Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be hopping mad if Rishi gets pm job?

267 replies

malificent7 · 10/07/2022 09:47

Simply because he is super rich and his wife evaded tax while we all struggle with the cost of living? How can they let him stand?

This is not a racist thread btw.

OP posts:
ShandaLear · 10/07/2022 16:15

To be fair, the rest of those who have declared they’re standing are bloody awful. There’s not one of them would get close to winning a general election. I’m surprised Suella and Grant (or whatever his real name is) weren’t laughed out of the place.

plugee · 10/07/2022 16:13

@00865jkk but Rishi does seem to be held to a different standard vs Boris. I mean I don't have faith in any of them but don't think we can do worse than Boris

rainingsnoring · 10/07/2022 16:11

Can't stand Rishi with his glossy videos and photo shoots with other people's cars, his/his wife's deliberate avoidance of tax at the same time as raising them to the highest level in 70 years for working people. He will clearly favour the elites and vote for austerity for everyone else.

However, they are all shockingly bad, devoid of ideas and tainted by association with everything that has happened in the Johnson government (hunt tainted by his previous tenure a Health Secretary).

The Tory party are divided and busy fighting each other at a time when the country is in a desperate state. They should all be ashamed of themselves.

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2022 15:52

I see Johnson’s allies’ smearing is working well. Rees Mogg, Dorries and Jenkyns must be delighted.

00865jkk · 10/07/2022 15:51

And in terms of course tries, I am originally from Russia and we know how much Russian money came to the UK. It took this war for them to be kicked out of the UK. Sadly they have just gone to Dubai that takes everyone's cash. But yes
, the fact they could basically live in the West did mean they could turn Russia into crap while selling the people nationalistic garbage. It's insulting for them to have criticized the West while ensuring their kids all live here even Putin. But it's similar elsewhere. So I prefer to have a political class that actually has to see what they've done, at least to some extent

00865jkk · 10/07/2022 15:47

@plugee just because people might not want Rishi doesn't mean they trusted Boris. I no idea why anyone in their right mind wanted Boris. The Tories now admit they selected him because they could win against Corbyn. We may only miss him because on the whole Boris was too lazy to really do policy.

My concern about the whole of the Conservative party is the extent to which they depend on their financial backers i.e. global multinationals and big business. For example, I would also be against Mogg.

It's tough to pick whichever tory is least like that.

plugee · 10/07/2022 15:41

@00865jkk so which current politicians are committed to this country? Are you assuming because he's not white he's less committed, did you think Boris was more committed? I'm sure he only renounced his American citizenship because of taxes.

The political elites in your country who resided abroad did they all hold different citizenships before?

Rishi's wife is Indian but that doesn't mean they want to leave anymore that any politician who appears to be committed can up & leave at some point after they serve.

TullyApplebottom · 10/07/2022 14:59

TenTree · 10/07/2022 14:37

Honestly, the vitriol from people who do not understand what they are talking about is actually quite concerning.

It was not tax evasion. It wasn't even tax avoidance. It was tax that there was no requirement to pay.

The non-dom tax rules were introduced by a Labour government, so it's not even like it's a Conservative policy she was benefitting from. The rules became significantly less lucrative under a Conservative government in 2011. Sunak made no changes to those rules at all.

I genuinely struggle why people believe that Indian wealth, generated in India, and kept in India (and for a period of no longer than 15 years) should be taxed in the UK.

Have your views on the Sunaks (although I'm not sure how I feel on judging him by her finances) but before you defend the basis of their views, you might want to make sure you understand the issue.

This is way too sophisticated for your audience, my friend

TullyApplebottom · 10/07/2022 14:58

SnowyLamb · 10/07/2022 14:26

I'd quite like a PM who sees his and his children's future in the UK. Wanting to be PM of a country you don't plan to stay in suggests commitment to hisnown ambition, not to the country.

And as PP says, tremendous damage has been done in counties where the elite tend to live abroad once they've done their harm.

