Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Britain is not ready for BAME PM

341 replies

notnever · 10/07/2022 01:06

Rishi might just be voted by MPs but will not win general elections. Already we are reminded he is rich, has an US Greencard, cut taxes, unrelatable, wife is rich and did not pay tax, did not declare tax, etc, as if any different from Boris.

Do you think Britain is ready for BAME PM?
Yes = you are unreasonable
No = you are not being unreasonable

NB, you don't have to explain whether it makes Britain racist or not. I am personally happy he is standing for leadership, it will be his good reminder (as many of us BAME know) racism trumps social class.

OP posts:
Lonelycrab · 10/07/2022 09:36

There were plenty of other reasons why people voted leave. I voted remain but come on, can we stop pretending that everyone who voted leave was doing it because they're racist?

Its not about everyone being racist though, just some. A lot of posters getting offended, claiming the op means the entire Tory voter based is racist- it’s not.

But that doesn’t mean some are racist, and the question is: are there enough of them to cause enough of a swing in any given vote.

Take my neighbour for instance. White male, mid 50s, covered in tats and passionate Chelsea supporter. We get on well on a superficial level. But when I asked him if the rented house next door to him had been filled yet, his response was he didn’t mind who moved in “as long as they’re not a Muslim or a darky”

My “d”f, 82 is openly racist and uses the n word regularly.

This is Britain 2022. You might not accept it but racism is actually more widespread than you think, if you scratch beneath the surface it’s there. I don’t think this is a racist country on the whole, but I think there are enough people that will not vote for a bame pm, for it to make a difference.

Queenoftheashes · 10/07/2022 09:33

Why is everyone still using BAME, I thought that got retired? Voters are pretty clear about what they want these days. I can’t see them voting for a white person because they’re white if it goes against their self interest. Tbh characterising brexiteers as knuckle-dragging racists is a short sighted outlook that hasn’t done the left any good so far.

Instantnoodles · 10/07/2022 09:31

None of them understand the impact that price rises are having on us. Why do we hold Sunak to higher expectations?

Because he was Chancellor of the Exchequer! It was literally his job to understand such things. So I don't apologise for holding him to a higher standard. Johnson is a low bar anyway.

If it must be a Johnson acolyte I would choose Javid. Somebody from outside the cabinet would be far better.

Friendship101 · 10/07/2022 09:30

I’m one of the deluded ones who thinks Britain isn’t that racist. No more than any other country anyway. 18 months ago I was such a Rishi fan and could totally see him as next PM, as could all of my white, mainly labour family and friends. Now however none of us want him. His lack of compassion these last months has been astounding and I am genuinely scared (even more than with BJ) for our poorer members of society if he gets PM.

I actually don’t know who I’d want out of any of them Tory lot.

Zarah Sultana however I can totally see her as PM in the next 10 years.

Magicpaintbrush · 10/07/2022 09:25

I just want someone to vote for who has integrity, decency and preferably with working class roots who understands that genuinely - that's it. I don't care what race or ethnicity they are, just the best person for the job please, end of.

cottagegardenflower · 10/07/2022 09:17

Only the BAME and women jump out at me as reasonable candidates. I'm white British

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 09:16

sunshineq · 10/07/2022 09:06

Probably not. Britain is racist, and anyone who says otherwise is deluded.

It’s one of the last racist countries on Earth, as high-quality research generally shows.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 10/07/2022 09:16

The proximity gap - would be the thing that worries me most.

By all accounts Rishi has grown up in an upper middle class environment and by his own admission has never had any 'working class' friends.

If this is true - and I believe it is - he stands a good chance of creating policies that do not help people on incomes lower than his - simply because he has no experience of this - and lacks the imagination - or empathy to factor it it.

Since one of the main issues in this country is income inequality - and also the housing crisis (i.e lack of affordable homes) - having him as P.M. I believe will be an absolute shambles. But then I would say the same for anyone of the Eton boys (replace Eton with other private school names).

And so that is my bias - declared here. But it is not a racial one. Not by any means. I see him being P.m. as a repeat performance of Boris. Which in the long run will be good for the opposition as it will mean the annihilation of the Tory party. In the short term though it will mean a great deal of suffering for those already struggling and attending food banks etc.

The fact that the government is advising people to go to food banks is beyond appalling that it has come to this.

