Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To struggle with a friends extreme anti abortion views

89 replies

bagpuss90 · 10/07/2022 10:57

I accept that we all have to agree to disagree on some stuff. But I am struggling with a friends extreme anti abortion views . She thinks even if a woman is raped- she shouldn’t be allowed an abortion. She’s quite opinionated anyway . I can see us falling out soon. I’ve told her I no longer wish to discuss it but she still airs her views. The thing that really gets me (and okay we have probably all done things we regret) is that she’s had two abortions herself including a late one . I don’t want to break off our friendship but I’m struggling

OP posts:
StaunchMomma · 10/07/2022 14:41

She'd be an ex-friend real quick, for me.

Also, I'd be bringing up that late abortion at every turn.

What a hateful bitch!!

Ohhhhladz · 10/07/2022 14:38

She certainly has a right to her opinion and I wouldn't try to "silence" her - that is, pressure her not to discuss the topic with anyone or speak publically about it.

BUT:

(1) a friend should be able to accept that a certain topic of discussion is off-limits. This doesn't mean that topic should never be discussed with anyone, just that you ask a personal friend to do you the courtesy of respecting your wishes to avoid that topic when you're present. For example, if you were struggling with trauma after a rape and had asked for friends to avoid bringing up the topic of rape until you've had a chance to process the trauma and learn to manage your reactions and your friend kept bringing up the topic when it was not essential to do so, you'd very likely consider your friend a bit of an inconsiderate, self-centred arse who values her sopabox - at all times, everywhere - over your well-being and the friendship.

(2) In the current global environment positions like hers disproportionately hurt women and perpetuate and normalise misogyny. If her views coexist with a huge targeted effort on her part to eliminate and recrimilnalise rape and to overhaul the whole environment around sexual health and reproductive rights to eliminate the need for abortion specifically, and she advocates phasing out abortion in favour of other options when they genuinely become available, then I might take a more sympathetic view. But her "no exceptions!" stance isn't reasonable. I think it's fine to cut such people out of your life or limit contact with them if you wish; there are plenty of misogynists you won't be able to avoid but you don't have to be close personal friends with them.

SQLserved · 10/07/2022 14:16

HappySunnyDaisies · 10/07/2022 13:34

@HairyMcLarie could not agree with you more.

I think “agree to disagree” it’s fine if the question is “marmite is the best thing ever” or something like that.

But when someone is being racist, misogynistic, homophobe, extremist or force birthers then no, “agree to disagree” is not okay.

You cannot be friends with someone who shares views that go against human rights.

I wouldn’t be friends with someone whose hero is Hitler, or who thinks slavery was the best thing ever.

Forcing ANY woman UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES to have a child against her own will is against human rights for so many reasons, and if that woman was raped even more so.

Makes my blood boil.

I couldn’t put it better myself.

Preaching tolerance for such inhuman and cruel views is barmy!

LooseGoose22 · 10/07/2022 14:15

My work colleagues were much more subtle/gentleman in their approach.. prob because we are just work colleagues, with no background of longterm friendship or even acquaintance. She's possibly going at it like this because she feels she knows you well/a long time. Or just her personality, or a combination.

IMHO you can only keep a civil distant acquaintance with her. Unless she changes her beliefs and lifestyle.

LooseGoose22 · 10/07/2022 14:11

*active friendship

LooseGoose22 · 10/07/2022 14:10

bagpuss90 · 10/07/2022 11:57

She does hold quite extreme views about other things. I mean she believes we are in the “end days” on Earth as written in the bible 🤷‍♀️

For various reasons my work place had/has several fundamentalist type Christians, and they are friends with, hang out with, socialise with etc other Christians who share their beliefs & lifestyle.

It is not really compatible with non fundamentalist Christian etc people. Most of them djng even want to be friends with non fundamentalist Christians. They might do so to see if you are amenable to joining their church and acquiring their beliefs l, but once its clear you're not, they'll generally not try tk ve friends.

Your friend may be at that point; she's petddhs trying to get you to "convert" because, if you don't, she feels like she can no longer have ablative friendship with you. That might account for the continued "preaching" ... until she gives up.

You can appreciate your friendship to date, but realise that it cannot, currently, really continue.

Luredbyapomegranate · 10/07/2022 13:59

My instant reaction is she sounds crackers, but actually probably deeply fucked up and in denial?

