Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to give up time to help kids catch up?

343 replies

PeachyM · 10/07/2022 14:08

So I’m a teacher. And we’re nearing the end of the school year- finally :) Two kids from the same family but in different years disappear off for a two week family holiday, which hasn’t been authorised. I’m not going to particularly question their parents’ decision because it’s up to them. But they’ve come back having missed two weeks of a core subject and the parents have now requested we give up time to help catch them up. I’ve said no because I already have a shit ton of end of year stuff to finish and I don’t have the time. Parents have accused me of being unreasonable and said that I’m refusing to do my job. Who’s in the wrong here?

OP posts:
Pelsall116 · 11/07/2022 18:13

They are
They took their kids out of school; therefore their problem and not yours

Skodacool · 11/07/2022 18:04

EL8888 · 10/07/2022 14:14

This is the perfect example of feeling the consequences of your actions so no l wouldn’t assist. Their children didn’t need to go on holiday. If they can afford to go on holiday, then they can afford a tutor. FFS some people are so entitled

I agree. I’m not 100% against taking children on TT holidays but I certainly wouldn’t take a Y10 child out.

DMW60 · 11/07/2022 18:03

As an ex-member of SLT, I would say that your school needs to develop a policy which states that, if parents want to take their children on holiday in term time, they will be issued with a Fixed Penalty Notice (fine) and school will not provide either work to take with them or extra lessons to help them catch up when they return. Then it’s clear to everyone and you just refer difficult parents (and painful kids) to the policy. Why should you take the flak?

WhimsicalGubbins · 10/07/2022 21:39

Wow! A lot of entitled parents on here!
and to the poster (cannot be bothered to find out your name) who said she ‘won’t have the school dictating to her when she can take her kids on holiday’ it’s not the school you absolute shining example of an entitled parent, it’s the government.
Fill your boots, take your kids out of school during term time, pay the fine when they come knocking, and suck it up when your kids start failing at school because you absurdly think it’s the teachers job to catch them up in everything they missed because YOU were irresponsible.

school is 9-3 weekdays. If anyone feels their kids are more special than anyone else’s and require lessons outside of this, or during the holidays, then pay for a tutor.

Threetulips · 10/07/2022 21:38

The teacher said that having to give up part of his half term would teach ds1 a good lesson for the future

Thats because your child chose not to do any work and was effectively punishing him for being lazy. Totally different where parents choose to take their kids on
holiday.

Kids nor teachers should be punished for parents choices.

mizzo · 10/07/2022 21:26

@ilovesooty
Don't be ridiculous.
🙄

Mamansparkles · 10/07/2022 21:04

SunshinePie · 10/07/2022 19:31

Are you sure that they didn’t just ask for the worksheets you did in class with the other kids during the 2 weeks? If so, then I think you could at least just tell them the topics they missed 🤷‍♀️The parents can go on Twinkle and get some worksheets themselves that way.

Yes, because teaching is just about giving the kids a stack of worksheets... that's definitely what happens in class. 🙄

RaleighDurham · 10/07/2022 20:42

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius I have little interest in what you feel about it now or then, beyond wishing that you don't suggest to others that this was a good idea.

Plogeggio · 10/07/2022 20:40

Reminds me of someone I know who takes her kid out of school in term time because its cheaper, but also employs an expensive tutor because her kid is behind. Seems a bit self defeating.

ilovesooty · 10/07/2022 20:17

mizzo · 10/07/2022 19:34

Didn't you bellow at them they had a week of detention (for something that was out of their control particularly as their parent worked shifts so couldn't choose when their leave was) snatch a book from another classmate and yell at them to
"COPY IT UPPP"? firing flecks of spit at them in the process
Or aren't you allowed to do that anymore?

Don't be ridiculous.

SkygardenTower · 10/07/2022 20:13

Fully agree that you need to say no, no personal catch up teaching. And pull up the rudeness, escalate to HOD or HOY.

Would sending a link to Oak Academy lessons on the topic work? Not used them in maths (I’m guessing your subject) but they are good in physics and would be relatively quick to find the right lessons.

Hope you have good support from your colleagues.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/07/2022 20:11

RaleighDurham · 10/07/2022 19:44

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius I've no idea - but you can salve your conscience by believing it if you like. Teachers like that are doing their colleagues a grave disservice, because it becomes expected service and gives everyone else a headache.
If your son was really just sitting in a corner copying up notes, why could he not have done that at home on your watch?

The teacher said that having to give up part of his half term would teach ds1 a good lesson for the future, @RaleighDurham - he felt it would be a better consequence for ds1 than having to do the copying at home. And I’m sorry to disappoint you but my conscience is completely clear - because I do not think I did anything wrong by following the teacher’s suggestion. Should I flagellate myself now, years after the event, for doing what a teacher suggested? Confused

CocktailCreations · 10/07/2022 20:08

My son was literally handed the teachers lesson plans and took photos on his phone. It gave him a general idea what he’d missed.

KatherineofGaunt · 10/07/2022 20:05

People who are suggesting teachers give up their own time, to catch up students after they've had a lovely holiday, might like to think that teachers have more than one pupil to teach, especially secondary. If you're required to give up 15 mins of your unpaid lunch for, say, a week to catch up one pupil, that's 1hr 15mins for one week. Now imagine ten pupils go away on term-time holidays. One teacher is giving up 12.5 hrs a year which is equivalent to at least two whole teaching days extra teaching, for free.