CaptainBeakyandhisband · 10/07/2022 09:13

You’re conflating the issue. I think Britain could be ready for a BAME figurehead, if they were like Obama. Rishi’s problem isn’t his skin colour, it’s that we cannot be sure he is trustworthy when it comes to the interests of the Everyperson. Though he has made some good decisions as chancellor that benefit real people. I still think the green card, the massive fortune, will alienate him.

plugee · 10/07/2022 09:08

Doesn't Rishi want to raise taxes or at least keep them where they are for social care?

We have a huge ageing population issue, we all need to pay more tax unfortunately.

HelloThereObiWan · 10/07/2022 09:07

I agree with you re Hunt.

I actually got bored by the time I got to the last two and I accept it doesn't look good as they are women so I'll try again:

Braverman: Has argued against the judiciary checks and balances we have in place to stop people like Boris doing whatever they like. Gave questionable advice regarding breaching the northern Ireland protocol.

Patel: I'd argue that my reference to Rwanda is enough but anyway. Held secret undeclared meetings with Israeli government officials who were seeking to influence the British government policy.

And the only reason I listed the BAME candidates was because this whole post is about how the UK won't elect one because of their ethnicity whilst I'm trying to point out their other flaws. But for balance:

Truss: A foreign secretary whose lack of geography knowledge sparked a diplomatic incident with the Russians. Has argued for fewer employment laws.

Hunt: His actions as health secretary meant that the NHS did not have adequate PPE stocks when Covid hit. Junior doctors actually went on strike during his tenure.

Tugendhat: Lack of experience overall. Has supported Israeli settlers on Jewish land. Generally little controversy overall as far as I can find.

Mordant: Won't be loved on here due to her support of trans rights.

Realised I missed Badenoch but I'm running out of time now as the kids are pestering me: Seems a bit obsessed with culture wars and little else.

Saracen · 10/07/2022 09:06

I dunno, I really didn't think the US was ready for Obama either, so that came as a big surprise. And then the Biden/Harris lineup with Biden being so old even raised the prospect of a female BAME president.

Being white definitely makes it easier to get elected, I'll agree.

sunshineq · 10/07/2022 09:06

Probably not. Britain is racist, and anyone who says otherwise is deluded.

Titsflyingsouth · 10/07/2022 09:05

I'd never been vote for Rishi. It has nothing to do with skin colour though.If he was Obama or someone with similar values though I would in a heartbeat!

Absolutely this. Couldn't give a shit whether the candidate was BAME - just don't want another 4 years of narrow minded 'little Britain' politics and fat cat ministers making the richest people richer whilst screwing over the rest of us...

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 10/07/2022 08:59

Completely unrelated to colour, I’d also like to know if Rishi is actively religious and if so, how much does his religion influence his beliefs and actions? Does he believe in the caste system for example? It would not be good for the U.K. going through a recession/financial crisis to have a billionaire PM who’s beliefs teach him that he ‘deserves’ to be rich because he did something good in a past life and the food bank customers are there because they did something bad in a past life i.e it’s their fault they are poor. Can you imagine how this would impact policy making around tax cuts for the rich, raising taxes against poor, slashing the state?

I would say the same about Rees-Mogg and how Catholicism impacts his behaviour. Look at the Supreme Court judges in America to see how religion can have a impact.

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 08:57

Sistanotcista · 10/07/2022 08:50

I have no objection to his personal wealth or his ethnicity and race. I have a huge objection to his lack of integrity - propping up BoJo, having a get-out-of-jail-free card in the form of a US green card, wasting millions on PPE contracts to dodgy providers, and failing to get his wife to pay tax. I know what she did with her tax was legal, but it wasn’t ethical, and showed a huge lack of integrity. This is a man who doesn’t see his future in the UK. His family are not paying tax, and he clearly hadn’t shut the door on relocating to the USA at some stage. I want a leader who is invested in the UK, not someone temporarily doing a job here.

His family are not paying tax? That would be a stunning revelation if true.

Mandatorymongoose · 10/07/2022 08:57

Disraeli was ethnically Jewish and noticeably so. He had converted to Christianity in religious terms (which since you basically had to to become an MP until 1858 was probably part of the reason he got to the office he did).

Jewish origin is a minority ethnic group, even though there are lots of Jews who would pass as white.

I think as a country we would elect another prime minister from a minority ethnic origin and it will be interesting to see if we get someone other than a straight white male as an option.

