Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Britain is not ready for BAME PM

341 replies

notnever · 10/07/2022 01:06

Rishi might just be voted by MPs but will not win general elections. Already we are reminded he is rich, has an US Greencard, cut taxes, unrelatable, wife is rich and did not pay tax, did not declare tax, etc, as if any different from Boris.

Do you think Britain is ready for BAME PM?
Yes = you are unreasonable
No = you are not being unreasonable

NB, you don't have to explain whether it makes Britain racist or not. I am personally happy he is standing for leadership, it will be his good reminder (as many of us BAME know) racism trumps social class.

OP posts:
Friendship101 · 10/07/2022 10:26

plugee · 10/07/2022 10:24

some dodgy aspects surrounding tax..

Nothing illegal & everyone does whatever they can to reduce the tax liability. Look at how many threads on here about reducing IHT or CGT.

Whilst the rich do this, it doesn’t make it ethically right. I’m part of the squeezed middle I guess and it really irks me.

Twillow · 10/07/2022 10:26

Teddeh · 10/07/2022 01:52

A day more ready than they were when someone posted this yesterday.

(If you're talking about Sunak specifically, though, he is not "BAME"; ethnically his background is Punjabi.)

BAME = Black, Asian and minority ethnic hence Sunak is BAME

plugee · 10/07/2022 10:24

some dodgy aspects surrounding tax..

Nothing illegal & everyone does whatever they can to reduce the tax liability. Look at how many threads on here about reducing IHT or CGT.

hattie43 · 10/07/2022 10:24

I don't care what colour they are I just want an honest politician with integrity who cares . I'm going to be disappointed because there isn't one

MyrrAgain · 10/07/2022 10:23

We've already had a PM from an ethnic minority group. Just pointing that out

sst1234 · 10/07/2022 10:21

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 10:09

I get the impression that the left-leaning posters on here would be utterly bereft to have a non-white PM. To them the right being racist is a matter of faith, something that they hold dear and do not want disproven.

This is despite the EHRC having found recently that Labour were racist to their core.

Quite. For the left, it would like losing a pound and finding a penny if a non-white leader was elected.

MacaroniBaloney · 10/07/2022 10:21

Is Britain not ready for a BAME leader or because of all the other reasons in yiur original post. You've mixed up his colour with all the other reasons you think will put people off him.

Does Britain only like poor, un connected BAME as potential leaders?

I think it would be quite the opposite.

kimfox · 10/07/2022 10:20

YABU and the things you cite about Sunak have bog all to do with ethnicity or skin colour anyway. As such I'm not sure how happy people would be with him!

I may have the wrong end of the stick about the electorate but if the stated policy fits and there is some level of integrity (! Or is that wishful thinking?) then I don't think people care about ethnicity. Brexit Britain seem to be happy with Priti Patel for example. I think people would accept a person of any colour for PM now, as long as they believe that person will improve things.

rushrushflat · 10/07/2022 10:18

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 10:09

I get the impression that the left-leaning posters on here would be utterly bereft to have a non-white PM. To them the right being racist is a matter of faith, something that they hold dear and do not want disproven.

This is despite the EHRC having found recently that Labour were racist to their core.

This and other posters on the same lines, I honestly think most of these vocal leftwingers not all mind, would be lost without a race card to throw around and claim the UK is utterly racist to its core.

I often question if they would even want to stamp out racism as it would give them no more mud to sling.

Nancydrawn · 10/07/2022 10:16

(I should say that there's no clear evidence that JRM avoided tax on any profit, as per the Paradise Papers. But he has defended tax havens and I find his approach to wealth grotesque. www.theguardian.com/news/2017/nov/09/brexiters-put-money-offshore-tax-haven)

Fifthtimelucky · 10/07/2022 10:13

I think we are ready for a BAME PM, but personally I'd go for Sajid Javid rather than Rishi Sunak.

I don't yet know enough about Kemi Badenoch or Suella Braverman, but they both look credible candidates. I feel the same about Tom Tugenhat.

