Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To struggle with a friends extreme anti abortion views

89 replies

bagpuss90 · 10/07/2022 10:57

I accept that we all have to agree to disagree on some stuff. But I am struggling with a friends extreme anti abortion views . She thinks even if a woman is raped- she shouldn’t be allowed an abortion. She’s quite opinionated anyway . I can see us falling out soon. I’ve told her I no longer wish to discuss it but she still airs her views. The thing that really gets me (and okay we have probably all done things we regret) is that she’s had two abortions herself including a late one . I don’t want to break off our friendship but I’m struggling

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PublicServicesNotTaxCuts · 11/07/2022 07:52

I could handle "hypocrisy" or changing minds ok : people should be allowed to change their views & hypocrisy is rife, anyway. Forcing pregnancy and birth on other women is worse than hypocrisy. The actually intolerable bit is demanding that she keep telling you her views when you asked her not to (& you disagree so much). That (lack of respect) is what I couldn't take any more.

ladydoris · 11/07/2022 07:26

bagpuss90 · 11/07/2022 06:44

I cant bring myself to keep reminding her of her abortions

You are a true friend to her. If you can bear with her perhaps she will in the future thank you for being there through her craziness.

Jennybeans401 · 11/07/2022 07:10

She's preoccupied with the topic because she deeply regrets the abortions. It's very sad, perhaps ask her if she might need to to talk about it with a trained counsellor. It would be annoying if there wasn't this back story.

bagpuss90 · 11/07/2022 06:44

I cant bring myself to keep reminding her of her abortions

OP posts:
TheWayoftheLeaf · 10/07/2022 21:35

I'd ditch her and I'd tell her why. I don't associate with those who want to take away the rights of other people. Or tell them what to do.

FunDragon · 10/07/2022 20:52

Personally I wouldn’t be able to continue the friendship OP.

I’m fine with diversity of opinion. But I think there are views that are different to my own but entirely worthy of respect (for example voting for a different political party) and then there are views that simply aren’t worthy of respect in a civilised society.

Her views fall into the latter category for me.

MarshaMelrose · 10/07/2022 20:49

But unless this topic of conversation has any significance to your current lives, have you thought of just not talking about it with her? Friendships don't have to be based on having the same opinions about things; they just need to be willing to respect each other's views.

The op said, I’ve told her I no longer wish to discuss it but she still airs her views. I don’t want to break off our friendship but I’m struggling.

To be fair the op doesn't want to stop being friends, she just wants to stop having the subject of abortion being constantly rehashed. The fact the woman ignores her request makes her feel disrespected.

MarshaMelrose · 10/07/2022 20:44

Wouldloveanother · 10/07/2022 18:07

Ok I’m going to go against the grain and say I would stay her friend, if the friendship was good and she had other qualities. One of my most fulfilling friendships is with somebody who is diametrically opposed to one of my core beliefs. I’m getting a bit tired of people who believe it is their right to only be surrounded in life by people who agree with their opinions. Not only is it narrow minded and intolerant but it deepened the chasm between people and severs any attempt to find common ground.

I agree with this. I have friends who voted Brexit and friends who didn't. I'm not going to cut off half my friends. I have friends who vote for different political parties but they're all lovely people with kind hearts. They just have different ideas of how best the country can be run. And, honestly, as we've aged, people change ideas according to their experiences. Most people are not so bull-headed that they can't see nuances in things. If you don't mix with people who think different things, you're just living in an echo chamber. And views become ever more extremist.

But in this instance, the op has asked thus woman to stop keep talking about it but the woman carries on. That would be like my friends just talking football 🥱 everytime we went out. If I asked them to consider my feelings and stop it, but instead they carried on, I'd question just how much they valued my friendship.

Headteacher415 · 10/07/2022 20:33

Ultimately, if you believe that an unborn baby is part of a woman's body, then it logically follows that the woman must have an absolute right to choose what to do with it. If you believe that the unborn baby is an independent life, then it logically follows that no one has the right to end that life. There is no middle ground here, hence it is such an emotive topic. Ultimately, you have different opinions about abortion, because you have different opinions about what a foetus is, because you have different opinions about what the meaning of life is.