Cornettoninja · 10/07/2022 08:57

But it doesn’t matter what they think. They either don’t vote in GEs or are not Tory party members. At the last election, you needed to be in the former group and right now you need to be in the latter to decide the PM.

I was more answering the incredulity that a poster could possibly come across so many people who didn’t support the tories in 2019 tbf. The numbers suggest that you’re far more likely to come across an eligible voter who didn’t than someone who did.

sst1234 · 10/07/2022 08:54

Not sure why people struggle to see past Rishi’s popularity gain during the pandemic. Any idiot can run the printing presses 24/7 to pay for a stupid lockdown policy. That’s what he did. The chicken are coming home to roost now, aka the coat of living crisis.

Also he only got the job in the first place because Javid resigned from the Chancellor post just before the pandemic in protest at meddling by Dominic Cummings. He only got the job because his leadership rival stepped aside. Right place, time time.

So really, let’s look beyond the BAME thing. Sunak is not fit for purpose because he was a crap chancellor.

Cornettoninja · 10/07/2022 08:53

Well, right now 83% of the vote on this post is YABU. I really hope that is indicative of the mood of the country- not necessarily for Rishi in particular

It is.

Sistanotcista · 10/07/2022 08:50

Dashel · 10/07/2022 07:05

I am white as is my DH and we both think he stands a good chance of becoming the the leader and winning and election - if he can get the party behind him.

Yes he is rich and his wife is even richer, but it seems a bit judgmental not to vote for him on that? I can’t imagine people saying an MP is too poor to vote for.

I have no idea who I would vote for if there was a GE tomorrow but the race of the leader wouldn’t enter into my decision making at all.

I have no objection to his personal wealth or his ethnicity and race. I have a huge objection to his lack of integrity - propping up BoJo, having a get-out-of-jail-free card in the form of a US green card, wasting millions on PPE contracts to dodgy providers, and failing to get his wife to pay tax. I know what she did with her tax was legal, but it wasn’t ethical, and showed a huge lack of integrity. This is a man who doesn’t see his future in the UK. His family are not paying tax, and he clearly hadn’t shut the door on relocating to the USA at some stage. I want a leader who is invested in the UK, not someone temporarily doing a job here.

ChrisS36 · 10/07/2022 08:50

Watch him. If he wins the leadership he will walk the general election.

Alltheprettyseahorses · 10/07/2022 08:48

HelloThereObiWan · 10/07/2022 08:41

Sunak: Received a fine for party gate. Posed with a Sainsbury's staff member car to fill up because he's that out of touch. Introduced big tax rises. Dodgy tax set ups for his wife.

Javid: Claims Ayn Rand has his political heroine which should tell you everything you need to know. Oversaw dodgy tax avoidance schemes when working at Deutsche Bank.

Zahawi: Currently under investigation by HMRC for his tax arrangements.

Braverman: Genuinely insane. Completely incompetent as Attorney General.

Patel: (is she running? I haven't seen) Genuinely evil. Rwanda FFS.

It's not racism. They are all either corrupt, incompetent, or in Patel's case, just evil.

The likes of Hunt are far worse. I'd argue that Hunt shouldn't be allowed to stand, he fortunately failed last time anyway which should be an excuse to bar him. But all the 'progressive' left/anti-Tories are interested in is attacking anyone with brown and black skin. Not with facts and proper political criticism either - with the emotive misogynistic smears of 'evil' and 'insane' while trying to project their own feelings onto Tory voters. I'm very anti-Tory myself but come on

Aprilx · 10/07/2022 08:48

I think Britain is easily easy for a BAME prime minister. I don’t think it will be Rishi, but nothing to do with his colour, I think his immense privilege will be the barrier.

sst1234 · 10/07/2022 08:48

Cornettoninja · 10/07/2022 08:45

13 million people voted Tory at the last election and won 47 seats from Labour

the tories won with 43.6% of votes leaving 56.4% who didn’t vote for them. The turnout overall was 67.3% of those eligible. You’re more likely to come across someone who doesn’t support Boris/tories than someone who does based on those figures (which have moved dramatically over the last few years).

It’s a good result but it does leave a large proportion that isn’t insignificant.

But it doesn’t matter what they think. They either don’t vote in GEs or are not Tory party members. At the last election, you needed to be in the former group and right now you need to be in the latter to decide the PM.