’t classed as in sole charge.

whattheduece · 10/07/2022 22:46

SunshinePie · 10/07/2022 20:36

She’s got all summer holidays to work - I’ve got a 15 year old neighbour helping me supervise my kids over the holidays whilst I work from home. She will be making at least £1000 from helping me out (15 hours a week, for 8 weeks, at £10 an hour. Your daughter could easily put flyers through local doors offering child supervision or babysitting services etc. It will be good for her to earn the trip herself!

Babysitting yes. Child supervision? A tricky one to offer this - anything over two hours a day a day NOT at the parents house the person must be ofsted registered.
I say this as a registered childminder.

FeelingwearyFeeelingsmall · 10/07/2022 22:44

She is old enough to understand that some things just aren't affordable. Tell her the truth.

Motherhubbardscupboard · 10/07/2022 22:42

I did an out of school activity which was basically my whole life outside school. One year there was a foreign trip, and my parents couldn't afford it. Literally everyone else went and I did feel left out, but I also understood that if my parents had sent me, there would have been no family holiday that year (and I'm talking camping, not AI) and I wouldn't have wanted the rest of the family to miss out. However, there were also numerous ski trips at school that I didn't go on, but neither did the vast majority of others - ski trips are always limited numbers and really expensive. I did go on a couple of exchange type trips which were less expensive, and maybe something else will come along that you'll be able to afford and that your daughter can contribute to if she starts babysitting etc. DH and I are in the fortunate position where in theory we could say yes to every school trip for our kids, but we don't, because some of them are just so expensive for a few days for one member of the family, and we also object to schools offering very expensive trips for exactly the reasons the OP is experiencing. Our kids have each done a couple of more affordable foreign school trips.

KweenieBeanz · 10/07/2022 22:39

Yeah lol she's lying if she claims 'all her friends are going'. Let's be clear this is not a 'school trip' in the usually understood sense, its a school organised holiday, during the school holidays, with a only a small fixed number of places available (usually about 25 kids go out of maybe 200). Only the minority will go on this school organised holiday. I'm always amused by how many kids claim to parents that 'all their friends are going', parents scrap together the money, to find it turns out, no, friends are not all going!!

LIZS · 10/07/2022 22:38

All her friends? I seriously doubt it! At 14 she is old enough to grasp that financial decisions have to be balanced and priorities determined. Just say no, sorry, not this time.

AssignedSlytherinAtBirth · 10/07/2022 22:37

I was about that age when my schoolfriends went on a trip to France. My parents said no but didn't really explain why. My memory is that I was the only one left out but maybe that's because any others who didn't go kept quiet. But anyway, I found it really hard listening to what a great time they'd had. I think you should make it happen if you possibly can, and explain the consequences either way (if you go on this, we will have to borrow, you'll have to pay towards it, and you won't be able to go on another one, or whatever).

RosesAndHellebores · 10/07/2022 22:34

@Touchmybum My DH was similar. He asked to go on one trip aged about 13 and was told no, there was no money for trips abroad. Every other trip, he threw the letter away before he got home. He was surprised when SIL1 could go on a "fun" trio to Europe and then SIL2.

He never forgot it, he is still a bit pissed off about it. He is 60. The consequence was that he signed off every single trip form for the DC he could get his hands on. Even the trip to the Galapogos Islands when DS was not a geographer. Even DS gave him the form back and said FFS dad, everyone's swerving that. It's ridiculous.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 10/07/2022 22:27

None of mine went on the skiing trips, I couldn't afford it. Same with the trip to America that was over £1000

Schools are not going to pay towards a ski trip

ShinyMe · 10/07/2022 22:23

I remember being maybe 12 and upwards, and my mum being very honest about what things cost, and talking to me about relative costs of things, and letting me choose. She'd explain that we could perhaps do this thing I really wanted, but it would mean going without xy or z, or that instead I could not have pocket money for x many weeks or months, or that I could have this, but then we wouldn't be able to afford another for this long. I think it was really helpful, because it made me really consider and think about how much I really wanted something, and often after thinking about it for a few days, I'd decide that I'd rather have 10 small things spread over the year, than one big thing that beforehand I really REALLY thought I wanted. I'm nearly 50 now and I still do it - do I REALLY want this £100 concert ticket, will I enjoy it 10 times more than 10 separate trips to the cinema? Do I REALLY want this takeaway, or would I enjoy that amount of money towards some new DMs which I can have a month earlier if I don't have the takeaway? It's stuck with me for ever now.

godmum56 · 10/07/2022 22:22

saleorbouy · 10/07/2022 21:38

For those who say she can't earn enough at her age, that's not true.
At her age I easily earned £75 - 100 per/week mowing lawns, cutting hedges and gardening and that was for £5.50 per/hr in the mid 90's.
I'm sure she could earn £10per/hr with a little entrepreneurship and dedication.

that may have been ok when you did it but I wouldn't pay a child to work in my garden, especially not using sharp or power tools. I'd be too worried about the consequences of an accident.

checkingout · 10/07/2022 22:20

I think travelling is important but over 1k sounds like an awful lot. If it's for the experience of skiing the school could have picked Scotland. Sounds like they're going to the Italian Alps instead though with the sterling so low everything's expensive.

00100001 · 10/07/2022 22:18

DuckBilledPlattyJoobs · 10/07/2022 21:54

This

LOL, as if the school would fund a jolly

Touchmybum · 10/07/2022 22:18

I have a tiny little chip on my shoulder about school trips. I really, really wanted to go on a school trip to France. My closest friends said they were going - and did go. That was back in ancient times though when under 16s could have a job and I'd been working on Saturdays and in school holidays since I was almost 15. My parents said I couldn't go, so I saved up and paid for it myself. I was good at French, and ended up pursuing it to degree level. I had never been to France.

A year or so later, there was a history trip to Paris. I was studying the French Revolution for A level History, and I was desperate to go. My parents said no, and this time I didn't have enough money to pay for it myself. I was gutted not to be able to go! Yes, my friends and classmates pretty much all went.

Fast forward a few years, and one by one, both of my sisters (neither of whom had a PT job) were funded by my parents when their turn to go came. I felt very hard done by!

Soooo, I wanted to be as fair to my kids as I could. DD1 had trips to Germany and Spain, plus a French exchange. DD2 had a trip to Spain, a French exchange, and a Travel & Tourism trip to Paris. She was also funded for a uni trip to NYC during her degree course. I wanted her to go... but I didn't. They were only able to accommodate something like 30, and DD2 and her friend were 29 and 30 😁DS however never did any school trips, which I feel bad about, but he never wanted to go, plus Covid hit before his GCSEs. I would have loved for him to have that experience too and would have funded 3 school trips somehow, same as his siblings!

I do remember DD1 losing the plot because I wouldn't pay for her to go to Spain for a very expensive sports trip! She wasn't even sporty lol! She's 25 now and I think she's long got over it!!

They also all got to do Guides/Scouts, various musical instruments each, swimming lessons, etc which had me running around 5 nights a week. I'm not sure they will ever appreciate the efforts/expense/sacrifices that were made for them...

£1k is a lot for most families to find. If you are going to struggle to find it, then you have to say no. Plus if you do say yes, then remember if you have other children, then they have to get the same opportunity. Personally I felt that £1k (think the sports trip was over that, and my DD is 25 now!) was better put towards a family holiday that we could all enjoy!

Swipe left for the next trending thread