Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To eat one meal a day

89 replies

Lemonite · 10/07/2022 18:03

Trying to lose the last 10lbs to get to my goal weight.

It's the most stubborn 10lbs in the bloody world. I track every calorie, I drink only water, exercise a lot, no snacking between meals or takeaways, no treats, no booze, essentially no fun whatsoever!

But it's not budging. And that's at 1300-1400kcals a day, consistently. But the past 2 months I've not lost a gram.

So - that must be my maintenance kcals. Would it be unreasonable to eat one meal a day (dinner) of around 800-1000kcals to just get this 10lbs shifted? Would it mess with my metabolism?!

Any tips I'd appreciate!

OP posts:
EssexSerpent · 11/07/2022 09:07

1000 cals a day for a couple of weeks over 1-2 meals will kick start you again. Lots of info. around on weight loss plateaus but you can get through them.

  • starvation mode and it messing up your metabolism (for what is being described here) as a theory has largely been debunked
  • lots of scientific evidence for health benefits of time restricted eating so chomp within a 6-8 hour window or just 1 meal if you can manage that
  • if you’re doing weight resistance training (and I mean proper weights not just 5kg kettlebells during HIIT), you will weigh more through muscle but will look leaner. At these calories levels you want to do that and not lose weight from muscle loss. So if you really have lean muscle you’ll also burn more fat so TDEE probably isn’t that far off
mama9876 · 11/07/2022 09:06

Why don't you measure fat % instead? you are excising a lot, your weight might be more muscle than fat?

TheAverageUser · 11/07/2022 09:03

I think it's fine to do or you can fast until 3pm, for example, and have a shake or similar and then a bigger meal around 6/7pm?

To everyone saying what's the point if she can't maintain it, she's maintaining weight now by eating 1400 calories so once she's dropped this weight she can go back up to that.

echt · 11/07/2022 09:00

If you have to get one meal day to use 10lbs then your goal is unrealistic.

Harridance · 11/07/2022 08:59

It's fine for some people, we all have different metabolisms and different needs

Hibiscrubber · 11/07/2022 08:57

It's depressing that so many women feel starving themselves is the way to go, to look good. Also encouraging others to do the same.

Speak to a professional - a nutritionist.

Impracticalbongos · 11/07/2022 08:54

One meal a day sounds like an utterly miserable way to live.

Wednesdayafternoon · 11/07/2022 08:53

Be careful OP.
Skipping meals might loose the weight but it won't keep it off. You'll also find it very hard to revert back to eating more as you'll gain and feel bad about it. Trust me, I've been there.
Your body needs more then one meal a day.

Dreikanter · 11/07/2022 08:50

Lemonite · 11/07/2022 07:13

@FinallyHere thanks very much!

Luckily my gym have started smart health checks, this is actually what prompted me to lose more fat.

My muscle mass is okay, 75% of total weight, but my weight isn't far off overweight BMI wise and my body fat is 23%. Very low visceral fat though. I definitely look 'soft' and the flab around my middle is the worst.

Thanks for the link! Still no budge on the scale this morning. Yesterday I walked 21k steps, 10k run, 20 min weights workout and ate 1100 kcal. Off to the gym now.

Maybe this is just what it takes to tone up? I know they say it's dedication and hard work.

Sounds as if your muscle mass has increased your BMI - I wouldn’t worry about that at all given your fat levels (DS is a power lifter, his BMI is about 28 but he has increased muscle mass and low body fat).

I’d ditch the scales and think more about toning exercises rather than pushing yourself to lose weight. Pilates might be worth trying?

CrystalCoco · 11/07/2022 08:49

Have you looked at any of the Body Coach workout plans, healthy nutritional meals (focussed on macros rather than calorie counting)

4-5 HIIT workouts per week to ramp up calorie burn

lots of water

no alcohol

includes healthy snacks

It's hard work but rewarding - you already work hard, something like this could be the game changer for you.

flipperdoda · 11/07/2022 08:35

I'm sorry and I know you probably won't believe me but previous posters are right when they said it sounds like you have an unhealthy attitude towards this. A healthy attitude towards food and exercise combined with being 10lbs over where you'd like to be is far better than an unhealthy attitude towards both (no matter what weight you might be with that). As people have pointed out - if you do this, and lose the weight, how are you going to maintain? Are you going to live the rest of your life only eating one meal a day?

