Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to say I don’t want to take a personality test at work

194 replies

PenelopeWhipStop · 10/07/2022 17:43

My manager has told me he intends to have us all take a personality test as part of our 1-2-1 meetings. I queried whether this was an organisational thing or his own personal decision (it’s his idea). It’s to help determine if we’re introverts or extroverts, how we learn, possible career paths.

I already know I’m an introvert! Was I being unreasonable to tell him I’m not keen for n his idea?

OP posts:
Notmanybroadbeans · 11/07/2022 01:55

Re: the post about the test uncovering personality disorders - it won't do that, surely. I've done at least three different kinds of these tests (MBTI, Insights, another one or two I can't remember the name of) and all the personality types are different but equal. There's no bad personality type. The whole point is to encourage you to appreciate the differences, e.g. Doris isn't just being a slowcoach, she's very thorough; blunt Rupert isn't necessarily a twat but wants to get things done right and on time. It shouldn't get too personal; it will be focused on your working style. The questions are dull as dishwater, you're not going to be on the couch with Sigmund Freud.

If your manager is anything like every manager I've ever had, he will immediately forget what personality type you are. He will either be captivated by his own result, or disappointed in it. Either way, the novelty will wear off before he's even looked at yours.

Notmanybroadbeans · 11/07/2022 01:35

They are largely bollocks, but taken with a pinch of salt can be quite enlightening.

But why would you give the wrong answers, as some are suggesting? You'll still get assigned a type, it's not going to look like a spoilt ballot. And then you'll still have to sit through the sessions listening to all kinds of rubbish being said about you, and having to answer to it.

Oldsu · 11/07/2022 01:19

In the 80s I worked for an ad agency, a third of the business was search and selection and I was friends with the guy heading it, they staring offering clients the Myers Biggs test as a way of getting them candidates suited to the particular vacancy well that's what they told them in actual fact as my friend fully admitted it was so they could charge them an extra 25%, fast forward a few years later both my friend and I lost our jobs through redundancy, he rang me a few weeks later he had got a job as an HR manager and there was a job going he knew I could do only I had to have an interview (not with him) part of the interview was the MBT, he rang me to say that I wasn't successful as my personality did not fit the job, he then said don't know what you were thinking when you did it Oldsu but you start Monday, I am still with the company only now I am at director level so I know its rubbish

PenelopeWhipStop · 11/07/2022 00:35

Fulbe · 10/07/2022 23:30

I'd say he has a good idea of your personality already from working with you. It could be him trying to be diplomatic in trying to deal with some issues either you or someone else in the team has, and asking everyone to do it is just his way of masking this. I'd be taking some time to think whether it is you that he has the issues with. From some of your responses to this thread (e.g. saying you're stubborn and a PITA) I'd think that there might be some things you would want to reflect on.

In my defence - me saying stubborn and a PITA was how I thought not taking a test could be interpreted. Last time we had a 1-2-1 I got great feedback and I’m on friendly terms with everyone on the team, including him.
I suspect there’s others who won’t be too keen on a personality test either.

OP posts:
entropynow · 10/07/2022 23:44

@alphapie
And you sound like a nightmare manager. Team spirit is NOT 'kow tow to the management's pseudo scientific fads or else'

brokengoalposts · 10/07/2022 23:41

They're supposed to be taken no less than 6m apart, so uni will have been too long ago to still be relevant.

They're a load of crap anyway. I've taken a few and have come out at both introvert and domineering, it all depends on what mood I'm in at the time.

entropynow · 10/07/2022 23:41

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/07/2022 17:45

No. What a dreadful idea. Is there any rigorous evidence that these are actually useful in any way?

No. Myers Briggs is BS and I get a different result every time. It tells you what you want to think of yourself at the time.

Fulbe · 10/07/2022 23:30

I'd say he has a good idea of your personality already from working with you. It could be him trying to be diplomatic in trying to deal with some issues either you or someone else in the team has, and asking everyone to do it is just his way of masking this. I'd be taking some time to think whether it is you that he has the issues with. From some of your responses to this thread (e.g. saying you're stubborn and a PITA) I'd think that there might be some things you would want to reflect on.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/07/2022 23:22

alphapie · 10/07/2022 19:37

@saraclara gosh you sound a total bore. Glad I've never had the displeasure of working with anyone so uptight in the workplace before.