But unless this topic of conversation has any significance to your current lives, have you thought of just not talking about it with her? Friendships don't have to be based on having the same opinions about things; they just need to be willing to respect each other's views.

alphapie · 10/07/2022 19:56

Wouldloveanother · 10/07/2022 18:07

Ok I’m going to go against the grain and say I would stay her friend, if the friendship was good and she had other qualities. One of my most fulfilling friendships is with somebody who is diametrically opposed to one of my core beliefs. I’m getting a bit tired of people who believe it is their right to only be surrounded in life by people who agree with their opinions. Not only is it narrow minded and intolerant but it deepened the chasm between people and severs any attempt to find common ground.

But that is their right, they don't 'believe' it, it's a basic fact, you can choose who you surround yourself with.

That's a right anyone has, I don't speak to anyone who voted for Brexit, I won't travel to states where they've banned abortion, I refuse to shop or pay for goods with any businesses who financially supported, publicly supported or whose owners financially supported vote leave, I wouldn't really be friends with a Tory either.

That's my right to do that, pretty simple concept to grasp

JanisMoplin · 10/07/2022 18:31

Wouldloveanother · 10/07/2022 18:07

Ok I’m going to go against the grain and say I would stay her friend, if the friendship was good and she had other qualities. One of my most fulfilling friendships is with somebody who is diametrically opposed to one of my core beliefs. I’m getting a bit tired of people who believe it is their right to only be surrounded in life by people who agree with their opinions. Not only is it narrow minded and intolerant but it deepened the chasm between people and severs any attempt to find common ground.

It is EVERYONE's right to be surrounded by people who share their opinions. And you will find most religious fundamentalists, racists, and pro-gun nuts like to hang out with other fundamentalists, racists and gun nuts. I don't see why it is so bad tp say that I don't want to make or remain friends with people like these.

I had a friend who I later discovered was anti-Muslim. I dropped her. She had several good qualities, but I decided to be "intolerant" of this particular quality.

Wouldloveanother · 10/07/2022 18:07

Ok I’m going to go against the grain and say I would stay her friend, if the friendship was good and she had other qualities. One of my most fulfilling friendships is with somebody who is diametrically opposed to one of my core beliefs. I’m getting a bit tired of people who believe it is their right to only be surrounded in life by people who agree with their opinions. Not only is it narrow minded and intolerant but it deepened the chasm between people and severs any attempt to find common ground.

WhereYouLeftIt · 10/07/2022 17:44

Leaving the subject of abortion to one side for a minute -

"I’ve told her I no longer wish to discuss it but she still airs her views."

So she is overriding your wishes because her airing her views is more important. She does not regard you as her friend, she regards you as her AUDIENCE. An audience that she is trying to convert and bring into the fold of the faithful.

I'd run fast and far from this woman, ASAP.

MarshaMelrose · 10/07/2022 17:12

I think abortion is a very personal subject so it's not one I really discuss with people. If they hold different views from me, I trust my friends to have good reason. But I wouldn't even want to discuss it more than once so to keep having it brought up would annoy me.
I guess what I'm saying is that I wouldn't stop being friends because we had a difference of opinion but I would if they kept doing things that I found annoying and which I'd repeatedly asked them not to do.

CapMarvel · 10/07/2022 17:11

DoubleShotEspresso · 10/07/2022 16:37

@CapMarvel
Would you be friends with someone who is openly racist or homophobic?

Not at all because I believe they ought to have the same rights and privileges in the name of fairness and equality.

OP's friend clearly thinks unborn babies too have rights (rightly or wrongly/based on her faith or other reasons).

Your point doesn't really make so much sense then does it?

The point, obviously, is that anyone can choose not to be friends with anyone for whatever reason.

I am not and would not be friends with an anti-choicer. I put such people in a similar group to racists etc as people whose views I just cannot align with or tolerate on any level.

alphapie · 10/07/2022 17:04

DoubleShotEspresso · 10/07/2022 16:56

@StaunchMomma

  • DoubleShotEspresso You are friends.

Friends can remain so but still hold different opinions surely?

There are opinions and there are opinions.

I personally couldn't be friends with anyone who was eg racist, homophobic, a climate change denier, an anti-vaxxer, a misogynist, a Trump loving gun-toter etc.

What can I say, I just hate c*nts, and I'm afraid people who are extremely anti abortion in the way OP has described would be in the cunt category for me.

As above I may not agree or even respect an opinion different to mine, but I'd defend anybody's right to hold that view, however revolting I might find that view.
Racism & homophobia represent hate to me so yeah couldn't consider a friendship with these.
Political views and rights to life though?! These are something I woukd happily argue against with any friend but equally agree to disagree.