I wouldn't want Priti Patel for many reasons, but her race is not one of them. Similarly, I wouldn't want Grant Shapps, but it's not because he's a white man!

Nancydrawn · 10/07/2022 10:13

I think Sunak is one of the better of quite a bad lot on a personal level.

I think the tax strategy that he and Gove took was relatively sensible; I don't mind higher taxes in the least, but Johnson's slash-taxes-spend-a-lot model was dumb. My concern, however, is that Sunak will bow to internal pressure and cut taxes, and then in turn cut services even further, which concerns me. This country doesn't need more austerity, and I think Sunak might take us there.

I don't love that he kept his wife's non-dom status to avoid taxation, just as I don't like that Jacob Rees-Mogg has been involved with offshore tax havens. Neither seem illegal, but both are ethically problematic in my eyes.

All of that said, I don't think that anyone who sat in government under Johnson should be PM. They put up with too much for too long. Some may have done it for (slightly) noble reasons. Most did it for sheer ambition. And they are complicit in the lying, the dismantling of public trust, and the corruption of Johnson's regime. A plague on all their houses.

As for his race, I suspect you are right, OP, at least for some people and at least to some extent. I think he will be held to different standards for identical behavior. Some people who were on board with Johnson and who find Jacob Rees Mogg's caricatured self comforting rather than grotesque will find Sunak offensive. But on the whole I think that people will vote for him. It might even give some cover for their racism ("I can't be racist, I voted for Sunak!").

Personally, I won't be voting for him because a) I don't live in his constituency, b) I'm not a Tory MP, and c) even if I were either of those things, I couldn't vote for anyone who had sat in Johnson's government for that long.

Designhelp · 10/07/2022 10:11

balalake · 10/07/2022 08:06

I think Britain is ready for a Prime Minister from an ethnic minority. Just not Rishi Sunak- I think Sajid Javid would be accepted by many.

Id go with this, Rishi is too rich and successful, some dodgy aspects surrounding tax..

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 10:09

I get the impression that the left-leaning posters on here would be utterly bereft to have a non-white PM. To them the right being racist is a matter of faith, something that they hold dear and do not want disproven.

This is despite the EHRC having found recently that Labour were racist to their core.

Designhelp · 10/07/2022 10:08

RenegadeMatron · 10/07/2022 07:37

There are some deeply disingenuous people on this thread.

All this, ‘I wouldn’t vote for him because X, Y, Z - nothing to do with his skin colour’. Please.

If only people had used those sorts of scruples when Boris was up for election.

But, no. The majority of people held their noses, and big, fat voted for him, anyway. His many flaws - including, but not limited to, incompetence - weren’t enough to stop the majority voting him in.

Likewise, if Boris were a woman, cheating on husband, and spawning kids, it would have been completely unacceptable.

He can do it because he’s a wealthy, privileged white man, and it gives him the sort of ‘pass’ other people simply do not get.

This with bells on

rwalker · 10/07/2022 10:07

Don't understand why this is even a question

Designhelp · 10/07/2022 10:06

brown543 · 10/07/2022 07:15

But I agree. Brexit Britain won't vote for a brown person.

Come on. Hands up, I voted for Brexit. As did most of my highly educated, work in professional services friends. I only mention this as Leave voters are usually presented as uneducated xenophobes. Frankly it's not really relevant but I also come from a fairly diverse family, my nephew's mum was born in the West Indies and my sister in law in Pakistan.

It's an unhelpful and sweeping statement. And just for the record, I doubt many Brexit voters wouldn't vote for Rishi for that reason. His more centrist views on cutting tax, maybe. He's my front runner at the moment but we'll see.

Funnily enough many brown and black people support Brexit

Rosessmelllike · 10/07/2022 10:05

The fuck is this thread? Are you the same person who keeps posting derogatory threads pitting ''BAME'', since you insist on using it, against non-''BAME''? Get a life

Designhelp · 10/07/2022 10:04

hotcoldnotsold · 10/07/2022 06:43

I actually think he has a chance tbh and that the UK would be ready for it. Not sure he has the experience or grit tbh but after bojo people may fancy a less conniving politician. I do also note that his wealth and privilege is always talked about as if we don't have plenty of other white politicians who are the same - I mean they're all mostly privileged including Starmer. But a lot of the liberal left like their BAME people in a box, vulnerable and in need of help, where they can play white saviour, and I think it's a new dawn when we suddenly have more minorities in leadership positions than ever before.