I'd look very dimly on any of my team who refused to undertake their sessions for this and it would definitely impact progression as it's just not a team focused attitude

Thus proving exactly why they're best avoided.

Bitwornout · 10/07/2022 22:19

I fucking hate them. Used by lazy managers to try and team build. I'm an extravert so it's not just introverts that dislike doing this. I am a grown up and I know what I am like and how I like to work. I can clearly articulate this to my colleagues but managers who lack intellectual curiosity love MB - so I suppose it's useful for identifying people you don't want to work for. I run a large functional team and have never ever put my staff through this nonsense. May as well ask people what star sign they are and base your work planning on that for all the good it does.

CallmeMrsPricklepants · 10/07/2022 22:12

I'm an academic. I wouldn't touch mbti with a bargepole. But there are trait measures that have decades of rigourous research showing their validity.

MigsandTiggs · 10/07/2022 22:09

@Luredbyapomegranate (Persephone, love your user name btw!)
I'm not associated with MB but used to be a qualified practitioner for a psychometric test helping non-engaging young people understand their relationship with authority etc. These test results were always confidential.

In my first job on leaving uni, the HR manager (my boss) asked me to do a 16PF test as she was thinking of introducing it as a management tool. I declined on the grounds that I felt it was based on research conducted on people in a different culture from mine, so not convinced about relevance in my case.😀

I've found usefulness where results can be used to introduce discussions on self awareness and behaviour in certain settings. "Fun" quizzes eg Which animal are you? aren't bad icebreakers, but they are just that - for fun.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 10/07/2022 21:27

MBTI evangelists are drawn to these threads like flies to shit. I swear there's some sort of klaxon goes out.

Regardless of any accuracy or validity claims, it is intrusive and overreaching for workplaces to make employees feel they should take personality tests for work. It's an invasion of privacy and could disadvantage perfectly good employees.

MigsandTiggs · 10/07/2022 21:22

cross post.

MigsandTiggs · 10/07/2022 21:22

defence of MBTI
For reference, OP.

Ginajo · 10/07/2022 21:12

I've done both Myers Briggs and insights in corporate environments. Both very useful in understanding myself and how I relate to others and also how to get the best out of my team.

The Myers Briggs definition of introvert and extrovert has always stuck with me. I'm fairly quiet and would describe myself as an introvert but it's about where you get your energy from - being with others or by being alone. I realised I'm actually an extrovert.

If I were you OP I'd try and see it as an opportunity. You might find it useful.

Luredbyapomegranate · 10/07/2022 21:09

MigsandTiggs · 10/07/2022 21:01

Absolutely this.
Myers Briggs type testing is accurate and reliable on the test, retest scores. It's not a fun FB quiz but an organisational tool to identify strengths and weaknesses. When used as part of a performance appraisal, it can highlight areas where employees need to develop and this can then be linked to the year's action plan for training and development. It's actually a good way to tick off progression points.

But I would definitely ask if a qualified person is conducting the tests. If it's just an unqualified manager, then ask the purpose, as any results will be unlikely to get any proper analysis.

@MigsandTiggs

Whether or not Myers Briggs has any validity or not is controversial. The company has certainly tried to improve it, and some academics think it has validity - and others absolutely don’t

www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-accurate-are-personality-tests/

I’m hoping your user name doesn’t indicate that you are involved with it (I’m sure you aren’t - just flagging in case.)

SirChenjins · 10/07/2022 21:08

MigsandTiggs · 10/07/2022 21:01

Absolutely this.
Myers Briggs type testing is accurate and reliable on the test, retest scores. It's not a fun FB quiz but an organisational tool to identify strengths and weaknesses. When used as part of a performance appraisal, it can highlight areas where employees need to develop and this can then be linked to the year's action plan for training and development. It's actually a good way to tick off progression points.

But I would definitely ask if a qualified person is conducting the tests. If it's just an unqualified manager, then ask the purpose, as any results will be unlikely to get any proper analysis.

Plenty of studies disagree with that MB claim.

SirChenjins · 10/07/2022 21:07

SandieCollins · 10/07/2022 20:36

I disagree.

