Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To eat one meal a day

89 replies

Lemonite · 10/07/2022 18:03

Trying to lose the last 10lbs to get to my goal weight.

It's the most stubborn 10lbs in the bloody world. I track every calorie, I drink only water, exercise a lot, no snacking between meals or takeaways, no treats, no booze, essentially no fun whatsoever!

But it's not budging. And that's at 1300-1400kcals a day, consistently. But the past 2 months I've not lost a gram.

So - that must be my maintenance kcals. Would it be unreasonable to eat one meal a day (dinner) of around 800-1000kcals to just get this 10lbs shifted? Would it mess with my metabolism?!

Any tips I'd appreciate!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Booklover3 · 11/07/2022 12:24

Especially when it’s hot weather ^^

Booklover3 · 11/07/2022 12:23

I don’t mind IF or OMAD but if you do OMAD you need to make sure you get all your calories in that one meal.

Quite often I get to 6pm or 7pm and realise I’ve only had a few cups of teas and nothing to eat.

OMAD does work for me. When I actually consistently do it.

Genericusername1234 · 11/07/2022 11:58

If you were going to skip meals for weight loss, surely dinner would be the one to ditch? I'm not recommending that, but generally eating more at night isn’t good for weight loss.
more importantly, this won’t be maintainable weight loss without chronic undereating. 23% fat is on the low side of healthy for a woman.

HairyKitty · 11/07/2022 11:58

I don’t understand some of the posts on here. OP may well have to restrict to 1000/1200 cals to lose the last few lb, but that wouldnt be her maintenance allowance as she’s going to lose weight on this amount. After she’s finished losing she can move back towards 1400 cals for maintenance.

Beautiful3 · 11/07/2022 11:49

If you did it twice a week, it would technically be fasting. Fasting does work.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 11/07/2022 11:45

You relationship with weightloss and food sounds extremely unhealthy. Why are those 10lbs so important to you? What will you do when you lose them and then find you keep having to overexercise and eat nothing to maintain it? What's your long term plan here?

Mat44 · 11/07/2022 11:42

This thread is so depressing. I can’t believe so many women are still so brainwashed by diet culture.

Obviously it’s great to look after yourself - Exercise because it feels good and makes you strong, eat because it tastes nice and nourishes your body. But all this starvation, calorie counting, deprivation, obsessing about a number on a scales is just beyond ridiculous. What’s going to happen when you suddenly reach this magic number??

Musti · 11/07/2022 11:31

I’m not an expert but people have posted on Team RH for example saying how they used to really restrict themselves and never lose weight. They upped their calories and stuck to the right proportions of carbs, fat and protein and did 10-15k steps a day and the weight fell off/they lost fat.

because if you have spent years restricting yourself your body holds on to the fat. You train your metabolism to slow down.

SandieCollins · 11/07/2022 11:25

Scianel · 11/07/2022 11:08

Not just the OP but all the encouragement - this is not a healthy way to live

If you read up on intermittant fasting or things like 16/8 you'll see there are tangible health benefits behind eating this way. We're brought up that you're meant to eat three meals a day and anything that deviates from that is questioned but the three meals a day thing isn't necessarily healthly or ideal for everyone.

Eating this way has removed any desire I used to have to binge or eat unhealthily and my relationship with food feels good.

This recent article says it’s still under researched but there is an association with eating disorder symptomology. It all warrants further research but the blanket recommendation of it as a healthy way to eat is concerning to me. theypubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34191688/

rocketfromthecrypt · 11/07/2022 11:20

SandieCollins · 11/07/2022 10:51

Blimey! What am I reading? Not just the OP but all the encouragement - this is not a healthy way to live. The level of exercise you’re doing on the amount of food you’re eating is not safe or sustainable.

Fad diets, competitive exercising, finding strategies to stop yourself being hungry. It’s like eavesdropping on a conversation between people with eating disorders.

I know - really weird and concerning - I feel as though I'm back at secondary school listening to my year ten classmates sharing tips on how to starve themselves.

LonelyPlanetGirI · 11/07/2022 11:11

DH does but he's a recovering anorexic.

That way madness lies. You won't be able to maintain it anyway, even if you lose it.

Scianel · 11/07/2022 11:08

Not just the OP but all the encouragement - this is not a healthy way to live

If you read up on intermittant fasting or things like 16/8 you'll see there are tangible health benefits behind eating this way. We're brought up that you're meant to eat three meals a day and anything that deviates from that is questioned but the three meals a day thing isn't necessarily healthly or ideal for everyone.

Eating this way has removed any desire I used to have to binge or eat unhealthily and my relationship with food feels good.

SandieCollins · 11/07/2022 10:51

Blimey! What am I reading? Not just the OP but all the encouragement - this is not a healthy way to live. The level of exercise you’re doing on the amount of food you’re eating is not safe or sustainable.

Fad diets, competitive exercising, finding strategies to stop yourself being hungry. It’s like eavesdropping on a conversation between people with eating disorders.

Hankunamatata · 11/07/2022 10:51

I had reached same sort of plateau and exercising. Gave myself a weekend off and dropped some weight. Perhaps you need more calories if your exercising so much?

