Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to say I don’t want to take a personality test at work

194 replies

PenelopeWhipStop · 10/07/2022 17:43

My manager has told me he intends to have us all take a personality test as part of our 1-2-1 meetings. I queried whether this was an organisational thing or his own personal decision (it’s his idea). It’s to help determine if we’re introverts or extroverts, how we learn, possible career paths.

I already know I’m an introvert! Was I being unreasonable to tell him I’m not keen for n his idea?

OP posts:
SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 11/07/2022 14:44

Ineedaduvetday · 11/07/2022 14:05

Just because you have to pay, doesn't mean there is no value

Who said anything that trite? Because I didn't.

EssexSerpent · 11/07/2022 14:38

Are you suggesting that a persons MBTI profile has been used as grounds for redundancy? Never seen or heard that but honestly if a company wants you out they will find a way and won’t invest in MBTI profiling to do it so that’s a major stretch for me.

Redebs · 11/07/2022 14:32

I would say absolutely don't engage in 'personality tests' in the workplace.
For a start, these are highly unscientific and unreliable. The idea that people can be assessed and grouped like this is an old-fashioned concept linked to some very dodgy reasoning.
Some management types believe they can apply them to workplace settings and it opens up a whole area of risk that promotion, opportunities and prejudices are given a pseudoscientific justification instead of looking at performance or workplace training. If your employer chooses to base decisions of salary or redundancy on those, then you can be seriously and unfairly disadvantaged with no chance of negotiation.
The main reason I would say no is that they are blundering through areas that are too personal and intrusive. You wouldn't share medical or therapeutic details with a layperson employer who could use them against you or share them without your knowledge. This is private. They don't own you Body and Soul!

SenecaFallsRedux · 11/07/2022 14:17

It plays into society’s incorrigible obsession with self and love of ‘learning’ about themselves.

I think this is a good point. I remember a manager I once had talking about each of us "doing the work on our inner selves" in a meeting. I thought to myself, I'm here to "do the work" I am paid to do. My inner self is none of your business.

Herejustforthisone · 11/07/2022 14:10

Ineedaduvetday · 11/07/2022 14:05

Just because you have to pay, doesn't mean there is no value

No, no. They’re absolute nonsense. Snake oil. It plays into society’s incorrigible obsession with self and love of ‘learning’ about themselves.

Ineedaduvetday · 11/07/2022 14:05

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 11/07/2022 08:44

You know the only reason they are licensed is so that someone can make money from them? That is what they are. Pseudo scientific questionnaires.

Just because you have to pay, doesn't mean there is no value

Onetoffeetin · 11/07/2022 10:16

You could always ask your manager what training they have in the administration and interpretation of psychometric tests. What governance is in place? Completing such tests should be done on a voluntary basis only. Quite irresponsible IMO.
What industry do you work in? Why is knowing this important?

Blowthemandown · 11/07/2022 09:36

PenelopeWhipStop · 10/07/2022 17:53

that was meant for Aquamarine’s first answer. Yeah, a load of bollocks!

Not everyone’s cup of tea but the proper ones can be very insightful. I love doing them. But I don’t think anyone can force you (unless you’re applying for a specific type of job perhaps - I’ve had to do that once). And certainly not on a whim. So he’ll have to manage without your input. I’d also want to know who can access/where the answers would be recorded, will they get deleted, data privacy etc.

Herejustforthisone · 11/07/2022 09:26

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/07/2022 23:22

Thus proving exactly why they're best avoided.

Quite. Imagine being a manager so unprofessional and lacking, that you bully your team into taking a test you can’t (and shouldn’t) administer and assess properly, and hinder the careers of those that don’t join in your ‘fun, team building’ exercise. I imagine they’re the sort of manager that would single out and hinder careers based on the misunderstood ‘results’, anyway.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 11/07/2022 09:21

MigsandTiggs · 10/07/2022 21:22

defence of MBTI
For reference, OP.

yes, do read that. It is illuminating. It states the obvious, adds some history very few re aware of and then goes on to state clearly that the Q suggests that some kinds of people are best suited for some kinds of job... its reliability is not in doubt, as I said, it gests the same results from the same individual repeatedly. Not surprising when you look at the questions. It's the validity that is in question.

The use it is put to is utter rubbish. The deductions, assumptions, straight jackets applied because of those deductions are ludicrous. Because people misunderstand what it is, what the 'results' mean etc

Any good manager would just talk to their staff.

EssexSerpent · 11/07/2022 09:19

Having done various of these in corporate environments for the last 20 years I do see the value in Myers Briggs and similar tools. My caveat is you need a good trainer or a manager very experienced in the frameworks.

Its interesting that you see it as a ‘test’ and your reaction. Reality is if your boss has a lot of experience with this, they’ll likely have a good idea which profile most closely fits you and your refusal is playing to type. You’ve already got a preconceived idea this will somehow highlight you as an ‘introvert’ (and why would that be bad?) but it’s way more than that. Are you open minded to experience it and consider you might learn something about yourself and other people? If you don’t, what have you lost?