Of course they’ve got limitations, pretty much anything has if you want to explore the evidence around it, but if used well they can be a great way to start a conversation. People can take on board what they want and leave want they don’t (a bit like horoscopes). Again, if a manager wants to label people based on this there are bigger issues. Likewise the suggestion that managers will gossip about results.

I personally wouldn’t do them individually in an enforced way but as part of a team away day, perhaps what you describe as ‘fun’ they can be great. As I say, it was a game changer for our team.

And that’s great your team enjoyed them, but I’m terms of accuracy they are to be taken with a big dollop of salt.

TolkiensFallow · 10/07/2022 21:06

If it’s the “Insights” training, it’s actually quite helpful

Luredbyapomegranate · 10/07/2022 21:04

Even the good ones have extremely limited accuracy. They are just guides for you as an individual, another person wouldn’t understand the nuance.

I’d send him a few reputable links as below, and say that you think that the evidence suggests they do considerably more harm that good and what managers should really be doing is talking to their staff.

I’m assuming he’s very young. This will probably put him off. You could also gently raise ir with HR, if your company doesn’t use them, it’s unlikely they will be happy with individual managers doing so.

ed.ted.com/lessons/how-do-personality-tests-work-merve-emre
ed.ted.com/lessons/how-do-personality-tests-work-merve-emre#review

ed.ted.com/lessons/how-do-personality-tests-work-merve-emre
ed.ted.com/lessons/how-do-personality-tests-work-merve-emre#review

MigsandTiggs · 10/07/2022 21:01

CallmeMrsPricklepants · 10/07/2022 18:21

The British psychological society are very clear that you have to be qualified and on the list of registered test users to administer psychometrics at work. Has he got his bps qualifications? Is he on the register? If not then I would point this out the HR.

Absolutely this.
Myers Briggs type testing is accurate and reliable on the test, retest scores. It's not a fun FB quiz but an organisational tool to identify strengths and weaknesses. When used as part of a performance appraisal, it can highlight areas where employees need to develop and this can then be linked to the year's action plan for training and development. It's actually a good way to tick off progression points.

But I would definitely ask if a qualified person is conducting the tests. If it's just an unqualified manager, then ask the purpose, as any results will be unlikely to get any proper analysis.

PenelopeWhipStop · 10/07/2022 20:59

ScreamingToddler · 10/07/2022 20:33

To all these managers relying on disturbing levels of pseudo science and accusing people of lack of teamwork,
how will you handle it when an employee turns out to be one of the 9.1% of the population with a personality disorder and the lid is blown off in your "fun test" because they didn't actually know this about themselves until they either can't do the test or get repeatedly totally different results each time? What will you do when someone with PTSD dissociates in one of them? What will you do when someone with anxiety is accused of a lack of team effort when really they're just anxious?
Nothing. You'll wash your hands of it and say "it was only a fun test to learn something about each other haha".
Do any of you actually THINK before throwing around potentially dangerous shite that some people take too seriously?
OP YANBU and if your manager thinks otherwise ask him where he got his psychiatry qualifications from.

Thank you.
you’ve just described my innermost, deepest darkest fears about a personality test and, ultimately, I don’t think it’ll do my mental health much good. I also don’t have confidence that my manager could manage the consequences!

OP posts:
festivebitches · 10/07/2022 20:55
  • I wouldn’t say it was the hill I wanted to die on. I just don’t like the idea and queried why he was intending to do this and let him know I wasn’t keen. He said he wouldn’t make me.

I’d consider myself quite open and honest at work and have already had discussions about what my strengths and weaknesses are (perhaps a personality test would bring out strengths or weaknesses I don’t know?). My main worry is what if a test comes back to say I’m totally unsuitable for my role? How will that then influence my manager and how he acts towards me?*

No test would be ever tell you you were unsuitable for your job. Also, You've probably been misinformed about these tests. They're not to test your personality, they're normally to help your manager understand your 'working style'. Like if you thrive in teams/autonomy, if you're more likely to be conscientious/steady etc etc. and there is no one desired style, certified facilitators of these tests will emphasise that all of these styles are required for a thriving team. The point of the tests are to understand how to work best in your team and how to understand how you and your team can work more cohesively. There really isn't anything to worry about. If anything, it shows your manager can be bothered to run an effective team. He/she is trying. I hope this helps

Swipe left for the next trending thread