Teaandcakeordeath83 · 11/07/2022 10:49

I've been trying to lose weight healthily over the past 6 weeks because I'd reached my heaviest weight ever and felt and looked bloody awful- I was particularly carrying a lot around my middle. Too much processed crap, too much food in general, basically sedentary. My two year old lifting my belly up and weight lifting it alongside my five year old asking me why I was so fat tipped me right over the edge. Anyway....

Podcasts got my head straight and set me on a path I am really enjoying. Firstly the "a thorough examination" podcast with the van Tullekan brothers on BBC sounds changed my head about what food actually is. Dr Rangan Chattergee has a really good one called feel better live more. There's some really good episodes. I really enjoyed the Satchin Panda (all about eating windows and the benefits they have on EVERYTHING) episodes and Valter Lungo's (all about fasting and fast mimicking diets- FMD). Lots of excellent peer reviewed science (rather than "that's not good for you" tutting based on nonsense and diet industry woo).

Now I am in a lot worse condition than you- I started at 14st9 and I'm 5'6". I've been following 16:8 for 6 weeks now (2 meals a day, no breakfast and no snacking), have been aiming for at least 70000 steps a week, have been doing yoga on the fiton app daily and have completed one 5 day cycle of FMD which I'll repeat monthly until I lose the weight I need to (3st 5lb to go...). I haven't calorie counted other than on the FMD and I eat mainly plant based with the very occasional odd bit of dairy. I don't eat meat or fish and have cut out all UPFs and sugar. I'm now 13st5 and absolutely loving the way I'm eating now. One thing I really noticed about the FMD days were that I was noticeably losing my weight on my stomach- Valter Lungo goes into detail on how FMDs target abdominal fats.

You sound like you're incredibly fit and are doing everything right. Please be kind to your body and mind. You need to rest as much as you need to move. Would those last 10lbs make a difference or are you being unnecessarily harsh on yourself based on the scale? When someone is as fit as you sound (a "gentle" 5k as an off day would probably kill me atm!) the scale might not be your friend in terms of telling you what you need to know.

NeverFlyCoach · 11/07/2022 10:28

I feel like I've wandered into a 90s thinspiration chat...

rocketfromthecrypt · 11/07/2022 10:19

Maybe you're just at the weight you're supposed to be at. Sounds as though the number on the scales is totally dominating your life, which is far more unhealthy than an arbitrary 'goal'.

Woozlewoo · 11/07/2022 10:15

You're not eating enough calories and your metabolism has slowed right down. This happened to me and I switched to 5:2 to shake things up a bit. You eat your maintenance calories for 5 days of the week and 800 calories for 2 days. Doing this, I started losing 1-2 lbs a week again and also enjoyed food again!

Just don't start on a fast day; have a couple of non fast days first. And spread your fast days out, don't lump them together or it's hard! I have Mondays and Thursdays as my fast days. Also, I weigh myself on a Friday morning, after my fast day.

I'm now at my goal weight and I've been maintaining by carrying on with 5:2 and eating more on my non fast days. This includes cake!

ihavenocats · 11/07/2022 10:14

Are the calories you are consuming containing nutrition that keeps you full and your body uses properly? Rice, oats, plants, beans, lentils, etc?

Or are they processed foodstuffs?

Your body will use them differently.

I have been overweight and underweight, not massively overweight and people think I'm very slim because I'm tall but I have been overweight. I ate lots of dairy and processed stuff.

I didn't "go on a diet", I streamlined my diet (we all eat, we are all "on a diet" all the time) I made that diet 90% good stuff, fresh foods that were going to nourish my body. And I didn't restrict myself as such from the crap, rather I left little room for it by filling up with things like big salads with chickpea tuna or brown coconut rice.

Delicious stuff that doesn't add excess weight because my body uses it for nutrition. Then I stopped craving the cakes, processed sugar, and processed vegan stuff as I was full for the most part from the good stuff.

I think this works. I don't think it's as simple as counting calories and I know it's not because it never seems to work.

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind1 · 11/07/2022 10:03

Starvation mode I mean.
No such thing.

StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind1 · 11/07/2022 10:00

It's a crock of shit.

questionthyme · 11/07/2022 09:58

Sorrynotsorry2 · 11/07/2022 09:57

Sounds like your body would be going into starvation mode and clinging on to all the "fat" . I wouldn't of thought you are eating enough calories for the amount of exercise your doing. try and up your protein intake a bit . Even if its just an extra chicken breast or half of one in your meals .

I don't think starvation mode is a thing

Sorrynotsorry2 · 11/07/2022 09:57

Sounds like your body would be going into starvation mode and clinging on to all the "fat" . I wouldn't of thought you are eating enough calories for the amount of exercise your doing. try and up your protein intake a bit . Even if its just an extra chicken breast or half of one in your meals .

Fallstar · 11/07/2022 09:17

I don't think you are being unreasonable at all. OMAD can be hugely beneficial for health, whether you have weight to lose or not.

Look at Dr Jason Fung, as suggested earlier, but also Dr Pradip Jamnadas (cardiologist) and Dr Mark Mattson (neuroscientist), who all believe that the eating-all-day pattern of three meals with snacks in between promoted by modern food manufacturers is unhealthy and not how humans evolved to eat.

maddening · 11/07/2022 09:08

This is where the meal replacements come in handy as they contain the nutrients you require. The main issue with vlcd is nutrients, it is hard to create a menu for 800 cals with everything you need included.

Swipe left for the next trending thread