Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour accused me of stealing their tree

257 replies

Ahelena79 · 10/07/2022 16:12

So our neighbour has a lovely willow tree. It does slightly overhang our border however I am very happy with that as it provides a lovely bit of shade in that corner of the garden which the kids sit under on hot evenings.

Around 4 summers ago I took several cuttings from this willow tree. I didn’t really think to ask at the time as they were nearly touching the floor of my garden and had no real impact on my neighbours life. Instead of chucking them back over the fence aggressively (which other neighbours have done to me!) I decided to plant them to grow a bit of a willow garden in one corner.

These willows have absolutely taken off. There’s about 6 in total all taken from branch cuttings. They are really tall now and can be seen from over the fence (which is 6 foot!)

My neighbour has recently seen them and is now demanding that his property is returned to him. He says I had no right to cut the willow and that they have always been his property even though I have nurtured them to life in the form of new trees. He says he will be contacting the police and threatening legal action. He told me that the willow is taken from cuttings of a family tree that was in his mothers garden and he considers it family property which he wanted to hand down to his kids but I’ve now stolen that from him?? He is absolutely crazy to be honest and I’ve had no previous dealings with him and I’m glad of that now!

Where do I stand legally on this?

OP posts:
howdoesatoastermaketoast · 10/07/2022 16:51

Ok I agree it's kind of a crazy seeming thing to do to lob trimmings over your neighbours fence but I see that you already know that theoretically it's what you should have done...

He seems to be taking it as a theft issue (you took something which belonged to me without permission) but honestly the value of the thing you 'took' (effectively nothing) the fact that by his own admission he didn't realise it had been taken for 4 years and the fact that his property was in your garden when you 'took' it means this isn't going to be something the police want to get involved in.

He could argue that he has a case for suing you but again I would have thought in any practical sense the problem with your neighbour suing you would be showing any material detriment that you didn't throw the cuttings back over. Which is to say you cost him nothing when you trimmed the overhang (he didn't even notice) or when you planted the material. He could have at any point in the previous 4 years taken cuttings himself and planted them to grow new trees of his own but he hasn't done this. The fact that you did in no way robbed him of the opportunity to do so.

By comparison 6 willow trees you have grown which are now over 6ft high you could be looking at a replacement value of £100 or £200 each depending on area and what's available in your local area and this difference in value is purely due to your time and nurture.

The six cuttings have little to no value by comparison - the smallest willow I could find for sale is £10 and is perhaps comparable to the cuttings you started from small willow

price list of trees Cheapest Salix they have is £280 but a little taller

If something comes through from small claims don't panic - if he threatens you with it say you'd prefer he take it to court so that you could both say your piece and let the judge decide over having a bad relationship for years say digging up the trees and returning them now isn't a fair or reasonable request in your mind but does he have a reasonable request he'd like you to consider?

ArtistViv · 10/07/2022 16:50

JennyForeigner · 10/07/2022 16:36

Offer him cuttings from your trees 😀

I second this, totally what I would do 😂

Floraanddougal · 10/07/2022 16:49

Well clearly he’s unhinged. But sadly he has right on his side. You legally need to offer the cuttings back. You can’t just cut em. Keep em and grow em. On the flip side it’s very rare anyone would behave in this manner, the police likely won’t get invovled but if they do you’d told they are his property and legally his.

RunningFromInsanity · 10/07/2022 16:47

This reply has been deleted

We've removed this post as it's not in the spirit of the site.

When I feel down, I just open MN and comments like these cheer me up.

WeAreBob · 10/07/2022 16:47

Maybe it has annoyed home because, while your allowed to cur anything overhanging your garden, you didnt cut them BECAUSE they were overhanging. You didnt do it because you don't want his plant in your garden. You cut his tree because you wanted some of it for yourself. Maybe that has made him feel like you've stolen from him.

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 10/07/2022 16:47

Your neighbour is an incredible pedant. I bet all the other neighbours hate him.

