Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Britain is not ready for BAME PM

341 replies

notnever · 10/07/2022 01:06

Rishi might just be voted by MPs but will not win general elections. Already we are reminded he is rich, has an US Greencard, cut taxes, unrelatable, wife is rich and did not pay tax, did not declare tax, etc, as if any different from Boris.

Do you think Britain is ready for BAME PM?
Yes = you are unreasonable
No = you are not being unreasonable

NB, you don't have to explain whether it makes Britain racist or not. I am personally happy he is standing for leadership, it will be his good reminder (as many of us BAME know) racism trumps social class.

OP posts:
milord · 10/07/2022 12:05

OP, are you suggesting we should turn a blind eye to all of Sunak's problems (and I'm sure all the candidates have issues relating to certain issues one way or another) simply because he is BAME? So being BAME means you can do whatever you like so long as the person voted in isn't white?

Or are you suggesting that the British electorate is a bunch of racists that will never vote for him at general election, so the Tories shouldn't pick him?

Or are you suggesting that any BAME person that's rich/higher class is electable, but any poorer/lower class BAME person is unelectable because the country only want to be led by rich, high class people?

By the way, I am only using ''BAME'' to copy you, but it's a deeply problematic word which you seem to have happily adopted.

I'm terribly confused by all the mishmashing together of several unrelated things in your opening post, which mostly seems to be making a dig about Britain being a festering sore of racism.

wellhelloitsme · 10/07/2022 12:04

Fifthtimelucky · 10/07/2022 11:24

I suspect @Beautiful3 is thinking of the ethnic breakdown for London. In the last census 43.4% described themselves as "white British"

But obviously London is atypical!

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates/articles/populationestimatesbyethnicgroupandreligionenglandandwales/2019

She's still wrong for London though:

London was the most ethnically and religiously diverse region in England and Wales where the largest ethnic groups were White British (43.4%), Other White (14.6%) and Black African (7.9%); people with a religion other than Christian accounted for over 25% of London's population compared with an estimated 10.6% of the overall population.

So 58% white in London.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/07/2022 11:47

Couldn't care less about Sunak's ethnicity. He's an UHNW elitist arsehole who shouldn't be anywhere near politics, let alone a top job where he can affect millions of people's lives with a stroke of a pen, but then I feel that way about all uhnw individuals, especially those who have never had any real appreciation/exposure to the struggles of the average person.

That said, Sunak has been voted for by his constituents since 2015 (?) so clearly there's no issue with his electability in the eyes of those who actually vote for him and there's plenty of other Conservative mps from minority backgrounds.

Are you suggesting that large chunks of Conservative voters, who already vote for those MPs, would stop if one was elevated to PM (insinuating that it is Tory voters who are the racists)? When the tories lose the next general election it will be down to their appalling record in government over the last 12 years, not because they have a BAME leader.

Personally, I think the fact that the tories will be in power over this winter, when the cost of living crisis really bites, will spell the end of their time in government. They seem unwilling or incapable of doing a single meaningful thing to address the situation and the impact is now so wide reaching that it will (thankfully) make them unelectable for years.

I also don't think the British public really pay that much attention to race when it comes to elections in general. Core beliefs are the primary driver with class and privilege backgrounds being much bigger factors after that than race.

loveforallhatredfornone · 10/07/2022 11:34

sst1234 · 10/07/2022 11:16

This narrative is an example of setting you house on fire but then make you grateful by sending a fire engine to save you.

If this incompetent government hadn’t locked down healthy people. Many millions would not have needed to be furloughed if the whole economy was not shut down unnecessarily. And yes it was unnecessary.

We were stood down unpaid before lockdown and before furlough. If the UK had not introduced furlough or gone into lockdown we would still not have been working and still had zero income and that would have been the case for the hundreds of thousands of people employed in my industry and those employed in our supply industries.

As for lockdown being unnecessary I disagree especially the first lockdown when we had no idea what Coronavirus was or how to treat it. We all saw the news reports from China and Italy of people unable to get medical help because the health services were overwhelmed. Lockdown was not about stopping the virus it was to stop the NHS being completely overwhelmed and unable to offer any care at all. All political parties were calling for lockdown and if it had been a labour government we would have been in lockdowns 1 & 2 earlier than we were if you believe what Starmer was saying at the time.

