Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour accused me of stealing their tree

257 replies

Ahelena79 · 10/07/2022 16:12

So our neighbour has a lovely willow tree. It does slightly overhang our border however I am very happy with that as it provides a lovely bit of shade in that corner of the garden which the kids sit under on hot evenings.

Around 4 summers ago I took several cuttings from this willow tree. I didn’t really think to ask at the time as they were nearly touching the floor of my garden and had no real impact on my neighbours life. Instead of chucking them back over the fence aggressively (which other neighbours have done to me!) I decided to plant them to grow a bit of a willow garden in one corner.

These willows have absolutely taken off. There’s about 6 in total all taken from branch cuttings. They are really tall now and can be seen from over the fence (which is 6 foot!)

My neighbour has recently seen them and is now demanding that his property is returned to him. He says I had no right to cut the willow and that they have always been his property even though I have nurtured them to life in the form of new trees. He says he will be contacting the police and threatening legal action. He told me that the willow is taken from cuttings of a family tree that was in his mothers garden and he considers it family property which he wanted to hand down to his kids but I’ve now stolen that from him?? He is absolutely crazy to be honest and I’ve had no previous dealings with him and I’m glad of that now!

Where do I stand legally on this?

OP posts:
howdoesatoastermaketoast · 10/07/2022 23:00

JellyBabiesSaveLives · 10/07/2022 16:20

Well he’ll give the police a good laugh

Can you take cuttings from the new trees that are the same size as the cuttings you took from his tree and give those to him?

that is an excellent idea as an offer - he won't like it but he's either batshit or a CF who senses a potential opportunity.

Dasher789 · 10/07/2022 22:46

Oh apologies @DogInATent is correct.
Cit advice website says:
If your neighbour won’t cut branches hanging over your garden, you’re allowed to chop them off - but only the bits on your side of the boundary. Check if your neighbour will let you throw away the branches - legally they own them.

GettingItOutThere · 10/07/2022 21:33

your neighbours fucking mental

yes you should have offered him the cuttings back

best fucking thread ever. congrats!

hahahah

Butchyrestingface · 10/07/2022 21:08

TheNoodlesIncident · 10/07/2022 19:44

@Butchyrestingface It's in OP's second post: I have already said to him how I got them as I never thought in a million years he would demand them back

I suppose I'm just struggling to imagine how that convo happened/went down.

Anyway, denial, denial, denial in the unlikely event this makes the small claims courts. Grin

DogInATent · 10/07/2022 20:52

Dasher789 · 10/07/2022 20:42

I always thought it was the case that you can cut branches of a neighbours tree which overhang into yours, so long as you don't cut beyond the boundary. If the branches were overhanging I'm not sure what the issue is, surely whether you bin the cuttings or replant is by the by?

You cut an overhanging branch, but the law says you must return it. It's not yours. But it's an unusual thing to get worked up about.

Dasher789 · 10/07/2022 20:43

Which overhang into your garden*

Dasher789 · 10/07/2022 20:42

I always thought it was the case that you can cut branches of a neighbours tree which overhang into yours, so long as you don't cut beyond the boundary. If the branches were overhanging I'm not sure what the issue is, surely whether you bin the cuttings or replant is by the by?

unname · 10/07/2022 20:41

Also, tell him you enjoy nude sunbathing and don’t appreciate him spying on you in your own garden.

StaunchMomma · 10/07/2022 20:36

Do you have DP/DH? If so I'd send them round and say that that you were mistaken and although you did chop the tree back the new trees were bought.

He'll say you're lying, which you are BUT the onus is then on him to prove it!

How anyone could get this worked up by an overhanging branch I do not know!

StaunchMomma · 10/07/2022 20:32

Let him call the police. He's talking utter bollox.

If a neighbouring tree is hanging over your property you are entitled to cut any overhang away. What you do with that overhang is entirely up to you.

He sounds like an absolute nutter!

Bringonsummer19 · 10/07/2022 20:19

You are crazy to plant so many willow trees in your garden, they are so destructive.

Herejustforthisone · 10/07/2022 20:19

For fuck’s sake. The histrionics on here. Let him report it to the police. They won’t give a single shit.

craftsupplyhoarder · 10/07/2022 20:16

He's nuts. He has no legal right to your trees, and your cuttings don't affect his ability to take more cuttings for his children. However, if someone is crazy enough to complain about this, I'd be worried he might be somewhat unhinged and potentially dangerous. I'd try to keep contact to him as minimal as possible.