247SylviaPlath · 10/07/2022 16:47

We have all kinds of self rooted trees here (either squirrels or birds spreading them I imagine) - the idea that a neighbour would want 'their' tree back is insane. Most of them get uprooted and composted but I've kept a couple of elder offshoots cause I love them). If it was hanging over your side the only mistake you made was to admit they came from you doing cuttings! I can't imagine giving a shiny shit if a neighbour wanted to do whatever with anything hanging over their side - they can cut it back and get rid of it, throw it over to us, run around the garden naked waving it around for all I care. Being told you're a thief is harsh frankly, but some people are very odd..

Getoff · 10/07/2022 16:46

I don't think he can claim the rest of her Willow growth as interest, as it was her land and the sunlight that fell on it that created that growth.

Getoff · 10/07/2022 16:44

But bottom line is you are a thief.

Yes, he can sue for the economic value of some Willow cuttings. I'm not sure what that is, but OP needn't worry about a court finding against her, as she can easily pay damages in the form of cuttings from her trees. She is perfectly hedged against this financial risk.

Nesbo · 10/07/2022 16:44

”Alexa, describe a situation the police wouldn’t give a shiny shit about”.

I wouldn’t engage, it takes 2 to have a “dispute”, a mad neighbour’s ranting about some cuttings doesn’t really count.

Isaidnoalready · 10/07/2022 16:44

Does he know they came from cuttings? Could you not say they came from seedlings that sprouted naturally in my garden I simply moved them no theft was undertaken

SirenSays · 10/07/2022 16:43

I'd take him a bottle and try to smooth things over. He sounds too crazy to war with.

Ahelena79 · 10/07/2022 16:42

This reply has been deleted

We've removed this post as it's not in the spirit of the site.

That’s what I’m starting to think. I really feel like I have stolen property from him and can’t justify in my head keeping them! However I wouldn’t want to return them as it would destroy the back end of my garden with having to dig all the roots up. Really not sure what to do! I could offer a nominal fee per tree as someone suggested..

OP posts:
LavenderfortheBees · 10/07/2022 16:40

I wouldn't plant a willow tree, let alone 6, within 50ft of my house. Can we have a diagram?

DontBlameMe79 · 10/07/2022 16:38

This reply has been deleted

We've removed this post as it's not in the spirit of the site.

JennyForeigner · 10/07/2022 16:36

Offer him cuttings from your trees 😀

Ahelena79 · 10/07/2022 16:35

We have quite a large garden and they’re at the opposite end so not near anyones foundations for all worried!

I really get I shouldn’t have ever just planted them but just seemed so meaningless at the time! He can only see them as they’re now taller than the fence and he can see them.

I am a little bit worried as one poster said I have clumped them all together! Is this bad and what’s likely to happen if they’re all growing like that? I had this vision of it turning into an end of garden canopy which the children could play under!

OP posts:
BudgetTarzan · 10/07/2022 16:34

Is he going to DNA test your tree to check they are related?

stuntbubbles · 10/07/2022 16:32

Countersue him for trespass, his tree planted itself all over your garden!

AlisonDonut · 10/07/2022 16:31

Not being funny but willow roots so easily, he could take as many cuttings as he likes from any of the branches and make his own new trees...I'd let him crack on. Unless he saw you take them I'd say that they fell onto your land and you just put them in water and they rooted. As he didn't ask for them back these miracles of nature were potted on and as the roots were grown post the branches falling, you would be happy to return them minus roots and all the additional growth since the moment they landed on your land.

Singinghollybob · 10/07/2022 16:30

Just deny you'd told him you'd taken them from his tree he can't prove you did and didn't offer them back to him.

billy1966 · 10/07/2022 16:28

Deny everything.

RedWingBoots · 10/07/2022 16:28

TabithaTittlemouse · 10/07/2022 16:26

Tell him that you will report him but his tree is trespassing on your property Grin

Won't work.

WeAreBob · 10/07/2022 16:28

That's a good point. Where have you planted 6 willow trees?

How do you have space to grow 6 willow trees?
I hope you haven't clumped them all together and they're no where near anyone's house!