I find it hard to get worked up about these things and at times it’s been hugely beneficial. It’s not just about you, the a group dynamic. There is no right/wrong profile, it’s learning style preferences which can be very useful to understand and recognise about yourself as well as others.

whenwillthemadnessend · 11/07/2022 09:18

I also think meyers Briggs Is very accurate for my family at least.

whenwillthemadnessend · 11/07/2022 09:16

Just
Lie on the test. How will he know. It's pretty obvious which answers will lead you to which the results.

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 11/07/2022 09:06

I'm not into MBTI and all that, but we're getting management coaching at work (1 hour a month minimum - kinda like therapy, but work oriented), and I'm finding it very helpful - I think at some point they might get us to do the tests, as a 44 year old I'd be surprised to learn much about myself that I don't already know, but I'll probably do it, just out of interest

C8H10N4O2 · 11/07/2022 09:02

alphapie · 10/07/2022 17:54

I'd consider why you want this to be a hill to die on.

Many organisations use these types of testing to help managers with training and coaching opportunities.

It's also not usually just an extravert or introvert thing either, many people are surprised by their results, some tests even show subconscious and conscious behaviour patterns, for me for example I over index in more 'friendly' work behaviours in work than I naturally would based on personality which I didn't really think about until we had our reports through. Some people the opposite and have a 'harder' work personality than their natural state.

These are all things that can help a manager work with a team. It's also helpful for co-workers to understand this too.

YABU

Name one which has proper evidence backing behind it, including testing conditions where the tests are administered by unqualified managers and HR reps.

These tests are no more scientific or accurate that zodiac signs and have the same level of confirmation bias. HR departments adore them because they sound "scientific" and objective - its a brilliant scam pulled on large scale businesses by some marketeers for the industry.

StColumbofNavron · 11/07/2022 08:56

Honestly I wouldn’t worry about it being anywhere near specific enough to say you are suitable for your job. We did Myers Briggs in a previous role as an entire Executive Assistant team and had to go to different sides of the room based on certain results - I was always on the 3 people (versus the 30 people) side. Nobody fired me, I carried on doing my job, my strongest attributes were just different things.

I already knew the various things about myself but it was definitely useful for me to learn about other people’s needs and them to learn about mine.

it probably is psycho-babble, but it was fun and really not a big deal. I’d save my energy for something else.

GabriellaMontez · 11/07/2022 08:46

Why don't you just make up the answers? It's all bollocks anyway.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 11/07/2022 08:44

Ineedaduvetday · 11/07/2022 06:41

A quiz from the Internet? No. However if it is a licensed test such as TMSDI or Myers Briggs etc then I think you'd be foolish to refuse. While I have no time for MB personally, some of the other tests can help teams work together by identifying styles and recognising strengths.

You know the only reason they are licensed is so that someone can make money from them? That is what they are. Pseudo scientific questionnaires.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 11/07/2022 08:43

Myers Briggs type testing is accurate and reliable on the test, retest scores. That just means if you answer the same questions the same way you get the same bloody results. It makes no comment on how accurate a reflection of the individual those results are!

stayingpositiveifpossible · 11/07/2022 07:09

TirisfalPumpkin · 10/07/2022 17:56

My work made us do this, and then we had a presentation about, look! Here are all the senior leaders’ results. They’re all extroverts!

It was pretty demotivating tbh. Even if you know it’s a load of pseudoscientific crap you could just see the idea crystallising in team leader’s mind as they looked at the team results: these will be groomed as future leaders, these are production line spods.

This.

CallmeMrsPricklepants · 11/07/2022 07:03

erinaceus · 11/07/2022 06:59

To give a different perspective, I always thought that whilst the tests themselves are not far off astrology in their ability to say anything objective about personality, what they can do is facilitate a conversation about preferences and learning styles and that sort of thing.

If you are able to look at it less as a judgement and more as a sort of inkblot test and prompt, you might find some use in it, particularly if there is anything about your own preferences that you would like to communicate to your manager.

This is exactly why the person providing feedback on it has to be trained. Trained to interpret the test and trained to discuss the findings.

erinaceus · 11/07/2022 06:59

To give a different perspective, I always thought that whilst the tests themselves are not far off astrology in their ability to say anything objective about personality, what they can do is facilitate a conversation about preferences and learning styles and that sort of thing.

If you are able to look at it less as a judgement and more as a sort of inkblot test and prompt, you might find some use in it, particularly if there is anything about your own preferences that you would like to communicate to your manager.

Forgotthebins · 11/07/2022 06:41

It’s tricky because the manager will likely hear this as you saying you don’t trust how the manager will use the results. Which based on the comments above seems fair. Do you know how they plan to use it?

Could you ask for a different test to be used, one which is less intrusive and which celebrates the diversity of personality types in the team? Or failing that, take control of the test analysis by claiming the introvert label with pride and be prepared to come back at them with all the brilliant things introverts add to teams?

Ineedaduvetday · 11/07/2022 06:41

A quiz from the Internet? No. However if it is a licensed test such as TMSDI or Myers Briggs etc then I think you'd be foolish to refuse. While I have no time for MB personally, some of the other tests can help teams work together by identifying styles and recognising strengths.

KatherineJaneway · 11/07/2022 06:13

girlmom21 · 10/07/2022 18:12

I bet you think the same about horoscopes, don't you?

No 🤔