Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to give up time to help kids catch up?

343 replies

PeachyM · 10/07/2022 14:08

So I’m a teacher. And we’re nearing the end of the school year- finally :) Two kids from the same family but in different years disappear off for a two week family holiday, which hasn’t been authorised. I’m not going to particularly question their parents’ decision because it’s up to them. But they’ve come back having missed two weeks of a core subject and the parents have now requested we give up time to help catch them up. I’ve said no because I already have a shit ton of end of year stuff to finish and I don’t have the time. Parents have accused me of being unreasonable and said that I’m refusing to do my job. Who’s in the wrong here?

OP posts:
RaleighDurham · 10/07/2022 19:35

"Two minutes?"
Spoken by someone who clearly has no idea of the time and effort put into planning for classes.

mizzo · 10/07/2022 19:34

Didn't you bellow at them they had a week of detention (for something that was out of their control particularly as their parent worked shifts so couldn't choose when their leave was) snatch a book from another classmate and yell at them to
"COPY IT UPPP"? firing flecks of spit at them in the process
Or aren't you allowed to do that anymore?

00100001 · 10/07/2022 19:34

pastaandpesto · 10/07/2022 14:20

As a parent in that situation, I would hope that the teacher would take two minutes to email me bullet points of the topics covered.

I would then expect it to be completely my responsibility to find appropriate resources (BBC Bitesize, books etc), work through them with DC, and do any marking.

Would that be reasonable?

Or maybe the kids can ask their school mates what they missed...

RaleighDurham · 10/07/2022 19:33

"In the example I gave, the HOD had to be in school anyway, working, so having ds1 in, to catch up what he had missed, wasn’t extra work for him"

Of course it was! Otherwise, why couldn't the child have done the work at home alone? Being in school in the holidays gave him something more than that - namely, the teacher's time and 1:1 attention. If the teacher was already in school, it was to do some other kind of work, not personal tuition.

SunshinePie · 10/07/2022 19:31

Are you sure that they didn’t just ask for the worksheets you did in class with the other kids during the 2 weeks? If so, then I think you could at least just tell them the topics they missed 🤷‍♀️The parents can go on Twinkle and get some worksheets themselves that way.

wellyelliebee · 10/07/2022 19:28

The person who basically said you should have procedures in place for kids who miss school really pissed me off. Yes, kids who miss school for deserving reasons, not kids who are taken off on a jolly by their parents. My mum died in the middle of my a-levels, I took a week off school but didn't want to take any more, each of my a-level teachers spent a little bit of time with me helping me catch up what I'd missed while I was off, and i was really grateful to them for doing that, because even as a grieving 17 year old i realised they were giving up their time to do it. I'd absolutely turn it back on them and keep saying that unfortunately it is very damaging to take unauthorised absences and this is why the school strongly discouraged because the school values their education and knows their education will be damaged by being out of school.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 10/07/2022 19:25

Yanbu at all.

I normally don’t have a problem with term time holidays at all (except in year 10 which is a ridiculous year to take them out) but I would not spend 1 second helping a child catch up who had been on holiday when they should have been at school and if they tried telling me I was not doing my job properly in a lesson I would come down on them like a ton of bricks and they would wish they had never spoken.
alternatively I have given up time to prepare resources for a girl who started halfway through the year and for a boy who missed classes as he was having special EAL ones.

Annoyedwithmyself · 10/07/2022 19:23

You're completely NBU OP. Think of the precedent this would set for others going away. With the cost of living getting higher etc, there will likely be more kids going for cheaper term time holidays. If you help one catch up it will become expected. If your SMT push back on this, speak to your union. Pull the kid up.in class for their lip. Explain in simple terms the action/ consequence at play here and how limited your time is.

Teachers on here have explained that there's no such thing as a ready made 'covid pack' and that these have to be made up with the current work. Covid/ illness is unavoidable and teachers have taken on extra workload to try and keep children up to date. No way should this apply to holidays.