Let him call the police. They won't care.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 10/07/2022 20:14

This reply has been deleted

We've removed this post as it's not in the spirit of the site.

Oh goodness no - that will just encourage him in his self righteous crusade against the willow witch OP

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 10/07/2022 20:11

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 10/07/2022 16:17

I’ve put that YANBU because he is being bonkers but I think technically whilst you are allowed to cut the tree which overhangs your property the cuttings remain his property, and you are meant to throw them back over (but nobody ever does). So that makes it interesting - you have grown something from his property, but they only exist because you grew them. Interesting situation.

You don’t them over, you offer them back

unname · 10/07/2022 20:08

Ahelena79 · 10/07/2022 16:42

That’s what I’m starting to think. I really feel like I have stolen property from him and can’t justify in my head keeping them! However I wouldn’t want to return them as it would destroy the back end of my garden with having to dig all the roots up. Really not sure what to do! I could offer a nominal fee per tree as someone suggested..

I wouldn’t give him back the entire tree. I’d cut off the tops and give him the cuttings.

Then I’d tell him I bought new ones and planted them if he mentioned it again.

I think he’s ridiculous and the law is ridiculous.

WeAreBob · 10/07/2022 20:05

MiniPiccolo · 10/07/2022 19:52

Not true. If it overhangs her garden, those bits are hers.

No, they aren't. You need to offer the cuttings back.

007DoubleOSeven · 10/07/2022 20:02

Legally: you're allowed to cut any overhang on your garden without permission from the plant owner so your neighbour is off his rocker. But, I do believe it's right that you're supposed to offer the cut material back to him. Did you offer them back to him and he's just forgotten?

However.
If you don't tell him they were cut from his willow, he won't know. Now, I'm not suggesting you deny it now, but some might find it the most effective way of dealing with this.

Without proof, there is no case.

Quite frankly, I can't begin to imagine getting so irate over something that would have no impact whatsoever to my life.

MiniPiccolo · 10/07/2022 19:56

Oh my god some of the posters here 🤣🤣🤣🤣 the dramatic tone.

OP hasn't stolen anything - it was over her boundary line.

It was his responsibility to keep the tree trimmed and is lucky she didn't cut the whole thing back on her side.

No she doesn't owe him them.
No she doesn't owe him money for them.
No she is not a thief.
No he doesn't have a leg to stand on.

I mean jesus, you'd hate to see what my Nan used to do in the garden nursery - taking home snapped shoots from the floor, to root up 🤣

MiniPiccolo · 10/07/2022 19:52

dementedpixie · 10/07/2022 16:15

Legally you should have offered any cuttings back to him. Could you not have just said you got them from elsewhere?

Not true. If it overhangs her garden, those bits are hers.

stairgates · 10/07/2022 19:50

you say you took them, did you take them from a branch that fell into your garden during a storm? Windfalls.

greatblueheron · 10/07/2022 19:47

Oh, and remind him that he will forevermore have to declare the 'dispute with the neighbour' if he ever tries to sell his house.

greatblueheron · 10/07/2022 19:45

I wouldn't offer him anything. Tell him you look forward to seeing his sad photo in a national newspaper highlighting what an idiot he's being.

TheNoodlesIncident · 10/07/2022 19:44

@Butchyrestingface It's in OP's second post: I have already said to him how I got them as I never thought in a million years he would demand them back

TheNoodlesIncident · 10/07/2022 19:42

Your first mistake was not thinking to ask before taking cuttings and rooting them from someone else's plant, it's irrelevant that they were on your side of the fence. You didn't simply trim them and bin the trimmings, you took cuttings, rooted them and planted them. If you intended to benefit from your neighbour' s tree, you should have asked.

Your second mistake was telling him you'd done that instead of "Ooh I can't remember, think DH brought them back one day because I'd said I liked yours?"

I would try to patch things up somehow as it's not nice living next to a hostile neighbour. He sounds rather intense, but if his mother's since died he might not be the strongest mentally he's ever been.

And also, per PPs' comments about the willow roots - six willow trees in your garden, are you mad?! Do you know what size they get? Our huge garden we had as kids had one weeping willow in it, it was beautiful and trained like a big bell tent. We loved that tree, but I wouldn't have one in my considerably smaller garden now!