I do weights too, and measurements and how you feel in your clothes/going up stairs/doing day to day activities is a better measure than weight. Your body can't necessarily put on muscle and lose fat at the same time - it's often a bit of one then a bit of the other. Discouraging? Can be, but only if you're worried about numbers rather than health. Best way to burn calories is to have lots of muscle, best way to build lots of muscle is to eat enough to fuel your exercise - and to get good rest, which includes at least one day off per week and good sleep.

I really hope you get to a point where you like your body, whether that's through weight loss or muscle gain or both - but please don't sacrifice mental health (disordered attitude towards food/exercise) to get there. It's really not worth it and so hard to unlearn.

sonsmum · 11/07/2022 08:10

don't do anything you can't sustain, otherwise what is the point? You'll possibly lose it, but then will regain when you revert to a less drastic pattern.

Scianel · 11/07/2022 08:10

I mostly eat one meal a day or at least fast till mid-late afternoon. I also don't eat sugar/aspartame/UPF and not much gluten or high carb food.
I feel very good on it, the whole lack of energy/blood sugar issues thing is just the first few days while you adjust. Once you're used to it it feels absolutely fine.
I do it for weight control but also health benefits. Our digestive systems really weren't designed to be constantly working.

xxcatcatcatxx · 11/07/2022 08:08
  • Maybe cut back on the exercise though it does seem a little intense if you’re only going to do one meal. I literally do no exercise and eat a massive meal with most of my calories for the day in though so please take care of yourself xxx
xxcatcatcatxx · 11/07/2022 08:02

I’m unintentionally doing this at the moment and it’s really not that bad, once you make it to 2ish you’re nearly at dinner anyway.

Mines not for weight though, I’ve out of my own money now my maternitys half and electricity is so expensive and luckily it’s wayyyyyy to hot to eat anything at the mo anyway xxx

NDandMe · 11/07/2022 08:00

bloomflower · 11/07/2022 07:52

yanbu OP, despite what others might think this is a super healthy way of doing it! and maintaining it. Humans weren't made to eat three meals a day. Only the last few generations that we have! Fasting is great for your metabolism.

I have no issue with fasting, I do it myself most days (16:8). The OP's other comments, however, are a bit concerning.

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 11/07/2022 08:00

Listen to your body. Starve yourself and yes, you will lose that 10lbs. Start eating normally again and it will go straight back on. Your body has found a weight it wants to settle at so stop trying to fight it so hard and relax a bit.

PurpleDaisies · 11/07/2022 08:00

So many red flags here.

You are not eating anywhere near enough for that level of activity.

You have a worrying attitude to scales.
You can’t take a rest day from exercise.

Where are you aiming for on the bmi scale?

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind1 · 11/07/2022 07:58

I've been doing this for around 15 years, NOT as a weight thing, but to keep my IBS under control which it does.
I eat whatever I like, but only one meal, dinner.
I never eat breakfast but will occasionally eat lunch, maybe once a month if there's a reason, a meal out with friends or similar, but then I take buscopan and immodium.

Rugges · 11/07/2022 07:58

I did this at the end of last month. Only for a couple of weeks and lost 8 pounds. Problem is that it re-triggered my binge eating disorder which I thought I ahd put on ice and I have put that back on and more since.

So, if you have had any issues in the past with binge eating or bulimia (which used to be my other problem) I would tread carefully.

HyggeTygge · 11/07/2022 07:55

Do you feel happy living like this?

(Meant kindly)

bloomflower · 11/07/2022 07:52

yanbu OP, despite what others might think this is a super healthy way of doing it! and maintaining it. Humans weren't made to eat three meals a day. Only the last few generations that we have! Fasting is great for your metabolism.

NDandMe · 11/07/2022 07:50

This level of obsession is what's unhealthy. What is stopping you from being happy right now, at a mere 10lbs over your decided number?

doadeer · 11/07/2022 07:50

*Yesterday I walked 21k steps, 10k run, 20 min weights workout and ate 1100 kcal. Off to the gym now.

Maybe this is just what it takes to tone up? I know they say it's dedication and hard work.*

This doesn't sound remotely healthy

Harridance · 11/07/2022 07:44

I thought fasting was good fir the body every now and then