You could kindly suggest that her lack of compassion and practicality is perhaps due to her own difficult experience, and really she needs to go address that. Which might both shut her up and encourage her to sort herself out.

Otherwise just tell her that in your view control over reproduction is at the root of human rights, and you cannot continue to spend any more time with her if she utters one more word on the subject. And stick to that. She sounds quite adolescent so firm boundaries may work.

Plutoisaplanet · 10/07/2022 13:54

“I’ve told her I no longer wish to discuss it but she still airs her views”.

This to me is the deal breaker. A complete lack of respect

LooseGoose22 · 10/07/2022 13:52

*But she is stable.

Sorry, I've realised that sounds in total contradiction to my last sentence; I mean she is stable in that she is no longer an alcoholic.

LooseGoose22 · 10/07/2022 13:44

I can only imagine the level of pain, confusion, desperation, vulnerability etc that would lead a woman who's had 2 abortions, inc a relatively late one to become a religious zealot, and so Anti abortion

She is probably struggling massively mentally.... she has found a crutch, possibly found something that she can get forgiveness through etc. This is possibly the only way she can exist, without losing her mind.

I know a lady like this, Dint know if she has ever terminations but she she an alcoholic who, like many female alcoholics, ended up being raped by a predatory man. She was raised in a very religious household, she has now returned to it, has married a Christian whose views are do extreme that other Christians on their church (described to me as a cult by a former member) find him extreme.
But she is stable. She is "happy".

Let her have the crutch she so obviously desperately needs, but if she won't stop preaching etc (likely) you are going to have to distance yourself.

Extreme religious views generally do not speak of a mentally well, stable person. That's what she is now, so you'll have to make your friendship decisions in line with that.

HappySunnyDaisies · 10/07/2022 13:34

@HairyMcLarie could not agree with you more.

I think “agree to disagree” it’s fine if the question is “marmite is the best thing ever” or something like that.

But when someone is being racist, misogynistic, homophobe, extremist or force birthers then no, “agree to disagree” is not okay.

You cannot be friends with someone who shares views that go against human rights.

I wouldn’t be friends with someone whose hero is Hitler, or who thinks slavery was the best thing ever.

Forcing ANY woman UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES to have a child against her own will is against human rights for so many reasons, and if that woman was raped even more so.

Makes my blood boil.

Cornettoninja · 10/07/2022 13:27

DoubleShotEspresso · 10/07/2022 13:14

You are friends.

Friends can remain so but still hold different opinions surely?

Yes they can, but when they can’t keep them to themselves (which also implies a degree of extremism) despite their friend asking them to drop the subject they probably can’t.

Amateur psychoanalysis on them will achieve fuck all too, it’s just giving them the opportunity to talk at you, which if you’re not on side or interested isn’t a friendship.

ladydoris · 10/07/2022 13:25

There is such thing as personal ethics and then social ethics. What is your red line might not be the red line that society has and for very good reasons. The difficulty is to have a friendship with someone who sees everything in black and white and never accepts that there are shades of grey. I would take a break, at least until the election in the us die down, I would not accept to discuss the subject with her at that point. As a friend the only aspect of abortion that I would talk to her about is her experience and how it shaped her, nothing more. You are entitled to your positions. If not, this is not friendship.

carrotChicory · 10/07/2022 13:25

As a teenager I had my rights removed about my own body and abortion . I went through absolute hell looking back I’m surprised I didn’t kill myself. What happened to me was horrific , barbaric and illegal.

My personal views about abortion extend only to myself. Every other woman deserves the choice. No matter what I think (which I know is clouded by what happened to me) even if my daughter ever wanted an abortion I’d be fully supporting her for that reason I’ve never really told others what happened to me as I want my daughter to always be able to approach me and not be wary.

KettrickenSmiled · 10/07/2022 13:25

Why do we need to get into any heavy conversations with friends. We tend to have a laugh when we go out.
It's not about "need" it's about "want".
I enjoy exploring the complex & interesting minds of my good friends. Hearing their opinions & experiences about all manner of topics.

I've never got into anything heavy and indeed with friends. Keep it light. Tell a joke as I said.
Sometimes we have lighthearted chat. Sometimes we spend the whole evening convulsed with laughter. But my friends have depths. I don't tend to get along well with shallow people, they bore me.

HTH @girlfriend44

najene · 10/07/2022 13:24

If it was my friend, I'd ask her to read Judith Jarvis Thomson, Defense of Abortion and tell me where she thinks Judith goes wrong.