Referring to any woman as belonging in "the c word category" is a complete no for me. I detest the word and think all women have a hard enough time these days and think this diminishes our rights snd views which I'm keen to see upheld, along with the right to an opinion , which yes o occasions I accept won't always be one I share.

Do you not think that someone thinking women shouldn't have the ability to control medical decisions over their own body is hateful?

You don't think forcing rape victims to give birth to a child they do not want is hateful?

You don't think forcing a 10 year old incest victim to give birth to a child that might kill her in the process is hateful?

DogsAndGin · 10/07/2022 17:03

What a coincidence. I know someone who is anti-abortion and yet has had at least one herself. I think they feel as though there’s ‘didn’t count’ or that their reason was an exception to their rules, or that they were ‘someone else’ back then. I don’t understand how they can be so hypocritical

DoubleShotEspresso · 10/07/2022 16:56

@StaunchMomma

  • DoubleShotEspresso You are friends.

Friends can remain so but still hold different opinions surely?

There are opinions and there are opinions.

I personally couldn't be friends with anyone who was eg racist, homophobic, a climate change denier, an anti-vaxxer, a misogynist, a Trump loving gun-toter etc.

What can I say, I just hate c*nts, and I'm afraid people who are extremely anti abortion in the way OP has described would be in the cunt category for me.

As above I may not agree or even respect an opinion different to mine, but I'd defend anybody's right to hold that view, however revolting I might find that view.
Racism & homophobia represent hate to me so yeah couldn't consider a friendship with these.
Political views and rights to life though?! These are something I woukd happily argue against with any friend but equally agree to disagree.

Referring to any woman as belonging in "the c word category" is a complete no for me. I detest the word and think all women have a hard enough time these days and think this diminishes our rights snd views which I'm keen to see upheld, along with the right to an opinion , which yes o occasions I accept won't always be one I share.

DoubleShotEspresso · 10/07/2022 16:37

@CapMarvel
Would you be friends with someone who is openly racist or homophobic?

Not at all because I believe they ought to have the same rights and privileges in the name of fairness and equality.

OP's friend clearly thinks unborn babies too have rights (rightly or wrongly/based on her faith or other reasons).

Your point doesn't really make so much sense then does it?

CapMarvel · 10/07/2022 16:14

SaltFlakes · 10/07/2022 11:51

This thread, and the number of 'no tories' in the dating non negotiables thread, really shows just how intolerant people on the left are.

I have plenty of friends with radically different views. Why should that stop a friendship? We just accept that the other holds 'unacceptable' views and move on.

Everyone has red lines when it comes to people they are friends with.

Would you be friends with someone who is openly racist or homophobic?

carrotChicory · 10/07/2022 15:42

StaunchMomma · 10/07/2022 14:41

She'd be an ex-friend real quick, for me.

Also, I'd be bringing up that late abortion at every turn.

What a hateful bitch!!

Shaming her for her late abortion to make your point would be very wrong.

Why not just go no contact or explain your stance reasonably ?

JanisMoplin · 10/07/2022 15:14

All this 'different opinions' stuff. Personally not interested in being friends with religious fundamentalists. They can go air their opinions somewhere else.

HappySunnyDaisies · 10/07/2022 15:11

It is not a “it’s just an opinion”. It is a belief they are trying to impose on someone else.

And the problem is that then a lot of people with “that opinion” get together, they chose a big idiot, vote to get bid idiot in power and then make “the opinion” a law.

99% of the reasons that anti-abortion people have is based on a religious belief which, spoiler alert: other people might not follow.

If anyone is against abortion that’s good for them, they can just not have one. But under no circumstance should that be imposed on anyone else.

MintJulia · 10/07/2022 15:09

Your friend is perfectly entitled to reject the idea of abortion absolutely for herself.

It's the fact that she thinks she has the right to decide for others, regardless of circumstance that would be the deal breaker for me. I couldn't be friends with someone so interfering or judgemental.

StaunchMomma · 10/07/2022 14:45

DoubleShotEspresso · 10/07/2022 13:14

You are friends.

Friends can remain so but still hold different opinions surely?

There are opinions and there are opinions.

I personally couldn't be friends with anyone who was eg racist, homophobic, a climate change denier, an anti-vaxxer, a misogynist, a Trump loving gun-toter etc.

What can I say, I just hate c**nts, and I'm afraid people who are extremely anti abortion in the way OP has described would be in the cunt category for me.