88milesanhour · 10/07/2022 19:21

mathanxiety · 10/07/2022 19:00

Agree with LeighMeLeabhair (sorry, can't do fadas on my phone).

If you dont want to send a sick/covid packet - are there textbooks?

I also think it's worth noting that kids in other countries have been off for the summer since end May/ early June. Teachers ime of those countries tend not to start topics or cover important topics in core subjects right before the end of the spring term as attention tends to flag and the chances are high that the same ground will have to be gone over again at the start of the next academic year.

It's not the children's fault that their parents decided to take a holiday. Punishing them for an entitled attitude without telling them why they're in the doghouse isn't going to teach them anything.

Who's punishing anyone?! There's a big difference between punishing and taking responsibility for your own actions. The parents have decided to take the kids out of school therefore they have the responsibility to catch them up with the work. The teacher is paid to educate your child during the specified term times. They aren't paid to do extra work because you/your child chose not to be there. Simple. No punishment involved just consequences.... which most of the world seems to be allergic to these days...

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/07/2022 19:16

In the example I gave, the HOD had to be in school anyway, working, so having ds1 in, to catch up what he had missed, wasn’t extra work for him - and it was his suggestion, @Threetulips. I am not expecting the OP to go in specially, or to go to any special effort, other than handing over someone’s exercise book for the kid to copy. And I did make it clear that I think the OP is entirely within her rights to refuse the extra tutoring she has been asked for.

I think my post makes more sense if taken as a whole.

I also think it is pretty likely that this kid and their parents would not accept a offer that meant their little darling missing any of his free time, whilst expecting the OP to give up hers - and this offer might make them stop and think about how unreasonable they are being.

RaleighDurham · 10/07/2022 19:16

"i am not sure in the school policy- but these feels unethical. Teachers shouldn’t be charging their own students for extra classes."
"I do repair a lot of teachers tutor for money in their free time (and there is nothing wrong with that) - but offering to help children in your own class for money feels off."

I'm not sure it was a serious suggestion.

RaleighDurham · 10/07/2022 19:14

We had a parent earlier this year who emailed in to ask if we could re-arrange the timetable for the end-of term assessments so her ds wouldn't miss them when he was out on holiday.

Mellowyellow222 · 10/07/2022 19:14

Hawkins001 · 10/07/2022 19:10

What about offering extra tutoring, at x amount, paid in advance for x hours a week ?

i am not sure in the school policy- but these feels unethical. Teachers shouldn’t be charging their own students for extra classes.

I do repair a lot of teachers tutor for money in their free time (and there is nothing wrong with that) - but offering to help children in your own class for money feels off.

RaleighDurham · 10/07/2022 19:13

"Punishing them?"

Who's punishing them?

Hawkins001 · 10/07/2022 19:10

PeachyM · 10/07/2022 14:08

So I’m a teacher. And we’re nearing the end of the school year- finally :) Two kids from the same family but in different years disappear off for a two week family holiday, which hasn’t been authorised. I’m not going to particularly question their parents’ decision because it’s up to them. But they’ve come back having missed two weeks of a core subject and the parents have now requested we give up time to help catch them up. I’ve said no because I already have a shit ton of end of year stuff to finish and I don’t have the time. Parents have accused me of being unreasonable and said that I’m refusing to do my job. Who’s in the wrong here?

What about offering extra tutoring, at x amount, paid in advance for x hours a week ?

Threetulips · 10/07/2022 19:05

Is there any chance that you will be in school during the summer holidays, @PeachyM, and would you be allowed to have this pupil in for the day to copy up,the work they’ve missed?

LOL!! That’s the funniest thing I’ve heard all week!

Seriously why not just ask all teachers to run a free summer school and have all children in who’ve missed work? Does that happen where you work? Do you give up your unpaid leave to help colleagues catch up? Do you offer teaching to coaching during your work breaks?