This is just mad. It’s made up. There is no evidence at all he or his family plan to leave the UK.
Although given the prevailing attitudes I wouldn’t blame them one bit if they did.

ChrisReasBathEggs · 10/07/2022 14:48

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 10:18

Nothing about tax evasion there. It’s interesting the lies being posted about the most prominent non-white candidate.

I don't think it's about not being white, it's about morals and competency. It is morally wrong to avoid paying tax as a chancellor whether it is legal or not. He broke lockdown laws and does not want to help people who are struggling with the cost of living (which in part he created with dodgy schemes that were not monitored for fraud and a ridiculous amount of QE). I don't think he was even that good as a chancellor to be honest. That is why I wouldn't want him as PM.

TenTree · 10/07/2022 14:43

SnowyLamb · 10/07/2022 14:26

I'd quite like a PM who sees his and his children's future in the UK. Wanting to be PM of a country you don't plan to stay in suggests commitment to hisnown ambition, not to the country.

And as PP says, tremendous damage has been done in counties where the elite tend to live abroad once they've done their harm.

His children will be UK dom. They will inherit their father's domicile status (and it's likely Rishi will have UK domicile of choice, rather than having retained his father's probably Kenyan dom).

All we know is that Akshata doesn't necessarily view UK as 'home'. That might be because if she divorces Rishi she intends to return to India. That wouldn't be that bizarre.

UK Domicile is very hard to lose if you're born here. It's only right that it is therefore very difficult to acquire too.

TenTree · 10/07/2022 14:37

Honestly, the vitriol from people who do not understand what they are talking about is actually quite concerning.

It was not tax evasion. It wasn't even tax avoidance. It was tax that there was no requirement to pay.

The non-dom tax rules were introduced by a Labour government, so it's not even like it's a Conservative policy she was benefitting from. The rules became significantly less lucrative under a Conservative government in 2011. Sunak made no changes to those rules at all.

I genuinely struggle why people believe that Indian wealth, generated in India, and kept in India (and for a period of no longer than 15 years) should be taxed in the UK.

Have your views on the Sunaks (although I'm not sure how I feel on judging him by her finances) but before you defend the basis of their views, you might want to make sure you understand the issue.

sst1234 · 10/07/2022 14:32

Nanananananana99 · 10/07/2022 12:52

Gordon Brown was a moralist, whose father was a Minister of the Church of Scotland so it doesn’t surprise me that he started to talk about the morality of legal tax avoidance.

As chancellor “Brown presided over the longest period of sustained economic growth in British history” and he was at the forefront of saving the banks from collapse through nationalisation etc

As PM his main focus was on early year’s education and it’s a shame he didn’t get a second term.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gordon_Brown

Re writing history, much?

Gordon Brown wanted the top job, and tore the wave of asset inflationary global economy while making some very bad decisions throughout. He presided over the biggest reason why this country has a low pay culture - tax credits. Rather than making employers pay the going rate, he created an underclass of welfare dependent people who could either choose not to work of work for less than the going rate with taxpayer subsidies. His economic policy left this country much less able to weather then financial crisis. And now he pretends to play the elder statesman. A terrible chancellor and a worse PM. Though not a war criminal, i’ll give you that.

00865jkk · 10/07/2022 14:28

@TullyApplebottom does it make it any better if I say that the whole of the Conservative party is currently not committed to the UK? so it might be a question of figuring out who is least likely to sell it off to the highest/lowest bidder. The tory party is as far as I know - mostly white and British. But those who pushed for Brexit mainly did it in order to open the UK up to the multinationals which they couldnt do so long as it was in the EU.

SnowyLamb · 10/07/2022 14:26

TullyApplebottom · 10/07/2022 14:22

Is that a serious question? He’s an MP, he’s trying to be PM. How much do non white people have to do before you can accept they’re committed to the UK? Do you want to resurrect tebbitt’s cricket test????

I'd quite like a PM who sees his and his children's future in the UK. Wanting to be PM of a country you don't plan to stay in suggests commitment to hisnown ambition, not to the country.