Luxa · 10/07/2022 11:30

as long as they didn't go to bloody Eton!

If any woman gets the job, problem solved.

Fifthtimelucky · 10/07/2022 11:24

I suspect @Beautiful3 is thinking of the ethnic breakdown for London. In the last census 43.4% described themselves as "white British"

But obviously London is atypical!

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates/articles/populationestimatesbyethnicgroupandreligionenglandandwales/2019

ClaudineClare · 10/07/2022 11:17

Post not pist.

sst1234 · 10/07/2022 11:16

loveforallhatredfornone · 10/07/2022 11:00

The industry I work in was affected by covid restrictions in other countries long before the UK went into lock down. We were stood down unpaid before the furlough scheme or the UK lockdown was announced. We were all terrified on our last day in on how we could pay any bills or get food on zero income so the announcement of the furlough scheme by the UK government was very welcome to us.

This narrative is an example of setting you house on fire but then make you grateful by sending a fire engine to save you.

If this incompetent government hadn’t locked down healthy people. Many millions would not have needed to be furloughed if the whole economy was not shut down unnecessarily. And yes it was unnecessary.

ClaudineClare · 10/07/2022 11:16

Beautiful3 · 10/07/2022 10:30

It doesn't bother me what colour our pm is, I don't care. But I do expect them to have been born and raised here, thats my only stipulation. I think you'll be surprised how many would want a brown pm. You do realise there are more brown people from different ethnicities, than white people now in the UK!

Can you pist a link to where did you get that statistic from @Beautiful3 ? 2011 census showed 87% of the UK population is white.

sst1234 · 10/07/2022 11:13

Beautiful3 · 10/07/2022 10:30

It doesn't bother me what colour our pm is, I don't care. But I do expect them to have been born and raised here, thats my only stipulation. I think you'll be surprised how many would want a brown pm. You do realise there are more brown people from different ethnicities, than white people now in the UK!

A bit off topic, but blatant misinformation like this really not helpful. UK is 79% ethnic white. So no, there are not more brown people than white.

wellhelloitsme · 10/07/2022 11:12

@Beautiful3

You do realise there are more brown people from different ethnicities, than white people now in the UK!

Where on earth are you getting that from?!

In 2019, the most common ethnic group in England and Wales was White (84.8%), decreasing by 1.2 percentage points since the 2011 Census; the next biggest change from 2011 was within the Other ethnic group which increased by 0.9 percentage points.

plugee · 10/07/2022 11:10

@loveforallhatredfornone I somehow left out good. i thought it was a good scheme

wellhelloitsme · 10/07/2022 11:08

Kidsaretryingtodestroyme · 10/07/2022 08:59

Completely unrelated to colour, I’d also like to know if Rishi is actively religious and if so, how much does his religion influence his beliefs and actions? Does he believe in the caste system for example? It would not be good for the U.K. going through a recession/financial crisis to have a billionaire PM who’s beliefs teach him that he ‘deserves’ to be rich because he did something good in a past life and the food bank customers are there because they did something bad in a past life i.e it’s their fault they are poor. Can you imagine how this would impact policy making around tax cuts for the rich, raising taxes against poor, slashing the state?

I would say the same about Rees-Mogg and how Catholicism impacts his behaviour. Look at the Supreme Court judges in America to see how religion can have a impact.

You could just have a Google to find out. Took me a few seconds to find this from an interview with him:

“British Indian is what I tick on the census, we have a category for it. I am thoroughly British, this is my home and my country, but my religious and cultural heritage is Indian, my wife is Indian. I am open about being a Hindu,” he says. He points out, for instance, that he doesn’t eat beef “and it has never been a problem”. As for America, it is different:“Religion pervades political life there, and that is not the case here, thankfully.”

Simonjt · 10/07/2022 11:02

Beautiful3 · 10/07/2022 10:30

It doesn't bother me what colour our pm is, I don't care. But I do expect them to have been born and raised here, thats my only stipulation. I think you'll be surprised how many would want a brown pm. You do realise there are more brown people from different ethnicities, than white people now in the UK!

Your ability to understand statistics is genuinely amazing.

loveforallhatredfornone · 10/07/2022 11:00

plugee · 10/07/2022 10:36

1)If it hadn't been for the furlough scheme millions of working class people (me included) would have been made redundant and forced into extreme poverty during the pandemic.