Amen to this!

Winederlust · 10/07/2022 10:01

OutDamnedSpot · 10/07/2022 07:45

The problem with Sunak is not his colour. It's the privilege his colossal wealth brings.

I wouldn’t vote for him because he’s so privileged and disgustingly rich that he has no idea how the rest of us live.

I think comments like these sort of prove the OP’s point. Boris (and a lot of tories) are also loving in completely different circumstances to most of us. None of them understand the impact that price rises are having on us. Why do we hold Sunak to higher expectations?

The answer might be uncomfortable.

Bit of an assumption that these PPs voted for Boris there though.
I wouldn't vote for Rishi for the same reasons i didn't vote for Boris, or for the Tories in general.
Javid or Zahawi would be more palatable in terms of their backgrounds and relative integrity.
Chances are though, Rishi will have the most backing from his party members, because he is super rich and super privileged in comparison, and the bottom line is that's what the Tories hold dear.

Valeriekat · 10/07/2022 09:56

Saj would be great. Sunak would be awful.

HashtagShitShop · 10/07/2022 09:47

I wouldn't vote for him but that's becauseof his party, that my local mp is up Boris' backside so much she's practically emerging from his mouth (not nadine) and that as a 24/7 carer from a neglected Northern town they've done nothing but make my life and that of the person I care for even more difficult exponentially and, occasionally, revelled in doing so. I would never ever vote Tory whatever their candidate was like.

I don't care what sex, religion, sexuality or race a pm was/is. I just want a fundamentally decent human being who cares about the job, the country and the people above their groin, ego and the money it gives. It shouldn't be that hard.

Friendship101 · 10/07/2022 09:43

Lonelycrab · 10/07/2022 09:36

There were plenty of other reasons why people voted leave. I voted remain but come on, can we stop pretending that everyone who voted leave was doing it because they're racist?

Its not about everyone being racist though, just some. A lot of posters getting offended, claiming the op means the entire Tory voter based is racist- it’s not.

But that doesn’t mean some are racist, and the question is: are there enough of them to cause enough of a swing in any given vote.

Take my neighbour for instance. White male, mid 50s, covered in tats and passionate Chelsea supporter. We get on well on a superficial level. But when I asked him if the rented house next door to him had been filled yet, his response was he didn’t mind who moved in “as long as they’re not a Muslim or a darky”

My “d”f, 82 is openly racist and uses the n word regularly.

This is Britain 2022. You might not accept it but racism is actually more widespread than you think, if you scratch beneath the surface it’s there. I don’t think this is a racist country on the whole, but I think there are enough people that will not vote for a bame pm, for it to make a difference.

i appreciate your point here but I know of absolutely no one in my friends or family who would speak like that anymore. 30 years ago my now 90 year old grandparents said some slurs but they no longer do and accept it is (and was) unacceptable. Should add I am in a northern mill town also where I know there has been a lot of tension but I no longer see it in my area or the town or the more deprived, very mixed background I work in.

Ireolu · 10/07/2022 09:40

I am black wouldn't vote for Sunak or any of the conservatives tbh. I know Kemi personally too and wouldn't vote for her despite this.

One just has to read the comments in the daily fail to understand what OP is getting at though. I am well aware that these comments do not reflect the thoughts of everybody. There r however many about some of the main candidates not being part of the 'lineage' and true 'culture' of Britain. So yes I am not sure this country is ready for a non white PM.

Findwen · 10/07/2022 09:40

The hope & desire for the left mentioned above seems odd to me, to have right leaning racists abandon the Conservative party. It would mean Sir Keir would then have them under his umbrella - Labour would have the anti-semites and the racists all under one tent.