And as PP says, tremendous damage has been done in counties where the elite tend to live abroad once they've done their harm.

SnowyLamb · 10/07/2022 14:24

When I first saw him deliver the Covid briefing, I said to DH "this man's going to be PM" so my initial reaction to him saw absolutely nothing detrimental in his race. I just think there's far too much baggage around him now. The tax, the lack of commitment to the country, the rule breaking and the support for Johnson.

If he gets selected he won't get elected and that's why he won't be selected.

TullyApplebottom · 10/07/2022 14:22

SnowyLamb · 10/07/2022 13:32

Because he's married to a woman who had officially declared that she wasn't permanently resident. What's so hard to understand? His wife and (presumably) children don't plan to stay, so how can he be committed?

Is that a serious question? He’s an MP, he’s trying to be PM. How much do non white people have to do before you can accept they’re committed to the UK? Do you want to resurrect tebbitt’s cricket test????

WotsitsQuavers · 10/07/2022 14:17

astoundedgoat · 10/07/2022 11:13

The fact that he is personally rich (through his wife) is neither here nor there, but doesn't it look more like he is a trophy project of his father in law, Narayan Murthy? I might be mis-remembering, but when he graduated and married his wife, Murthy set up him with a hedge fund, then set him up to run as an MP, and now Murthy gets the perfectly high status husband for his daughter in the shape of a Prime Minister?

I'm going to disagree with Sunak on most of his political beliefs, so I don't believe he's any worse than most of the candidates, but it feels like he is a highly intentional and perfectly executed project by his father in law. If he hadn't married Akshata Murthy he'd probably just have had a successful, but quiet financial career.

Not sure if that makes him a better or worse candidate for PM, but it does seem driven by strategy rather than passion, from the outside.

This. He is full PR and photo op. Making him look taller, PR photo ops, ready for rishi website registered in December 2021.

He does look like a trophy Ken Puppet. Who is the Puppetmaster? What are the motives?

00865jkk · 10/07/2022 14:15

@plugee honestly because having lived in a country in which the political elite mainly resided abroad once they were finished - the main problem is never having to live with their policies (as class). For example, environmental regulation/pollution regulation - not a problem if your kids live in Switzerland while you destroy them at home. It's fine to let the healthy service go - if you just travel to Germany if you're ever sick. Equally why care about the roads when you never use them. I can go on but there are many many reasons why it is not always a good idea to have political elites who basically see your country as a way of enriching themselves and your mates while ending up living somewhere else. Look at the rest of the world - and how many of their elites end up in London.

plugee · 10/07/2022 14:14

@SnowyLamb where did I say that?

LadyWithLapdog · 10/07/2022 14:12

@AnaïsM you are a shit-stirrer. I refer you to what I wrote. HTH.

SnowyLamb · 10/07/2022 14:10

plugee · 10/07/2022 14:08

Well then they're unlikely to be elected PM!

Apparently so as they are 3rd gen immigrants!

It's perfectly legitimate for an individual to accept that they might have to leave the UK for the best opportunities, but it's hardly the attitude you want from your PM

Why not? why does the public need to feel that the PM wants to stay in the UK forever to be a good PM?

You don't want your PM to be someone committed to the long term future of the country?

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 14:08

LadyWithLapdog · 10/07/2022 14:00

It’s obscene to have so much money you know you won’t live long enough to spend it.

It’s obscene to be so greedy you don’t pay your fair share in the country you live in, or you pay thousands a year to register yourself as non-dom so you can avoid tax.

Greed.

You have evidence that she hasn’t been paying her taxes? That’d be political dynamite, would you share it here?

plugee · 10/07/2022 14:08

Well then they're unlikely to be elected PM!

Apparently so as they are 3rd gen immigrants!

It's perfectly legitimate for an individual to accept that they might have to leave the UK for the best opportunities, but it's hardly the attitude you want from your PM

Why not? why does the public need to feel that the PM wants to stay in the UK forever to be a good PM?