I think this was a scheme. I wasn't furloughed but I don't understand the narrative that furloughed are the new benefit scroungers or that you could prevent people from working & expect them to have nothing.

The industry I work in was affected by covid restrictions in other countries long before the UK went into lock down. We were stood down unpaid before the furlough scheme or the UK lockdown was announced. We were all terrified on our last day in on how we could pay any bills or get food on zero income so the announcement of the furlough scheme by the UK government was very welcome to us.

Cornettoninja · 10/07/2022 10:58

Beautiful3 · 10/07/2022 10:30

It doesn't bother me what colour our pm is, I don't care. But I do expect them to have been born and raised here, thats my only stipulation. I think you'll be surprised how many would want a brown pm. You do realise there are more brown people from different ethnicities, than white people now in the UK!

Eh? Where did you get those figures from? Last I checked Caucasian people made up 80%+ of the UK population.

Charles11 · 10/07/2022 10:58

I think there's a difference between multiracialism and multiculturalism. The right seems to promote multiracialism and the left, multiculturalism.
This is where there seems to be a huge difference in attitude and why the Tories appear to be more diverse in race as a party, and why they seem to have less pigeon holed mps from multiracial backgrounds.
Labour champions multiculturalism and have mps pigeonholed into the 'correct' multicultural areas. With this strategy, it's unlikely that labour would ever have a black or Asian leader.

Questionaboutjoboffer · 10/07/2022 10:57

I think the issue of ethnicity is largely irrelevant in this case.

It’s more a case of if anyone from the line up or the Tory party can be trusted to govern properly.

The whole thing is a sick farce IMO.

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 10:52

Friendship101 · 10/07/2022 10:26

Whilst the rich do this, it doesn’t make it ethically right. I’m part of the squeezed middle I guess and it really irks me.

So you don’t pay into a pension, use your personal allowance or have an ISA?

plugee · 10/07/2022 10:38

@Friendship101 but do you have a problem with less rich people using CGT & IHT loopholes. I don't think the tax system is working & would bring CGT in line with income for example & have much higher levies on 2nd homes but that wouldn't be popular with the general public.

plugee · 10/07/2022 10:36

1)If it hadn't been for the furlough scheme millions of working class people (me included) would have been made redundant and forced into extreme poverty during the pandemic.

I think this was a scheme. I wasn't furloughed but I don't understand the narrative that furloughed are the new benefit scroungers or that you could prevent people from working & expect them to have nothing.

FrippEnos · 10/07/2022 10:33

The thing is that if the conservatives vote in Rishi, Javid etc.
It will be interesting to see if the next election is fought on principles and policies or racism.

loveforallhatredfornone · 10/07/2022 10:30

I'd support Rishi Sunak as PM.

1)If it hadn't been for the furlough scheme millions of working class people (me included) would have been made redundant and forced into extreme poverty during the pandemic.

2)His wealth to me isn't an issue, I could support a candidate rich or poor.

3)His wife's non-dom status was perfectly legal, money made in India was taxed in India, money made in the UK was taxed in the UK - how many of you would be happy being double taxed on your income?

  1. The current economic crisis is global not just the UK and is not his fault in any way.

  2. Cutting taxes is fine (and he has done this by raising the NI threshold) but services need to be paid for and if we have tax cuts services will need to be cut or more debt accured and our children, grandchildren and great grandchildren will be the ones who have to pay it,

If it's not Rishi Sunak I'd like Tom Tugendhat as the next leader.

Beautiful3 · 10/07/2022 10:30

It doesn't bother me what colour our pm is, I don't care. But I do expect them to have been born and raised here, thats my only stipulation. I think you'll be surprised how many would want a brown pm. You do realise there are more brown people from different ethnicities, than white people now in the UK!

MarshaBradyo · 10/07/2022 10:28

AnaïsM · 10/07/2022 10:09

I get the impression that the left-leaning posters on here would be utterly bereft to have a non-white PM. To them the right being racist is a matter of faith, something that they hold dear and do not want disproven.

This is despite the EHRC having found recently that Labour were racist to their core.

I think you’re right you can see it on here

I’m very happy to see diversity in the leader race and glad to see who the front runners are