Teachers need breaks more than most.

noblegiraffe · 10/07/2022 19:02

Telling teachers that they need to do extra work for free because won't someone think of the children is an attitude that needs to get in the bin.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/07/2022 19:01

When ds1 was in Year 9, his biology teacher discovered he had done no biology whatsoever, the previous term, despite the previous teacher chasing him about it - I hadn’t seen his biology book, so I had no idea. The teacher who made the discovery was also Head of Department, and he offered us a choice - either make up the work in after school detentions, or come in during half term, when the teacher had to be in school anyway, and catch up then. We chose the latter, as we felt it would make more of a point to ds1, if he had to miss holiday time.

Is there any chance that you will be in school during the summer holidays, @PeachyM, and would you be allowed to have this pupil in for the day to copy up,the work they’ve missed? Make them give up part of their holiday to make up for missing school?

That would have the extra benefit that you’d be offering to help - on your terms - so they couldn’t carry on whingeing, and they might refuse the offer, in which case you could say you had been more than generous with your offer of help, and they had refused it, so you wash your hands of them.

All that said, I agree 100% that the parents and the kids are cheeky fuckers, and it is entirely reasonable of you to want your break time, free of doing extra tutoring.

mathanxiety · 10/07/2022 19:00

Agree with LeighMeLeabhair (sorry, can't do fadas on my phone).

If you dont want to send a sick/covid packet - are there textbooks?

I also think it's worth noting that kids in other countries have been off for the summer since end May/ early June. Teachers ime of those countries tend not to start topics or cover important topics in core subjects right before the end of the spring term as attention tends to flag and the chances are high that the same ground will have to be gone over again at the start of the next academic year.

It's not the children's fault that their parents decided to take a holiday. Punishing them for an entitled attitude without telling them why they're in the doghouse isn't going to teach them anything.

CocktailCreations · 10/07/2022 18:54

Would most kids really need a tutor for missing 2 weeks of school? It seems really OTT to suggest it. My son caught up really quickly with a bit of effort and very little input from teachers. It’s only 2 weeks.

88milesanhour · 10/07/2022 18:52

I don't believe in schools dictating when I can and cannot take them on holiday. However, if I ever do take mine out during term time you can be damned sure I would be taking 100% of the responsibility for catching them up with the work and not expecting their teacher to do it. Imagine if you had to do this for every kid in the class on different weeks?! Ridiculously entitled

TigerRag · 10/07/2022 18:50

Mfsf · 10/07/2022 18:18

I think you can compromise . Send them what was missed ( as in a small list ) and tell them they can help them catch up ? Sim ouro that be acceptable for you ?

If you do that for every child who missed school, that's a lot of extra for you.

I once missed 3 weeks of school due to illness. No one sent work home but I got a telling off for being off for those 3 weeks and no one was going to help me catch one. One teacher did suggest that I could come in and collect work. I was recovering from surgery on my back!

SoftwareDev · 10/07/2022 18:50

Bottom line - they are saying their time (to holiday) is somehow more important than yours.

Nope!

Thankfully my school took a firm hard line stance on this. Reason being - once one teacher does it for one child there is an expectation that all teachers should do this (inviting the floodgates open to complaints). If you do the maths on this time wise it's ludicrous - even if just ONE child goes on holiday in your class per year.

Teachers are overworked and under appreciated. These parents chose to take their children out and miss valuable learning time - they are therefore be adults and deal with the fallout of that by hiring tutors.

Magicandspiders · 10/07/2022 18:49

This is why parents are fined! They are obviously being unreasonable and well done you for sticking to your guns. I'm also a teacher and no way would I do that. If they were unwell then possibly but not holiday.

whowhatwerewhy · 10/07/2022 18:47

I would hope the the parents are sent a letter explaining that it's not your responsibility to " catch " the children up . The parents should of thought of the impact on there education before taking them on holiday.