Most likely she won't do that (especially given you describe her as something of a religious nut), but, still, give her a chance to remain your friend.

(JJT gives what I still think of as the best purely women's rights argument. It stands up really well against those who want to claim a foetus/embryo has rights, whether from conception or after some other point. So it's particularly germane for countering religious-based thoughts on abortion.)

KettrickenSmiled · 10/07/2022 13:20

thecatsthecats · 10/07/2022 11:59

I do find it concerning that as a society we're losing our ability to talk about things we disagree about.

I'm not saying that you have to stay friends with her, but I think that talking to her might help her, and would at least be mature.

I'd be asking questions like:

"What do you feel about the abortions you had?"
"What if you were in the same situation today?"
"Tell me more about your faith?"

People change as their lives change. My mum is now pro-abortion, and she experienced a huge amount of trauma in her life. People judging her, hating her life choices - those things never did a damn thing to change her. Being shown patience, understanding and tolerance did.

(I work with rehabbing extremists, so I know that it's not a simple thing to do, but it really does alarm me that as a society we write off people for the smallest of differences - which wildly flies in the face of improving social relations)

It's not a "small difference".

It's a gaping chasm of difference: the differentiator being a woman's right to control her own fertility & birth decisions. OP's friend believes women should be forced to give birth. She may as well live in Gilead.

KettrickenSmiled · 10/07/2022 13:18

SaltFlakes · 10/07/2022 11:51

This thread, and the number of 'no tories' in the dating non negotiables thread, really shows just how intolerant people on the left are.

I have plenty of friends with radically different views. Why should that stop a friendship? We just accept that the other holds 'unacceptable' views and move on.

OP's "friend" won't accept that though @SaltFlakes. She keeps forcing her opinions despite OP telling her that she doesn't want to hear them.

Tell me what's tolerant about that, or about forcing birth on a woman who does not want a baby?

beautyisthefaceisee · 10/07/2022 13:16

Is it the guilt?

My friend went a similar way and is now very critical of abortions.

Cornettoninja · 10/07/2022 13:15

She’s not your friend really is she? You don’t seem to like her views nor her yours.

it’s a great shame if you’ve had a long friendship but fundamentally you’re just not compatible if ‘agree to disagree’ isn’t working.

bluntly, your friendship is already over, it’s up to you when you can accept that as the reality.

KettrickenSmiled · 10/07/2022 13:14

Flangelica · 10/07/2022 11:32

These comments are awful.

Of course she is entitled to her opinion! Just because she disagrees with you doesn't mean she can't have an opinion.

And just because she's had an abortion doesn't mean she can't be anti-abortion now. People change. Experiences change people. Perhaps she regrets her abortions so bitterly that it changed her mind about them.

Don't be her friend if you don't want to.

People can hold any opinion they choose.
I don't have to listen to it if I find it repugnant. Neither does OP.

DoubleShotEspresso · 10/07/2022 13:14

You are friends.

Friends can remain so but still hold different opinions surely?

user1471447924 · 10/07/2022 13:14

She’d be a former friend so fast…

KettrickenSmiled · 10/07/2022 13:12

bagpuss90 · 10/07/2022 11:11

She’ become very religious -it’s tied up with that

So she can fuck off & take her controlling nightmare of a god with her.
Good riddance.

KettrickenSmiled · 10/07/2022 13:11

I’ve told her I no longer wish to discuss it but she still airs her views.
Fuck her off, she's not your friend.

is that she’s had two abortions herself including a late one
It's not your job to analyse her complicated, possibly guilt-ridden feelings, or to have to call her out on her hypocrisy.
She can be as anti-abortion as she likes - for HER OWN WOMB. She doesn't get to opinionate on anybody else's.

I don’t want to break off our friendship but I’m struggling
I can't see why you want to retain her friendship, she's behaving as if she has the right to dictate other women's choices. So give h3r one last chance - next time she raises it, tell her you don't want to hear her nasty controlling views.
If she presses on regardless - get up & leave, or kick her out if she's at yours.

There is no tactful or ameliorating choice, with bullies.
She's bullying you - she knows damn well you don't want to discuss this with her, & forces you to listen anyway.
She'd like to bully other women out of the choice SHE MADE FOR HERSELF. She's a hypocritical scumbag, & you should feel free to tell her so as soon as you've had enough.