Multiply that by 5 subjects (I'm thinking Maths, English and three sciences for core GCSE) and suddenly those ten pupils are commanding 50hrs of extra, free teaching. That's about two weeks' worth of extra work in the school. And that's only ten pupils out of, potentially, 1500, so in one year there could be far more than 10 pupils going on holiday in term-time.

Not so reasonable now, is it?

And emotional blackmail like "you should do it for the children" is just ridiculous. Most teachers do a lot already and you're showing your ignorance about what teachers actually do by suggesting we don't care about the pupils already.

Hawkins001 · 10/07/2022 20:05

RaleighDurham · 10/07/2022 19:16

"i am not sure in the school policy- but these feels unethical. Teachers shouldn’t be charging their own students for extra classes."
"I do repair a lot of teachers tutor for money in their free time (and there is nothing wrong with that) - but offering to help children in your own class for money feels off."

I'm not sure it was a serious suggestion.

If the parents wanted their children to catchup and had the funds available, then they could see if the teacher would tutor their children out of hours, for x.amount. Supply and demand,.plus they took the children on holiday.

Hawkins001 · 10/07/2022 19:59

Mellowyellow222 · 10/07/2022 19:14

i am not sure in the school policy- but these feels unethical. Teachers shouldn’t be charging their own students for extra classes.

I do repair a lot of teachers tutor for money in their free time (and there is nothing wrong with that) - but offering to help children in your own class for money feels off.

I Understand your perspectives, but the teacher is already busy, the parents took them, on holiday, and if it's out of school hours, it covers the teachers time and experience and knowledge to help them catchup.

clary · 10/07/2022 19:56

To those talking about text books and page numbers, it’s likely text books are not used, and if they are, the student will not have their own copy.

To those talking about a policy for a child who misses two weeks through sickness, IME this is actually quite unusual (when did you last have two weeks off work sick?) but if it does happen then it is often planned and dealt with as per my post below. It’s time-consuming but teachers are prepared to do it. I don’t see any reason at all why they should do the work in this case. Having a policy doesn’t mean the work takes no time.

@PeachyM I hate the attitude (displayed by a few on here sadly) that “it won’t take long”. I no longer teach but I work in a high-pressure industry and a colleague and I joke about the people who come to us on a daily with “can you just”s - implication that a job will take five mins when it will take 45. Our time (and yours) as professionals is valuable and maybe this experience will teach the parents and students to value it. And schools do do a lot of work in June and July with year 10s, if with no one else. There’s a lot to get through!

InFiveMins · 10/07/2022 19:51

YANBU.

They are being absolutely ridiculous and can pay a tutor to help their children catch up.

THEY made their children miss school, so THEY are responsible to ensure their children catch up - and you aren't able to facilitate it, so they will need to find another resource. Simple 😊

noblegiraffe · 10/07/2022 19:45

A kid coming into the largely empty school building during the school holidays to sit with a teacher strikes me as a safeguarding no.

RaleighDurham · 10/07/2022 19:44

@SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius I've no idea - but you can salve your conscience by believing it if you like. Teachers like that are doing their colleagues a grave disservice, because it becomes expected service and gives everyone else a headache.
If your son was really just sitting in a corner copying up notes, why could he not have done that at home on your watch?

CallmeAngelina · 10/07/2022 19:41

Somewhere along the line, some parents have been allowed to entertain the notion that they are the client and that schools (and the staff within) are at their beck and call as service providers.
This is NOT the case and has come as a rude awakening for some.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/07/2022 19:40

RaleighDurham · 10/07/2022 19:33

"In the example I gave, the HOD had to be in school anyway, working, so having ds1 in, to catch up what he had missed, wasn’t extra work for him"

Of course it was! Otherwise, why couldn't the child have done the work at home alone? Being in school in the holidays gave him something more than that - namely, the teacher's time and 1:1 attention. If the teacher was already in school, it was to do some other kind of work, not personal tuition.

Then why did the teacher suggest that ds1 went in, @RaleighDurham?

It taught ds1 a lesson - do your work or miss out on a couple of days of your half term holiday. He could have done it at home, but the teacher thought - and I agreed - that this was a better option.

I also know that it did not mean extra work for the teacher because he told me so. He did not do any extra tutoring - he just sat ds1 in the corner of his classroom, with a book to copy.

spanieleyes · 10/07/2022 19:39

This is a 15 year old, not a 5 year old. They should be perfectly capable of asking their classmates what they covered whilst they were away and catching up with it. Why should if be down to the teacher? I think secondary teachers might see 200 students a week, imagine if they all decided to take 2 weeks off at various points during the year and expects the teacher to sort out their " catch up" work!

WishILivedInThrushGreen · 10/07/2022 19:38

This is the reality.
I was an HLTA in a primary school.
So many times I'd have to stop providing support to pupils with SEN in order to bring an absent child ( due to unauthorised absence) up to speed .
In their absence, the class will have done mathematical arrays and simple multiplication.
Absent child will come back and be greeted with more complex multiplication.
Child will be clueless and parent will kick off that their child is struggling.

Really pissed me off

Entitled parents were one of the reasons I resigned and took early retirement.

RaleighDurham · 10/07/2022 19:38

If I were to put into bullet points the main themes I'm teaching on a given week, you'd get, for example, "spellings im-. ir- prefixes, comprehension, fractions, explanatory texts, cricket skills, settlements, food chains, pentatonic scales, internet safety."
Just how is that going to help anyone at home?

Swipe left for the next trending thread